Mac Mini vs. Windows Build

regnak

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 29, 2007
Messages
165
The other night my Aunt called me and told me that she was looking at purchasing an iMac, however, when she called for financing they convinced her that $1,800 was quite steep to be paying for a computer when you could build your own for considerably cheaper. Now, I don’t know how the hell she got to $1,800 but I’m going to assume that she was looking at the 20” version plus some upgrades.

Knowing my Aunt she won’t really be playing video games but she will be doing photo and video editing. Now for photo and video editing I believe a Mac would be better mainly because they come with iPhoto and iMovie which are quite easy to use and I truthfully do not believe she’ll be working in Photoshop or something that professional. I was looking at some Mac-Minis for her but they look underpowered. I know that you can’t directly compare PC and Mac specs so would, let’s say, the basic specs of 1.83GHz and 512MB of RAM at the price point of $800 be enough for what she wants to do? I’d then have her buy an external hard drive for more space as doubling your hard drive space from 80GB to 160GB is a $200 increase in price which is outrageous when you can just purchase an external for much cheaper.

Or, should I go the PC route and build her a PC where I’d focus on productivity and silence with the following specs (which are subject to change upon recommendation):
Case: Antec P180 Silver ($118.17)
CPU HSF: Zalman CNPS-9500 ($49.99)
Disk Drive: LG Black SATA DVD Burner ($29.99)
Hard Drive: Samsung Spinpoint SP2504C 250gb ($66.99)
Power Supply: Corsair 520HX ($86.08)
RAM: G.Skill 2gb DDR2-800 NQs ($88.99)
Video Card: eVGA 7600GS 256mb ($74.99)
Video Card HSF: Zalman VF-900 ($34.98)

Up for contest:
CPU: AMD X2 5200+ ($128.00)
Motherboard: Abit AN52 nForce 520 ($68.99)
OR
CPU: Intel C2D E4400 ($126.01)
Motherboard: Gigabyte GA-945P-S3 ($68.99)

Operating system: Vista 64Bit OEM ($89.00)
OR
Operating system: Windows XP Pro ($89)

Both Intel/AMD builds total at about $835.

In the end I could always shave off quite a bit from the price by forgetting about silence and using the stock coolers and a cheaper case; what are everyone’s thoughts about this? So, should I have my Aunt purchase the Mac Mini or should I throw together a PC similar to this making changes as recommended based on what she wants to do.
 
Back
Top