Microsoft Debuts Costly Raspberry Pi Alternative

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Everything about this Raspberry Pi alternative looked great...until I saw the $299 price tag. :eek:

The pint-sized PC features a 1.33GHz Intel Atom processor with integrated HD graphics, 16GB of EMMC storage, a MIPI connector for display and camera, HDMI, one USB 2.0 port and a micro-USB power port. Ethernet or wifi is available only through USB, meaning users will have to connect to the internet or other networks with a USB adapter.
 
That "article" reads more like click-bait. Not much of a surprise since it came from zdnet.
 
Still, Microsoft hopes the board will find a home with Independent Hardware Vendors and hardware enthusiasts willing to shell out eight times the cost of the $35 Raspberry Pi Model B. Even Intel's own Galileo board, which also targets developers, is significantly cheaper.

Hope is the correct word , I thought they ditched Ballmer to get rid of people with dead end hardware projects ;)
 
$299 isn't that much more than $34... duh.. :rolleyes:
 
Microsoft said the price covers the cost of the hardware, a Windows 8.1 image, and the slightly vague "utilities" required to apply it to the Sharks Cove.

MS misses the point again. People use Rasp Pi devices because they don't have to pay for an expensive OS and random "utilities".
 
LMAO
Yeah, I'm sure that will take off and crush the Pi. :D

If you want a good alternative to the Pi, I suggest looking at the ODROID systems.
 
That "article" reads more like click-bait. Not much of a surprise since it came from zdnet.
bingo!
People need to go
Here : http://channel9.msdn.com/Events/Build/2014/2-536
here
http://blogs.msdn.com/b/windows_har...arks-cove-is-now-available-for-pre-order.aspx
and here
Here : http://www.sharkscove.org/

This is not set / targeted for hobbyist but more for developers , with what is thrown in the whole kit...i.e. the hardware and non hardware pieces related to the whole kit. It's actually not that $$$ .
besides prices may come down for new kits as more are picked up .
 
4571-sharks-board-close-440-jpg-550x0-v1-550x401.jpg


Also, this thing is ugly as hell.
It looks like it was made in the mid-90's, and the GPIO pins are awkward as hell.

First teased during its April Build conference, the Raspberry Pi-ish device is the result of the combined efforts of Microsoft, Intel and product manufacturer CircuitCo.
I expected better from Intel, but not the other two.
 
I don't get why Win8 was included with it, but otherwise it's a pretty decent looking embedded system board if the price were reduced to better represent its performance segment.

BTW, it was Intel and CircuitCo which made the board. MS only ruined it by including Win8, making the pricing fairly ridiculous. :p
 
I cant help but think that the journalist if you can call them that are the ones who spun this as a raspberry pi alternative more than MS. If you actually read the article that this is based on MS makes not a single mention of raspberry pi. This is a prototyping and development product. From a cost perspective of course it makes no sense it is just as expensive if not more expensive than many full fledged windows products such as tablets, and whole desktop PCs.

So the joke is on the idiots who jumped the conclusion that MS launched this to kill raspberry pi.
 
BUhhhhHHhhhhdhhahhahahhhahahahhahhahaahahahaahahh!!!!!!!!!

Read this in the middle of browsing a site to buy parts for Raspberry Pi project. Struck me as pretty funny. :D

Raspberry Pi A or B model costs $34.

first comment under that article is about someone bitching a Rpi isn't a $35 'computer'
http://www.zdnet.com/raspberry-pi-how-i-spent-almost-150-on-a-35-computer-7000020574/

which we all know is BS. Someone who would be using a Rpi would have spare parts to use for experimenting.
 
That board is targeted at Windows developers working on tablets and smart phones that want a board they can hardware on before they get their real hardware made. This is cheap compared to previous x86 single board computers from Kontron or the like.

And it has a modern/new quad core Atom that turbos up to 1.8ghz. And draws only 2W. So it runs circles around the NUC and especially the RPI if you care about CPU performance. The raspberry pi isn't in the same zip code in terms of CPU performance.

And having 16gigs of fast emmc makes things quite convenient. But if you want that on a cheap device you should be getting a Beaglebone Black. Which is also significantly faster than a RPI. And ~$50
 
And it has a modern/new quad core Atom that turbos up to 1.8ghz. And draws only 2W. So it runs circles around the NUC and especially the RPI if you care about CPU performance. The raspberry pi isn't in the same zip code in terms of CPU performance.

And having 16gigs of fast emmc makes things quite convenient. But if you want that on a cheap device you should be getting a Beaglebone Black. Which is also significantly faster than a RPI. And ~$50

This still serves no purpose. If you HAVE to run Windows for whatever reason then this is still a POOR choice. The NUC consumes a very small amount of power, only incrementally higher then the Atom, and it FAR outpaces it in terms of performance. If you are running windows, you aren't worried about power, or you would be running a Windows Phone OS on ARM or something similar.

RPI is a very powerful platform for what it does. It will play mp3, it will play mp4, it will run JAVA, python, Appache, etc....And it supports multiple OS versions. It's also open source.

That board is targeted at Windows developers working on tablets and smart phones that want a board they can hardware

This is in no way near the RPI target market. So I would hardly call it a RPI alternative.
 
