Living with Windows 10 S

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
Windows blogger Paul Thurnott has decided to subject himself to using W10 S every single day between now and the middle of August, and he doesn’t seem to be having a great time so far: calling it a “painful” experience, he discusses a number of problems that potential users will encounter, which include apps crashing, being forced to use Edge to browse the web, and mandatory Microsoft accounts.

...in an attempt to figure out which failings are big enough to require a compromise on Microsoft’s part, and which are just me being normal and set in my ways, I’m going to undergo some pain. I’m going to try and make this work. Again, I know this won’t go well. But I’m really going to try and fight through it. And it’s already been a fight. The first 36 hours of using Windows 10 S haven’t exactly been tear-inducing, but they’ve been painful. Aggravating. Irritating. And exhausting. I’ll get to that, and I’m sure I’ll be ruminating more as we move forward about the work flow changes that this system may require of us all.
 
"Now, I’ve already used Windows 10 S, so I know what I’m in for. And it’s not pretty. So I’m going to bend the rules a little bit."

Ringing endorsement there!
 
1st Paul is more than a windows blogger.
2nd Unlike Apple journalists, Paul calls it like it is and MS respects him for it.

Not sure who would want this other than school systems providing laptops to their k-12 students and maybe grandparents who are not computer savvy.....
 
Start with Windows 10 Pro, cripple it up by removing the best aspects - Desktop and Win32 programs - Chrome/Steam/Photoshop/etc, and leave only the most reviled aspects of their embarrassing, six year metro era of suck (Store, Cortana, Bing, Edge, mobile apps) - what's left? Windows 10 Store edition.

Genius.
 
Last edited:
Not sure who would want this other than school systems providing laptops to their k-12 students and maybe grandparents who are not computer savvy.....

I don't see any compelling reason that a school would look at 10 S and say "Oh we HAVE to have that", when maintenance-free Chromebooks already exist, are cheap, and thousands can be deployed at a time by plain school administrators, no dedicated IT staff required.
 
Start with Windows 10 Pro, cripple it up by removing the best aspects - Desktop and Win32 programs - Chrome/Steam/Photoshop/etc, and leave only the most reviled aspects of their embarrassing, six year metro era of suck (Store, Cortana, Bing, Edge, mobile apps) - what's left? Windows 10 Store edition.

Genius.

Edge is better than IE...........
 
Hahaha using Windows 10 Pro is similar to having a pepperspray for an enema but Windows 10 S is more like taking molten lead up the ass.
 
Edge is better than IE...........

It has its advantages over IE and even Chrome on certain devices particularly lower end tablets and 2 in 1s, touch simply works better with Edge than Chrome on Windows 10, I often run both simultaneously.

Windows 10 S makes sense in certain situations, it's obviously not the crowd in this place. The education editions have the option of upgrading any device to Windows 10 Pro at will free of charge and all the devices can be managed via inTune for Education and don't require any on premises infrastructure.

The biggest issue is the Windows Store and the availability of apps. It's not as bad as some make it out to be but needs to be a lot better. There are now Win32 apps coming into the store, a lot of basic users would get all that they'd need from 10 S and the Store.
 
It has its advantages over IE and even Chrome on certain devices particularly lower end tablets and 2 in 1s, touch simply works better with Edge than Chrome on Windows 10, I often run both simultaneously.
At least with 10S you won't get that option, good thing you're one of the few that likes Edge.
but you like everything microsoft, so that does not come as a surprise
 
Hahaha using Windows 10 Pro is similar to having a pepperspray for an enema but Windows 10 S is more like taking molten lead up the ass.

Always the colorful metaphor!:D I think this is where a lot of the debate over Windows 10 stems. Today if the second anniversary of 10s general release and I've been using the insider builds from day one October 1, 2014, so personally I've been using 10 daily for close to 3 years. Besides issues with some Insider Builds over the years and issues with the Surface Book at release, Skylake drivers weren't ready at release but I've had similar problems with new hardware and Windows before.

10 has supported well almost everything I've normally done with Windows devices.
 
