Linus Torvalds Suspends Key Linux Developer

People who do it to share their code and ideas, and not as a ploy to indoctrinate people to their fascists views on technology and to feed their egos. Linus is an egomaniac of the worst degree.

He did share it with the world. You can take the code and freely fork your own kernel from it, where you are in charge, where everyone holds hands and sings Kumbaya with every new submission.
 
Perhaps you don't remember but, during the non-Steve Jobs years, Apple nearly went bankrupt. By the end, the shareholders were begging for him to come back.

I don't like what Apple does as a company and I don't like Steve Jobs ethics but he did get stuff done and turn around Apple.

If you had continued reading before posting, I commented on this very fact further down...
 
Most computers run Linux, it has already succeeded, and many large companies commit code to it.

It has succeeded on the server side, embedded side, and the mobile side (though Android, while based on Linux, is hardly a full Linux implementation). I'm talking about the client side, where it competes with Windows and OSX.
 
You need to learn your history.

Shuttleworth wasn't funding or backing Ubuntu from the start (his $10mil backing and creation of the "Ubuntu Foundation" wasn't until 2005 after Warty). As a matter of fact...all the brains that made Ubuntu into what it became left shortly after Shuttleworth started micromanaging things which began in earnest around 2007. AAMOF, most people with long enough memory look fondly back on those pre-Shuttleworth micro-management relesases as the best and best working Linuxes in the distros history....and all those following blow ass in comparison.


Shuttleworth is what is wrong. Bighead CEOs with no clue about technical details forcing everyone else to make their code like theirs or else. His Weyland fiasco is a great example. When I see Shuttleworth I instantly think of the Pointy Haired Boss from Dilbert.

This part I didn't know. I wasn't paying attention to who was running the show back when I started Using Ubuntu (which I did from ~2005 to 2011) I've just heard the Shuttleworth name enough that I thought he had an involvement early on as well.

Either way, my point is the same. Ubuntu may have gone astray in the last 4 years or so, but up until that point they were the largest driving force in making Linux usable to the average end user. No one has done as much in this regard as Ubuntu, and as reputations go, they have one that is much more civil than Mr Torvalds.
 
That is nonsense. Something I expect from clueless managers that think arrogant self aggrandizing hacker types are "superstars".

I have worked with a wide range of SW developers for nearly 20 years. I have seen these arrogant/hacker "superstars" in their own mind, types. They were never the actual superstars anywhere I was working.

They were usually slightly above average, worked long hours and cut corners to increase their productivity and let other people clean up their messes. You don't want hire these guys, but they aren't superstars. If you can't tell the difference, let someone else vet the talent.

I have seen real superstars, that make real the claim that developer productivity varies by up to 10X. The best I have ever seen was on of the most humble, easy going guys I ever met. He was quickly made an architect, but he still kept turning in more quality code/design work than anyone else, and would help anyone at the drop of a hat.

Some people are just perfectly suited to their role in life, and have extraordinarily above average abilities. The super competent are no myth.

The myth is that everyone is somehow created equal.

You would be a huge idiot to pass up hiring a genuine superstar if you are lucky enough to have the opportunity.

I couldn't agree with you more. I'm not suggesting you don't hire good people. I am suggesting you don't hire the self aggrandizing prima donna's who think they are hot shit, and don't have enough interpersonal skills to deal with disagreement in a civil manner.

That's my entire point.
 
On a side note: I just noticed they are calling it just "Ubuntu" now, rather than "Ubuntu Linux"... When did that happen?
 
ubuntu = google OS,
i wouldn't call it linux, google is a microsoft of open source, it destroys privacy in everything it's evolved in, ubuntu ships with spyware called zeitgeist, and of course people rejected it and would remove it, so they made it unremovable by making it a dependency for unit,
ubuntu should be on your linux shit list

I hadn't heard of Zeitgeist, as I discontinued Ubuntu use when they introduced Unity (I've been on Mint mostly since), but a quick Google search suggests it is a tempest in a teapot.

Is Zeitgeist Spying on You?

Looks like it is simply a search indexing engine to improve searches from the Unity Dash, and the data it collects never leaves your local machine.

In a way, you could compare it to the Microsoft Indexing service.
 
I am interested in what the core Linux developers have been doing all these years. Unix was finished in the 70s and Linux is supposedly a knock off. So what have these kernal developers been developing in the last 15 years? Bug fixes?
 
Zarathustra[H];1040749014 said:
(though Android, while based on Linux, is hardly a full Linux implementation).

