Looking for storage advice (new setup) [detailed post]

sn0man

Gawd
Joined
Jan 25, 2007
Messages
609
Current Setup

3 disks (Maxtor DiamondMax 10, 16MB buffer, ATA-133)
Disk 1 - separate IDE cable
Disk 2 & 3 - same IDE cable​



Disk 1: 1 Partition, 150GB (14.2GB used), Windows Installation & Installed Programs - reformat & clean install every 2-3 months

Disk 2: 4 Partitions, 300GB (~230GB used)
  1. Documents - moderately changed/modified
  2. Photos - rarely changed/modified
  3. New Downloads - heavily changed/modified
  4. Misc. Storage - heavily changed/modified

Disk 3: 1 Partition, 300GB (~260GB used), Music archives - usage grows in amount but once files are stored they're rarely changed/modified


History

My hard drives are now the oldest part (by far) of the computer I built about a year ago. They were used in my old HP Pavilion from a few years back, and have been with me ever since. The old drives are PATA, and my new motherboard has 3 SATA-II slots so I'm looking to take full advantage.

I like the idea of a separate drive for Windows-only: for performance reasons & since I reformat often, and would like my other data to remain untouched. I was thinking of the new Velociraptors for that, but I don't do a ton of gaming or video editing - so I'm not sure if the cost for performance would be as noticeable/beneficial as for others. And as you can see, after my ~15GB of installs the rest of the 300GB or even 150GB of a Velociraptor would go unused.

The second new drive I'd like to get would be for my Docs/Photos/Downloads/Misc. Storage. Since I last set up my drives years ago, I've been reading a lot of differing opinions on partitioning - mainly people starting to steer away from it in favor of single disks just separated by folders (or whatever). Looking at my disk usage (above), I'm wondering what opinions you guys had on the matter.

Finally, I'd like an updated drive for storage of my music files. This drive would have to be big, with room for future needs. IF recommended NOT to partition the 2nd drive above (with the docs/downloads/etc.), I'm wondering whether it would be best simply to combine this Music drive along with my documents and everything else - on something huge like a 1.5TB disk instead. Once again, keep in mind my disk usage.


Ideas for the New Setup

What I'm looking for are recommendations & opinions on how I can improve my setup.

Key points:
  • NOT a gamer / video editor
  • NOT looking to set up a RAID
  • do NOT have an unlimited budget

  • I'm looking for performance/longevity first, but also value & bang-for-the-buck

The 1st drive that came to mind for my Windows/Programs installation was the WD Velociraptor, but given what I've said if there's something smaller and less expensive but close in performance that would be great - unless someone wants to convince me just to splurge on the raptor.

As for the 2nd drive (or 2nd & 3rd), I've been considering the Seagate 7200.11's or WD Caviar Blacks. If buying 2 drives, I was thinking of a 500GB or so for Docs/etc., and 1TB for Music. If it's recommended I push all that stuff together, I'd probably be thinking of a 1TB or 1.5TB.



Any thoughts / ideas / recommendations are HIGHLY appreciated.
(general setup, number of drives to use, partitioning or not, brands, models, etc.)​
 
Well if you truly want a separate drive for the OS and you want a fast one I would get a WD6400AAKS, its typically the fastest 7200rpm drive...I know you only use ~20gb so you might be thinking this is a waste, but its fast and only about $75....you can also make it faster by shortstroking it...when you install windows only make the partition 25-30gb or whatever you deem to be the max needed amt...this will increase your random access times to that close of a vraptor, and you will have high throughput as well.

For storage I'd go with a single drive...depending on how much you want to spend go with a 1tb or 1.5tb both are great values about $0.13/gb.
 
Would you advise against using a separate drive for Windows only? I was just always under the impression that performance would be better if things that ran concurrently had their own cable/channel/whatever.

If I were to put everything on a single drive, I'm guessing you'd recommend just partitioning off the first 30gb or so for my Windows installs, and then putting everything else together on the 2nd partition?
 
For the ultimate performance...yea a separate drive for the OS....but you dont really lose that much when using the drive for both...Also its one less thing to break, less heat, power, noise, etc...you get the idea. I have several systems with just one 640gb and I put aside 64GB for the OS and leave the rest for data and it is plenty fast for daily desktop use.
 
I'd suggest a pair of the 640gb drives, put the OS on a ~60gb partition on one with your music+pics in the remaining space. Put everything else on the other drive.
 
Back
Top