At least with 10S you won't get that option, good thing you're one of the few that likes Edge.
but you like everything microsoft, so that does not come as a surprise

Edge has some advantages in certain scenarios that I use. Sure, being locked to Edge would be a problem for a lot of people but for the types that would be ok with 10 S, not nearly as much as more advanced PC users.

And it's not so much a matter of loving what Microsoft does or Windows 10, Windows 10 continues to support all of the things I've being doing with Windows PCs for years. It is the only option for PC gaming if you want access to the latest and greatest in PC gaming, I'm far from the only one who thinks this thus why 10 is quite popular with gamers.
 
MS claims one of the targets is school systems. Most systems I know of run custom applications either developed in house or bought for a lot of money. Unlikely they are going to dump them for some Windows Store version if one is even available. Also, unless MS is going to allow a complete shut down of telemetry, many schools won't legally be able to run any version of Win 10 due to privacy laws concerning student information.

Unclear from TFA, but will it allow a universal ID or is each student going to have to create their own Microsoft ID in order to use 10S?
 
It is the only option for PC gaming if you want access to the latest and greatest in PC gaming, I'm far from the only one who thinks this thus why 10 is quite popular with gamers.
Edge has some advantages in certain scenarios that I use. Sure, being locked to Edge would be a problem for a lot of people but for the types that would be ok with 10 S, not nearly as much as more advanced PC users.

And it's not so much a matter of loving what Microsoft does or Windows 10, Windows 10 continues to support all of the things I've being doing with Windows PCs for years. It is the only option for PC gaming if you want access to the latest and greatest in PC gaming, I'm far from the only one who thinks this thus why 10 is quite popular with gamers.
The majority disagree with your opinion of Edge.
As for gamers and 10's popularity, it had nothing to do with playing games and everything to do with forced "FREE" os and the false allure of DX12.
 
They're trying to compete with Chromebooks, mostly in the educational space. I guess it's adequate for that purpose, I have no experience with either in that setting.

They really need to be worried about Google making a serious push for the entire desktop/laptop market. They could easily roll out a 'Chrome Pro' OS and laptops alongside Chromebooks in every Walmart and tech store in the country.

Windows 10 is a dumpster fire and the Windows user base is fragmented. 7 users who haven't already moved on to desktop Linux need somewhere to go when 2020 comes around. If anyone can tap that market it's Google.
 
The majority disagree with your opinion of Edge.

How many of these people use Windows tablets or 2 in1s? Like I said, there are certain scenarios where Edge works better, I didn't say it was better at everything than Chrome. Clearly it's not when it comes to extensions.

As for gamers and 10's popularity, it had nothing to do with playing games and everything to do with forced "FREE" os and the false allure of DX12.

There's more to it than this simplistic notion. For VR there are an increasing number of titles that require Windows 10. Not a flood but there are some, and one very good one Superhot VR requires 10. When I spend the money on something like VR, I want to be able to use whatever I want and the reality is that for VR that does require 10.
 
Windows 10 S makes sense in certain situations, it's obviously not the crowd in this place. The education editions have the option of upgrading any device to Windows 10 Pro at will free of charge and all the devices can be managed via inTune for Education and don't require any on premises infrastructure.

I call BS on that one. Can they upgrade to pro for free in some cases ? Sure they can.... can the school computer teacher roll out an entire schools 10s computers safely and securely without help. Hell to the nope. Perhaps non-pro IT staff like high school computer teachers could manager to get a bunch of windows 10 s machines up and running securely but the min they start upgrading them to 10 they are going to need some back up to secure things properly.

There are a bunch of things working against 10s in education.... Google has been beating them up in education for good reason, MS hasn't really addressed any of them. School teachers never felt they should be acting as IT personal... and School Admin types hate paying for IT personal. Google solved those issues for both groups... MS is crazy if they think locking a version of windows to their store alone is going to swing either of those groups back to their side.
 
I call BS on that one. Can they upgrade to pro for free in some cases ? Sure they can.... can the school computer teacher roll out an entire schools 10s computers safely and securely without help. Hell to the nope.

Simple cloud based management is the point of Intune. I've never used it but have read up on it. It's basically the same concept used for managing Chromebooks. How well it works, again I've not used Intune but I'm guessing it's a simpler process than you're describing.
 
