Looking for advice about new system upgrade

kur1j

Gawd
Joined
Sep 13, 2003
Messages
682
Well its about that time now my PC is hitting the 3 year mark in about 3 weeks or so and I am going to be looking to upgrade it (I do not really upgrade I just buy a whole new system).

It is an Intel Asus P4C800E-Deluxe, P4 2.8Ghz Prescott, 1GB ram, ATi 9800 Pro. I spent about 1100 dollars on it and I have been extremely impressed. I have not had any real major problems with the system what so ever, mobo did kinda go nutty about a year after I got it but got that fixed in about 2 days. 100% rock solid stable.

To start off, I do not want an AMD based machine so please do not suggest it. I do not feel like explaining my position and why I do not want an AMD based machine, I have my reasons. I have HAD 3 AMD machines and have a bad taste in my mouth about the things. I have had good success with intel and want to stay with them. That is why I am posting this is the intel forums :D.

1.
So to start off with the questions, would it be worth it to wait for the Quad Core CPU's to be viable in a 1000-1100 dollar machine?

I do gaming/school/photoediting/video editing/programming and a few other odd and ends. I do not sit weeks on end encoding video's for work or something but I do get a few people asking me to help them turn home movies into DVD's and stuff like that.

2.
I am assuming the difference in the intel extreme edition and the regular one is still the amount of L2 Cache (X6800 having 2MB of cache per core and the E6700 sharing 4Mb of Cache with both cores). When I bought my prescott the only real difference was the prescott had 1MB L2 Cache the northwood had 512Kb and the P4 Extreme Edition had 2MB of L2 Cahce (not 100% on the numbers but I think its close). Am I correct on my assumption?

I am going to be spending around 1000 dollars on video card/ram/mobo/cpu. I have a nice 21'' monitor, Klipsch 5.1 Pro Media Ultras and plenty of HDD's and a nice case and antec PSU. If I missed anything remind me please but I don't think I did.

I have no idea what motherboard to get but would like an equivalent board to the P4C800-E Deluxe. As for video card I do not have the slightest idea on what to get. Personally do not care as long as it performs well. ATi or NVidia doesn't matter just one that performs well that will fit into the 1000ish budget. Same for ram, the machine I posted above I have corsair XMS memory in it and it hasnt given me any problems.

Sorry for the long post and thanks for taking the time to read it and any responses would be greatly appreicated. Thanks.
 
If you are going to spend around $1000 for the mobo, CPU, RAM, and vid card here is what I recommend.

Asus P5B or Gigabyte 965P-DS3
Core2Duo 6400
EVGA 8800GTS
2x1GB Corsair PC6400 DDR2, the CAS 5-5-5-12 stuff.

The above components will come in right around $950-1000.

You might want to consider getting some SATA optical drives since there is only 1 IDE port on the board, SATA hard drives too if you have IDE drives now.
 
PClark99 said:
If you are going to spend around $1000 for the mobo, CPU, RAM, and vid card here is what I recommend.

Asus P5B or Gigabyte 965P-DS3
Core2Duo 6400
EVGA 8800GTS
2x1GB Corsair PC6400 DDR2, the CAS 5-5-5-12 stuff.

The above components will come in right around $950-1000.

You might want to consider getting some SATA optical drives since there is only 1 IDE port on the board, SATA hard drives too if you have IDE drives now.
Well I have 2x 300GB IDE HDD's and a 36GB SATA raptor and a DVD burner :-/.
 
most new board only have 1 IDE controller and 2 PCI slots... so you could use 1 PCI for a IDE card....
 
don't get the p5b vanilla or p5b-e.. the ram voltage is too low :( kinda regret it, its limiting my overclock to 3336mhz.

the ds3 is much better for overclocking, or the p5b-deluxe (down to $176).

p5b-e is overpriced now that the deluxe dropped $30. ah well!!
 
kur1j said:
2.
I am assuming the difference in the intel extreme edition and the regular one is still the amount of L2 Cache (X6800 having 2MB of cache per core and the E6700 sharing 4Mb of Cache with both cores). When I bought my prescott the only real difference was the prescott had 1MB L2 Cache the northwood had 512Kb and the P4 Extreme Edition had 2MB of L2 Cahce (not 100% on the numbers but I think its close). Am I correct on my assumption?

