• Some users have recently had their accounts hijacked. It seems that the now defunct EVGA forums might have compromised your password there and seems many are using the same PW here. We would suggest you UPDATE YOUR PASSWORD and TURN ON 2FA for your account here to further secure it. None of the compromised accounts had 2FA turned on.
    Once you have enabled 2FA, your account will be updated soon to show a badge, letting other members know that you use 2FA to protect your account. This should be beneficial for everyone that uses FSFT.

M3A1 Prototype - Customizable SFF Aluminum Case

Status
Not open for further replies.

CMadki4

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Feb 3, 2011
Messages
4,438
Closed for now. Slammed with other projects. When I reopen this project I will be going in a slightly different direction. Thanks all for your input! I'll be sure to keep you all posted. :)

Banner_02.jpg


INTRO
[H]i folks! Inspired by my interactions with people these forums and locally, I set out to start my own company: M3 Case Designs, where my goal is to offer unique fabrication services to enthusiasts by an enthusiast. So I built a CNC plasma cutter, purchased a brake press and some other used equipment and got to work. Having spent the last 6 years as a Manufacturing Engineer (and many more years Lord willing) I'm taking what I've learned and applying it in smaller scale. As always I appreciate the feedback, support and honesty from [H] members and your extensive knowledge in your perspective areas of expertise.

CONCEPT
Rather than chase the ever elusive "perfect case", the idea here with the M3A1 case is to offer a base model and give you modular options to add or subtract features. This way you can have the case you want and need for your specific taste and requirements. Configure it how you want it. Build your "perfect case", so to speak. And you're not limited to a list of options. If you think of it, I can probably make it. Or damned if I won't give it my best!

SPECS
M3A1, aptly named as the first case model being offered, is a small all aluminum. (Fun fact: It also coincidentally shares the same designation as the famous "grease gun" used by Allied Forces during WWII). Designed to be reconfigured with various hard drive brackets, face plates, power supply locations and side panels, it's meant to customized. No Dremel required ;)

The specifications may vary as the prototype takes shape, but here are the preliminaries:

Standard Features:

  1. All aluminum, black textured powder coat finish (custom colors available)
  2. USB3.0
  3. Compact, portable and rugged
  4. Fits 11.5" graphics card
  5. Two (2) 2.5" drives + one (1) 3.5" drive
  6. Two (2) 120mm fan locations (front and side)
  7. 145mm CPU cooler overhead clearance (with front mounted SFX PSU configuration)
  8. SFX or ATX power supply (SFX front or rear, ATX rear only)
  9. Desktop or mini tower orientation (set on it's bottom or sides)
Custom Options: (just to give you an idea, but not limited to...)

  1. Vertical orientation (rear panel UP)
  2. Custom lengths (more or less GPU length capacity)
  3. More HDD brackets in lieu of graphics card
  4. Custom face plate (HD Audio, USB3.0, LED ring power button, or completely clean/blank)
  5. Extended mATX version
  6. Extended full custom water loop version
  7. Engraving and custom cutouts
ITXassembly_06-1.jpg


This work log will follow the development and fabrication of the M3A1 prototype. The CNC plasma cutter is dialed in, I've got a pallet of aluminum sheets and all the Solidworks designing for round one is complete (and I'll be honest, the chassis is already cut, bent and riveted together as we speak ;) ).

Stay tuned!
----------------------------------------------------------
UPDATES:

UPDATE 4: Variations; 1/2/2013

Happy new years everyone! I haven't forgotten this project. But I have been reevaluating things and looking at a few different layouts. In addition to the cube style case I'm looking at making something along the size and layout of a console system.

Here's a rough idea of what I'm chewing over now:
comparisonassembly-1.jpg


On the left is M3A1 as originally built (see OP). Next over is a shorter version of M3A1. Then we have a slim layout and a slightly less slim layout. I'll share more as I think through these and get feedback from you all.

----------------------------------------------------------
Previous Updates:

This is the prototype as it sits now. I've cut the front, rear and side panels as well as the motherboard tray. They went together quite nicely and just with a few rivets in it is extremely rigid and sturdy. It's cut from 0.063" (1.6mm) 5052H32 aluminum sheets; a nice aluminum to work with. There are a few things I have noticed already and I've changed the *.sldprts and update the NC files so they will be fixed in the next run. For now, I'll move forward with cutting the additional brackets and covers and see what other changes to add to the punch list.
m3a1_01.jpg

m3a1_02.jpg

m3a1_03.jpg

m3a1_04.jpg

m3a1_05.jpg
I've started developing the vertical stance version of M3A1. This setup is popular for it's limited use of desktop (small footprint) and excellent thermodynamics with the "chimney effect" (i.e. heat rises). The chassis itself remains unchanged, but it sits on a base and is topped with a cover for all the cables.
vertm3a1-1.jpg
I cut the 2.5" SSD/HDD bracket and set it in the case for a quick test fit. Like a glove! I'm going to change this bracket to also hold a 3.5" on the backside.
IMG_4150-1.jpg

IMG_4158-1.jpg
 
Last edited:
Good cases with customized primary features is a business model that I think should have existed a long time ago. I do t know if it will work out for you, but I hope it does.

