Microsoft: An Open Source Windows Is ‘Definitely Possible’

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Is an open source Windows "definitely possible?" Sure. Is it probable? I don't think so.

But one day, the company could “open source” the code that underpins the OS—giving it away for free. So says Mark Russinovich, one of the company’s top engineers. “It’s definitely possible,” Russinovich says. “It’s a new Microsoft.”
 
I'm looking forward to Winbuntu and WinArch.
 
Well, they're already giving 10 away to anyone on 7/8/8.1 so never say never I guess....
 
The only reason Microsoft would release Windows as open source is to make everyone not American feel better about using Windows. Cause everyone else is more interested in using Linux over Windows because of the Snowden information.
 
They see the end is coming and are hoping to stay relevant... Why are x86 instructions hard coded everywhere!? This isn't even kernel code this is for Microsoft word
 
I can easily see this happening as MS continues its move of Office from locally installed software to the web-based client/server model.
Once support and sales for locally installed software is terminated, the consumer OS becomes a non-issue.
MS would continue to develop their closed source OS solely as a server platform.

Think of the advantages of not having to deal with patches and security issues for any client side software.
That would be left in the hands of the open source community, allowing MS to concentrate the majority of their efforts on the two areas that I would guess to be the most lucrative.
 
Microsoft have other open source projects but, while the source code is available for viewing, the licence doesn't allow it to be modified or forked. This eliminates a lot of the benefits of open source software. It's basically a move to improve Microsoft's image - they get to claim their software is open source while not allowing the user to do anything with it.

It's like how they claim Microsoft Office is 100% comparable with the Open Document Format, which it technically is but it completely mutilates the documents. Again that's an image move - they get to claim ODF compatibility without actually being compatible.
 
Why are x86 instructions hard coded everywhere!? This isn't even kernel code this is for Microsoft word
What are you talking about? If anything, the ARM ports show Office code is fairly portable and not dependent on "x86 instructions hard coded everywhere". Further support comes from MS itself: http://channel9.msdn.com/Shows/Going+Deep/Craig-Symonds-and-Mohsen-Agsen-C-Renaissance

MS moved away from x86 assembly in Windows quite a long time ago in favor C instead.
 
A lot of Windows source code isn't 'open', but it is available to some developers. If I have a reason for it, of course. They aren't just going to hand it to you. NDA's (which if broken have some huge consequences) a huge deal.

Seeing Windows open source would almost kill Windows. Who do you go to for support? Microsoft wouldn't be liable for any fork or anything other than their own. Once it's modified, it's all without support. Yet Microsoft would get the blame.
 
The only place that Linux is popular in comparison to Windows is in the server OS market--and a common misconception about Open Source is that it's free...;) It's anything but free--IBM, for instance, makes a mint from its custom Linux OS server & software, and a quick trip to Red Hat illustrates how Linux is *not* free in the cases where it is used the most. Mozilla, home of Firefox, is a for-profit company now that depends on various streams of revenue to survive, including in-browser advertising, etc. Sometimes Linux is free to end users and sometimes it's not--depends on where you get it and which distribution it is.

Ironically, on the desktop client side, where Linux is usually "free," Linux makes up less than 1% of the user base--Windows crushes it decisively in share even though Windows is traditionally not free. Linux users, XP & Vista users, Mac OS X users, etc., who want Win10 will all have to buy it to get it, even though it will be a free upgrade for Win7/8 owners. I guess the point here is that people don't mind paying for functionality and hardware and software compatibility second to none. I can't imagine Microsoft turning the code base over to Tom, Dick, and Harry...;) Can you imagine the security nightmare that would entail...? Anything is theoretically possible, but some things simply completely improbable....
 
It's anything but free--IBM, for instance, makes a mint from its custom Linux OS server & software, and a quick trip to Red Hat illustrates how Linux is *not* free in the cases where it is used the most.

CentOS says hi.

What you're really paying for the IBM & Redhat implementations is the support.
 
CentOS says hi.

What you're really paying for the IBM & Redhat implementations is the support.

That's the model of most open source software. It's developed by the community and then it's forked to a "community edition" and a "supported" edition. The latter gets you support, quicker updates, and other premium features - maybe even optimized hosting (WordPress). There's too many open source projects that have done this model to list.
 
That's the model of most open source software. It's developed by the community and then it's forked to a "community edition" and a "supported" edition. The latter gets you support, quicker updates, and other premium features - maybe even optimized hosting (WordPress). There's too many open source projects that have done this model to list.

Yep. And if Microsoft were to head in that direction eventually - over the next 5-10 years - it would be by being dragged there kicking and screaming, not because they had any change of heart.
 
What you are paying for in windows is really its support =]. A business model is a business model some where somehow sooner or later someone pays. Simply changing who pays and how they pay or what the clowns think they are actually paying for doesn't making something free. Many of the most popular Linux distros have a paid side and its easy to see that if the paid side didn't exist neither would the free side and a lot of the "free" labor that goes into it and then even LESS people would use Linux. One might even make the argument the reason Linux has always been behind on the consumer desktop is because the money is in enterprise so the developers have never really focused on the consumer thus making it impossible for Linux to please consumers. Hence the first time in its history that Linux would finally make consumer inroads was when a company used it as a base for a real consumer OS, IE android. But of course there is still a business model and someone still pays. Android is not free advertisers pay, and OEMs pay for certain features.
 
while i dont see it happening, at least not anytime soon (very interesting comment about the cloud based subscriptions lending plausibility though, totally agree with that one) can you imagine if it happened just overnight, today?

there'd be an EXPLOSION of vulnerabilities released. then a little later, windows wouldnt suck.

both of which would be pretty weird.

plus imagine a wintendo thats an incredibly stripped kernel with virtually nothing but video card support + your games. would be pretty neat..
 
Windows doesn't "suck". For how widely used Windows is it's like comparing apples to oranges when talking about security.

The same argument since Windows got popular; why write software that attacks a few percent of those that use computers when you can attack almost everyone by going after Windows? If Mac OS or a Linux distro were in the same spot then people would feel differently.

Also, since I got into computers 15 years ago I can say that almost all issues I have ever encountered were PEBKAC.
 
It'll never happen, the second we have open-source Windows we won't need it anymore because it's just a matter of time until someone builds a cross-platform Windows library implementation that will run on any OS you like. A 100% compatible Wine.
 
Back
Top