Looking for an LCD with pretty specific requirements

dderidex

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Oct 31, 2001
Messages
6,328
I've decided it is time for an LCD upgrade. Thing is, I'm being very limited with the budget primarily because I just don't use the PC with high-demanding applications enough to need something spendy. Also don't need a lot of real estate, as we have a modest sized condo, so 30"+ monitors are just ridiculous.

For comparison, I'm currently running a 5:4 ratio 17" Sony SDM-HS75P. I like the responsiveness and color of this monitor plenty. To be clear on this - I have no complaints about this monitor, and like it fine.

However, we are watching quite a bit of movies on it, and I'd like to get a monitor more 'flat' than 'tall'...so, looking at the widescreen (1440x900) 19" LCD monitors as an upgrade.

I happen to PARTICULARLY like (about the monitor I have, and my wife's laptop) the 'glossy' coatings newer LCDs seem to have. I had a few Dells back in the day (2005fpw, for example) and rather HATED the look of them without it.

Anyway, budget is $200.

This one seems like an obvious choice. A poster over at Anandtech recommended this as an option, too, although it wasn't a terribly STRONG recommendation (more of a 'I've heard of this one, at least'). I was even looking at this one over at Best Buy, although it doesn't have the coating I like...I would get Rewardzone points for it (enough to push me into another gift card, so basically $20 off) and also there is the whole 'instant gratification' thing.

So....thoughts?
 
Check out the LG227WTG at bestbuy

Its 22 inches though (On sale for $289 this week) and is really nice. I just picked one up and I love it. Has a glossy screen and looks really nice.

EDIT: oh damn I didnt see your budget nvm, sorry
 
How reliable is that site? I'm leery of 'refurbs' - especially with LCDs. Picked up something like that from Dell once, had over a dozen dead or 'bright' pixels.

Well, either that site doesn't regularly update its inventory stock or no one seems to be willing to buy that LCD because it's been at 96 stock for a while now.
 
How reliable is that site? I'm leery of 'refurbs' - especially with LCDs. Picked up something like that from Dell once, had over a dozen dead or 'bright' pixels.

I would not buy an LCD online. If it has stuck or dead pixels it will be a pain in the ass to exchange, I got two samsung monitors this week from samsclub and both had stuck pixels. I ended up returning them both then going over to bestbuy and getting my LG monitor. The geeks squad plugged it in and ran a stuck pixel finder on it before I left the store too. Great place to pick up an LCD monitor.
 
I would not buy an LCD online. If it has stuck or dead pixels it will be a pain in the ass to exchange, I got two samsung monitors this week from samsclub and both had stuck pixels. I ended up returning them both then going over to bestbuy and getting my LG monitor. The geeks squad plugged it in and ran a stuck pixel finder on it before I left the store too. Great place to pick up an LCD monitor.

Did you have to pay for that?

Last time I was LCD shopping at Best Buy was when I actually picked up the monitor I have. I asked them 'so...can you guys check this for dead pixels'? No. 'Can I at least open it in the store to see if there is any cosmetic damage or anything?' Not without buying it, no. The fellow was rather rude about me even asking that.
 
No they didnt charge me. I had to buy it first though.

But I could have returned it if it had a stuck pixel.

The guy I asked was really nice about it.

I asked can you check it for a stuck pixel? And he said Yeah sure but we cant open it until you buy it. Just go buy it then head over to the geek squad counter and they will test it out for you.

They ran dead pixel buddy on it and everything.
 
Back
Top