You obviously know what you're doing since you've already built a case. But I have a suggestion. Rather than clone a sg05, how about an innovative design that is harder for big companies to pull off. For instance, to sell large volumes they need to support large sets of components. If you test with a slim handful you can design a better more unique case with only part selection as a catch.

Reading the falcon northwest tiki story you can see the only cooler they could use was the water cooler they chose. But they designed that years ago. Now there are many slim cpu coolers, and ivy bridge heat output is very limited and well understood. Take silverstone's sfx 450w, a couple slim heatsinks, the asus itx, a pcie riser, and a gtx 680. Lets see what you can do with that! You can even try it with no internal storage. This can be added though 3 and 5 inch external bays, reducing capacity but maintaining versatility...

Look at tom bihn bags for an inspiration to your business. High quality, hand made in the usa, expensive but worth it, and with many high margin expansion/customization options available. Just like food and free to play games, high margin treats for those who have more money than sense are how you bring home the bacon
 
Here's an option that I considered in the past, and I know I'm not alone because someone asked about it on this very forum the other day: adding more power with some combination using a pico psu. Imagine selling a case with no gpu support (Cheapest pico psu?), gpu support (big psu), and high power gpu support (Gtx 690 support with both psus and the adaptor to make it work). This is the kind of stiff a big volume business has a hard time understanding, and it leaves the niche open for a low volume high margin business to enter.
 
Here's an option that I considered in the past, and I know I'm not alone because someone asked about it on this very forum the other day: adding more power with some combination using a pico psu.

Imagine selling a case with no gpu support (Cheapest pico psu?), gpu support (big psu), and high power gpu support (Gtx 690 support with both psus and the adapter to make it work). This is the kind of stuff a big volume business has a hard time understanding, and it leaves the niche open for a low volume high margin business to enter.
 
...Take silverstone's sfx 450w, a couple slim heatsinks, the asus itx, a pcie riser, and a gtx 680. Lets see what you can do with that!...

Thanks!

I've considered the above as well and will develop a slim case as I get a little deeper. But if someone approached me wanting such a slim gaming case I could fabricate one for them and offer it thereafter.

I'm going to start with this case, work out the bugs and fine tune the whole design to manufacturing process, taking feedback as I go.

I've got a notebook full of sketch of unique case designs I'd like to make. But if anyone wants a different case style or something special I can make cases on demand per request. That's the advantage of doing everything in house. :)
I've done a few other unique cases per customer specifications with great success. Now I'm going to try to have a few regular products offerings that I can produce in larger quantities to offer a lower unit cost.
 
Last edited:
Here's an option that I considered in the past, and I know I'm not alone because someone asked about it on this very forum the other day: adding more power with some combination using a pico psu.

Imagine selling a case with no gpu support (Cheapest pico psu?), gpu support (big psu), and high power gpu support (Gtx 690 support with both psus and the adapter to make it work). This is the kind of stuff a big volume business has a hard time understanding, and it leaves the niche open for a low volume high margin business to enter.

Interesting. That's an good idea. And totally doable. You hit the nail on the head with filling the gap a large manufacturer can't afford to fill themselves.
 
Pardon the awful cell pictures (oof, they are bad). My DSLR is currently out on loan.

This is just the rough first run prototype. I didn't expect to actually use the first parts I cut, but when test cutting they turned out so well I figured why not!?

I've already pinned a few dimensional changes I want to make. Subtle little changes that will help overall functionality.

Edit: [photos deleted and replaced with better ones in OP]
 
Last edited:
Ooh, nice! I like where this is headed. :D
Thanks!

I've also designed a water cooling iteration of this case, capable of a complete custom loop with a 120 and 240 radiator setup. A tight squeeze, but it theoretically should work. We'll see when a physical prototype takes shape and I flesh out the details.
 
Looks neet. Wouldn't mind seeing a mATX version of this, just so you could do a dual slot SLI, IE gtx 680. Looks very interesting.

Is this for a client, or something that we can buy direct?

