looking for advice on HTPC build

tmaz08

n00b
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
6
Hello:

I am looking to build an HTPC, primarily for DVD/Bluray playback on a 32" Panasonic Viera (720p). As I want to rip my collections onto the computer, I will ultimately reqiure a lot of HD space. While I don't intend on doing any gaming on the computer, I would like to able to use some CPU-intensive software (Photoshop, Macromedia Studio, MATLAB, etc.).

With that in mind, based on what I have read here and on other sites, here is the build that I am considering:

Proposed Build

I will add a Bluray drive later. I also plan on adding more of those 640 GB hard drives for storage. I am planning on using Vista, mainly because I have heard that Bluray playback on Linux is very challenging. Were Bluray playback an option on Linux, however, I would gladly pursue that route. As I mention below, I plan on using a case that I already own.

What do you guys think of this build given my intentions for the computer? A couple of questions in particular:

1. Is that a good choice for a power supply?
2. Do you recommend including that smaller HD for my OS? Am I better off just getting 1 TB drives now if I want space?
3. Will I have problems with HD playback if I include a lot of software on the computer?

I actually already have a PC hooked up to a 40" Bravia. It is a five year old desktop with an IC7-G, Pentium 4 (3 GHz), 1GB DDR400, and Radeon 9800 Pro. My plan is to use the case (Lian Li PC-60) from this machine for the HTPC (to save money). The case is meant for an ATX motherboard, but the board that I would like to get is micro ATX...

4. Do you know if micro ATX boards generally fit in ATX cases?
5. Would I be better off just getting a new case?

I actually ultimately plan on building a second HTPC for the 40" Bravia, but this machine will be more gaming oriented. Were I somehow able to salvage my old computer, however, I might do that in the meantime...

6 . Is it worth even bothering?

The machine will currently play DVDs on my Bravia, but it's very loud and I have little HD space together with only two SATA 150 connections.

I really appreciate any advice/suggestions that you can offer. Thanks a lot.
 
1. I'm not an expert on power supplies--you would probably get better feedback from the appropriate subforum. In any case, though, what you have is not a very demanding rig, power-wise--I'd be surprised if the whole thing draws 200W when finished.
2. An 80GB drive is fine--you won't save much money or get any other benefit from using a smaller drive.
3. Assuming the extra software isn't things like spyware, viruses, etc, you'll be fine.
4. Yes.
5. That's up to you--it's a matter of aesthetics more than anything else.
6. It depends on what games you plan to play. Crysis, of course, is a no-go. Personally, I'd recommend parting out the old rig, and using the money from that to subsidize the purchase of new hardware.

If you're not going to purchase a Blu-ray drive right now, I'd recommend you give Linux a try. There are some fantastic guides out there that will take you step-by-step through the process, with pictures and everything.

One thing I didn't notice on your list was a remote. Do you have a plan for that?
 
1. Looks good. Corsair makes nice PSU's.

2. A small HDD for the OS is recommended. I do recommend it just for the sake of easily being able to reformat without having any of the video data on the same hard drive. Plus it makes less of a chance of your video stuttering due to video and the OS being on the same drive, especially in the case of high definition video.

3. Depends what software. Usually for a HTPC, you should try to keep everything to a minimum, using it only for audio/video use. If you do install tons of programs, just make sure there's no tasks or anything running in the background that eat up your CPU usage.

4. Yes, microATX boards fit in ATX cases.

5. It's up to you. I recommend a case with super quiet fans (low speed ~800rpm) and a 'quiet' case to begin with. Shock mounted hard drives, foam padding on the case insides, etc.

6. It's all up to if you think the cost benefit is worth it if you have to put any money into it. If you say it's too loud, I'd just throw some silent fans in it, maybe a new heatsink on the CPU, and call it a day. It shouldn't be much more than $70.

And just as a side note, you don't even need a fan on that Mini Ninja heatsink with the AMD 5000+ 65nm. I run mine passive with no fan and it works great and never even gets hot. All I use it for is high def media, and I can confirm it presents zero problems for hours of extended viewing.
 
