LHC Restart Likely Delayed Until October

You know if I was the director of this science team, I would just flat-out lie about the risk involved. I mean who would really know except a few 100 scientists in the world who could grasp such high-level math. All science is a risk: All of it. What is called for here is risk analysis; accordingly, if the risk if infinitesimally small then proceed with the project. People looking for 100% guarantees in this venture or anything in life are going to be sorely disappointed.

because less transparency in government-funded projects is always a good thing :rolleyes:
 
because less transparency in government-funded projects is always a good thing :rolleyes:

Normally less transparency is a good thing but with things like stem cell research, the LHC, climate research and other highly misunderstood projects, I think populist rule by committee is bullshit. Sometimes you need to protect projects from the stupidity of other people. As I said If I were the director of 50 scientists all of whom had multiple Phds including myself and they came to me with the consensus that their is a .00000000001 chance we might destroy the earth and the surrounding solar system or we might re-write the rules of science and advance our civilization by leaps and bounds, I would say what are we standing around here for lets do this thing. Should I really care that joe average is worried that the universe might implode and he won't be able to watch the season finale of owww my balls? Life is risk: Science is risk. Besides, their are tons of things that could happen that would wipe us all out anyway. Hell, we haven't even figured out how to stop fighting amongst ourselves for resources, how to fix our energy supply problem or even seed worlds. We need more progress, not less.

Personally, I think we are getting to that tipping point in Civ [in history and the game] where we either have to stop screwing around and evolve into a species that gets out into space in order to avoid its own destruction or we collapse in on ourselves and try again in a few millennia... that is if the earth is still even around. People need to understand that humanity might not always exist. We could all die out pretty easily. 4000-5000 yrs of civilization is a blink of an eye in geological terms.
 
Normally less transparency is a good thing

i'm guessing you meant that normally it's a bad thing, but in either case your ideas were clear enough. also, was that an Idiocracy reference? :cool:

i agree with your premises for the most part, but i think your conclusion is a very slippery slope. who gets to decide what "highly misunderstood" research projects should be pursued despite possible public objection? one could argue that eugenics is a highly misunderstood field of research, or mind control for that matter.

the other thing is, i don't believe there's much risk of joe average halting progress of the LHC. the "micro black holes could destroy the solar system" debate wasn't exactly a controversy per se, not until the science news media picked it up and sensationalized it. joe average might bitch and moan, but at the end of the day he's too worried about catching oww my balls to do much in the way of protestation.

i think the answer is the opposite of what you suggest. rather than keeping knowledge from the public, it needs more. i believe if our culture didn't emphasize the monetary value of, well, anything and everything, people would take greater interest in the arts and sciences, and media sensationalism might even become a thing of the future past.
 
i'm guessing you meant that normally it's a bad thing, but in either case your ideas were clear enough. also, was that an Idiocracy reference? :cool:
Yes, it was a sly reference to Idiocracy. My life is a constant battle between that movie and the princess bride according to my s.o. Who knew?
i agree with your premises for the most part, but i think your conclusion is a very slippery slope. who gets to decide what "highly misunderstood" research projects should be pursued despite possible public objection? one could argue that eugenics is a highly misunderstood field of research, or mind control for that matter.

And I would say to that science is a tool. A tool on its own is neither good nor evil since it has no anthropomorphic reference. It is the application and use that is the problem. User error, you might say. Take your examples of eugenics or mind control: I can think of a couple of ways where the application of said technology would be a good thing, for example, curing disease on a genetic/pre-embryonic level or having the ability to will your body to heal itself through the power of thought. Advancements can always be abused or utilized for the common good.

the other thing is, i don't believe there's much risk of joe average halting progress of the LHC. the "micro black holes could destroy the solar system" debate wasn't exactly a controversy per se, not until the science news media picked it up and sensationalized it. joe average might bitch and moan, but at the end of the day he's too worried about catching oww my balls to do much in the way of protestation.

I don't know, the power of a few discontents is not to be underestimated. A couple of complainers taken out of context can spiral into a PR nightmare. Then people start to distance themselves to avoid political fallout, funding is cut etc etc. Here is a personal anecdote from my life in government[academia]: A colleague of mine writes up a proposal to change the way we process incoming students into the dept. It will not only save the dept. money but it will save time and be way less hassle for students as well. 15 of the professors and staff think it's great.. 2 people have a problem with it. Who are these two people, you might ask? Yep, that's right the dean and his admin asst. They don't like it because it's hard to learn new things, they are used to the old way and it might make the admin position redundant since all that position does is deal with intake. Of course, we could have made a new position or found some other duties for her but that is just too much work apparently... Did my colleagues proposal get approved? Did we re-org to better serve our students? I think you know the answer to that.

i think the answer is the opposite of what you suggest. rather than keeping knowledge from the public, it needs more. i believe if our culture didn't emphasize the monetary value of, well, anything and everything, people would take greater interest in the arts and sciences, and media sensationalism might even become a thing of the future past.

