Match.com Sued By Heartbroken Member

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Although I can see this guy’s point, I don’t think suing Match.com for "humiliation and disappointment" is going to help him find a date.

Sean McGinn alleges the popular matchmaking Web site dangles phony date bait by posting profiles of people who no longer subscribe to its $39.99-a-month service. As a result, lovelorn singles have been "defrauded" out of millions of dollars and countless hours spent sending heartfelt missives in vain.
 
Maybe the recipients of these "heartfelt missives" are not interested in responding back at all or in-kind to a complete stranger...

Expecting the online world to be friendlier and more sugar-coated than the real world is this guy's first mistake.
 
Next you're going to tell me that those ads that pop up for sites like Adult-Friend-Finder really aren't of hot women who always seem to live in my geographical area!
 
$40/mo? hoe desperate can you get?

Although I can see this guy’s point, I don’t think suing Match.com for "humiliation and disappointment" is going to help him find a date.

It would get him many many dates from gold diggers if he won...

It is kind of a bait and switch when they show pictures of people who really have nothing to do with the site. How hard would it be to scan their database for active members...? They've got to have a couple horn dogs employed who would do it on their own time.
 
They are lying about the service they provide and pretending to provide service they don't (pretending those members are still active) to make more money. Sounds like a fair suit to me.
 
Although I can see this guy’s point, I don’t think suing Match.com for "humiliation and disappointment" is going to help him find a date.

Actually Steve the irony here is that he DID find someone through the site ;) But I guess he's suing in behalf of the 'other' people that were 'duped'
 
If the ads use people that were once members, wouldn't that be indicative of the types of people paying for the service?
 
Maybe the recipients of these "heartfelt missives" are not interested in responding back at all or in-kind to a complete stranger...

Expecting the online world to be friendlier and more sugar-coated than the real world is this guy's first mistake.

I believe his argument is that match.com charges for recipients to just "read" the message yet they don't state this when you send the message. So, he does have a point. The site is probably loaded with people not willing to pay $40 to "see" who or what sent them a message.
 
sorry, but it does tell you the general time frame of when the person last logged on- you are really not that clever if you continue to email people that haven't been on in weeks....
 
They are lying about the service they provide and pretending to provide service they don't (pretending those members are still active) to make more money. Sounds like a fair suit to me.

Every site does this. Companies will sometime hire models for company pictures.


Another sue happy person who can't get laid.
 
I believe his argument is that match.com charges for recipients to just "read" the message yet they don't state this when you send the message. So, he does have a point. The site is probably loaded with people not willing to pay $40 to "see" who or what sent them a message.

Yes and No. They make it sound as if he is complaining about not knowing which accounts are active period, however I actually think he is meaning what you said and which are paid accounts and which are the free accounts.

I signed up for a free account years ago just to look at the site. It told you when the last time somebody logged in. So you could use that to see if the people are you sending messages to are active accounts or someones that quit using the service. The only thing you did not know is if they could respond back to you or not (ie if they were using a free acount or a paid account)

The overall problem with this type of complaint is who is to say that is why you didn't get a reply back? Maybe you are going after somebody that doesn't find you appealing. Maybe you need help with your communication skills trying to get the other person to respond back. It is going to be hard to prove that every single person you ever sent a message to was nonpaid account. Mix in the fact that you can see when the other person was online, you can see if the account is active or not. I myself would assume that somebody that hasn't logged into a dating site in over a week or two is either no longer looking, or has found somebody they are trying to start a relationship with already. Thus either way would not try to send them any message till after i seen them come back online. If somebody not responding back to you hurts your feeling that badly that you would say you suffered humiliation, you might want to consider spending that money on some mental health or something instead of a dating site. Or maybe just getting a life and you are pathetic.
 
Let's see:

A) trying to meet someone at a bar while you're drunk

B) trying to meet someone online, through conversation, while you're both sober

I used to go to bars, I had fun, I got drunk, I'm lucky I didn't catch any permanent STDs, I played around with girls who weren't really compatible with me on a mental level, a couple of them were girls where I thought to myself "WOW, she is smokin hot" and they looked even better up close and un-covered - I still get this tingly spine, curling toes, hairs standing on end feeling just thinking about how ridiculously hot one of them was. But I had absolutely nothing in common with her in terms of interests, hobbies, etc. And she was insane about keeping her place exactly how she wanted it, if a pillow was out of place, she couldn't stand it.

My wife on the other hand, I met online. We talked more in the first couple days of "meeting" than I had with all my other "met in person" exes combined. We're still together after more than 7 years and our second kid is on the way. We had some rough spots, but, now, things are back on the way towards getting better all the time again.

Now - back to the original topic - personally, I am so totally sick of false advertising, and I would like to see any lawsuits against corporations, that have any merit at all succeed because I'm tired of global super mega corporations bullying governments and increasing profits at the cost of the general public's quality of life so that the few mega-rich elite can get even richer than they already are.

