Lawyers Could Be Next Profession Replaced by Computers

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
Having your case argued by a robot seems totally absurd, but automation does make plenty of sense for many legal duties that include document gathering and contract work. I am actually a huge proponent of this for governmental responsibilities bound by statute such as FOIA requests. In some cases, you are forced to pay gathering, research, and redaction fees, when most of those tasks are, well, robotic, and should mostly be in a database anyway that can be easily accessed and edited virtually. Best of all, software would actually know the law: you would be surprised at how many people at a district attorney’s office would rather violate state statute than do a little paperwork.

…blue collar jobs aren't the only ones at risk. The legal profession — tradition-bound and labor-heavy — is on the cusp of a transformation in which artificial-intelligence platforms dramatically affect how legal work gets done. Those platforms will mine documents for evidence that will be useful in litigation, to review and create contracts, raise red flags within companies to identify potential fraud and other misconduct or do legal research and perform due diligence before corporate acquisitions. Those are all tasks that — for the moment at least — are largely the responsibility of flesh-and-blood attorneys. Increasing automation of the legal industry promises to increase efficiency and save clients money, but could also cut jobs in the sector as the technology becomes responsible for tasks currently performed by humans.
 
Well computers certainly already help with discovery for lawyers a job that used to be forced on up new lawyers in firms or temps that are law students.
 
Last edited:
Best of all, software would actually know the law

But this is the crux of the whole damn thing. Is the law a firm set of rules or is it "living"?

Law is a reflection of society. Society is the ebb and flow of human interaction. Science will NEVER tell you murder is wrong. But humans will. What side of the line would a robot full into?

Society is a human construct. Let the humans deal with it.
 
Science will NEVER tell you murder is wrong. But humans will. What side of the line would a robot full into?

The meatbags are less productive if they're going around killing each other.

Sarcasm aside, morality is a real thing that we can understand. Even insects like bees and termites have systems in place that prevent and punish antisocial behaviors like killing other members of the hive. All actions can be measured in terms of their impact on the individual and society.
 
Last edited:
Getting closer and closer to becoming self aware.
 
Algorithms and AI are already replacing the financial jobs, so this is a logical step.

Those thinking this is limited to blue collar jobs are in for an awakening. Hence why people like Bill Gates are saying that this type of stuff may need to be taxed to slow it's adoption. The writing is on the wall.
 
The meatbags are less productive if they're going around killing each other.

Sarcasm aside, morality is a real thing that we can understand. Even insects like bees and termites have systems in place that prevent and punish antisocial behaviors like killing other members of the hive. All actions can be measured in terms of their impact on the individual and society.

My statement was that science will not tell you it's wrong. It can tell you the effects, but not if it's wrong. Right and wrong are not a real thing. They are just something we conjure up at our discretion.

high_court_1175485.jpg
 
The first step is computer reviewed cases for simple things where computers would excel and where there isn't a jury. For example finding mistakes in paperwork that can get a case dismissed, or searching for legal precedent to convict/dismiss. High profile cases that need a human to prey on the feelings of a jury would still want the real lawyer.
 
I needed to file some legal papers a while back. All he did was type the answers to the questions into some web based program and print the resulting form.
There is 0 reason I could have not filled in the information myself.
I asked him about it and he replied your paying me for telling you which form to file. Totally could have been automated.
 
The next gen of Law and Order will be quite the snooze with robot D.A.'s, A.D.A's and defense attorneys, establishing a conclusion in less time than it takes the defendants heart to beat twice:(

I bet they announce the episode's conclusion before the first commercial break in order to be more expeditious than their human counterparts. Damn bots!!!!!
 
We already mine documents for their forensic value through a pile of servers. All automated. Somebody still has to make sense of it all though.
 
DMV. DMV. DMV.

Sorry that just came to me, and oddly enough online has solved that issue mostly.
 
But this is the crux of the whole damn thing. Is the law a firm set of rules or is it "living"?

Law is a reflection of society. Society is the ebb and flow of human interaction. Science will NEVER tell you murder is wrong. But humans will. What side of the line would a robot full into?

Society is a human construct. Let the humans deal with it.

Laws are meant to be firm but having room to evolve, atleast that's what my business law prof says
 
Best of all, software would actually know the law: you would be surprised at how many people at a district attorney’s office would rather violate state statute than do a little paperwork.

No, I wouldn't be surprised at all. If anything, I would assume that the purported rate of this occurring is critically under-reported.
 
I get to be involved in lots of FOIA type requests and subpoenas. We've automated the queries a lot. You could probably automate the legal process deciding what is compliant with the request. I don't see how you could automate the redaction though. The content can be damn near anything. You probably could train an AI to do it, but unless you can train one to do it in a generalized form, it would be kind of pointless.
 
Please let's not continue to assume computer algorithms are infallible. They still need to be programmed by humans.
 
Yeah, I like the idea of interns being replaced with Legal Discovery Software. But I'm sure the current interns don't.


It's going to be awhile before we make AI smart enough to replace the lawyers themselves, but I have no doubt it'll happen eventually. Most law decisions can be guessed pretty consistently by anyone who knows the rules. Also, anyone who thinks that robot lawyers will being a competitive system like the courts to it's knees, well, just look how combative software trading algorithms are.

So yeah, nothing is stopping this from happening, aside form the an analysis not yet performed.
 
The legal system is a joke built on jokes, I'd rather have lawyers wiped out by robots than factory workers.
 
Back
Top