Laptop choice - down to two, and need some help

JeffS

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 5, 2003
Messages
200
Hi all,

I've been shopping out a new laptop to replace a nearly dead Compaq V2000 (yes it's old and way underpowered by current standards).

I've narrowed it down to a Sager 8690 and an Asus G53 over at Xoticpc.com

With similar specs they are coming out close enough in price that I can go either direction.
I like the styling of the Asus, but my main goal is to get a laptop that is going to last a long time. I don't plan to replace it for at least 5 years, more if can get away with it.

First, I only know Asus as a MOBO maker, and have no experience with their laptops. Are they well constructed? Do their current G series models seem pretty solid like they will hold up to years of use? It will do some minor traveling, but most of its time will be hopping between rooms in my house. The Sager has a good rep, but I've never used one of those either.

Second, does anybody know if the keyboard on the sager is backlit? I think it is, but haven't been able to confirm. I know the Sager isn't, and I'm not letting that be the make it or break it decision, but it could be a tipping point if all else is even.

Third, does anybody know how the video cards compare? One is the GTX 460M and the other is the HD 5870 GDDR5. I know that the 460M is pretty knew, so I don't know how much is known about it yet, or if anybody has hands on experience with it. But any advice would be appreciated.

Thanks for any help.

-Jeff
 
Take the Asus.

If you have questions about either model, call XoticPC, they're pretty good at customer service from what several friends (that purchased Asus laptops from them) have told me recently.
 
Go for the better warranty. Also, I hate to be the guy that suggests a 3rd option, but you might want to consider a different route than a gaming laptop. I'm not sure what you plan to do otherwise, but chances are a mobile GPU is not going to last you 5 years.
 
I decided to look at gaming laptops because they seem to have the best specs as far as hardware goes. I'd like it to be able to play games, but that's not my focus. The main heavy hitter that I'll be doing is Photoshop, and some other editing/pano stitching/HDR rendering software.

I'm stepping up from a Compaq V2000 with an AMD Turion64 from 5 years ago, so anything will be a jump in the right direction. But getting something with some horsepower under the hood would be nice.

If you've got a 3rd or even 4th option to suggest, I'm open to ideas. I originally looked at the Sager NP5125 as it seemed to be a bit easier on the budget. I figured spending a few bucks to go quad core might buy me some longevity though.
 
as far as i can tell Sager might get louder considering their design and fans they've put on it, also they will most defenitely be heavy and cube like (it might just be me but the newer designs are much better as i've seen dell xps designs and i've liked it thick in the back and slim in the front) also i've found more people buying asus than sager also i really never heard of sager till i decided to buy Asus G73. also sager laptop's fans are in the bottom so it will get hot if you decided to use it on your lap and might block air. Asus laptop will also have upgread option for future (the G series). if you know asus has solid MOBO than trust your instict and go with it for laptop too and you won't be disappointed. (no gurrenties though).

now forgive me if i'm wrong but if you are buying laptop after 5 years, trust me things have gone from bicycle to farrari for computers, as soon as you buy one i promise you they'll have upgreaded version in a month. so just jump at one station and wish to catch another train to get there in future.

for more options check newegg they might not have the best price in town but they sure have easy to nevigate options for looking on things, just go on another site later on and if you can customize the laptop you want you are in heaven.
 
You're forgiven. :) I know that 5 years in laptop time is like a century to the rest of the world, but I also can't replace a laptop that often. So since I figured the last one put up a good 4 years, and has survived its 5th year with a lot of coaxing and bit of extra work, I think 5 years isn't a bad time frame to hope for a laptop to last.

I'm not expecting the laptop I buy to be at the top of the heap in 5 years. Hell I'm not expecting it to be the absolute top when I get it. I just want it to still be able to get the job done in 4-5 years.

By then my wife will be out of school and the loans mostly paid off (if all goes well). So by then, I can afford to pick up some shiny new hardware and go balls out on it. Right now, it's just maximizing my dollar.

-Jeff
 
While I do it myself anyway, I don't recommend "consumer class" laptops to others (what I mean is that I only by business class machines for myself and don't recommend the stuff you can buy in stores to anyone I know).

The business class products are much sturdier in my experience, and built to last for many years while consumer class products - the stuff you can buy in stores, and yes you can get Asus machines in stores; Sager not quite as often but I have seen them in a Micro Center from time to time - tend to be the most plastic, cheap build quality, flimsy and generally unreliable machines so, again, I just don't recommend them.

If you're buying for time meaning you want a laptop that will work for years to come then I'd recommend you take another look at the whole situation and focus on the business class products from Dell (the Latitude line or even the Precision for a few buck more), the HP EliteBooks and ProBooks (can be had for decent prices), and even ThinkPads.

You may pay just a bit more than the stuff in the consumer class products but, I personally think they're worth the additional cost. Also, the business class products tend to have better warranties that offer more (like on-site service if needed) for longer periods of time (most offer 3 years with the purchase whereas typical consumer class machines get a year at best).

Just stuff to consider...
 
I thought about business class, but opted to get a little more computer for a little less money. the Elitebooks are nice, I use one for work. Unfortunately to configure it to the spec I'm looking for it comes in over $3500. I can go with a "gaming notebook" for about half that.
 
Back
Top