Laptop AC adapter-- should it be grounded?

venm11

2[H]4U
Joined
Oct 6, 2004
Messages
2,236
So - I needed to replace an AC adapter for an old laptop and got a good deal on ebay. Now I realize that it doesn't have a grounded plug, whereas the old one did. This just strikes me as a bad idea for any electronics susceptible to nosie (line or rf) or static discharge.

Or, maybe the laptop is never grounded when plugged in, and grounding is really just for the power supply? The laptop would be able to filter some noise, etc through it's own onboard power supply, but how does it deal with grounding needs?
 
So - I needed to replace an AC adapter for an old laptop and got a good deal on ebay. Now I realize that it doesn't have a grounded plug, whereas the old one did. This just strikes me as a bad idea for any electronics susceptible to nosie (line or rf) or static discharge.

Or, maybe the laptop is never grounded when plugged in, and grounding is really just for the power supply? The laptop would be able to filter some noise, etc through it's own onboard power supply, but how does it deal with grounding needs?

If your new found PSU has a "UL" label on it you are probably fine. Be careful about eBay, you just never know where some (any?) of the stuff sold on there was sourced.

What you have is a "brick" type PSU and there should be no common ground point between the ground in your electrical system and the laptop.

In a laptop your primary power source would be the battery and the PSU is simply recharging the power source hopefully faster than you use it. These days it is not unusual to see 2 and 3 wire plugs on different models from different companies.

Hope that helps:)
 
Well.... now that it's out of the bag it doesn't have UL, nor CE nor anything on it. It says "made in china". Interestingly, it says, "Connect only to a grounded outlet". Also, "I.T.E. use only", which I gather generally alludes to the particular UL certification which this apparently doesn't have to begin with.

Is this even legal to sell in the US? Seems like there must be requried safety standards. My Dell brick has ~21 standards logos on it.

What do you recommend?
 
Well.... now that it's out of the bag it doesn't have UL, nor CE nor anything on it. It says "made in china". Interestingly, it says, "Connect only to a grounded outlet". Also, "I.T.E. use only", which I gather generally alludes to the particular UL certification which this apparently doesn't have to begin with.

Is this even legal to sell in the US? Seems like there must be requried safety standards. My Dell brick has ~21 standards logos on it.

What do you recommend?

Lol, hell man, it's all made in China;)

Well, basicly there are thousands of products that come into this country through the "grey market". What that means is the factory sold it out the back door to somebody with money. The factory doesn't back it, figure no warrantee and on and on.

Amost anytime you see a product like that or even things like Sony XBR TV.s at scary low prices that's why. Now, all that aside the unit is probably fine as long as the rest of the specs match the old unit.

Grey market goods have been the bane of the electronics business and clothing business for as long as I can remember and now it's hitting the Auto industry hard parts wise. Fenders, bumpers, deck lids well, pretty much your whole car can be replaced with grey market stuff that will not pass industry saftey standards.

Sorry, small rant;)
 
Well, isn't it somehow required by law that these product conform to some safety standards?

This is a US-based dealer, from which I feel I should expect much better. I'm also planning at some point to resell this laptop or give it away, and I'd be very uncomfortable if it was unreliable or dangerous.

(btw... what are you saying about XBRs? because I'm considering buying one)
 
Well, isn't it somehow required by law that these product conform to some safety standards?

Not exactly in so many words. A UL cert just means when it blows up it won't burn your house down. There are FCC restrictions about interference but that doesn't mean anything about safety. Beyond that though the Consumer Product Safety Commission is charged with that task but the laws are rather vague and so they don't have a lot of teeth and most of the issues they catch are after the fact.
 
Not exactly in so many words. A UL cert just means when it blows up it won't burn your house down. There are FCC restrictions about interference but that doesn't mean anything about safety. Beyond that though the Consumer Product Safety Commission is charged with that task but the laws are rather vague and so they don't have a lot of teeth and most of the issues they catch are after the fact.

So there's basically no real law or reasonable expectation for the consumer, it's completely caveat emptor? And post-disaster enforcement? That seems bizarre to me.

