Looking for low wattage replacement for 9800PRO

cruci

n00b
Joined
Sep 18, 2006
Messages
3
Over the next few months I'm going to be installing my computer in my motorhome, and I need to replace the power hungry 9800PRO with something that uses a little (or a lot!) less power.

I am guessing that the 9800PRO being the top of the line card from several generations ago, there must be a budget version from a more recent generation that will give me the same or similar performance, but not need all that extra wattage.

It needs to be AGP, I have no preference between ATI or nVidia, and I wouldn't want to have my performance go down ideally.

The rest of my specs = AMD 64 2800, 1 gig ram, Gigabyte Triton K8 mobo.

Also, the part needs to be sourced in the UK.

Thanks.
 
That seems like a tough question to answer, mabey not. Just about any of the new generation cards that will give equal or better performance will be as or greater in power consumption that your 9800pro. Some one here could probably answer this better than I did, but I'll check around and see if I can find something for you.
 
I did a little research and X-bit labs has a few articles on the subject of power consumption.
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/video/display/gpu-consumption2006_7.html
Google yielded that a 9800 pro consumes about 47 watts under load which is more that I thought. According to X-bit the x800GT, X1600XT, 6800 or the 6600GT all produce close to that, it went as far as the X800GTO is about max with in your range for power. These are some good viable option to the 9800PRO, especially the 6600GT. Do a google search for power consumption of modern video cards and judge for your self.
 
RadDad said:
I did a little research and X-bit labs has a few articles on the subject of power consumption.
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/video/display/gpu-consumption2006_7.html
Google yielded that a 9800 pro consumes about 47 watts under load which is more that I thought. According to X-bit the x800GT, X1600XT, 6800 or the 6600GT all produce close to that, it went as far as the X800GTO is about max with in your range for power. These are some good viable option to the 9800PRO, especially the 6600GT. Do a google search for power consumption of modern video cards and judge for your self.

Thanks for that, great article. What I'm after is similar gfx performance, lower power consumption. I am hoping that I can go for something like a x1300, but now I need to compare gfx performance...
 
If I am not mistaken the X1300 series is very similar in performance until you get to higher resolutions. You have to remember that the X300, X600, X700,X1300 and X1600 are all 128bit memory interface so higher resolutions and eye candy will slow thwm a bit. Your best bet is to get a X800 pro or the 6600GT you will get more than enough performance with about the same wattage consumed.
 
RadDad said:
If I am not mistaken the X1300 series is very similar in performance until you get to higher resolutions. You have to remember that the X300, X600, X700,X1300 and X1600 are all 128bit memory interface so higher resolutions and eye candy will slow thwm a bit. Your best bet is to get a X800 pro or the 6600GT you will get more than enough performance with about the same wattage consumed.

Yeah, I'm trying to maintain performance but reduce wattage, not increase performance and maintain wattage ;)

All the 6600 GT cards I've seen have extra molex power connectors, so I don't think they're really going to be low wattage. The 6600 GDDR3 card in the xbit labs article above seems to only be PCI-E, so no good to me.

The x1300 is looking to be the one, surely it can't be THAT much worse than the 9800pro? :(
 
As far as I know, an AGP 7600 GS has simultaneously better performance and lower power consumption. I believe it lower power consumption than any of the cards mentioned.
 
x1400 mobility but its clocked the same as a regular x1300 so yea its good for games. CSS fear cod2. for res 8x6 for 10x8.
 
arthur_tuxedo As far as I know, an AGP 7600 GS has simultaneously better performance and lower power consumption. I believe it lower power consumption than any of the cards mentioned.


He is correct it uses about 5-8 watts less than the 9800 pro. That card will rock for you in the performance arena. I know you want to maintain the same performance lessen your wattage, but to gain quite abit of performance and still reduce your wattage that would be the ticket. Great call arthur!
 
Agree with the 7600 GT. That card would probably have the best performance per watt of any current mid-range card. The 7600 GS would shave off another 7-8 watts when loaded and should provide enough performance. According to Bit-Tech, the 7600 GS is a tad bit faster than the X1600 XT, which is a very capable card (though consumes as much power as a 7600 GT). Certainly fast enough to run through the gamut of most current games so long as the resolution is low (preferably 10x7).

EDIT: Oh, and MSI is one AIB that's currently doing a 7600 GS in AGP.
 
RadDad said:
He is correct it uses about 5-8 watts less than the 9800 pro. That card will rock for you in the performance arena. I know you want to maintain the same performance lessen your wattage, but to gain quite abit of performance and still reduce your wattage that would be the ticket. Great call arthur!
Thanks! :)

Although I'm starting to feel like a pimp for the 7600 series. But hey, if it stops making sense to recommend them, I'll stop doing it.
 
I take it that you are already using an lcd monitor and not a crt of any size.
last year when i was on generator power my 21" crt would bog the generator down on startup :eek: :D
 
If you want to get similar performance with lower wattage, you might pick up an x800 pro and underclock it. You could sacrifice quite a bit of clockspeed and still come out on top of your 9800 pro with pretty low energy consumption.
 
Back
Top