Mac Mini with Server 10.5?

sdotbrucato

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Oct 7, 2005
Messages
1,722
Okay well currently I'm in charge of my family's small business' network. We have a Dell PE1900 with Windows SBS2003 with DHCP, DNS, Exchange, and AD duties.

We all use Macs at home and I was kind of leaning towards getting a Mac Mini with OS X Server loaded on it to take over. And then get a bunch of Mac Mini clients in the office,

The reason I'm leaning towards the mini as the server is because of the expense of a Mac Pro or XServer. It will only be hosting ~10 clients.

So my question is, do you think this setup will work out, or will I experience massive bottlenecks? (Besides storage, which I have a RAID 5 NAS box setup for anyway) Or is there any benefit in keeping the Windows network in the office. The only program we really use is QuickBooks and I know they have a Mac variant of it so I'm not too worried. Other than that, its MS Office Suite.

TIA
-Steven
 
I have run Server on a mini as a 10 client net install server. Not the greatest solution, it tends to choke a lot. I would say leave the dell in place. If its not hurting anyone, leave it.
 
the mini is fine for a few clients, but it chokes with more clients.
 
Theres nothing really wrong with the setup currently, its just the Windows licensing is getting old. but I suppose I can wait until upgrade season and talk them into a Mac Pro or better yet an XServer

Thanks for the input guys
 
Theres nothing really wrong with the setup currently, its just the Windows licensing is getting old. but I suppose I can wait until upgrade season and talk them into a Mac Pro or better yet an XServer

Thanks for the input guys

maybe linux is an option then?
 
maybe linux is an option then?
I'm not too familiar with Linux, and either is anyone in the office. We all use Macs at home, and I just thought it would be a good transition but I guess I'm going to stick with Windows for now
 
I'm not too familiar with Linux, and either is anyone in the office. We all use Macs at home, and I just thought it would be a good transition but I guess I'm going to stick with Windows for now


I'm a linux / unix / mac admin at work. If your not comfortable with the command line, then linux servers are not for you. On top of that, the Server Admin Tool for OS X server is terrible. Their whole suit of graphic tools are really unstable for Leopard. I don't recommend it at all.

Its a good call to stick with your windows server.
 
okay fair enough.

I hear Snow Leopard is going to be including some good business type programs, such as exchange integration and things of that like, what do you guys think on keeping the Windows server on the backend but bringing in some Macs as office clients?

Any big problems I would expect?
 
okay fair enough.

I hear Snow Leopard is going to be including some good business type programs, such as exchange integration and things of that like, what do you guys think on keeping the Windows server on the backend but bringing in some Macs as office clients?

Any big problems I would expect?
Shouldn't. Macs integrate very nicely into a Windows domain.
 
I agree with supergper. Windows server with Mac clients should be no problem at all. OS X does a nice job with Win integration.
 
I agree with supergper. Windows server with Mac clients should be no problem at all. OS X does a nice job with Win integration.

Mixed feelings about this statment. If you turn down the security so they can connect by samba for file shares they are fine. Appletalk on windows server sucks. It doesn't use the newest standard and causes issues with longer directory structors.

With some planning you can get them working in the enviroment. Takes a little of work though.

As far as windows licensing the desktops are pretty much the same as the apples. For the server with 10 users you really are not saving that much by going to the apple.

One thing about windows server as well. Exchange is pretty much the best at what it does. The outlook webmail is far better then apples webmail solution for mail on the go and its features for sharring contacts, calendars, etc is better as well.
 
Mixed feelings about this statment. If you turn down the security so they can connect by samba for file shares they are fine. Appletalk on windows server sucks. It doesn't use the newest standard and causes issues with longer directory structors.

With some planning you can get them working in the enviroment. Takes a little of work though.

As far as windows licensing the desktops are pretty much the same as the apples. For the server with 10 users you really are not saving that much by going to the apple.

One thing about windows server as well. Exchange is pretty much the best at what it does. The outlook webmail is far better then apples webmail solution for mail on the go and its features for sharring contacts, calendars, etc is better as well.
Please explain what you are talking about??? I've never had to "turn down security" so I could connect via SMB (CIFS) to a Win Server share. Appletalk does suck, it has been developed since Win2K, you'd be nuts to use it anyways. To get a mac setup in a Windows domain takes no more work than it does to setup a Windows box to work in a windows domain. Also, you can setup address book so it pulls contacts from a Global Address book from Exchange. The only place Mac falls short is with actual exchange integration. Entourage still lacks a lot of the features Outlook has and Apple Mail is basically nothing more than an IMAP connection. If you don't run an Exchange server then there are no problems.
 
Please explain what you are talking about??? I've never had to "turn down security" so I could connect via SMB (CIFS) to a Win Server share. Appletalk does suck, it has been developed since Win2K, you'd be nuts to use it anyways. To get a mac setup in a Windows domain takes no more work than it does to setup a Windows box to work in a windows domain. Also, you can setup address book so it pulls contacts from a Global Address book from Exchange. The only place Mac falls short is with actual exchange integration. Entourage still lacks a lot of the features Outlook has and Apple Mail is basically nothing more than an IMAP connection. If you don't run an Exchange server then there are no problems.

You have to turn off SMB signing unless they fixed that in 10.5. This isn't that big of a deal but it is lowering the security.

The line that setting up a mac in a windows domain is the same amount of work as setting up a windows pc is bullshit. Yes it has gotten better but it does still take some planning. Taking the extra setups to get .local domains working on the mac systems is an example(very easy to fix). I do agree Entourage is lacking compaired to outlook(well it has been I haven't tried the one in 08 yet). It is still better then running address book and mail via imap. In the case of the OP they say they are running exchange so these issues are worth mentioning.

It is also worth mentioning that SBS03(well exchange 03) does include an outlook license for each user but you can exchange that license for an entourage one(04). All you have to do is pay for the media from MS. In the OP's case they use office so they would be getting entourage with it but it is still nice to know.


The issue with appletalk I was talking about is that windows only supports an older version of appletalk. It only runs appletalk 2 something where appletalk 3 came out with osx. This leads to some issues that the newer versions(and the smb standard) fix, mainly with bigger directory tree's. Some things with speical characters cause issues too but I can't remember what it was off the top of my head. I know a few places that used 3rd party apple talk addons for windows server to correct this. Best option is to just kill smb signing via the gpo for the mac users and let it connect that way.
 
Back
Top