Simple cloud based management is the point of Intune. I've never used it but have read up on it. It's basically the same concept used for managing Chromebooks. How well it works, again I've not used Intune but I'm guessing it's a simpler process than you're describing.

As I said IF they don't upgrade to 10 pro sure MS tools can setup pretty secure machines for students. Once they start upgrading machines to pro though they introduce a lot of insecurity that school teachers are neither paid or equipped to deal with really. Setting up multiple windows 10s machines still requires running around with USB sticks and a process that may be quicker then setting up a full version of windows sure but is still 4-5x longer then the process of setting up Chromeos machines.

MS may have attempted to do something different... but at the end of the day its still MS. Wanting to get schools into site licence territory... they may have made the road in a bit more attractive on the surface. That is all though its just window dressing for their platform. I doubt many that have already moved to Googles offerings are going to be swayed back by 10s or MS half backed education tools. Google is likely going to continue rolling, I expect MS foot print in education is going to continue falling... I mean the fall may slow a bit, but only because they don't have much further to fall.
 
There's more to it than this simplistic notion. For VR there are an increasing number of titles that require Windows 10. Not a flood but there are some, and one very good one Superhot VR requires 10. When I spend the money on something like VR, I want to be able to use whatever I want and the reality is that for VR that does require 10.

Wrong. Superhot VR works fine on 8.1 w/ my Vive, and it works perfectly on 7. But let's keep the autistic astroturfing going.

"VR games require 10..."
"Well okay not all VR games require 10, but some might..."
"Well okay its just one VR game that requires 10..."
"Okay I have no clue what I'm talking about, not even that one VR game requires 10... but spamming my FUD macros about Windows overall having more games than Linux at least deflects and misdirects from a discussion about the relative failure of 10."

Brain surgery on-parade, ladies and gentlemen.
 
Last edited:
"Okay I have no clue what I'm talking about, not even that one VR game requires 10...

Hmmm, all of this nonsense when the product description on Steam says that Superhot VR REQUIRES Windows 10: . And there are others I have. So look, you can go on and on with this line or argument but all I was doing was looking at the system requirements listed for the title.
 
Hmmm, all of this nonsense when the product description on Steam says that Superhot VR REQUIRES Windows 10: . And there are others I have. So look, you can go on and on with this line or argument but all I was doing was looking at the system requirements listed for the title.


So DPI is lying?
 
It's MS's way of creating a walled garden like Apple does with their IOS. At least with IOS, you can use other web browsers
 
It's MS's way of creating a walled garden like Apple does with their IOS. At least with IOS, you can use other web browsers
I can't think of a worse way to experience the web than being tied to one browser unless you were locked into safari. /s
 
Last edited:
So DPI is lying?

What are you talking about? Here are two other VR games I've purchased recently that list Windows 10 as required:





I've not tested them for Windows 7 or 8.1 under VR. I'm just pointing out what the Steam Store lists at the requirement. So if someone is lying is ain't me, I'm just relaying what Steam is saying.

I've got a Vive and have a Rift on pre-order. Anything that coming out for those devices is pretty much guaranteed Windows 10 compatibility. I don't give a shit about who is telling the truth other than the people I'm handing my money over to which in this case is Valve.

Maybe Valve is lying, I can't be if all I've doing is reporting what Steam is saying.

You don't use VR, I have no idea why you keep wanting to bring up the subject.
 
Last edited:
What are you talking about? Here are two other VR games I've purchased recently that list Windows 10 as required:





I've not tested them for Windows 7 or 8.1 under VR. I'm just pointing out what the Steam Store lists at the requirement. So if someone is lying is ain't me, I'm just relaying what Steam is saying.

I've got a Vive and have a Rift on pre-order. Anything that coming out for those devices is pretty much guaranteed Windows 10 compatibility. I don't give a shit about who is telling the truth other than the people I'm handing my money over to which in this case is Valve.

Maybe Valve is lying, I can't be if all I've doing is reporting what Steam is saying.

You don't use VR, I have no idea why you keep wanting to bring up the subject.


Or maybe it's just marketing with Microsoft trying, once again, to push everyone towards Windows 10 when everything from Windows 7 onwards will quite possibly run the software just fine.