People cry "but it will hurt the small businesses" - hey, I'm all for a socialist government that SUPPORTS small businesses success at the expense of greed kings. Let's have public health care, so small businesses don't have to choose between trying to pay for insurnace they can't afford and a work force that doesn't have proper health care!

So, these online dating services, they should not have "fake" profiles to fool suckers out of their money.
 
all these sites do that.

sign up a trial account and watch tons of females send you e-mails interested in you.

The second you actually pay the monthly fee the e-mails stop coming.

classic bait and switch.
 
lol $40/month. What happened to old fashioned meeting people outside? Save you some money for something more important, too. Like gas or food.
 
Standard business practice.

Let me guess, you haven't been laid and oppose all corporate movements?

Standard business practice until someone speaks up and crys foul play.

I'm married (translate that however)
I dont oppose all corporate movements, just the ones that involve making money by deception and lies.
 
Let's see:

A) trying to meet someone at a bar while you're drunk

B) trying to meet someone online, through conversation, while you're both sober

I used to go to bars, I had fun, I got drunk, I'm lucky I didn't catch any permanent STDs, I played around with girls who weren't really compatible with me on a mental level, a couple of them were girls where I thought to myself "WOW, she is smokin hot" and they looked even better up close and un-covered - I still get this tingly spine, curling toes, hairs standing on end feeling just thinking about how ridiculously hot one of them was. But I had absolutely nothing in common with her in terms of interests, hobbies, etc. And she was insane about keeping her place exactly how she wanted it, if a pillow was out of place, she couldn't stand it.

My wife on the other hand, I met online. We talked more in the first couple days of "meeting" than I had with all my other "met in person" exes combined. We're still together after more than 7 years and our second kid is on the way. We had some rough spots, but, now, things are back on the way towards getting better all the time again.

Now - back to the original topic - personally, I am so totally sick of false advertising, and I would like to see any lawsuits against corporations, that have any merit at all succeed because I'm tired of global super mega corporations bullying governments and increasing profits at the cost of the general public's quality of life so that the few mega-rich elite can get even richer than they already are.

People cry "but it will hurt the small businesses" - hey, I'm all for a socialist government that SUPPORTS small businesses success at the expense of greed kings. Let's have public health care, so small businesses don't have to choose between trying to pay for insurnace they can't afford and a work force that doesn't have proper health care!

So, these online dating services, they should not have "fake" profiles to fool suckers out of their money.

all these sites do that.

sign up a trial account and watch tons of females send you e-mails interested in you.

The second you actually pay the monthly fee the e-mails stop coming.

classic bait and switch.

The problem with that is that neither of these really sound like what he is pissed off about. It has nothing to do with being given false hope that some hot girls wanted him, or about fake profiles persay.

It was that he sent out message after message after message for weeks or months and never got a single response.

So he assumes that everyone one of these girls is inactive and thus their accounts should be removed as it is leading people to think they are active users since they have an account on there.

He is overlooking the fact that they don't want to talk to him, they are using free acounts to just look and are waiting to pay to join after they see some guys that they would like to try to meet. Apposoed to paying right away upfront just to see the 500+ "will you fuck me?" messages they will recieve every hour if they are even remotely attractive. I might be wrong, but don't the sites let you see who it was that sent you something but make you pay to read it or respond? If so, then that means that if he is sending message to people that have logged in recently and not getting replies it is either due to them being fake accounts or the girls just not being into him.

Main problem with his arguement is that the site doesn't require you to pay to sign up. So if you remove any nonpaying member then you are taking away a feature of the site. That is just one of the risk that you take on sites like that. the people you are sending messages to may not be a paying members. Some might wait till they get a message form somebody they might be interested in before they start to pay. So that would make them lose out on money removing that feature. If you mark pay and non pay accounts then you run the risk of free account memebers not getting people to look at their account as they might be afraid the person would not pay to be able to read or respond to their message.
 
sorry, but it does tell you the general time frame of when the person last logged on- you are really not that clever if you continue to email people that haven't been on in weeks....

I'm guessing you didn't read the article.:)

The suit also alleges that "Match induces canceled members to log in . . . creating the appearance that inactive members are active" by sending bogus BlackBerry notifications that read, "Someone has winked back at you."
 
I'm guessing you didn't read the article.:)

But if they logged in to look at something like that then they are active and would be actually get a message that you sent them just as if they were logging in and looking every day.
 
They are lying about the service they provide and pretending to provide service they don't (pretending those members are still active) to make more money. Sounds like a fair suit to me.

agreed. fake ads are the reason you cant use craigslist for online dating, and if match.com is the same way, why pay?
 
Although I can see this guy’s point, I don’t think suing Match.com for "humiliation and disappointment" is going to help him find a date.

Didn't read the article, did you Steve? The guy has a GF, who he met through the service. The suit is about deceptive practices. Whether or not Match is guilty or not, I have no idea, but it wouldn't surprise me.
 
i met my soon to be wife on yahoo, but it was when they were running some promotional deal and i didnt pay anything.
 
