Logitech vs. Saitek (keyboard duel)

Which 'board would you buy?

  • Logitech G15

    Votes: 114 63.0%
  • Saitek Gamers Keyboard

    Votes: 67 37.0%

  • Total voters
    181
I see.

I've been reading reviews of the G15, Gamers' KB, and the Eclipse. I have to say that the Eclipse is looking and sounding better and better. It's just more practical for me, I'm not a big multimedia guy and would probably never use most of the keys on the Logitech.

I like the Eclipse for the fact that's it's a straight forward keyboard, plus the keys are laser cut for the light to shine through them instead of around them.
 
winston856 said:
I see.

I've been reading reviews of the G15, Gamers' KB, and the Eclipse. I have to say that the Eclipse is looking and sounding better and better. It's just more practical for me, I'm not a big multimedia guy and would probably never use most of the keys on the Logitech.

I like the Eclipse for the fact that's it's a straight forward keyboard, plus the keys are laser cut for the light to shine through them instead of around them.

The light doesn't shine through very well on the ones I've seen. The light illuminates the lettering on the keys for the G15 VERY well. They are very easy to see and there is a soft glow to the edges of the keys.

The Saitek keyboard just doesn't feel very good to me. My personal take on it.
 
I want to know where in the fuck are you guys even finding g15's according to logitech america that thing isnt even out yet.
 
Om1kron said:
I want to know where in the fuck are you guys even finding g15's according to logitech america that thing isnt even out yet.
.
CompUSA and Best Buy both have them. I got mine from CompUSA. Discounts kick ass. :cool:
 
I have both the Saitek and the G15. They are similiar in many ways with only subtle differences.
1. The key ilumination on the G15 is tons better on the G15 because they only light the characters instead of the area around the keys. Tends to overpower the keys on the Saitek in darker conditions. Only way someone would not notice this is if they are 100% touch typist or never type in the dark.
2. The Siatek macro keys are not attached to the keyboard but like has been said the programing feature of the G15 is far superior plus the G15 actually has more with the M# keys whick effectively mean you have 3 times the number of macro keys.
3. G15 has the WinKey disable switch on the board for less interuptions in game. No more prying it off the keyboard because you accidently pressed it one too many times.
4. Media key are better than anyother "media" keyboard I have ever tried but takes a little setting up in some cases. Worked out of the box for me for Windows Media Player, Winamp and ATI Multimedia player.
5. The LCD has great potential but the support is sparse atm. I use LCDHype and have absolutely no problem with it using to much resources or preformance issues. If Logitech or the Gaming industry gets behind the LCD then I could see it becoming a standard on a lot more peripherals.

Antec P160 case
A8N SLI Deluxe
AMD +3500
2GB RAM
ATI X800
Dual WD 250GB HDD
Sony DRU 720A DvD
Logitech MX1000 Mouse
Logitech G15 Keyboard
Dual Samsung 913T Monitors
 
Seizure Explosion said:
thought I'd ressurect this thread to ask which one has a good feel regardless of looks and functions.
Lol, that one of the biggest debates of this thread. I'm an owner of the Saitek Eclipse and think it has the best feel of any keyboard I've ever owned. By the way, I bought my first keyboard in 1990 so I'm somewhat experienced in these things. Though I've not used the Logitech board, so I can't directly compare them.

If pressed, I'd say you probably wouldn't actually notice a difference between the feel of these two keyboards.
 
Super Tech said:
I have both the Saitek and the G15. They are similiar in many ways with only subtle differences.
1. The key ilumination on the G15 is tons better on the G15 because they only light the characters instead of the area around the keys. Tends to overpower the keys on the Saitek in darker conditions. Only way someone would not notice this is if they are 100% touch typist or never type in the dark.
2. The Siatek macro keys are not attached to the keyboard but like has been said the programing feature of the G15 is far superior plus the G15 actually has more with the M# keys whick effectively mean you have 3 times the number of macro keys.
3. G15 has the WinKey disable switch on the board for less interuptions in game. No more prying it off the keyboard because you accidently pressed it one too many times.
4. Media key are better than anyother "media" keyboard I have ever tried but takes a little setting up in some cases. Worked out of the box for me for Windows Media Player, Winamp and ATI Multimedia player.
5. The LCD has great potential but the support is sparse atm. I use LCDHype and have absolutely no problem with it using to much resources or preformance issues. If Logitech or the Gaming industry gets behind the LCD then I could see it becoming a standard on a lot more peripherals.

As a pro-gamer:

1) Who needs lights when you're busy thinking of where the enemy is?
2) I suppose that's nice but that's a lot of extra buttons/macros to memorize and it will interfere with the game.
3) Excuses.
4) Why would you use multimedia when you're gaming?
5) The LCD is pointless. I've seen someone program a Quake 3 HUD in there. I laughed.

