TechieSooner
Supreme [H]ardness
- Joined
- Nov 7, 2007
- Messages
- 7,601
It'll be one expensive experiment to show... That we can't create or destroy matter 
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
You know if I was the director of this science team, I would just flat-out lie about the risk involved. I mean who would really know except a few 100 scientists in the world who could grasp such high-level math. All science is a risk: All of it. What is called for here is risk analysis; accordingly, if the risk if infinitesimally small then proceed with the project. People looking for 100% guarantees in this venture or anything in life are going to be sorely disappointed.
because less transparency in government-funded projects is always a good thing![]()
Normally less transparency is a good thing
Yes, it was a sly reference to Idiocracy. My life is a constant battle between that movie and the princess bride according to my s.o. Who knew?i'm guessing you meant that normally it's a bad thing, but in either case your ideas were clear enough. also, was that an Idiocracy reference?![]()
i agree with your premises for the most part, but i think your conclusion is a very slippery slope. who gets to decide what "highly misunderstood" research projects should be pursued despite possible public objection? one could argue that eugenics is a highly misunderstood field of research, or mind control for that matter.
the other thing is, i don't believe there's much risk of joe average halting progress of the LHC. the "micro black holes could destroy the solar system" debate wasn't exactly a controversy per se, not until the science news media picked it up and sensationalized it. joe average might bitch and moan, but at the end of the day he's too worried about catching oww my balls to do much in the way of protestation.
i think the answer is the opposite of what you suggest. rather than keeping knowledge from the public, it needs more. i believe if our culture didn't emphasize the monetary value of, well, anything and everything, people would take greater interest in the arts and sciences, and media sensationalism might even become a thing of the future past.
And I would say to that science is a tool. A tool on its own is neither good nor evil since it has no anthropomorphic reference. It is the application and use that is the problem. User error, you might say. Take your examples of eugenics or mind control: I can think of a couple of ways where the application of said technology would be a good thing, for example, curing disease on a genetic/pre-embryonic level or having the ability to will your body to heal itself through the power of thought. Advancements can always be abused or utilized for the common good.
Here is a personal anecdote from my life in government[academia]
It is been my experience that most people [including myself from time to time] are lazy and selfish. They do not like learning new ways to do things even if it will make their life easier. Sometimes, you have to drag people into the future kicking and screaming.
i agree that science is a tool, absolutely. but your answer still side-stepped the question of 'who gets to decide?'
heh, i was an academic admin for 3 years, and i want to teach at the post-secondary level after completing my graduate education; i know exactly how you feel.