Looking for a DUAL processor motherboard

dangfx

Gawd
Joined
May 2, 2001
Messages
707
Hey there,

I am looking to build a new SMP rig (workstation mostly for graphics and video), but I havn't made up my mind whether its should be Intel or AMD -based yet.

As things are now, is going dual better for AMD solutions or Intel solutions?

For the motherboard, it should have the following:

--dual CPU (naturally)
--FSB of at least 800mhz
--Memory speed of at least 400mhz (DDR or DDRII)
--either AGP (Pro/50/8x) or PCI Express slot, doesnt matter
--at least 2 SATA ports, RAID capable
--NO onboard SCSI (important!!)
--at least a couple regular PCI slots
--all the rest, like USB2.0, IEEE1394, NIC, wifi, etc.
--SLI not needed

One more question: can an SSI form factor board fit into a standard ATX case? (i already have the case)

One MORE (stupid) question: can you put regular old PCI cards (say, a USB card or an older standard sound card) into a PCI-X slot?


THANKS!!
 
PCI-X can work in PCI albeit slowly, PCI could work in PCI-X if it weren't for the much faster clock which will probably make it explode theatrically.

Newegg has a section just for server boards which is a good place to start looking, that or hit the products section of Tyan, Supermicro.

Dual core?

Whatcha got against onboard SCSI btw? Couldn't you just disable it and use your card anyway?

Can't say as I've heard of any SLI multiprocessor boards. Kinda two seperate market targets. Usually.

Alot of good boards are extended ATX which will most likely not fit in most ATX cases...

FSB is 200MHz, anything higher than that is market clock.
 
dangfx said:
--FSB of at least 800mhz
--Memory speed of at least 400mhz (DDR or DDRII)
--either AGP (Pro/50/8x) or PCI Express slot, doesnt matter
--at least 2 SATA ports, RAID capable
--NO onboard SCSI (important!!)
--at least a couple regular PCI slots
--all the rest, like USB2.0, IEEE1394, NIC, wifi, etc.
--SLI not needed

One more question: can an SSI form factor board fit into a standard ATX case? (i already have the case)

THANKS!!

SSI form factor if im correct is rather large, as in E-ATX big. It also requires its own power supply if i remember correctly.

But more importantly. FSB doesnt 'have' to be 800mhz, the opterons run less than that and outperform xeons. DDR-400 isnt needed, only 333 (if opteron).

You sound like a prime candidate for the NCCH-DL with 2 2.8ghz Nocona Xeons with standard DDR-400, has 800mhz fsb too aswell as AGP 8x support. Has 2 x PCI-X and 3 x PCI. 4 port sata (or 6 cant remember) raid, fits in ATX, though it requires an EPS PSU. The main good thing about this board is that it supports normal DDR-400 and PCI-X, both of which are rare in an ATX dual-board.

Just get an NCCH-DL imo.

If you wanna spend a bit more, then get a Thunder K8W, a new case(EATX), an EPS PSU, 4 sticks of ECC DDR-333 and 2 x Opteron 248. This system will be quite a bit faster though cost about 2.5 times as much heh.

For both system its probably best to get a 6800gt or ultra and soft-mod it to a quadro for graphics work. Anyways, im done :)

Any more questions just ask.

ashmedai said:
Can't say as I've heard of any SLI multiprocessor boards. Kinda two seperate market targets.

The Thunder K8WE is a friggin awesome SLI dual-opteron board. Theres quite a few because SLI can be used for graphics (SLI Quadro goodness).
 
HEY GUYS!!!

Thanks a lot for the replies....

ashmedai-
-Thanks for the PCI info.
-I will browse newegg's sections.
-I dont want the SCSI simply becuase it brings up the price too much. I know that this is going to be an expensive upgrade already, but I'm trying to cut costs wherever i can. Besides, a couple 10K Raptors in RAID0 will be fine for me :)
-I wont be doing SLI -- i use dual monitors, so not an issue

FunkStar-
-Thanks for the SSI info. I was looking at an Intel board that is SSI, but it didnt have the video capabilities i need, so its out anyway.
-Thanks for the memory info. If i decide to go AMD, I will note that I dont need DDR400, but if i go Intel, I will.
-I looked at the NCCH-DL too. But one problem:
4 port sata (or 6 cant remember) raid
Are you SURE about this? It seems that its SATA is non-raid.
-Again, dual monitors, so no SLI for right now.