Final answer: Saitek Keyboard - it's smaller, has quick response to touch, and gives more space for my mouse.

-J.
 
GeForceX said:
As a pro-gamer:

1) Who needs lights when you're busy thinking of where the enemy is?
2) I suppose that's nice but that's a lot of extra buttons/macros to memorize and it will interfere with the game.
3) Excuses.
4) Why would you use multimedia when you're gaming?
5) The LCD is pointless. I've seen someone program a Quake 3 HUD in there. I laughed.

Final answer: Saitek Keyboard - it's smaller, has quick response to touch, and gives more space for my mouse.

-J.

1) If you're looking for where the enemy is, you probably shouldn't be looking at the keyboard so it doesn't matter. Also, you can turn them off or make them less bright.
2) If you're a "pro gamer", you shouldn't have trouble remembering where your macros are, if you'd even need them.
3) You don't have to disable the windows key. You don't make sense.
4) A lot of people turn off game music while playing, and listen to their own music instead.
5) You do not have to use the LCD, but it's there if you wanted to use it. And just because the game support isn't that great now, doesn't mean it won't be useful in the future. I honestly don't know what I would use it for in a game, but I know it would be nice to have while listening to music, or to display IM text so I wouldn't have to minimize.

None of the points you made make sense to me, aside from the Saitek being smaller.
 
The point was - The G15 is all flashy marketing and a waste of money. I rather a MS Internet keyboard for $12 over any of those. ;)

-J.
 
Ok, I couldn't resist. We had a G15 in stock at work and I looked at it and was like the hell with it and bought it. I love it! The keys are nice n soft and quite and the backlight works great. The only thing I don't like is how wide it is. Other than that, great keyboard!
 
GeForceX said:
The point was - The G15 is all flashy marketing and a waste of money. I rather a MS Internet keyboard for $12 over any of those. ;)

-J.
Then your final answer should have been a MS internet keyboard :p

some people don't think it's a waste of money though
 
GeForceX said:
The point was - The G15 is all flashy marketing and a waste of money. I rather a MS Internet keyboard for $12 over any of those. ;)

-J.

You are ceertainly entitiled to your opinion. Personally, I think the LCD display kicks alot of ass for managing your songs in Media Player or Winamp. That's the feature that I find to be the best.

Being able to de-activate your Windows keys is pretty sweet as well. Overall, there are alot of things I like about the keyboard.
 
yeah about the G15 baclight...from all the picture's I've seen it cuts off at the left of the keyboard. That's pretty crappy.
 
what pic shows that? The two I have are just about as evenly lit from left to right as possible.
 
Seizure Explosion said:

just picked up my G15 and its NOT like that at all. The lighting is top notch and evenly distributed, the best part is that the lighting doesn't distract you. The light remains on the keyboard and doesn't project into your eyes for distraction. It's just there to illuminate the characters and provide an ambient lighting around the keys, nothing more.

And the touch, OMFGWTFBBQ this thing feels amazing to type on. It's like your hands are on air. They keys have just the right amount of feedback, they make minimal sound, and they have a texturized rubber feel to them, it's sextacular. I'm thinking of adding this keyboard to all the computers in my house, I can't use generic anymore. :p
 
Seizure Explosion said:
yeah about the G15 baclight...from all the picture's I've seen it cuts off at the left of the keyboard. That's pretty crappy.

Mine doesn't. It lights evenly across all the keys.
 
I see what you mean, but those of us that already have them know that pic is chopped to show the day/night difference in the keys' appearance.

There is no such gradient in the lighting.
 
Great. I was hoping to fine one product-shattering flaw in one of these to make my decision easier. But nooooo. Alas, I digress. I may go with the Logitech because, in accordance to what I felt standing there in an awkard standing-but-typing position at the local best buy, which was that the Saitek keys are too close together.
 
I love my Dinovo Logitech keyb, but for teh G15 VS siatek gamer i'd go for teh gamer, cuz the g15 looks like a prop from stargate.
 
Personally, I don't think it matters, as long as you get a Speedpad to go with it. It sells around $25, and it's the best investment in gaming I've ever made. When it's set up right, virtually any game can be played with Speedpad + Mouse... VERY comfortable, and VERY efficent.
 
i have a saitek eclipse and i love it, can play in low light conditions all i want. I love the layout, its a decent sized keyboard, but it has huge keys which i like for gaming. Keys are responsive. Its a minimalist dream. My clanmate has a g15, he says its good but not worth the 80 bucks incl tax. He has XP MCE and he says it doesnt play nice with the keyboard.

I love the saitek cus it does what i need very well, gaming and typing. I usually die alot because i miss a key ( i hate laptop keyboards x.x). This is right up my alley, high visable keys that are impossible to miss. All the multi-media,macro, LCD screen as all extras that i dont need and not worth the extra $ imo.
 