May be my next mATX case. There aren't many really good ones out there right now. :(
 
this is a near identical layout to the Lian Li PC-Q08
Layout varies very little from case to case. Especially on SFF there are a limited number of ways you can configure each component relative to each other and stay compact. The layout make look similar now, but this is significantly smaller than the Q08 and has a few very key differences that haven't been revealed yet. :)

Looks neet. Wouldn't mind seeing a mATX version of this, just so you could do a dual slot SLI, IE gtx 680. Looks very interesting.

Is this for a client, or something that we can buy direct?

May be my next mATX case. There aren't many really good ones out there right now. :(

A mATX version is totally doable.

This particular case is not for a client, it's purely a prototype. Once I get this design and it's option parts squared away it will be available for purchase and customization on my website. But at any time you can request a quote for exactly what you want whether it's based on this design or something completely different. :)
 
So are you selling custom cases once you finish with the prototype? I might be interested if the price is right.
 
So are you selling custom cases once you finish with the prototype? I might be interested if the price is right.
Absolutely, yes. These cases will be available once the prototype is complete. But if you want something now I do custom case designs on demand as well. I'm working a slim mATX gaming case and a hanging 24x3.5"HDD enclosure for two other [H] members, so I'm always up for custom jobs!
 
Absolutely, yes. These cases will be available once the prototype is complete. But if you want something now I do custom case designs on demand as well. I'm working a slim mATX gaming case and a hanging 24x3.5"HDD enclosure for two other [H] members, so I'm always up for custom jobs!

How nice. But first, how much does it cost + shipping. I love my CoolerMaster Elite 120 Advanced. However, there is just one flaw, I have very little options when it comes to cooling the CPU. If you can somehow still build the chasis to the same specs and dimension as the Coolermaster Elite 120 Advanced, I would definitely be interested if the price is right.

Thanks man.
 
How nice. But first, how much does it cost + shipping. I love my CoolerMaster Elite 120 Advanced. However, there is just one flaw, I have very little options when it comes to cooling the CPU. If you can somehow still build the chasis to the same specs and dimension as the Coolermaster Elite 120 Advanced, I would definitely be interested if the price is right.

Thanks man.
The Elite 120 is a cool case. Since this case is still under development I don't know what the final cost will be. But it will be more than the Elite 120.

What features of the Elite 120 in particular are you wanting retain? Other than improved CPU overhead for my cooler options, what are you wanting to be different?
 
I've updated the OP, putting the updates in there as apposed to in replies.
 
For those interested in using such a case as a NAS, how many drives would you like to see crammed in there? (realistically, haha)
 
For those interested in using such a case as a NAS, how many drives would you like to see crammed in there? (realistically, haha)

Personally, I consider 4 3.5" drives to be an absolute minimum for a NAS. Video can fill up even 4TB drives rather quickly. If you could shoehorn between 6 and 8 3.5" drives into a nice, small footprint, you may have a winner on your hands. Just my opinion.
 
I'm going to take another look at getting as many drives in there as possible. Having no graphics card helps big time. Getting them in there isn't actually too bad, but making sure they fit AND are properly cooled is more complex. Maintaining good airflow with a tiny box full of little warm spinning disks is tough. But where there is a will there is a way!
 
more input for you: this, like the falcon northwest tiki, is my idea of a good time: http://www.g-alantic.com.tw/1082/ga620 and http://www.e-itx.com/ga620.html . these guys even sell the riser and the power if you check the accessories. and multiple different configs, too. you can see from the internal pictures that they've pushed the design tighter than most would try...

input #2: one problem I have with high end stuff into a tiny space is dust from all the air flow. I don't like dust, and most cases are bad at dealing with dust period, but it gets worse with small ones. they usually don't even have a filter. BUT, if a system is designed to not use much air flow (rare load periods excluded), then you can get away with not dealing with dust. thanks to modern low power idle hardware, this is becoming a reality.
 
Last edited:
Subbed

Very nice work so far. Can't wait to see more updates.
Thank you very much!

Small Update: I'm having to redesign the structure of the case. While it is extremely sturdy as it is now, the materials cost is just too high. This would drive the cost the cost too high, imo. So, I'm looking at reducing the amount of material required without sacrificing structure integrity, function or aesthetics.
 
Rather than make any compromises in the design, I've found a different supplier for my aluminum locally that can supply me with a better $/lb rate. Game on...