I have no idea what motherboard to get but would like an equivalent board to the P4C800-E Deluxe. As for video card I do not have the slightest idea on what to get. Personally do not care as long as it performs well.

Sorry for the long post and thanks for taking the time to read it and any responses would be greatly appreicated. Thanks.


All Core 2's share cache. The difference between them is either 2mb or 4mb on the dual cores and 8mb on the quads. Besides the 2.93Ghz clock speed on the X6800, the multiplier is also unlocked. Otherwise it's exactly the same as the E6700 with a 260Mhz speed increase.

I've got an E6700 running in an ASUS P5W-DH Deluxe board that uses Intel 975X chipset. It's older than the 965 chipset so it doesn't support DDR2 800. This board is good for overclocking and comes with a lot of extra features like built-in wireless, dual LANs and a remote to control the PC (although it seems to work only 50% of the time). The 975 series is pretty close to the 875 by comparison.The 965s are the same with the Intel 865s.

I chose mine by reading lots of reviews and checking overclocking features. I also wanted two IDE controllers and wanted one to be part of the chipset instead of using a JMicron controller. Another plus was silent cooling :)
 
this is what I have kinda narrowed it down to.

Corsair TWIN2X2048-6400 2GB Kit DDR2-800 XMS2-6400 Xtreme Performance Memory

$219.90 after rebate.

eVGA 640-P2-N821-AR GeForce 8800GTS 640MB GDDR3 PCI Express x16 HDCP Video Card - Retail

$399.99 after rebate

ASUS P5B Deluxe Socket T (LGA 775) Intel P965 Express ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail

$176.99


the thing I am debating about is the CPU and kinda sketchy on the GPU.

Intel Core 2 Duo E6400 Conroe 2.13GHz LGA 775 Processor Model BX80557E6400 - Retail

$220.00

OR

Intel® Core 2 Duo E6600 Conroe Processor 2.4GHz, 1066FSB, LGA775, 4MB Cache Retail

$311.90

w/ E6400 its $1014

w/E6600 its $1105

would it be worth me to get the 6600, just reading the stuff on tomshardware it looks like the 6600 is right below the 6700 and the Extreme always. Where the E6400 falls down the line a good bit in some of the benchmarks. So would it be worth the $90ish dollars getting the 6600 over the 6400?

Is the video card overkill? No doubt it is a good card being #2 or #3 a lot of the time out of the video card test on tomshardware but I play the majority of my games on 1280x1024 and enjoy it with a few of the eye candys no anything spectacular but decent.

As for my CDROM/IDE delimma I think I am going to just get an SATA DVD burner or something as I got about 50 dollars from bestbuy today for christmas. That would give me 2 SATA (Raptor / CDROM) devices and 2PATA devices (2x 300GB hdds).
 
Well before you posted I did a little research and i saw that it says it recommends a 400W or above :-/.

http://www.club-3d.nl/distri/productinfo/spec_vga.php?ordercode=CGNX-GTS8840

this review says otherwise as well.

http://www.neoseeker.com/Articles/Hardware/Reviews/bfg8800gts/10.html

but if you still think i should get one what would you suggest? I honestly think that I wouldn't have a problem with this PSU but thats just me.


But doing a little more research on this...I did find out on that page I sent you it also says (12V/26A) well I have not seen a single PSU that has a 12V rail that can supply 26Amps. So what are they saying?

Also when I was looking on newegg at the new antec PSU's I saw that it said " 2x PCI-E" connectors. So do these new PCI-E cards require a special power connector other than the regular square 4 pin rectangular regular HDD power cable?
 
keldegar said:
don't get the p5b vanilla or p5b-e.. the ram voltage is too low :( kinda regret it, its limiting my overclock to 3336mhz.

the ds3 is much better for overclocking, or the p5b-deluxe (down to $176).

p5b-e is overpriced now that the deluxe dropped $30. ah well!!

The new p5b-e has 2.2 volts... My P5B is rock solid stable even after overclocking to 3 ghz... I can't say the same thing about the DS3 I used to own..

There is Vdimm mod... You can set it to 2.4volts if you wanted... You don't need anything other than 10k resistor...
 
Back
Top