Newegg is selling G15 for $70
enter code LOGITECH10 to make it $60 before shipping
 
DudeItsMe said:
Personally, I don't think it matters, as long as you get a Speedpad to go with it. It sells around $25, and it's the best investment in gaming I've ever made. When it's set up right, virtually any game can be played with Speedpad + Mouse... VERY comfortable, and VERY efficent.

QFT. :)

-J.
 
I picked up the Saitek Gaming keyboard today. For some reason, my system won't boot properly with this board plugged into it. I have to hit the RESET in order to get into Windows with the usual "Windows did not boot properly....." message. My BIOS settings are correct and I've tried all the USB ports. Not sure what the issue is, but it's really got me irritated to the point where I'll be bringing it back on Monday. Once booted into Windows though, it does work pretty well. Anyone else hear of any issues like this with the Saitek?
 
The Logi is way cooler, but I want a keyboard simply to match my mouse (Diamondback).
 
The pictures are wrong.

-Larry

Seizure Explosion said:
yeah about the G15 baclight...from all the picture's I've seen it cuts off at the left of the keyboard. That's pretty crappy.
 
My office is like the Bat-Cave. I HATE overhead lighting and refuse to turn it on.

Lighted keys. That's what I needed :)

-Larry


UltimaParadox said:
Honestly, I really don't see the draw of these two keyboards, but to each their own
 
I got the saitek eclipse because 1. it was on sale, 2. I've had 'multimedia keys' on other keyboards that I never use, and 3. I don't need a 3/4"x3" lcd on my keyboard because I have a 21" widescreen LCD monitor. I never look at my keyboard when typing anyway, so what's the point of having a screen there? That's why I don't have a screen in my tower either.

And yeah, speedpad 4 the w1n, no doubts about it. I've just got the old n50... I just haven't gotten around to upgrading to a n52 yet. As far as programming macros, the speedpad is a piece of work. The only thing I need the backlight for is the $^#@# <symbols, not swearing! :D > keys, I always forget where they are on the keyboard. Oh, and the function keys.

I bought some surfacemount leds with the hopes that I could mod the keyboard to either display red or blue, but the leds weren't bright enough and they were the wrong package size. I'll probably try it again sometime soon though.
 
Logan321 said:
I've had 'multimedia keys' on other keyboards that I never use, and 3. I don't need a 3/4"x3" lcd on my keyboard because I have a 21" widescreen LCD monitor. I never look at my keyboard when typing anyway, so what's the point of having a screen there? That's why I don't have a screen in my tower either.
It's pretty useful if you listen to music at all. Lets you know song information, and can quickly skip songs or adjust system volume, although you probably already can adjust speaker volume easily.

Right now I've been lazy and haven't installed any custom LCD apps, so I only use the Media Information and the Clock. Clock is nice because I have my taskbar set to hide, and I can see what time it is when I am playing a game. Also, it lets me know how many new emails I have in thunderbird.


Logan321 said:
The only thing I need the backlight for is the $^#@# <symbols, not swearing! :D > keys, I always forget where they are on the keyboard. Oh, and the function keys.
I thought you never look at your keyboard while typing? ;)
 
I like the G15 more. I prefer its keystroke, layout, style and comfort over the Eclipse. The LCD is a nice touch too. Now if Logitech had a mouse to go with its color scheme...
 
I like the Logitech, but the paint thing is a REAL issue.

-Larry
 
I have had both, but I didn't really like either. The saitek had longer key travel than the logitech, but the logitech had a mushy key feel. The travel was a good distance, but the keys felt oily, and too soft. I wanted a really typing keyboard. I still would give a preference to the logitech over the saitek.

Currently I switched to the Wolfclaw, and prefer it over both.

1. I wanted a gaming keyboard
2. I didn't need the numberpad
3. The keys on the Wolfclaw are just like the old school keys from a keyboard in the early 90's. Lots of travel, and feel great when typing. The circle section has much lower profile laptop like keys for fast precise access.

So my preference list is

1. SG Wolfclaw
2. Logitech G15
3. Saitek Eclipse
 
TechLarry said:
My office is like the Bat-Cave. I HATE overhead lighting and refuse to turn it on.

Lighted keys. That's what I needed :)

-Larry

Do you really have to look down to your keyboard? I know I never do
 
I would buy the G15, but since you'd have to move your mouse I voted for the Saitek. I hate having to move my mouse :mad:

G15 ftw, though.
 
Got my replacement G15. Since it was only 2 weeks old I just took it back to BB and exchanged it.

I don't see anything different, so I don't expect the paint to last on this one either.

I'll just keep doing it until they get it right. I don't see anything better.

-Larry
 
Back
Top