Thanks a lot for your response... very helpful.

I do not have plans for a remote at the moment. I should have mentioned that I do not have plans in the immediate future of watching/recording TV on the computer. With that being said, however, I would like a remote for ease of use.

The main issue that I need to decide on before buying is the case. By using my old Lian-Li mid-tower, I will save money. I'm not sure, however, whether this will function well as an HTPC case... Here is a link to a newer model of my case:

Newer generation of my case

My case actually has a window on the side with a pair of fans (one intake, one exhaust over CPU). With that setup I think I could overlook a CPU fan, as you recommended w1retap. The case includes nothing that I'm aware of though for noise dampening... I suppose I could add these things myself.

I would actually prefer Linux, but I'm hesitant to bother because I will add Bluray in the very near future.

Thanks again for the responses.

EDIT: I actually don't have a lot of space for my case near my Panasonic... I can either sit the computer upright on the carpet next to my TV stand or fit the computer on its side in my TV stand. Would there be any issues in lying my case on its side on a TV shelf? In this setup, the DVD/Bluray drive would sit on its side...

I'm actually a bit concerned with having the case upright because the heatsink is so large...
 
You'll be fine with the case in either orientation. Noise control is firstly all about the components you buy--choose low-heat components (which you have) and you can eliminate most of the fans. In general, the machines you see around this forum have way more fans than they need to. Think of all the Dells, HPs, Gateways, eMachines, etc that have a PSU fan and a CPU fan and that's it.

By the way, it IS possible, though technically not legal, to do Bluray playback under Ubuntu.
 
I think that I have settled on my build... After some space considerations, I have actually opted for an HTPC case (ATX)...

One final change that I have made is swapping the GIGABYTE GA-MA78GM-S2H Micro ATX board for the GIGABYTE GA-MA78G-DS3H ATX board. According to Newegg and Gigabyte, these boards should be identical other than the ATX board including more SATA/PCIe connections (which I would like for HD space/wireless card/etc.).

Is there anything that you see that I might lose in going to the new ATX board from the micro ATX board?

Thanks again.. I'm looking forward to setting this up.
 
The AMD+ATI 780G boards are designed for this very thing. The Gigabyte version tends to be the top version in all of the reviews out now.
 
i know you want to save money on the case - but imho - if you are going to put it in your living room... the case matters. not only are you going to get questions when people come over asking what a computer is doing in your audio rack, but you have to look at it all day (i purchased an htpc case years ago when companies were not focusing on htpc cases - i spent a pretty penny on mine - and to this day i'm not liking it).

on that note... i'm have been eying this case:

little brother
big brother
 
That is exactly the case that I am now planning on getting actually (the TF11)...

Unfortunately, it appears as if you cannot get this in the US for a couple of months... Dell lists it on their site with five to seven days shipping, but apparently that is way off...
 
a 750watt thermaltake or corsair psu. u want a high power one that is energy efficient, with a nice big fan that will run cool and not loud :)
 
a 750watt thermaltake or corsair psu. u want a high power one that is energy efficient, with a nice big fan that will run cool and not loud :)

why would you need a huge (expensive) psu? i have a 380w that powers my x2 3800+ with 4 hard drives (1x36gb raptor, 3x500gb seagates), dvd burner, nvidia 8500gt... seems to do the job and it's also nice and quiet!!
 
i was just looking at your cart... another consideration:

i know that ddr2 is cheap nowadays, but 4gb for an htpc is overkill don't you think? you can get some 2gb kits for around $20 after rebate. i'm running 2gb on my htpc and it's been running fine for years (even under vista!!). that'll save you $50 towards your case ;)

edit:

While I don't intend on doing any gaming on the computer, I would like to able to use some CPU-intensive software (Photoshop, Macromedia Studio, MATLAB, etc.).

blah... just noticed that. go with the 4gb. lol
 
i own a nmedia case and i really like it, not a huge name brand but they are nice....
http://www.nmediapc.com/product 2n.htm

2806.jpg
 
Back
Top