What? It is based on a fork of the vanilla 3.4 kernel. The Linux foundation recognizes it as a distribution.

Please provide specific reasons and sources for why it is not a "full Linux implementation".
 
Unix was finished in the 70s and Linux is supposedly a knock off.

Unix was not finished development in the 70s. It is still under active development.

So what have these kernal developers been developing in the last 15 years? Bug fixes?
New features, bug fixes, etc. What have the Windows developers been doing since the release of Windows 1.0?
 
Hmm, the culmination of over 15 years of windows development (which is probably over thousands of person-years of development)...

... is Windows 8.

Yup, made me wince too.
 
New features, bug fixes, etc. What have the Windows developers been doing since the release of Windows 1.0?

MS has totally rewritten the kernel a few times (windows 1.0) and since XP, are mostly adding new APIs and bug fixes. I wasn't aware that Linux has added any new features to the kernal since the 90s. My guess would have been adapting it to run on more processors, efficiencies and bug fixes. In either case, I doubt much work is being done to either kernal these days. They are both very mature.

As for the Windows team, they have thousands of people working on stuff not related to the kernal. Mostly presentation GUI stuff.
 
What? It is based on a fork of the vanilla 3.4 kernel. The Linux foundation recognizes it as a distribution.

Please provide specific reasons and sources for why it is not a "full Linux implementation".

I base that comment on it's rather limited implementation of basic *nix commands.

You CAN make it more complete by installing busybox on a rooted device, but out of the box it's more like Android is to Linux as OSX is to BSD. Derived highly from the common source, but also very different.

In my humble opinion, of course.
 
Unix was not finished development in the 70s. It is still under active development.

Didn't Bell Labs have a final Version 5 Unix release in 1974? (I wasn't to be born for another 6 years, so my knowledge of this era is hazy though)
 
I am interested in what the core Linux developers have been doing all these years. Unix was finished in the 70s and Linux is supposedly a knock off. So what have these kernal developers been developing in the last 15 years? Bug fixes?

You could call Linux a knock-off if you want, but as I recall reading it was a total kernel rewrite initially due to frustrations with licensing non-free implementations.


Either way, both actual unixes (like BSD) and Linux have come a long way since their original implementation (And based on my personal experience with BSD, Linux has come a lot farther :p )
 
Zarathustra[H];1040749257 said:
Didn't Bell Labs have a final Version 5 Unix release in 1974? (I wasn't to be born for another 6 years, so my knowledge of this era is hazy though)

Actually, initial testing was in 1969, with the first stable release in 1971, and first commercial install in 1972?

It WAS called Research Unix, but it could have been considered a finished product (in as much as any product is ever finished in the software (and especially operating system kernel) world, where it is more of an eternal process of continuous updates.

Who's to say the Linux 2.4 Kernel was ever a final release, since we since have had the 2.6 and 3 kernels? :p
 
Zarathustra[H];1040749253 said:
I base that comment on it's rather limited implementation of basic *nix commands.

Traditional *nix commands are part of the userland and have and aren't part of Linux, let alone a requirement for Unix certification or POSIX compliance.
 
Zarathustra[H];1040749257 said:
Didn't Bell Labs have a final Version 5 Unix release in 1974? (I wasn't to be born for another 6 years, so my knowledge of this era is hazy though)

Variants of Unix have born and died over the years. IBM, SUN, and HP (at the least) still actively develop Unix.
 
Traditional *nix commands are part of the userland and have and aren't part of Linux, let alone a requirement for Unix certification or POSIX compliance.

Fair enough. My comment I guess was more to the effect of that it doesn't feel like a *nix user experience.
 
Zarathustra[H];1040749327 said:
Fair enough. My comment I guess was more to the effect of that it doesn't feel like a *nix user experience.

As far as mobile Linux goes, Meego (now Mer), based on Moblin and Maemo definitely feel more like using a full implementation.
 
Zarathustra[H];1040749041 said:
I hadn't heard of Zeitgeist, as I discontinued Ubuntu use when they introduced Unity (I've been on Mint mostly since), but a quick Google search suggests it is a tempest in a teapot.

Is Zeitgeist Spying on You?

Looks like it is simply a search indexing engine to improve searches from the Unity Dash, and the data it collects never leaves your local machine.

In a way, you could compare it to the Microsoft Indexing service.

not quite just the indexing service, if you use mint, chances are you have it running on your pc, since mint is built on ubuntu,

According to the Zeitgeist website, the program keeps a log of all of the user's activities and notifications with and from his data. Every time you open a file or visit a website, every time you open or send and email, every time you go on a chat room it's keeping a log of everything you do.

and it i can bet it's not fully localized program, but also has some network code in it, which really is a perfect spying tool
 
You need to learn your history.