Now that I'm poking around on ebay, I'm noticing that abotu 50% of the 18.5 70W adapters ahve grounded plugs, and about 95% of them have some safety certifications. I bought from these guys in US because the previous guy from HK couldn't successfully deliver the item. The transaction was otherwise quite good and customer support was responsive, however, I can't bring myself to trust this adapter.

http://cgi.ebay.com/Compaq-nc6000-n...ryZ31511QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem
 
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I was tempted to get a power adapter off of ebay for my laptop, but I couldn't bring myself to trust my $700 laptop to a sub $5 plug. I spent more for a used HP model, but I've had zero problems with it.

I'm with you on this though, don't want to spend too much money on an older laptop, but I don't know if I'd trust that either...
 
For what it's worth, neither of my laptop supplies, the original and a cheap spare I got
from compgeeks, have a grounded AC plug. They are bricks that take the old figure 8 two
wire AC line cord. So, apparently laptops aren't necessarily grounded to your service ground like a desktop PC would be.
 
If your new found PSU has a "UL" label on it you are probably fine. Be careful about eBay, you just never know where some (any?) of the stuff sold on there was sourced.

What you have is a "brick" type PSU and there should be no common ground point between the ground in your electrical system and the laptop.

In a laptop your primary power source would be the battery and the PSU is simply recharging the power source hopefully faster than you use it. These days it is not unusual to see 2 and 3 wire plugs on different models from different companies.

Hope that helps:)

No, whenever plugged in a laptop is running from the powersupply. Besides that it's also charging. If it charges slower when you using it on full load then it means they gave you a powersupply with not enough power.

The PSU of my ThinkPad T61 is a 90W 20V one. The T61 with onboard video mostly come with a 65W. The benefit of the higher voltage is lower current. Lower current = less loss, less heat with bad contacts = better.
 
Well, isn't it somehow required by law that these product conform to some safety standards?

This is a US-based dealer, from which I feel I should expect much better. I'm also planning at some point to resell this laptop or give it away, and I'd be very uncomfortable if it was unreliable or dangerous.

(btw... what are you saying about XBRs? because I'm considering buying one)

This is a google search list, poke around a bit:

http://www.google.com/search?q=grey...t:*&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&startIndex=&startPage=1

And things like this:

http://www.pioneerelectronics.com/PUSA/FindStore/Unauthorized+Internet+Dealers
 

I'm familliar with Pioneer's warranty policy, and that makes sense because they want customers to buy from reputable (and approved) dealers. From those links, it sounds like some "dealers" may be selling products intended for other target markets, but I don't understand what the benefit to them is in importing it or shipping it internationally. Actually, I wondered if you were suggesting that there were counterfeit XBRs or tv's refurbised with cheap parts.
 
I'm familliar with Pioneer's warranty policy, and that makes sense because they want customers to buy from reputable (and approved) dealers. From those links, it sounds like some "dealers" may be selling products intended for other target markets, but I don't understand what the benefit to them is in importing it or shipping it internationally. Actually, I wondered if you were suggesting that there were counterfeit XBRs or tv's refurbised with cheap parts.

This is getting way off topic but...

Counterfeit and Grey Market are two very different animals.

There are specific laws regarding counterfeiting how ever since we all know you can buy a Rolex anywhere on line for $35.00 to $? most are easy to spot.

Grey Market is far worse because the respective manufactures are all involved. I don't care who the manufacture is or what product they sell they all have one thing in common. They all sell products out the back door. To keep it short I'll pick on Sony.

We would all love to think every product they produce is perfect but, there are sometimes glitches and the company (every company) has a choice, fix it, toss it, or sell it to anyone with money. Produce more they you thought you could sell...well, it has to be sold somewhere.

Second problem. Sony of Japan is one company. Sony USA is an another company. Sony USA sells products to resellers and Sony USA will back the warrantee out of their own pockets. Sony Japan will have nothing to do with paying for USA product repair.

I used Sony as an example, pretty much every mass producer does this in one form or another
 
Back
Top