Lair got a 4.5 on gamespot.

zamardii

2[H]4U
Joined
Nov 22, 2004
Messages
3,106
http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/action/...topslot;title;1&om_act=convert&om_clk=topslot

Apparantly, the way you control the game is so terrible that that's what brought the score down as low as it is. The story was good, the graphics are amazing, but the controls (by what I read) are absolutely horrendous. Well... I guess i'll see how Heavenly Sword fairs. There's still a lot of great PS3 games coming out this year, but i'll want to rent this one anyway, just so I can see for myself.
 
Listen to EGM Live's latest podcast. Julian [SIZE=-1]Eggebrecht defends Lair against the EGM score. (Personally I side with EGM.)
[/SIZE]
 
Hillarious.
Whats the most important part of a game? Being able to control it!
This is illustarted really well in the Angry Video Game Nerd's video on the PowerGlove. Google it if you want to see a shining example of how great games can be made to seem like a pile of crap because you cant control them well.
 
Listen to EGM Live's latest podcast. Julian [SIZE=-1]Eggebrecht defends Lair against the EGM score. (Personally I side with EGM.)
[/SIZE]

Its an interesting explanation. But its hard to say....I mean I got used to the games controller eventually and thought it used them well but everyone seems to hate them so even if what he is saying is true you have to think that it was just a mistake. Or at the very least given us the option of using the joysticks,
 
A hilarious thing to be sure. Really drives home the point that graphics mean nothing in the overall scope of gaming. :p
 
Here's something you all might want to check out. It's a forum post on the Lair forum on gamespot entitled "The REAL reason why Lair got bad reviews." I don't know if I believe the guy, but apparantly we should wait until the next PC World magazine to comes out to see if the guys is wrong.

Read it if you were looking forward to Lair.

http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/action/lair/show_msgs.php?topic_id=m-1-37973604&pid=929230

I doubt what he is saying is true. He's probably one of the devs trying to get people to buy the game, rofl.
 
Here's something you all might want to check out. It's a forum post on the Lair forum on gamespot entitled "The REAL reason why Lair got bad reviews." I don't know if I believe the guy, but apparantly we should wait until the next PC World magazine to comes out to see if the guys is wrong.

Read it if you were looking forward to Lair.

http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/action/lair/show_msgs.php?topic_id=m-1-37973604&pid=929230

BS. If that were really the case, Factor 5 would have put out a patch that updated the review copy of the game to the new retail copy, and told reviewers to install the patch.
 
Jerry Holkins said:
You may find yourself in disbelief an hour into it, the Electronics Boutique receipt crumpled in your fist, trying to correlate Lair's non-stop torrent of anguish and your missing sixty bucks.

I think that sums it up best.
 
BS. If that were really the case, Factor 5 would have put out a patch that updated the review copy of the game to the new retail copy, and told reviewers to install the patch.

Well, they kept the game from releasing another couple of weeks. So one would assume that something was terribly wrong so they fixed it. I guess i'm just in denial...lmao. I was looking forward to this game. I'm going to rent it either way.
 
I bought the game when I heard it was released at Gamestop, it fails, miserably. The controls are just too frustrating. It wasn't just the SIXAXIS thing, I read the manual on how to do very basic moves and for some reason the game was just refusing to do them. I put a good 2 hours of gameplay into the game before I stopped and put it back in it's case. It's going back to gamestop on tomorrow, what a waste of $.
 
A hilarious thing to be sure. Really drives home the point that graphics mean nothing in the overall scope of gaming. :p

Hardly. Graphics mean a lot. Sure gameplay mean the most, but to say that graphics dont mean anything is just silly. Great gameplay, plus great graphics is a win/win. If graphics didnt mean anything, you'd be playing a NES.
 
Hardly. Graphics mean a lot. Sure gameplay mean the most, but to say that graphics dont mean anything is just silly. Great gameplay, plus great graphics is a win/win. If graphics didnt mean anything, you'd be playing a NES.

Last week I had friends over and we played a lot of Atari 2600. :eek:
 
Hardly. Graphics mean a lot. Sure gameplay mean the most, but to say that graphics dont mean anything is just silly. Great gameplay, plus great graphics is a win/win. If graphics didnt mean anything, you'd be playing a NES.

I take it you have never played a text adventure game. ;)
 
I'm calling shens on this one, I've seen your console collection pictures. :p

Sure, you may have see three - even four 360s, on my desk. On my desk I'll keep any old garbage. In front of my TV, there are 2600s as far as the eye can see.

<shifty eyes>
 
Hardly. Graphics mean a lot. Sure gameplay mean the most, but to say that graphics dont mean anything is just silly. Great gameplay, plus great graphics is a win/win. If graphics didnt mean anything, you'd be playing a NES.

Those old games though are still very fun and still bought today (XBM and Virtual Console)
If they kept making games, we'd probably all keep those systems a little longer :)

I understand what you are saying, but really deep down, it's the gameplay.
 
Only EGM and Play reviewed that version. Everyone else waited for the final review code.

Kind of weird then considering EGM gave it low scores and Play gave it 9/10, but then people in the Play magazine forums are saying that it was a "paid" review
 
This is not a good game. That's the best way I can sum it up.

And the controls aren't the biggest problem (at least for me they weren't). The game is bugged up the ass and feels like an early beta. Screen tearing, horrible collision models, flying through things, terrible fucking camera, unclear objectives, no HUD, broken animations, Lair has it all. In spades.

And that's not even getting into the story itself, which is about as interesting as a Murder, She Wrote marathon.

