Last AGP? Only PCI-E From now on?

LeadMetal1402

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 11, 2004
Messages
156
Is it true that the x800 core and the 6800 core are the last cards for agp8x? So basically what I'm saying is: Nothing can be faster than that in the upcomming years?
 
Both companies will pretty much be strictly PCI-E in 2005 with probably there lower ends offered in AGP though thats no guarentee either, they are really pushing OEM to PCI-E and DYI will be soon to follow
 
so where does that leave the amd platform? will they have pci-e up and working by the time high end graphics is pci-e only?
 
At this point in time, AMD board won't start showing PCI-E until late fall. Which sucks cause I really want to upgrade to a 939 AMD, but the prices are so outrageous too *sigh*

I might just slap a 6800GT in my setup and call it good till next year.
 
Well, I have heard that both card makers want to make the move to only pcie, but they realize that not everyone will be jumping to buy the new hardware necessary to run it, so they compromised and will start producing pcie as soon as possible, but in future cards may be bridged back the other way, from pcie to agp, for those not willing to upgrade.
 
They MIGHT be the last native AGP core. However, since PCIe is faster with more bandwidth and AGP8x still has plenty of headroom left. The HSI bridge solution should work fine and not cause much, if any of a performance penalty.

And both companies have said they plan on continuing to deliver AGP cards for a while to come (via bridge)

Nvidia's bridge works both ways.... native AGP core to PCIe slot, or native PCIe core to AGP slot.

So your answer, no not even close to the last AGP solution... possibly the last native core.
 
chrisf6969 said:
So your answer, no not even close to the last AGP solution... possibly the last native core.
One might say that AGP videocards are going to become the PCI videocards of tomorrow :)
 
Elledan said:
One might say that AGP videocards are going to become the PCI videocards of tomorrow :)

except that there won't even be agp slots anymore...
 
Elledan said:
One might say that AGP videocards are going to become the PCI videocards of tomorrow :)

That's a little glib. AGP to PCI-E involves a fundamental architecture change, while PCI to AGP really didn't. But your point is completely valid. :p

The idea was to more or less force people to upgrade, especially since the K7 core will not support PCI-E. There will be a lot of people not willing to go to 64-bit on AMD's end for quite some time, although that is probably one reason why AMD introduced the Sempron. They're claiming that this is the final AGP generation, especially since the low-end cards will be designed around PCI-E, but I wouldn't be so sure. Technology has been moving very slowly lately so I do expect to see AGP into 2005.
 
I also expect AGP to be made until 2005/2006. Heck you can still buy PCI Videocards with 64 and 128 meg of Ram on them....
 
Maxx said:
The idea was to more or less force people to upgrade, especially since the K7 core will not support PCI-E.
Sorry, but that's completely false.

ISA, PCI(-X/E), AGP, etc. are implemented by the chipset, not by the CPU.
 
ehZn said:
except that there won't even be agp slots anymore...
Not necessarily. I know that at least VIA is working on a dual PCI-E X16/AGP design (quite tricky), and Intel (I think) has shown off a couple of mainboards with both PCI-E and AGP, the latter assumed to be implemented using an AGP - PCI bridge (very, very slow). There's also the possiblity of using an AGP - PCI-E bridge (faster than on the PCI bus).
 
IceWind said:
At this point in time, AMD board won't start showing PCI-E until late fall. Which sucks cause I really want to upgrade to a 939 AMD, but the prices are so outrageous too *sigh*

I might just slap a 6800GT in my setup and call it good till next year.

The Inquirer says that the first A64 PCI-E mobo, the K8T890 (VIA), is supposed to be sampling in June and will be in production in Q3 2004. Where did you get the late fall date? Oh, and one quick question: is it smarter to get an Athlon 64 system without PCi-E, or an Intel system with PCi-E?
 
