Meyer Fired Over Failure to Target Mobile Devices?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Could Dirk Meyer's focus on the desktop market (or lack of focus on the mobile market) be the reason for his downfall? I suppose it could be, that is a more logical explanation than most of the unsubstantiated stories floating around the rumor-verse right now.

Citing people familiar with the matter, a story in today's Wall Street Journal (subscription required) said that AMD's board had been concerned for the past year over Meyer's seeming lack of motivation and interest in expanding the company's reach into mobile devices. Following a meeting in November, the board grew more impatient, eventually forcing Meyer to resign on Monday.
 
I think AMD would have got it's ass kicked if it tried to do mobile devices.
 
The fact that they had to sell their mobile/ARM division to prevent bankruptcy, what did they expect?

Let's see, AMD existing without a mobile division, or AMD not existing at all. Which is better for the company?
 
This is how I see it:

Mobile == Low Power
Small Device Size in Fab == Low Power
Intel is at least 1.5 generations ahead of AMD/Global Foundries in Fab Technology. Intel transitioned to 32nm technology in Jan 2010 when the Arrandale chips were available for purchase, AMD still has not, as of Jan 2011, sold any 32nm x86 chips in retail.

That means that AMD could *NEVER* compete against Intel effectively in the x86 mobile space. 45nm technology versus 32nm... in the mobile space equals HUGE FAIL... which is exactly what has happened.

So *firing* the CEO for lack of mobile vision is just getting rid of a scapegoat.

Yeah, yeah, AMD sold their ATI mobile graphics division to Qualcomm, that certainly didn't help, but what non x86 chips did AMD have any foothold in, in the mobile sector which these days == ARM based chips? Really none. Their embedded graphics were mostly used in Cable Boxes. And whatever ATI "technology" was used in Qualcomm's chips before AMD sold them off was always trounced by the NVIDIA mobile graphics accelerators.
 
This is how I see it:

Mobile == Low Power
Small Device Size in Fab == Low Power
Intel is at least 1.5 generations ahead of AMD/Global Foundries in Fab Technology. Intel transitioned to 32nm technology in Jan 2010 when the Arrandale chips were available for purchase, AMD still has not, as of Jan 2011, sold any 32nm x86 chips in retail.

That means that AMD could *NEVER* compete against Intel effectively in the x86 mobile space. 45nm technology versus 32nm... in the mobile space equals HUGE FAIL... which is exactly what has happened.

So *firing* the CEO for lack of mobile vision is just getting rid of a scapegoat.

Yeah, yeah, AMD sold their ATI mobile graphics division to Qualcomm, that certainly didn't help, but what non x86 chips did AMD have any foothold in, in the mobile sector which these days == ARM based chips? Really none. Their embedded graphics were mostly used in Cable Boxes. And whatever ATI "technology" was used in Qualcomm's chips before AMD sold them off was always trounced by the NVIDIA mobile graphics accelerators.

Unless AMD can find their alternative to High-K they will never meet or exceed Intel. Ever. High-K put the nail in AMD's coffin. They just don't know they are dead yet.
 
I think AMD would have got it's ass kicked if it tried to do mobile devices.

Exactly.

This is how I see it:

Mobile == Low Power
Small Device Size in Fab == Low Power
Intel is at least 1.5 generations ahead of AMD/Global Foundries in Fab Technology. Intel transitioned to 32nm technology in Jan 2010 when the Arrandale chips were available for purchase, AMD still has not, as of Jan 2011, sold any 32nm x86 chips in retail.

That means that AMD could *NEVER* compete against Intel effectively in the x86 mobile space. 45nm technology versus 32nm... in the mobile space equals HUGE FAIL... which is exactly what has happened.

So *firing* the CEO for lack of mobile vision is just getting rid of a scapegoat.

Yeah, yeah, AMD sold their ATI mobile graphics division to Qualcomm, that certainly didn't help, but what non x86 chips did AMD have any foothold in, in the mobile sector which these days == ARM based chips? Really none. Their embedded graphics were mostly used in Cable Boxes. And whatever ATI "technology" was used in Qualcomm's chips before AMD sold them off was always trounced by the NVIDIA mobile graphics accelerators.

A more in depth version of what the guy above said.

AMD will never meet or exceed Intel. Ever. High-K put the nail in AMD's coffin. They just don't know they are dead yet.

Fixed and cue the guy with Bulldozer pic. :rolleyes:
 
I really and truly hope my perception of this is just me being paranoid. Does anyone have recent news on Glo-Flo's Hi-K implementation? They have been working on it for a good while now from the various reports.

As for Dirk, yeah I am sitting here really wondering "What Next?". And the general lack of "News Leaks" about BD also has me worried a little. On the other hand, it should be quite interesting to see where Dirk pops up next.

Gary
 
Anandtech actually has some insight on what may be coming:

http://www.anandtech.com/show/4123/what-a-day-amds-ceo-dirk-meyer-resigns

Mark my words, at some point they're going to try to sell the company to ATIC. Let ATIC deal with fighting Intel, and the board/investors can pocket a nice profit. Certainly if you were trying to sell, you'd sack Dirk. He doesn't seem like the kind of guy that would let them do it.

If that's the case, then the current board at AMD is giving up the "sinking ship", but then again, if may also be the only way to save AMD.
 
Back
Top