I'll have a full bitch-fest on my site about it tomorrow. I strongly believe that out of Lair's 25m+ budget Factor 5 keeps talking about, at least 20m of it was spent on blow and hookers. Seriously, the game is that bad. Well, it's actually not that bad, it's just that bad for a $25m game.
 
This is not a good game. That's the best way I can sum it up.

And the controls aren't the biggest problem (at least for me they weren't). The game is bugged up the ass and feels like an early beta. Screen tearing, horrible collision models, flying through things, terrible fucking camera, unclear objectives, no HUD, broken animations, Lair has it all. In spades.

And that's not even getting into the story itself, which is about as interesting as a Murder, She Wrote marathon.

I'll have a full bitch-fest on my site about it tomorrow. I strongly believe that out of Lair's 25m+ budget Factor 5 keeps talking about, at least 20m of it was spent on blow and hookers. Seriously, the game is that bad. Well, it's actually not that bad, it's just that bad for a $25m game.

*LOL* After reading that I can't wait to see your full impressions of the game!
 
Does anyone think they will release a patch to fix this? If they do release a patch, would they start printing newier versions of the game with the fix already on disc? Are they really gonna say "ok, well game was released, next project?" or will the genreal public, bad reviews make these devs wake up from all the blow they were doing :(
 
Does anyone think they will release a patch to fix this? If they do release a patch, would they start printing newier versions of the game with the fix already on disc? Are they really gonna say "ok, well game was released, next project?" or will the genreal public, bad reviews make these devs wake up from all the blow they were doing :(

The entire game needs to be "FIXED". I don't think this can be done with a patch. :)

The controls are not the only thing that makes Lair a terrible game. The game has graphical glitches and frame rates that slow to a crawl in large battles. Also, the gameplay is quite repetitive and dull. The camera angle can drive you mad. Then you factor in the awkward and unresponsive controls and you have a disaster of a game. I would be hard pressed to buy this game up in the budget bin for $30. Lair is definitely not worth $60.
 
The entire game needs to be "FIXED". I don't think this can be done with a patch.

The controls are not the only thing that makes Lair a terrible game. The game has graphical glitches and frame rates that slow to a crawl in large battles. Also, the gameplay is quite repetitive and dull. The camera angle can drive you mad. Then you factor in the awkward and unresponsive controls and you have a disaster of a game. I would be hard pressed to buy this game up in the budget bin for $30. Lair is definitely not worth $60.

Man, what a let down. :(
 
The entire game needs to be "FIXED". I don't think this can be done with a patch. :)

The controls are not the only thing that makes Lair a terrible game. The game has graphical glitches and frame rates that slow to a crawl in large battles. Also, the gameplay is quite repetitive and dull. The camera angle can drive you mad. Then you factor in the awkward and unresponsive controls and you have a disaster of a game. I would be hard pressed to buy this game up in the budget bin for $30. Lair is definitely not worth $60.

Even with the other flaws, I'd still play Lair if it supported the analog sticks.
 
I guess a cool thing about this game is that it supports remote play with the psp.
 
I have never seen framerate drops, and im about half way through the game. I've never seen screen tearing on my dell 2407 either. I have no idea WTF you guys are even talking about.

Lair is an okay game. The problem is, its different, and people cant handle it. no one is putting in the time required to get adjusted to the whole motion control thing, especially most chump review sites or magazines.

On a next-gen grade scale, the game deserves no less than a 7. How a gaming magazine or site can give this game a 4.5, but then give any Wii game anything higher than that just makes no effin sence to me.
 
This is not a good game. That's the best way I can sum it up.

And the controls aren't the biggest problem (at least for me they weren't). The game is bugged up the ass and feels like an early beta. Screen tearing, horrible collision models, flying through things, terrible fucking camera, unclear objectives, no HUD, broken animations, Lair has it all. In spades.

And that's not even getting into the story itself, which is about as interesting as a Murder, She Wrote marathon.

I'll have a full bitch-fest on my site about it tomorrow. I strongly believe that out of Lair's 25m+ budget Factor 5 keeps talking about, at least 20m of it was spent on blow and hookers. Seriously, the game is that bad. Well, it's actually not that bad, it's just that bad for a $25m game.

What website is this?
 
I have never seen framerate drops, and im about half way through the game. I've never seen screen tearing on my dell 2407 either. I have no idea WTF you guys are even talking about.

Lair is an okay game. The problem is, its different, and people cant handle it. no one is putting in the time required to get adjusted to the whole motion control thing, especially most chump review sites or magazines.

On a next-gen grade scale, the game deserves no less than a 7. How a gaming magazine or site can give this game a 4.5, but then give any Wii game anything higher than that just makes no effin sence to me.

WTF is the "next gen grade scale"? Either the game sucks of it doesn't, I don't care what it looks like.

Graphics can make a good game better, but they won't make a shitty game good.
 
WTF is the "next gen grade scale"? Either the game sucks of it doesn't, I don't care what it looks like.

Graphics can make a good game better, but they won't make a shitty game good.

heh exactly.

But for his "Next gen grade scale" it still sucks compared to already released next gen games. heh
 
Isnt there supposed to be a team that tests these games before they come out?? Seriously why would you even let this thing out the door. Delay the shit out of it if you have to but dont release buggy peices of crap. I just dont get it :confused:
 
It doesn't shock me at all most of consoles first few games suck mad ass it would be best to wait at least a year before expecting some actual quality in the games.

On that note Heavenly Sward is probably going to suck as well.
 
On a next-gen grade scale, the game deserves no less than a 7. How a gaming magazine or site can give this game a 4.5, but then give any Wii game anything higher than that just makes no effin sence to me.

Probably because Nintendo knows how to properly utilize their motion sensitive controller in games. Lair's devs apparently did not.
 
Back
Top