Elledan said:
Not necessarily. I know that at least VIA is working on a dual PCI-E X16/AGP design (quite tricky), and Intel (I think) has shown off a couple of mainboards with both PCI-E and AGP, the latter assumed to be implemented using an AGP - PCI bridge (very, very slow). There's also the possiblity of using an AGP - PCI-E bridge (faster than on the PCI bus).

ok, dedicated agp slots. those agp-through-pcie slots suck right now.
 
ehZn said:
ok, dedicated agp slots. those agp-through-pcie slots suck right now.
Real (native) AGP is not impossible to implement together with PCI-E. Only issue is that both the X16 PCI-E slot(s) and the AGP slot have to play nice together in the northbridge.
 
ehZn said:
ok, dedicated agp slots. those agp-through-pcie slots suck right now.

Wrong, mate. AGP through PCIe slot would show pretty much no performance loss because PCIe 16x has quite respectable bandwidth. What you are thinking of is AGP through PCI slot, which has already been mentioned as being hella slow.
 
Still all speculation at this point. I know they had some engineering sample mobos at computex, but they were shaky about the performance and wouldn't say how they did it.

I would be overjoyed if they came out with a high end board that had dedicated agp and pcie.
 
ehZn said:
Still all speculation at this point. I know they had some engineering sample mobos at computex, but they were shaky about the performance and wouldn't say how they did it.

I would be overjoyed if they came out with a high end board that had dedicated agp and pcie.

That was on an Intel motherboard, where they put an AGP slot on the PCI bus. (kinda like running in 1x AGP mode) But actually performance was not THAT bad considering it was on the PCI bus. IT was slower than native 8x AGP or PCIe obviously.

But using a PCIe native core card that has an onboard PCIe to AGP bridge so the card is an AGP card to plug in to an AGP slot will NOT sacrifice performance much at all. I'm guessing here.... but I would bet only 1-2% slower if anything.
 
chrisf6969 said:
That was on an Intel motherboard, where they put an AGP slot on the PCI bus. (kinda like running in 1x AGP mode) But actually performance was not THAT bad considering it was on the PCI bus. IT was slower than native 8x AGP or PCIe obviously.

Yes. I knew this before, I just figured people knew that I meant the agp on pci slot, the pcie was a typo before.

I seriously doubt that solution will go anywhere.

There is one pcie card on zipzoomfly http://www.zipzoomfly.com/jsp/ProductDetail.jsp?ProductCode=321900 and the fact that there are already intel cpu mobos with pcie is encouraging, but I really hope it's established when I buy new stuff :rolleyes:
 
Ya, it looks to be the dawn of PCI-E revolution. The AGP served us well. You will not find a MoBo out there that has both interfaces as well. It just doesn't work. Though the manufactures will have to do some driver tweaking to get PCI-E where it needs to be.

Caliche
 
I would like to see a motherboard that has AGP slots instead of PCI slots. :D
 
chrisf6969 said:
That was on an Intel motherboard, where they put an AGP slot on the PCI bus. (kinda like running in 1x AGP mode) But actually performance was not THAT bad considering it was on the PCI bus. IT was slower than native 8x AGP or PCIe obviously.
Try .5x. This slow, to be precise.

PCI isn't just AGP with severely reduced bandwidth (133 MB/s), but also without GART (Graphics Allocation Remapping Table). In other words, it's a miracle that PCI videocards perform the way they do.
 
The only way imma upgrade my mobo and proc this summer (like i want to) is if i find a mobo with AGP and PCIe, and where AGP performs just as good as it does natively (maybe im dreaming).
 
that is a good idea, but i would want PCIe x16, im more worried about upgrading my Gfx card in the future mobo, and i wouldbe looking to stay AMD
 
advanced101101 said:
that is a good idea, but i would want PCIe x16, im more worried about upgrading my Gfx card in the future mobo, and i wouldbe looking to stay AMD

Understandable. These seem to be more like niche boards than anything else. Although I'm a little hesitant right now taking a chance on the first gen of new tech is a little risky. Even though it would give you kick @$$ bragging rights.
 
[H]alcyon441 said:
Understandable. These seem to be more like niche boards than anything else. Although I'm a little hesitant right now taking a chance on the first gen of new tech is a little risky. Even though it would give you kick @$$ bragging rights.

Definently, i dont plan to upgrade my mobo/proc until Xmas anyway, even though i wanna make one last upgrade before D3 and HL2 :(
 
Back
Top