Maximus III Formula SATA question

polonyc2

Fully [H]
2FA
Joined
Oct 25, 2004
Messages
30,631
newb question but I'm really interested in knowing the answer...I've noticed motherboards that have 2 different sets of SATA connectors...for example the Maximus III board has 6 SATA connectors powered by the P55 chipset and an additional 4 SATA connectors powered by the JMicron or Marvel chipset...does one provide better performance then the other?...what's the point of having 2 sets of SATA powered by 2 different chipsets in one motherboard?

I've always plugged in all my optical drives and hard drives into the main SATA chipset...am I missing something?...can anyone explain to me this feature and its benefits...Thanks
 
Last edited:
its to balance the load.. instead of loading all the sata ports onto 1 chipset.. it allows you to balance the load of all the drives over 2 different chips.. its mostly there for people that run RAID.. so that no single chipsets bottlenecking the entire RAID array.. but some one can correct me if im wrong.. but i believe thats the basic reasoning behind it..
 
its to balance the load.. instead of loading all the sata ports onto 1 chipset.. it allows you to balance the load of all the drives over 2 different chips.. its mostly there for people that run RAID.. so that no single chipsets bottlenecking the entire RAID array.. but some one can correct me if im wrong.. but i believe thats the basic reasoning behind it..

thanks...so for non-RAID setups there is no performance difference when choosing one chipsets over the other?...I thought I read someplace where it stated that it was best putting your optical drives on the secondary chipset with your main hard drives on the first
 
JMicron is usually considered inferior in speed and reliability to the Intel/AMD chipsets.

Many boards use a JMicron chipset for eSATA and IDE features.
 
thanks...so for non-RAID setups there is no performance difference when choosing one chipsets over the other?...I thought I read someplace where it stated that it was best putting your optical drives on the secondary chipset with your main hard drives on the first
It's best to put as much as you can on the chipset's drive controller and avoid using the secondary one. The P55's SATA ports will have better compatibility, better performance, and will give you less trouble in general. They are just there to give you more SATA ports than the P55 can provide on its own, as well as an IDE channel since there is none built into the chipset.
 
One reason is to provide additional ports, but additionally it can make cabling easier especially the way we laid out the ODD SATA headers. Also in some situations it can improve overclocking because the PCH might be affected but the offset controller ( such as the two other JM controllers )may not be. In terms of performance both are true SATA II implementations and the bandwidth and burst potential offered is in line with current generation hard drives. Overall I would not be concern with using these other controllers they work without issues. In terms of our design usage model, normally your main drivers will run off the PCH , ODD drives will run off the SATA ODD headers and if you are running raid you will use our Speeding HDD headers which is a hardware based controller that offers better CPU utilization and performance than the Intel controller. Hope this clears things up for you. Please enjoy the rest of your day.
 
if you are running raid you will use our Speeding HDD headers which is a hardware based controller that offers better CPU utilization and performance than the Intel controller.

A friend and I have been having a discussion about this....he swears this controller is a Intel hardware based RAID controller but we can find no reference on the Intel site and I was always under the impression that a hardware based RAID had to have a seperate CPU.

Your statement above talks about better CPU utilization of the main chip. How could this be hardware RAID if it doesn't have it's own chip for calculations?

Every other RAID performance comparisons have shown the Intel chip to be faster than 3rd party solutions. Do you have any links to show me the increased performance over the Intel chips?

Inquiring Old Hippies, as well as others who have held my views, wanna know. :)
 
Back
Top