Trying to 'essentially' label DPI a liar over what Steam reports is necessary and what DPI has discovered is necessary isn't going to change his experience and is just making you look like a shill.
 
Or maybe it's just marketing with Microsoft trying, once again, to push everyone towards Windows 10 when everything from Windows 7 onwards will quite possibly run the software just fine.

Trying to 'essentially' label DPI a liar over what Steam reports is necessary and what DPI has discovered is necessary isn't going to change his experience and is just making you look like a shill.

Holly shit BatMan! You didn't even take two seconds to look at the truth. Devolver Digital is the publisher for Gorn. The SAME co-publisher that has two of the only four Linux VR only titles currently listed on Steam.
 
Holly shit BatMan! You didn't even take two seconds to look at the truth. Devolver Digital is the publisher for Gorn. The SAME co-publisher that has two of the only four Linux VR only titles currently listed on Steam.

Microsoft obviously lay down marketing requirements Valve has to adhere to, it happens all the time. Certain manufacturers I've worked for have had some outlandish requirements when marketing for their platform - This is the way of the world son.

When someone finds that something runs outside of the specifications listed on Steam, there's nothing wrong with stating how interesting such a finding is, commenting on how it's great that people aren't tied to Windows 10 with all of its issues and moving on. When you praise Edge, when you unnecessarily praise Windows 10 and when you defend the odd decision that is Windows 10S and do so, so predictably, you come across as a shill and it's obvious that your claim of using Windows 10 as it supposedly supports the latest and greatest is only part of the story.

Try not to blindly defend every stupid decision Microsoft make and most definately stop attacking users that post their honest experiences.
 
I've not tested them for Windows 7 or 8.1 under VR. I'm just pointing out what the Steam Store lists at the requirement. So if someone is lying is ain't me, I'm just relaying what Steam is saying.

Except "what Steam is saying" wasn't your original claim stated as fact. You're continually trying to create the narrative that "more and more games require 10" but then grasp at straws trying to produce examples. You originally stated:

For VR there are an increasing number of titles that require Windows 10. Not a flood but there are some, and one very good one Superhot VR requires 10.

And so an "increasing number of titles" was really just a single title, and not even that single title requires 10. It works perfectly with 8.1 and my Vive, and the developer's own forum as well as Steam forums confirm it works with 7.

Whether the developer had some marketing deal with MS or just erroneously didn't include 7 and 8.1, who knows, but developers have zero financial incentive to make their titles 10-only. And that's not going to change anytime soon.
 
Last edited:
Except "what Steam is saying" wasn't your original claim stated as fact. You're continually trying to create the narrative that "more and more games require 10" but then grasp at straws trying to produce examples. You originally stated:

And so an "increasing number of titles" was really just a single title, and not even that single title requires 10. It works perfectly with 8.1 and my Vive, and the developer's own forum as well as Steam forums confirm it works with 7.

Whether the developer had some marketing deal with MS or just erroneously didn't include 7 and 8.1, who knows, but developers have zero financial incentive to make their titles 10-only. And that's not
going to change anytime soon.

Get off your high horse. I simply reported what Steam had listed as the requirements and I said I didn't go test otherwise. I've pre-ordered a Rift as well and I'm simply not interested in validating what Steam is listing as a requirement for VR games, they're all going to work Windows 10, most likely other versions but Windows 10 are where most PC gamers are, that's coming from Valve, not me. You can hate Windows 10 all you want but you can't blame me for how Steam labels system requirements.

Do not fucking blast me when Steam is wrong. And don't expect me to spends tons of money on gaming and other only Windows hardware for prior versions.
 
Get off your high horse. I simply reported what Steam had listed as the requirements and I said I didn't go test otherwise. I've pre-ordered a Rift as well and I'm simply not interested in validating what Steam is listing as a requirement for VR games, they're all going to work Windows 10, most likely other versions but Windows 10 are where most PC gamers are, that's coming from Valve, not me. You can hate Windows 10 all you want but you can't blame me for how Steam labels system requirements.

Do not fucking blast me when Steam is wrong. And don't expect me to spends tons of money on gaming and other only Windows hardware for prior versions.

DPI's not on any 'high horse'...