Currently under development:

  1. vertical version covers
  2. ssd/hdd bracket
  3. misc. improvements/countermeasures
  4. and a new slim version w/ full sized dual PCI expansion slots
I expect to be cutting new parts this week. It's busy with Christmas just around the corner so bare with me. :)

ITXassembly_02_SLIM-1.jpg
 
Last edited:
wow, now THAT is hot - what kind of PCIE-16x riser are you looking at to get the connection from the board to the bottom of the card (near the edge of the case)? Ribbon?
 
wow, now THAT is hot - what kind of PCIE-16x riser are you looking at to get the connection from the board to the bottom of the card (near the edge of the case)? Ribbon?
Haha, thanks Machup! Not sure on the ribbon riser, I've haven't sourced that yet. Recommendations?
 
The ribbons are actually pretty sucky (and not flexible enough to do a short-radius 180 at the edge of the case at the base of the vid card) -- I think you might have better luck flipping the video card 180 degrees (so the screw-down flange is away from the mobo) and then dropping it to the bottom and putting the SFX psu on top. Then you could just use a 90 degree riser directly off the mobo :)
 
I see my busy spell has left you with idle hands :) Cool concepts and it looks great so far!
 
Good cases with customized primary features is a business model that I think should have existed a long time ago. I do t know if it will work out for you, but I hope it does.

You obviously know what you're doing since you've already built a case. But I have a suggestion. Rather than clone a sg05, how about an innovative design that is harder for big companies to pull off. For instance, to sell large volumes they need to support large sets of components. If you test with a slim handful you can design a better more unique case with only part selection as a catch.

Reading the falcon northwest tiki story you can see the only cooler they could use was the water cooler they chose. But they designed that years ago. Now there are many slim cpu coolers, and ivy bridge heat output is very limited and well understood. Take silverstone's sfx 450w, a couple slim heatsinks, the asus itx, a pcie riser, and a gtx 680. Lets see what you can do with that! You can even try it with no internal storage. This can be added though 3 and 5 inch external bays, reducing capacity but maintaining versatility...

Look at tom bihn bags for an inspiration to your business. High quality, hand made in the usa, expensive but worth it, and with many high margin expansion/customization options available. Just like food and free to play games, high margin treats for those who have more money than sense are how you bring home the bacon

Be sure to check out the ThreeZero Project worklog as well, I think you will find a lot of what you are talking about right there. Good thoughts.
 
The smallest possible case would be something like this, while still supporting a very powerful video card. No overclocks, though, given the small CPU cooler (but you could use the new Noctua L9i, which is better than intel's default). The mod author preferred to dismantle an ATX PSU, but i think it would be better using the Silverstone SFX psu, as it should fit. And i wouldn't use any front fan(s) and just rely on each component's cooling fan (gpu, cpu and psu). It would make a very open case, so dust could be a problem, if no filters are used. But than you'll have a monster pc in the space of a small NAS, even smaller than a console, i think.

As for the smallest SG05-like case (i.e. no pci risers used), i think it can be achieved only by using an integrated w/c like Corsair H60 and placing the PSU (SFX or ATX) directly over the CPU area, while the radiator sits at the front of the case. Thus, the height of the case is reduced, it should be around 14 cm. Of course, you lose the optical drive, but i don't think many will miss it.
 
Last edited:
The smallest possible case would be something like this, while still supporting a very powerful video card. No overclocks, though, given the small CPU cooler (but you could use the new Noctua L9i, which is better than intel's default). The mod author preferred to dismantle an ATX PSU, but i think it would be better using the Silverstone SFX psu, as it should fit. And i wouldn't use any front fan(s) and just rely on each component's cooling fan (gpu, cpu and psu). It would make a very open case, so dust could be a problem, if no filters are used. But than you'll have a monster pc in the space of a small NAS, even smaller than a console, i think.

As for the smallest SG05-like case (i.e. no pci risers used), i think it can be achieved only by using an integrated w/c like Corsair H60 and placing the PSU (SFX or ATX) directly over the CPU area, while the radiator sits at the front of the case. Thus, the height of the case is reduced, it should be around 14 cm. Of course, you lose the optical drive, but i don't think many will miss it.
Hey, that's a badass little case that guy is building!

Yeah, with the influx of ideas for a slim case rather than the mini cube, I've gone off on a tangent designing that slim ITX in the picture above. It looks nothing like that now. The mini cube (SG05 variant) is what it is. It can get a little smaller, but basically M3A1 is a answer to the call for an all aluminum mini ITX case capable of holding full length GPUs. Making it smaller is just another challenge to add to the checklist.

I'm fired up on the slim ITX design now too. But I really need to follow through with M3A1 first. In all honesty, I have enough of both designs completed to cut parts and make a prototype of each. Problem is I'm busy as hell with other custom cases! I need another one of me in the shop. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top