Shuttleworth wasn't funding or backing Ubuntu from the start (his $10mil backing and creation of the "Ubuntu Foundation" wasn't until 2005 after Warty). As a matter of fact...all the brains that made Ubuntu into what it became left shortly after Shuttleworth started micromanaging things which began in earnest around 2007. AAMOF, most people with long enough memory look fondly back on those pre-Shuttleworth micro-management relesases as the best and best working Linuxes in the distros history....and all those following blow ass in comparison.


Shuttleworth is what is wrong. Bighead CEOs with no clue about technical details forcing everyone else to make their code like theirs or else. His Weyland fiasco is a great example. When I see Shuttleworth I instantly think of the Pointy Haired Boss from Dilbert.

The funny part about that nonsense is ububtu was pretty shitty until about 7.04. But oh yeah it's fun to hate shuttleworth. Never mind carry on.

I think it's funny how Torvalds is called unprofessional when that's exactly how it should have been handled. Too fucking much coddling these days. It's not a business, the guy want an employee and Torvalds is not some CEO.
 
Zarathustra[H];1040747473 said:
It doesn't matter how brilliant you are. Being a childish unprofessional asshole is never acceptable. This is why Steve Jobs was kicked out of Apple in the 80's.

It doesn't matter how smart or good you are at what you do, playing well with others is always more important and will yield better results in the end. Organizations that don't fire the likes of Thorvald's or young Jobs are the ones who foster hostile work environments and will never be successful.

For Linux to really succeed it needs to dump Thorvald's and all other abrasive personalities like him, no matter how "good" they are.

Yup just as Apple how well that went for them, I think they'll take your advice without thinking twice about it.
 
Zarathustra[H];1040747750 said:
And why do you think he wasn't deemed ready to be CEO of a large company?

He always had a remarkable vision (even though I never really agreed with it) but what he lacked was the maturity to realize that he didn't have all the answers and to listen to the people he hired. That coupled with his tantrums pretty much assured he wasn't ready.

When he returned to Apple in the mid 90's he was a much humbled man by his experiences in the previous decade, and that is what allowed him to lead the success of the company that was to come.

Yes, the people who ousted Jobs in the mid 80's nearly ran Apple to the ground with their lack of vision, but on the flipside, if Jobs had remained, I'm not convinced there would be an Apple at all today.

I think you severely miss the point of teamwork vs. being a prima donna vs. being an asshole. A team of people who never disagree will not be the most awesome team ever that outproduces any brilliant person. A team will have disagreements, and someone has to sort them out, it's called management. You can be an asshole who is capable of conceding to an issue based on the merit of an argument, and you cna be an asshole capable of management.

Linus by all appearances is not an outright asshole. What he is is blunt and not interested in smoothing over feathers after a certain line is crossed. He'll also use the occasional 4 letter word when he has hit that point. That too does not make him an asshole. If there si a point to argue regarding his effectiveness, it is more likely the fact that he stays out of things he could probably fix until they have escalated severely. Viewed in terms of traditional corporate structures, we just got to see someone get fired for NOT being a team player rather than because someone was being a prima donna. The question is did we see a CEO have to get involved at the mid-manager level because nobody else would sort out their bullshit at an appropriate level? I"m not familiar enough with the details of the FOSS command chain to say that is an accurate description, but if it is close, I can see why he'd be pissed enough to drop the F-bomb.

As for Steve Jobs, he was an asshole who could manage to an extent by being a huge prick. What he couldn't do was to manage his own vision in a manner that was profitable. So apple kicked him to the curb, and he went elsewhere and repeated that same problem until he figured out how to say no to himself, and when doing so mattered. By all accounts he remained a giant asshole who managed by being a giant prick to everyone both before and after with little to no concern for the happiness of the team or such things as consensus.
 
not quite just the indexing service, if you use mint, chances are you have it running on your pc, since mint is built on ubuntu,

As I understand it is a dependency of Unity, so probably would not be installed on versions that use different window managers, but I could be wrong. I will have to check when I get home.
 
I trust this clears things up :

800px-Unix_history-simple.png
 
I trust this clears things up :

800px-Unix_history-simple.png

It's interesting that MINIX is listed as fully Open Source.

Wasn't Linus Torvalds inspired to create the first Linux kernel BECAUSE of his frustrations with licensing MINIX? That suggests it wasn't quite open source, no?
 
Back
Top