Laptop for computer/wintel/apple illiterates?

Juardis

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 23, 2007
Messages
310
Don't know what forum this is appropriate to, but here goes.

My mother-in-law is completely computer/OS illiterate. She has, what is essentially, a dumb terminal that has net access. The "computer" is no longer supported and she can't get her email/net access half the time, so she thinks she wants a laptop.

So what would you recommend?

I originally recommended a Dell laptop with a wireless router and DSL and a cheap all in one color printer. But all new Dell's come with VISTA and, from what I understand, VISTA is not for the computer illiterate. Additionally, she would need to worry about virus software, spyware software, etc. God forbid there's a problem with any of the OS or software since she'd be totally unable to solve it. But she's deadset on getting a laptop so she can fold it up and put it away when it's not in use. Anyway, I'm not sure this is best for her. Maybe a Macbook, or something else, is better?
 
Dell is still offering XP on all of their machines. Check the OS and Front Page News forums for more info and links..
 
Yeah, a MacBook sounds like a good idea. There aren't many things out there on the internet that can screw up OS X and it is more than enough machine to check e-mail.
 
i would say go with the macbook if she can afford it. they have nice big pretty (easy to see) icons, and everything is nice and simple.

the lack of viruses/adware/other crap is also good for new users, they will feel confident if you tell them they can't mess anything up.
 
Although my opinion probably counts for nothing, I'm not an advocate of macs for illiterates. I own the last model iBooks and I personally feel it requires more knowledge than Windows. Yes, it's less prone to viruses/spyware and all that jazz, but I find that doing anything more than the bare minimum in computing (web, email, typing) is slightly more complicated. I say this because software is more scarce and when you find it, it's not always as user friendly. Sure, I like my mac but for a 'noob' I'm not sure it would be the best thing to get. Another element is that I find macs to have a steeper learning curve than windows, and hell windows laptops are cheaper.

EDIT: Dell does offer some of their systems with XP if you want it.
 
Vista vs XP. In her case, it will not make a big difference since she is just using email/internet. If you feel like she has some programs that may or may not be compatible, then just play it safe and go with XP. I heard dell is offering xp on their computers again.

I'd say a good size would be 14-15" (Not too big & not tiny)

When you decide whether to get a mac or windows laptop, be sure to take into account that you're the one who's probably going to teach her how to use it. (So if you choose mac, be sure to be familiar with it).

Dell, HP, Lenovo all make good laptops. (Although Lenovo is more expensive)
 
Vista vs XP. In her case, it will not make a big difference since she is just using email/internet. If you feel like she has some programs that may or may not be compatible, then just play it safe and go with XP. I heard dell is offering xp on their computers again.

I'd say a good size would be 14-15" (Not too big & not tiny)

When you decide whether to get a mac or windows laptop, be sure to take into account that you're the one who's probably going to teach her how to use it. (So if you choose mac, be sure to be familiar with it).

Dell, HP, Lenovo all make good laptops. (Although Lenovo is more expensive)
Yeah, I know, I know nothing about Macs and I will be her defacto IT consultant (unfortunately):D That's why I originally suggested a Dell. I have a Dell lappy with XP Pro and am happy with it, but it does come loaded with a lot of crap software that will only confuse the ever loving daylights out of her. I just uninstalled everything that was ticking me off.

As for being able to choose XP vs. VISTA, that must be new, because 3 weeks ago she didn't have that choice. That would be MUCH better for her (and me) since everything is mature in XP.

And finally, 15" was what I thought she'd be happy with. I certainly don't have to worry about her gaming, so that saves a LOT of money right there. :)
 
Maybe she'd be happier with a HTPC? If she's not that computer literate, then the idea of accessing the internet through her TV might be more appealing to her. Heck, you might even find that getting her a Wii or Xbox360 might be better suited to her needs of getting online.

In this day and age, the internet isn't *just* the province of PC/Mac users any more, there's tonnes of additional ways for people who just want to e-mail & surf to get online.
 
I agree, get her a mac. Huh? you don't know *nix? you don't know mac os? what kind of tech support are you?!?! lol... think of it as an opportunity to learn more about both, linux and macosx. Also, slap bootcamp on there, lol.
 
Back
Top