So yeah, the NCCH-DL is a close one, I dont mind the AGP, but no raid (??) means a no-go.


I was looking at this supermicro: the X6DAL-B2. Take a look, tell me what you think. Its no AGP, but is PCI-E 16x, so thats fine. And has raid. My one concern is what it says by "Important Chassis Notes" It says:
-To ensure system stability, a 420W (minimum) ATX power supply [8-pin (+12V) + 4-pin + 24-pin is required.
-Chassis must have CPU mounting holes required for 800MHz FSB CPUs with this serverboard.

HUH?? It IS a standard ATX board, so will it fit in my current ATX case?? The other thing is that its more expensive than the Asus, which I dont like..... man, i wish the asus had raid.... or something else exactly LIKE the Asus NCCH-DL with raid....
 
Supermicro targets servers & workstations, Asus targets consumers. Guess which will cost more.

Do you anticipate needing PCI-X at all, and if so at what speed bus? PCI-X 66 comes alot cheaper than 133.
 
It mentions the "SATA: Promise® PDC20319, 4 ports" on the spec page, and also there are RAID drivers under the downloads. I think they just assumed workstation system builders would know what that was.
 
It mentions the "SATA: Promise® PDC20319, 4 ports" on the spec page, and also there are RAID drivers under the downloads. I think they just assumed workstation system builders would know what that was.
Yes, its just the dumbos like me who dont realize it. But are we sure the PDC20319 is in fact a RAID controller? Can this be confirmed anywhere on the Promise website or knowledge bases/white papers/etc?

As for PCI-X, I dont NEED it right now, but you never know.... btw, can you explain to me the differences in the types of devices that need/use 66mhz vs 133mhz?


Other than that, I think NCCH-DL is a good bet.... can anyone confirm that this is a good, solid board? I only found that one GamePC review on it... and although it was good, seems like little else has been said about it. I found one thread about it here at HF and it seemed like a nightmare (although mostly due to an unsupported PSU??). I still want more feedback on the board though......
 
how much of a factor is money?

PC-DL = $200
Dual 1.6LV Xeons = $120 (appx)
drop in some ram, and you got a nice video editing machine.
 
another older/cheaper alternative mobo would be the msi k8t master 2

it uses the via k8 chipset which is stable
has usb 2, raid, broadcom gigabit ethernet, agp 8x etc...
and comes with nice copper custom heatsinks in the box to allow for better cooling than the stock opterons heatsinks.

of course you'll be stuck with ecc ram but if you are doing a workstation/server you'll want that anyway.

i've had mine for quite a while and it's been very solid.

also will fit into an atx case as long as the case isn't a smaller mid tower without much room between the 5 1/4" drive cages and mobo as the ram is in a spot to cause problems if you have a longer dvd/cd drive.
 
Do you mean two separate processors or one processor that has a dual core?

..If you meant dual core, then wait about a month for the Intel 955x chipset to come out, which will have dual core support.

As far as two processors, I don't know much on the subject, but I think Xeon motherboards have support for two separate processors
 
dangfx said:
But are we sure the PDC20319 is in fact a RAID controller?

I saw enough that I'm 80% sure, but it's always a good idea to drop the manufacturer an email for a little pre-sales lovin' to be sure. Tried to look on Promise's site but it's kinda screwed up.


dangfx said:
can you explain to me the differences in the types of devices that need/use 66mhz vs 133mhz

Same stuff, but faster.


AuDioFreaK39 said:
then wait about a month for the Intel 955x chipset to come out, which will have dual core support

From some of the rumors I've heard about Intel's dual core efforts I'm not sure I'm going to like it, at least not until the second round or later. AMD's sounds like it'll work better though.


AuDioFreaK39 said:
but I think Xeon motherboards have support for two separate processors

Sure, if they've got two sockets on the mobo...if they don't then you can't really plug in a second one can ya? Easy way to check. ^_^
 
Back
Top