I suppose you are right in this respect. I am not so much in favor of keeping knowledge in the dark but rather ignoring the white noise of people who shouldn't have a say in the matter and those who should know better but complain just to be contrarian. It is been my experience that most people [including myself from time to time] are lazy and selfish. They do not like learning new ways to do things even if it will make their life easier. Sometimes, you have to drag people into the future kicking and screaming.
 
And I would say to that science is a tool. A tool on its own is neither good nor evil since it has no anthropomorphic reference. It is the application and use that is the problem. User error, you might say. Take your examples of eugenics or mind control: I can think of a couple of ways where the application of said technology would be a good thing, for example, curing disease on a genetic/pre-embryonic level or having the ability to will your body to heal itself through the power of thought. Advancements can always be abused or utilized for the common good.

i agree that science is a tool, absolutely. but your answer still side-stepped the question of 'who gets to decide?' knowledge without a knower is indeed meaningless; i think i failed to phrase my rhetoric precisely enough to get to the heart of my concern. it's not so much a question of who gets to decide what research is conducted, but who get gets to decide how scientific knowledge is used. personally i wouldn't be morally opposed to an organization dedicated to encouraging individuals to voluntarily participate in eugenics practices, but forced sterilization of people with undesirable traits, or forcing those with desirable traits to reproduce more prodigiously, is a violation of human rights and dignity (and i hope i don't need to disclaim "IMO" for that one).[/QUOTE]

Here is a personal anecdote from my life in government[academia]

heh, i was an academic admin for 3 years, and i want to teach at the post-secondary level after completing my graduate education; i know exactly how you feel. your example isn't perfectly fitting though, since one of the two discontents also happened to be on top of the power hierarchy in that department. imagine if the debate about this reorganization had occurred among the student body. i think one or two discontented students wouldn't be able to change much, but if a large percentage of the student body protested the lack of change, wrote about it in the school newspaper, etc., i think things would look a bit different.

It is been my experience that most people [including myself from time to time] are lazy and selfish. They do not like learning new ways to do things even if it will make their life easier. Sometimes, you have to drag people into the future kicking and screaming.

you hit on something very personally meaningful to me, right there. one of my main research interests is the relationships between culture, self-identity and cognitive dissonance--specifically, why people seem so often to reject new ideas, technologies and practices that can and would benefit them. but i digress.
 
i agree that science is a tool, absolutely. but your answer still side-stepped the question of 'who gets to decide?'

Ah, but you see that is not exactly the right question to be asking. The right question would be, "Is our capacity to be and do good [in the platonic sense] overshadowed by our the flaws inherent in the design of human nature and our species as a whole" The 'who' then becomes irrelevant since 'humanity' itself becomes the arbiter of the question.

heh, i was an academic admin for 3 years, and i want to teach at the post-secondary level after completing my graduate education; i know exactly how you feel.

My example still holds up imo because the background of the situation was such that the dean didn't really care about the proposal the negativity all came from the admin asst. The dean just rubber stamped anything she said not to mention the fact that the dean enjoyed having the privilege of having his own little 'secretary' mad men style. Not to disparage the support that some admin assts provide but this was not a doctor/nurse relationship by any means. And in point of fact, the students were clamoring for a change which was why the proposal was written in the first place.

As a side note: Here is some unsolicited advise with a side of salt lick. Politics is perception and perception, politics. At a certain level it doesn't really matter what you know since everybody and their mother has a Phd at that point. Who you know and how much money you bring into the dept is key. Obviously, when you first start out you won't know anyone [usually] and after getting settled in your classes the first qtr/semester try to reach out to donors, start up fundraisers, get on committees, write some grants, publish articles or in other words do everything you can to make yourself invaluable. The tenure review committee eats that stuff up and if you happen to get someone on your review board that dislikes you politically [which I guarantee will happen] you can successfully argue how much you do for the dept to deflate their opposition.

Oh and be wary of people who work their alma mater into every conversation or email. Unless you went to that uni, they are not your friend. Notice how I never mention where I studied and who I studied under even though it was fairly prestigious... that's because I'm not a d-bag. ;)
 
Back
Top