Leaked Slide Shows AMD BGA CPU?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It looks as though some leaked slides have hit the internet that show an upcoming BGA processor from AMD that could potentially take on Intel’s Atom. No one knows where the image came from but, it doesn't really matter, it is always fun to speculate on rumored products anyway.

This supposedly leaked slide (for which we couldn't verify a source) details a single-core 64-bit processor dubbed "BGA CPU" that runs at 1GHz, utilizes DDR2-400 memory, and sports on-chip L1 & L2 caches.
 
It sounds like an underclocked/ULV Sparta (Sempron LE-1xxx) in a new package. It will still lack a relatively low power chipset with graphics like the Poulsbo chipset for Atom and of course have a much larger package overall than the tiny Atom. Then there's more bad news later in the year when Intel releases a *dual core* Atom in the same 8W TDP range as the mystery AMD BGA chip.

Is this a new game to see how far AMD can stretch itself?
 
I don't put much faith in "leaked slides" - they're easy to fake.. Judging by how many "leaked slides" AMD, Intel and Nvidia produces, one would think they don't do anything else all day than design slides :p
 
Now the Speed war turns from Most GHz or instructions/second

to Slowest most useful processor.
what is the use in having a computer that cannot even decode Blu-Ray disks?
back to the Internet enabled smart fridge concept we go.
the OLPC/UMPC market must really be growing. Why not just use an ARM-9 processor?
 
what is the use in having a computer that cannot even decode Blu-Ray disks?
Why not just use an ARM-9 processor?
1) Most people who play Blu-Ray discs use a stand-alone player. BD drives are not even a popular option in laptops with faster processors.

2) software compatibility, and much lower performance. Atom based systems work more like regular desktop systems. Even "open" ARM-based platforms like Nokia's Maemo handlelds (N770/N800/N810) have pretty limited software selections. Compare that to Linux and XP based MIDs/small laptops like the Eee PC.
 
This may be a leaked slide, and the specs may have no merit at all.

However, AMD must be working on a successor to the GEODE series. So I believe this slide does hint at a product that is real. I believe AMD confirms the very existence of this product with their own official presentation they did last year. You might remember this presentation, because they also introduced Bulldozer at the same time.

I'm specifically mentioning the first few slides of this presentation in this article:
http://enthusiast.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTM2NywxLCxoZW50aHVzaWFzdA==
 
well, it will have Atom beat on the memory side of things, using an integrated controller, but Atom will own it in power consuption.

I keep saying I'm waiting for this or that for an UMPC.

I think I've finall narrowed down all of the specs of what I want:
a dual core chip @ 1+Ghz (Atom should fit the bill)
1++ Gb of ram
12++ Gb of harddrive space (preferably a fast SSD)
10" - 12" screen
usable keyboard (not too small)
wifi, bluetooth, LAN & webcam built in.

I think thats it. Macbook air would be good if it wasn't so expensive. I want a cheap version of it with WinXP. :) Or maybe the Asus EEE with 10" when they upgrade to dual core Atom.
 
What the big deal. BGA will save a little bit of $$, and make manufacturing easier, but there is NO LAW that says you can't solder the current CPU's into the pc board. You dont HAVE to use a socket.

In fact, Im suprised the serious super overclocker dude don't pull the sockets and solder thier chips directly into the board.... to remove that last little bit of parasitic L and C and R at the pin interface. :eek::rolleyes::p
 
I have no idea what that is but... the Bobcat core based products are currently being developed, as we announced last year. Bobcat is a new grounds up core aimed at ultra low power applications.
 
http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?p=1032627694#post1032627694
reply

1) Most people who play Blu-Ray discs use a stand-alone player. BD drives are not even a popular option in laptops with faster processors.

2) software compatibility, and much lower performance. Atom based systems work more like regular desktop systems. Even "open" ARM-based platforms like Nokia's Maemo handlelds (N770/N800/N810) have pretty limited software selections. Compare that to Linux and XP based MIDs/small laptops like the Eee PC.
Good points,
but I am always looking for a lower power HTPC, the atom is more designed for smart controls or other applications where it can sleep 99% of the time.

Also the ARM controls are getting better, when you can find products like these-
http://www.emacinc.com/panel_pc/ppc_e7.htm
http://www.emacinc.com/som/som9260.htm

However, AMD must be working on a successor to the GEODE series. So I believe this slide does hint at a product that is real. I believe AMD confirms the very existence of this product with their own official presentation they did last year. You might remember this presentation, because they also introduced Bulldozer at the same time.
yes they have been working,
From the reports I have been reading, the Atom is about the same processing power as the LX900 processor (the evolved Cyrix processor, cyrex to Geode, to NS Geode, to AMD GX, to LX series, better power specs but still a decently crummy processor)
 
Why does AMD always doom themselves to fail from the start by lining themselves up directly to compete with Intel?

They need to be taking side approaches like they did with AMD64 back in the day, not just following the leader.
 
I have a Geode LX1750 (1.4GHz low power T-Bred/Athlon XP-M) and it's not too bad. I had a whole server based around it that used only 49W from the wall with the hard drive running (a little less when idle) and a little more than 60W from the wall at full load. Too bad power management didn't seem to be working on the board. I'm in the process of replacing it with a second picoBTX/E2200 system, which doesn't use too much more power (nearly the same at idle).

The Atom 1.6GHz is about equal to a Pentium M 800MHz-900MHz. Please don't compare it to an ancient Cyrix core. :p Even the slowest Atom is faster than the LX900.
 
well, it will have Atom beat on the memory side of things, using an integrated controller, but Atom will own it in power consuption.

Maybe, maybe not. How much power does the atoms northbridge pull? The 8W TDP is including the northbridge. Most likely it also refers to the higher spec model, not the slower more power miserly ones in the family.
 
Maybe, maybe not. How much power does the atoms northbridge pull?
A 1.6GHz Silverthorne (2.5W) + 945GSE chipset (4W UMPC Poulsbo version), including video consumes a total of 6.5W max (or for full desktop-type I/O add in another 1.5W max for the ICH7-M). Typical power for the Atom CPU running Office-type apps is 0.22W. I can't find typical power for the chipset.

AMD's CPU alone has an 8W TDP, and without the benefits of HK/MG (extremely low leakage on Intel's 45nm process), AMD's chip won't even come close in typical or idle power. With a low power mobile-type chipset (I/O, video, etc), that's still several more watts added to AMD's already relatively high total.

The rumored AMD chip isn't so much a competitor to Atom, it's more of a "don't count me out" offering.
 
Back
Top