Less an Upgrade, more a new system!

Joined
Sep 8, 2007
Messages
697
Hi,

It feels kind of lame to have my first post be a question, but I've never really had anything of value to add or any need to ask questions before. Now I do, so I have to start the bad way. I've been reading the reviews and off and on the forum for about 3 years.

So first a smidge of background here. I'm from Canada, but I moved to Berlin a year ago to live with my girlfriend (now wife). yay internet. My Computer will in the next few weeks be packaged up and shipped over here (Air Freight). It met my needs then, but with some of the new games out there, it might fall a bit short. My wife's computer doesn't really meet her needs at all. If her computer met her needs, I would likely build from scratch, instead... upgrade!


What I have (as I remember it)
Gigabyte somethingorother formerly top of the line AGP mobo.
AMD dual core at 1.8GHz
BFG 6800GT OC 128MB
2 GB OCZ RAM (400MHZ, DDR1)
I think 3 HDs (40 GB, 80GB, 150GB??)
19" BenQ LCD monitor of "it was on sale" chewiness (it's not terrible, but not great)
Case: Antec P180.... I like it, but cable management blows.

Yep, pretty cobbled together from my first system through 1 upgrade, a PSU that took mobo/RAM/CPU with it, and another mini upgrade.

I'm looking to upgrade the mobo, proc and Vid card, and give the old stuff to the wife. I might give her the RAM too, to get some DDR2.

My needs:
1. Games
2. Games.
3. and uhhh generic writing things, maybe some 3D Max

I've always played games at an "OK" resolution (1024x768 or 1280x1024) with middle range settings. I'd settle for that now, but I wouldn't mind having my games look pretty for once? I'm also looking for something that might last a bit into the future. Games I really want to play are: Supreme Commander, Warhammer Online/Dawn of War/Mark of Chaos, STALKER, Oblivion, FEAR, etc.

Limitations:
1. well, it's berlin, so things have the same numbers, but now its Euros. ;) about $8-900 US preferably, more is do-able with good justification, I've got a cool wife! :)
2. The Monitor: I won't need a 640MB card
3. I have the luck of the... not the Irish.... So no focus on OCing... a bit with the Vid card maybe...

This is what I cobbled together for myself... now tear it apart and make me cry! :) My wallet is begging for it.

PSU: Corsair 620HX 620W PSU - €130

Mobo:
ASUS M2N32 WS Professional nForce590 SLI - €160

Video:
XFX GeForce 8600 GT XXX Edition - €172

Proc:
AMD Athlon64 X2 3800+ EE Windsor 2x2.0GHz - €58

RAM
2048MB OCZ PC2-6400 CL5 KIT XTC Gold - 90€

Cooler:
Arctic Cooling Freezer 64 Pro €20

Actual Retail Price: $867 US

I also looked at:
EVGA GeForce 8800 GTS 320MB - €256 or €275 (for the Superclocked)

Now, I used to prefer AMD over Intel (small vs BIG)... but AMD isn't really small anymore, So I'm flexible there. Reccomend whatever. :)

Any suggestions (please with a reason) are greatly appreciated. I'm trying to get the biggest bang for my buck, but I wouldn't mind some "flash" (high settings for once) with it.

Thanks a bunch for your input! I hope to contribute more in the future, if I can. :)
 
looks like a decent setup, however...

at this point, going with a mid-range intel chip will more-than-likely keep you happy well into the future. more than anything, make sure you allocate a large chunk of your budget to the cpu and video card if you'd like to play games at high settings. shop for the cpu and gfx combo that will keep you happy and build around them.

here's a screenshot of a newegg shopping cart i put together:



i think that's a better bet for you @ $780 before rebates.

i know it may or may not be different for you depending on your location, but try putting together your own cart and let us know what price you get from your preferred vendor.

good luck!
 
OK Canadian in Berlin you aked for it, I've been AMD all the way since I started building systems but AMD makes no sense right now unless you're on a mega tight budget, otherwise its C2D and Quad all the way....

Now I've put together a pretty damn fine bang-for-buck system for you, even if I do say so myself! :D

First the price: 420.23 GBP = 619.105 EUR = 852.350 USD

All parts sourced from www.scan.co.uk, I have no idea if they ship to Germany but I do recommend them, their service is first rate.


banghy2.jpg


Now there's is a bit of give and take in benchmarks of some games etc, in respect of a E4300* v's AMD Athlon64 X2 3800+ EE but I noted you mentioned Supreme Commander, *now I know the image below doesn't have the proc I've listed in the system above, I've listed a slightly faster one! ;)

But the benchmark tells its own story:

927882421ca0.png


Now I know this aint the end of the story AMD Athlon64 X2 3800+ EE will beat the E4400 in some benchmarking situations, so really I'd recommend you think about an E6600 and remove all doubt.
 