This still serves no purpose. If you HAVE to run Windows for whatever reason then this is still a POOR choice. The NUC consumes a very small amount of power, only incrementally higher then the Atom, and it FAR outpaces it in terms of performance. If you are running windows, you aren't worried about power, or you would be running a Windows Phone OS on ARM or something similar.

The NUC also requires RAM, a HDD and an OS. If that OS happens to be Windows, it will automatically push the NUC above the price point of this system.
 
This still serves no purpose. If you HAVE to run Windows for whatever reason then this is still a POOR choice. The NUC consumes a very small amount of power, only incrementally higher then the Atom, and it FAR outpaces it in terms of performance. If you are running windows, you aren't worried about power, or you would be running a Windows Phone OS on ARM or something similar.

RPI is a very powerful platform for what it does. It will play mp3, it will play mp4, it will run JAVA, python, Appache, etc....And it supports multiple OS versions. It's also open source.

The thing about this board that seems to set it apart from everything else that's been mentioned are the wide array of hardware interconnects. This board has a very targeted purpose, Atom SoC Windows device driver development. If you're not developing device drivers for Windows on Atom devices, this hardware isn't for you. If one were looking simply for a cheap x86 Windows platform, the coming wave of $100 Windows tablets would make much more sense.
 
The thing about this board that seems to set it apart from everything else that's been mentioned are the wide array of hardware interconnects. This board has a very targeted purpose, Atom SoC Windows device driver development. If you're not developing device drivers for Windows on Atom devices, this hardware isn't for you. If one were looking simply for a cheap x86 Windows platform, the coming wave of $100 Windows tablets would make much more sense.

That's a very good point.
The product is sound, but the article is click-bait, unfortunately.
 
This still serves no purpose. If you HAVE to run Windows for whatever reason then this is still a POOR choice. The NUC consumes a very small amount of power, only incrementally higher then the Atom, and it FAR outpaces it in terms of performance. If you are running windows, you aren't worried about power, or you would be running a Windows Phone OS on ARM or something similar.

RPI is a very powerful platform for what it does. It will play mp3, it will play mp4, it will run JAVA, python, Appache, etc....And it supports multiple OS versions. It's also open source.

This is in no way near the RPI target market. So I would hardly call it a RPI alternative.

There are a bunch of different NUCs. The $149 one (with no ram/storage/windows license) with a Celeron 847 uses 13.8W versus the Atom in Sharks Cove at 1.63W. So almost an order of magnitude less power. The Atom in Sharks Cove is a quad core Atom running slightly faster, and best I can tell performs equivalently in benchmarks to the much older Celeron overall. Any of the i3 NUCs are of course going to perform better, but when you full assemble one they will be well over $300 with Windows license.

People are releasing low power x86 based tablets running Windows. They have to develop drivers on those platforms somehow. That's why this exists.
 
^ I have to agree.
This does not compete with the Pi, or any other ARM device such as this.

It was a bad, click-bait, article.
 
$299? fuck just get a dell venue 8, has more speed.

Yea and your Dell Venue + all the other snide comments come with
the add on and extra hardware that this hardware has...
this is not a toy it is not for daily tinkering ..
I would suggest you actually read up on the device and the detailed hardware specs for this and also maybe open your eyes to what this piece of equipment is actually for...
Detailed Hardware specs for the device = I would suggest looking at the following pdf file start at page 7 all the way to the last page... MS is being up front completely in regards to what this can and can not do and what it's for... The price is justifiable for what they are doing with this ....

http://www.sharkscove.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/Sharks-Cove-Technical-Specifications.pdf

This is not made for the joe blow home user or tween that wants a little toy to play with or tweak and go...
 
^ I have to agree.
This does not compete with the Pi, or any other ARM device such as this.

It was a bad, click-bait, article.

I'm not so sure if it was a true click-bait article or if the author just didn't understand what Shark Cove is relative RPi. At any rate it looks like most people here and even in the comments section of the OP are getting the message across. I admit I wouldn't mind having one of these to play with even though I know that's not what it's really for. But for $300 I'll pass for now.
 
I'm not so sure if it was a true click-bait article or if the author just didn't understand what Shark Cove is relative RPi. At any rate it looks like most people here and even in the comments section of the OP are getting the message across. I admit I wouldn't mind having one of these to play with even though I know that's not what it's really for. But for $300 I'll pass for now.

Yeah, the article was at least a bit misleading.
But your statements about it being a device used for driver development makes a lot of sense.

$300 for an x86 board like this seems high, but for the purpose, it's actually pretty valuable for the cost.
It's pretty much the x86 equivalent of the ODROID boards, which can be used for the development of Android apps, drivers, etc.

The Raspberry Pi is kind of in the lower-end spectrum, being used for smaller projects and controlled devices, rather than development, though I'm sure it can do that as well to a much smaller extent.
 
I don't think anyone uses a Pi for anything but hobby stuff so I am not sure there is any reason to compete with it. I used to use mine as an ArchLinux box to run a webserver. I used to have a modified PogoPlug to do the same thing.
 
Back
Top