Lazy Mobo Choice.

Joined
Jul 7, 2004
Messages
50
I, my friends, am lazy. I appologize for not going out and doing the research that I well know I should have. Here is a list of motherboards that I have to choose from, and I would like to know--based on price value and superb performance--which of them would be 'best'. I am, of course, setting up a p4 3.0gig system, and at the moment I'm not too concerned with OC'ing, (as I'm aware that, while they are tough, Prescotts run very hot). The video card will be the NVIDIA GeForce FX 5900 128MB 8x AGP because I've heard that this is the best available budget card. (I prefer NVIDIA simply for ease of windows emulation, but I'm not hellbent, if theres something better for an equal price, please let me know).

Alright, here is the list of motherboards I have to choose from, in order of least expensive to most. Thank you for any help.

- ABIT IS7-V2 848P Intel® i848
- ABIT IS7-E I865PE
- MSI 865PE NEO2-PS
- Gigabyte GA-8IPE/1000 I865PE
- ASUS P4P800 SE I865PE
- ABIT IC7 I875PE
- ASUS P4P800-E DELUXE I865PE
- ASUS P4C800-E DELUXE I875PE
- GigaByte GA-8IK/1100 I875PE
- DFI LP-PRO I875B
 
if your not going to research it, just throw darts at the list, you'll have the same result...
 
I know many people are going to have varying opinions, (and there is bound to be many elitist fan-boys voicing their personal views), but hopefully I will be able to get a consensus based on less-biased peoples’ first hand experience. Overall, it would be just as effective as reading a few ‘enthusiast’ web-reviews. Besides, based on how my brain works, if I were to throw darts at the list, I would generally aim for the most expensive, and I know that's not the most efficient choice of action. So let me hear your opinions and knowledge. It’s actually not that I’m overly lazy, I’m just not educated enough to know where to even start researching. Also, I am in somewhat of a hurry to order this machine.
 
I like my IC7-G. Stable, OC's well, has good features. The temp gauge reads about 10C higher than actual temp, but that's not a real problem.

-SEAL
 
i rather get a 6600 or a 6600gt over the 5900. since youre going intel you might as well get pci-express as its available to you. what will you be doing with pc btw?
 
I beleive from what I have seen and can recall that the 865PE chipset (which most of those boards are) is so mature that you wont be able to tell the difference in performance between them. It will be the features that make the difference. Google "865PE roundup"


I tend to agree with heero for future proofing I would go socket 775 and the 6800GT.

The 6800GT was just released in agp but they are overpriced atm.
 
Theres no way I can afford a 6800, nor would I want to (I don't think i'd be wise).

About the most I will spend is the GeForce 6600 GT 128MB AGP8X.
 
Doh! my bad typo, it is the 6600GT that was just released in AGP but they are putting the screws to early buyers at $240+ when the PCIx version is around $180.

Was trying to suggest that if you could wait a couple or 3 weeks it might come down. The reviews look pretty good.

Sorry about the confusion
 
I figured man, look what ive put together. Hows it look?

CoolerMaster TAC-T01-E1C Wave Master Aluminum 420W Case (SILVER)
Intel® Pentium® 4 Processor 530 w/ HT Technology 3.0GHz 1MB CACHE
Abit AG8-V I915 CHIPSET SOCKET775 PCI EXPRESS MB W/ SATA, GIGABITE LAN & 7.1 SOUND
1GB (512MBx2) PC3200 DDR400 Memory (Corsair_XMS)
160GB 7200 RPM ATA 100 HARD DRIVE -- Recommended
NVIDIA GeForce 6600 GT 128MB 16X PCI EXPRESS VIDEO CARD
COMBO DRIVE(DVD-ROM & CDRW) (BEIGE)
3D WAVE ON-BOARD 5.1 SOUND CARD
 
Just got myself an ABIT IC7-G to replace my dead ABIT Ai7.

Sweet motherboard and even got 5mhz higher FSB overclock

Ive had the following

ABIT Ai7
ABIT IC7-G
ASUS P4C800 Deluxe
ASUS P4P800 Deluxe

and this new abit is by far my favourite, definitly the most stable, and it has more options than you can shake a stick at.
 
Back
Top