HOLY COW, they charge $40/month?! :eek:

I always figured it was like maybe $5 or $10 a month. That's like almost 3 times as much as a WoW subscription, and probably about as effective. :p
 
I'm guessing you didn't read the article.:)

hmm- I did read it but quickly, but I see your point. I was envisioning him just emailing people regardless of how long ago they were on and expecting to hear back. I do not know all the details, but I can't understand how he knows that the winks he gets are bogus or legitimate from simply logging in. I also presumed that the people who were not on for several weeks because they were no longer interested for whatever reason would also not be interested in logging back in just because of an email inducing them to do so.

I personally used the site for a while and found a girl I've been dating steady now for over 2 years, but when I was on and looking I can tell you that there are a lot of real, good looking and pretty interesting people on it- I've met a few and corresponded with many more. But they are people and a person may simply not have a good success rate at attracting them regardless of the medium. I suspect that had a lot more to do with the guy's problems regardless of whether he was sent "bogus" winks or not.

I also live in NYC and to all the guys that snicker out there, there a lot of people here that might be interested in you, but in an enormous city like this you will never meet in a million years simply because you never will cross paths in your ordinary life. Perhaps you can't imagine a life like that but it happens.
 
I will add, he does come off as a whiny baby, but he also has a semi-valid complaint. Match.com claiming they have "86 million members!" when they actually have like 10 million members and 76 million dead trial accounts is pretty crappy. The whole point of a big site like that is, with so many people, there's bound to be someone out there for you.

Going back to my WoW comment (kind of pathetic in a love thread, I know :p), it's the same reason no one's playing the new and shiny Age of Conan, but the aging WoW still has 12 million subscribers: more people to play with. What would happen if Eidos claimed they had 10 million subscribers to their game, then you bought it and logged in only to find that no one is online because all those accounts are dead? They'd probably get sued as well.
 
That also explaines whey there is not Barbie MMO. That shit would be flooded with pervies.
 
Next you're going to tell me that those ads that pop up for sites like Adult-Friend-Finder really aren't of hot women who always seem to live in my geographical area!

I'm kinda shocked about that too! I always wondered why whenever I hit F5 on a Pirate Bay page, the same local hot blonde girls would change their names so much. :confused:
 
I had a paid account for americansingles for a couple of years. When I started you could reply to a message you received even if you had a free account. I ponied up hoping that perspective mates could still answer even if they hadn't paid. I found out two years later that they changed that. Both sides need to pay to send mail. I no longer saw the point. Paid $25 per month for two years.

Match.com may be advertising a six month guarantee, but in my opinion, that is back-asswards. The service should be free until you you make progress, say, after three messages to the same person. Maybe they could just give you three free per month, any more you would need to pay for.

When I quit that sight, I deleted my account. No point in letting them show my mug to prop up their numbers if I can't be contacted through that service. And if some fantasy chic really liked my mug then she wouldn't be disappointed that she couldn't contact me.

This guy may be a loser, but I still believe his case has merit. Don't know that he could get much money, but class action status is the right way to go.

Me? Yea, maybe I look like a loser to some of you "kewl" guys here as well, but I use OKcupid now, completely free site.
 
He must have been really desperate. Would never pay $39.99 a month for something like that...
 
I had a paid account for americansingles for a couple of years. When I started you could reply to a message you received even if you had a free account. I ponied up hoping that perspective mates could still answer even if they hadn't paid. I found out two years later that they changed that. Both sides need to pay to send mail. I no longer saw the point. Paid $25 per month for two years.

Match.com may be advertising a six month guarantee, but in my opinion, that is back-asswards. The service should be free until you you make progress, say, after three messages to the same person. Maybe they could just give you three free per month, any more you would need to pay for.

When I quit that sight, I deleted my account. No point in letting them show my mug to prop up their numbers if I can't be contacted through that service. And if some fantasy chic really liked my mug then she wouldn't be disappointed that she couldn't contact me.

This guy may be a loser, but I still believe his case has merit. Don't know that he could get much money, but class action status is the right way to go.

Me? Yea, maybe I look like a loser to some of you "kewl" guys here as well, but I use OKcupid now, completely free site.

As I recall, in the old days the free memberships couldn't see some (all?) of the pictures associated with an account and maybe you didn't see all of the persons profile. If they're all as you describe, then it's really worthless. Do the free accounts even let you search through the database? I always thought it was lame that you had to fill out a huge survey before you could even see if there was anyone you might be interested in.

It reminded me of etailers that required you set up an account to find out how much shipping cost.....all of those sites ended up with bogus info....which probably explains why my spam account gets so much spam. Ever wonder how much spam spam@yahoo.com gets?


He must have been really desperate. Would never pay $39.99 a month for something like that...

I had a friend who tried an offline dating service, and it was significantly more expensive than $40.00/month. As i recall, it was more than a grand....of course they did guarantee a certain number of dates.....as i recall, he started dating someone he met (not though the service) within a month of paying and later moved to Europe....so probably a big waste of cash, but the point is that $40.00 isn't that much.
 
Back
Top