Wow guys,

Thanks for the help and advice From what I read, Intel really is the way to go right now, so I've gone back through, read reviews, pored through tomes of computer lore, and talked to the wife about increasing the budget.

The new improved results:
EVGA nForce 680i LT SLI
- I read good things about this board, also good for overclocking if I indeed decided to try

XFX 8800GTS 560M XT 320MB 2xDVI/TV
- Cheaper than the EVGA reccomended here by 20 euros, good performance, and when it starts lacking, I could always consider going SLI!

- 620W Corsair HX620W
- Lots of large pictures, an extensive music collection backed up in .mp3 format and a love of watching videos/Movies/TV Shows while I play online games (Cash farming in WoW for example) means I like lots of harddrives, I'd the overhead here, over the lower Wattage Corsair

Intel Core2 Duo E6550 2x2.33GHz TRAY 4MB
- I pondered Quad-Core, and decided I'll pass for now, I could always get one later when they are cheaper.

Arctic Cooling Freezer 7 Pro
- Mmmm, cold. Anyone know if I can mount this to blow the warm CPU Air straight UP or BACK, and therefore directly out of the case? That would rock.

2048MB A-DATA PC2-800 Vitesta Extreme CL4 KIT
- Same stuff I saw here

I know this system would rock, but I'm descended from Scots, pinching pennies and squeezing value out of things is what we do best! I even know a good hardware site that fits... hardwareschotte.de (Hardware Scotsman). :D

Anyway, some further comments/reccomendations or equally good but cheaper alternatives are welcome...

Cheers and Thanks again to all participants! :)
 
Wow guys,

Thanks for the help and advice From what I read, Intel really is the way to go right now, so I've gone back through, read reviews, pored through tomes of computer lore, and talked to the wife about increasing the budget.

The new improved results:
EVGA nForce 680i LT SLI
- I read good things about this board, also good for overclocking if I indeed decided to try

XFX 8800GTS 560M XT 320MB 2xDVI/TV
- Cheaper than the EVGA reccomended here by 20 euros, good performance, and when it starts lacking, I could always consider going SLI!

- 620W Corsair HX620W
- Lots of large pictures, an extensive music collection backed up in .mp3 format and a love of watching videos/Movies/TV Shows while I play online games (Cash farming in WoW for example) means I like lots of harddrives, I'd the overhead here, over the lower Wattage Corsair

Intel Core2 Duo E6550 2x2.33GHz TRAY 4MB
- I pondered Quad-Core, and decided I'll pass for now, I could always get one later when they are cheaper.

Arctic Cooling Freezer 7 Pro
- Mmmm, cold. Anyone know if I can mount this to blow the warm CPU Air straight UP or BACK, and therefore directly out of the case? That would rock.

2048MB A-DATA PC2-800 Vitesta Extreme CL4 KIT
- Same stuff I saw here

I know this system would rock, but I'm descended from Scots, pinching pennies and squeezing value out of things is what we do best! I even know a good hardware site that fits... hardwareschotte.de (Hardware Scotsman). :D

Anyway, some further comments/reccomendations or equally good but cheaper alternatives are welcome...

Cheers and Thanks again to all participants! :)

Right looks like a grand system, the only thing I have question marks over is the Arctic Cooling Freezer 7 Pro, but thats personal preference.
 
These Core2 chips are so easy to OC without compromising stability, you should really get a different chip. The 7x multiplier is too low on the E6550. I'd strongly suggest stepping up to the E6750, which can hit 3.2Ghz easily.

E6550: 7 * 333 = 2.3Ghz, DDR2-667 << STOCK speeds
E6550: 7 * 400 = 2.8Ghz, DDR2-800 << Easy OC
E6550: 7 * 465 = 3.2Ghz, DDR2-930 << Good OC
E6550: 7 * 500 = 3.5Ghz, DDR2-1000 << Great OC

E6750: 8 * 333 = 2.6Ghz, DDR2-667 << STOCK speeds
E6750: 8 * 400 = 3.2Ghz, DDR2-800 << Easy OC
E6750: 8 * 450 = 3.6Ghz, DDR2-900 << Good OC
E6750: 8 * 500 = 4.0Ghz, DDR2-1000 << Great OC

FYI, you won't really notice the difference between CL4 and CL5, so don't pay a huge price premium for the tighter timings. Of course, the definition of "huge" is all on you, lol.

I'd also suggest goin with the Scythe Ninja Plus Rev.B instead of the AC Freezer 7 Pro.
 
Back
Top