know any true surround headphones

hard-in-da-paint

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 4, 2011
Messages
168
i currently use tritton ax pros. i just wanted to clarify to people who want to buy surround sound headphones that there are many different types. so be careful what u buy. (look at the connection they use). lets start out with stereo headphones.(3.5mm jack) they take multi channel audio and smush it into 2 channels. simulated surround sound heaphones(usb,3.5mm, optical) do something similar, but instead of just smushing it into 2 channels, they take the audio, and produce all the channels through the 2 drivers. for example you can hear the different channels, but only from two directions, left and right. true surround sound headphones(optical, analog 5.1 sound 3.5mm jacks) take the multi channel audio and produce it into differently placed drivers in the headphones (tritton ax pros have 4 drivers per earcup.) i only know of turtle beach and tritton making true surround sound headphones, anybody know any?
 
How can you have multiple drivers for multiple channels by each ear. That's not surround sound. You can't put a speaker on your forehead and that's where the center channel is located in a 5.1 setup.

You only have 2 ears so you only need 2 sources of sound. Your brain along with the shape and placement of your ears does the rest of the work in determining where the sound came from.
 
How can you have multiple drivers for multiple channels by each ear. That's not surround sound. You can't put a speaker on your forehead and that's where the center channel is located in a 5.1 setup.

You only have 2 ears so you only need 2 sources of sound. Your brain along with the shape and placement of your ears does the rest of the work in determining where the sound came from.


This is completely true. Don't believe? Put in the cheapest earbuds you have and listen to the low bit-rate virtual barbershop on youtube and tell me you don't get believable surround sound experience out of just two drivers.
 
Yep, decent sounding, but surround. :confused:

537860694_481872048d.jpg
 
Google Sennheiser Surrounder for images lol

ha i did. that's absurd. my girlfriend already thinks i look goofy enough wearing my headphones, i don't need to throw gasoline on that fire.
 
They are stupid. I was actually thinking of building a halo surround like that with a cheap 5.1. Using cables from the ceiling....Seriously. I like to play with speakers apparently. Thank goodness my wife laughs at me and doesn't give a flip.
 
They are stupid. I was actually thinking of building a halo surround like that with a cheap 5.1. Using cables from the ceiling....Seriously. I like to play with speakers apparently. Thank goodness my wife laughs at me and doesn't give a flip.

No, what you need is one of those halo things they use on people who break their necks - then you mount the speakers on brackets off of that.
 
Well if you want real, proper, positional HRTF to give a convincing image with headphones, you have to spend a shitload of money. Reason is they must track your head movement and it is specialized and high end, thus costly. I am aware of three options:

1) HeaDSPeaker. Cost 380 Euro which is like $540 currently. It is a processor and a unit that attaches to any large headphones and provides head tracking. Takes USB or DD/DTS input and handles the HRTF. No idea how good it is, it is fairly new and I've heard nothing about it. Part of the quality would depend on the phones used.

2) Beyerdynamic Headzone Home HT. Costs about $1800 for an all inclusive system. Comes with phones (DT-880s), processor, IR tracking, the whole 9 yards. You feed in a 5.1 DD or DTS signal, it does the rest.

3) Smyth Realiser A8. Costs $3700 for a system. It is a more advanced processor, which is capable of measuring and reproducing actual surround systems. It can function along with on so you put on your phones, it automatically switches to phones, take them off it switches to speakers and you never hear a difference. Comes with the processor, measurement mics, tracking gear, and high end Stax phones/amp though it can worth with others.

You can have what you want, real, proper HRTF that makes it sound like you are listening to a surround system, but you'll pay big bucks to have it.
 
How can you have multiple drivers for multiple channels by each ear. That's not surround sound. You can't put a speaker on your forehead and that's where the center channel is located in a 5.1 setup.

You only have 2 ears so you only need 2 sources of sound. Your brain along with the shape and placement of your ears does the rest of the work in determining where the sound came from.

ik wat ur talking about, but ( and no im not a little fanboy) my ax pros clearly define which direction the sound is coming from. the center channel sound functions like normal headphones, it just kind of comes out of both middle drivers. but i mean surround sound by the fact that it has forward and rear channels and the center channel that function like a real 5.1 sorround sound setup. in cod, i hear someone coming up behind me from the rear drivers. same with the front.
 
ik wat ur talking about, but ( and no im not a little fanboy) my ax pros clearly define which direction the sound is coming from. the center channel sound functions like normal headphones, it just kind of comes out of both middle drivers. but i mean surround sound by the fact that it has forward and rear channels and the center channel that function like a real 5.1 sorround sound setup. in cod, i hear someone coming up behind me from the rear drivers. same with the front.

I believe you do hear some positional sounds in headphones like the ones you described with multiple speakers, but at what cost?

I have never had a problem hearing position in regular 2-drives headphones like my Sennheiser HD600s. In fact, I think the increased sound-stage from a good pair of stereo headphones helps detect sound position even better.

If you pay $100 for headphones that have 6 drives crammed in them then you are paying $16 per speaker. With a stereo set for $100, you are paying $50 per speaker and therefor getting a much better speaker with much better sound.

I guess what I'm saying is that I haven't heard a pair of headphones with multiple drivers that had any better positional sound than a good pair of stereo headphones. Not that multi-driver headphones don't work period.


For a game like Call of duty or counterstrike, the key is to select the headphone option and not the stereo option when using headphones. Even though both settings output 2 channels, the headphone option tunes the sound to add in tiny audio cues that allow the brain to determine location with only 2 speakers. Selecting stereo is designed for stereo speakers, but selecting headphone, runs the sound through a HRTF algorithm for position.

See here for more info on how this works:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Head-related_transfer_function
 
SirMaster and Sycraft have it right.

A good pair of stereo headphones beats any 5.1 headset ever made. There is simply a huge difference in terms of detail level, sound or head stage size and sound quality.

Stereo headphones, good ones, with proper amping and the right source setup, can literally form a globe of sound around your head. Just like what the multiple speaker headsets try to do. The difference is the good headphones sound is so much clearer that you can discern not only direction but also distance and elevation.

Now many new headsets, stereo ones, do much better nowadays. Many of them will do nicely for the money. When you upgrade, there is a point of diminishing returns. If you get a pair of say Denon D2000a decent soundcard for around $300 or so, you would need to spend roughly twice that to get a "worth it" upgrade. After that $600 level, you would really need to go for broke to get that same feeling. Like the Smyth realizer mentioned previously.

So, buy stereo, be happy?
 
What headphones have you tried so far? What DSP (digital signal processing) have you tried?
 
i agree, stereo headphone quality is much better, as i only use my ax pros for call of duty. litterally. on other games i use my beats by dre earbuds, there good enough for me. before i got the ax pros i did experience some directional sound, but with the more clearly defined directional audio through multiple drivers i have really improved in my gameplay. im not old enough to have a job, so 300 dollar headphones plus an amp that costs another 100 or so is out of the question.
 
Nobody is saying you need a $300 set of headphones and a $100 amp.

Its possible to get a HD595 for under $125.
 
i agree, stereo headphone quality is much better, as i only use my ax pros for call of duty. litterally. on other games i use my beats by dre earbuds, there good enough for me. before i got the ax pros i did experience some directional sound, but with the more clearly defined directional audio through multiple drivers i have really improved in my gameplay. im not old enough to have a job, so 300 dollar headphones plus an amp that costs another 100 or so is out of the question.

Sell your the beats by dr dre...and the ax pros...and buy some decent sounding headphones :)
 
Back
Top