...You are. You're the only person I've ever seen on these forums that wholeheartedly believes Windows 10 is a necessity considering hardware used.
 
DPI's not on any 'high horse'...

...You are. You're the only person I've ever seen on these forums that wholeheartedly believes Windows 10 is a necessity considering hardware used.

WTF are you talking about? I simply pointed out the requirements for three VR titles that Steam said required Windows 10. If that's not true then why blast me over something Steam is reporting incorrectly? That's a really high horse. And you don't even use any of this stuff.

Anything VR is going to support Windows 10 for many years to come and that's just not the case for prior versions of Windows.
 
WTF are you talking about? I simply pointed out the requirements for three VR titles that Steam said required Windows 10. If that's not true then why blast me over something Steam is reporting incorrectly? That's a really high horse. And you don't even use any of this stuff.

Anything VR is going to support Windows 10 for many years to come and that's just not the case for prior versions of Windows.

This isn't the first thread where you have claimed that windows 10 is required for a bunch of VR games.

I completely understand if you where snowed by the MS paid for Min system requirements listed by the developer. That is MS intention... if you didn't scroll down to the user comments or check out the forums where users report 7 and 8 work no issues that's ok I don't scroll down much on steam either. :)

MS has a long history of fuddy marketing, don't feel played to much.
 
This isn't the first thread where you have claimed that windows 10 is required for a bunch of VR games.

Valve is the one making these claims and what would you know about VR games you've never touched?

People getting made at me over what Valve is stating need to go talk to them. Seriously, you folks are losing it.
 
The author's experience mirrors my experience working with an Android phone.
 
Yet, every....single....time that a w10 post shows up, you will make sure to switch the conversation to the fact that you do use VR, regardless if is relevant or not.

So why not?

First of all I said from the very beginning I didn't put the system requirements on Steam's store. And I also said that I don't buy expensive hardware based on people who don't read labels. Maybe Linux of macOS or something else is the future of PCs. Fine, I'll download and install it and it'll work with everything I have and I'll be on my way. It's not that big of deal if stuff works. I just want to do things I want to, and even for a place like this what I want to do is a bit complicated.

Windows 10 is the preeminent gaming PC OS these days. If there is something better I'm happy to use that. I'm out of the hardware market for CPUs and GPUs this year. I'm picking up a Rift and probably a Windows mixed reality setup. Anything more interesting or better or runs a zillion times better without Windows 10 or Windows period?

I just don't give a fuck. I just want to do the things I want to do and the OS is irrelevant.
 
WTF are you talking about? I simply pointed out the requirements for three VR titles that Steam said required Windows 10. If that's not true then why blast me over something Steam is reporting incorrectly? That's a really high horse. And you don't even use any of this stuff.

Anything VR is going to support Windows 10 for many years to come and that's just not the case for prior versions of Windows.

[sigh]

I'm not blasting you over anything. If anything, you were the one that lashed out at DPI for pointing out that not only does SuperhotVR not require Windows 10, despite what the min requirements may claim, but for pointing out that everyone's had enough of the way you cannot help but claim that Windows 10 is an absolute necessity for anyone interested in gaming under modern hardware - I believe it was yourself that called DPI's claims nonsense.

Therefore, it is yourself that is on the high horse and not DPI for highlighting his personal experience and rightfully speaking his mind regarding your attitude.
 
First of all I said from the very beginning I didn't put the system requirements on Steam's store. And I also said that I don't buy expensive hardware based on people who don't read labels. Maybe Linux of macOS or something else is the future of PCs. Fine, I'll download and install it and it'll work with everything I have and I'll be on my way. It's not that big of deal if stuff works. I just want to do things I want to, and even for a place like this what I want to do is a bit complicated.

Windows 10 is the preeminent gaming PC OS these days. If there is something better I'm happy to use that. I'm out of the hardware market for CPUs and GPUs this year. I'm picking up a Rift and probably a Windows mixed reality setup. Anything more interesting or better or runs a zillion times better without Windows 10 or Windows period?

I just don't give a fuck. I just want to do the things I want to do and the OS is irrelevant.

Great!

The problem is, everyone's sick and tired of hearing it.
 
Back
Top