Kaspersky Lab: Microsoft Software Products Pretty Darn Secure

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Kaspersky has just released its latest IT Threat Evolution report and at long last, a top ten list that Microsoft is happy about not making. Microsoft has been making headway in the fight to keep its software resistant to vulnerabilities as possible. You can thank Microsoft’s automatic updates for helping clean up its act. :cool:

A few years ago, Microsoft would be all over the list, but starting with the release of Windows Vista, the company has seriously cleaned up its act.
 
UAC was a great idea. It is a shame they made the option to turn it off.

If you used a desktop environment with root privileges in the UNIX world, you'd be laughed out of town.
 
If UAC couldn't have been turned off, then software developer would have had no choice but to redesign the way their software had to run and update. I disable UAC at home but I enforce it at work via Group Policy on servers and workstations.
 
If UAC couldn't have been turned off, then software developer would have had no choice but to redesign the way their software had to run and update. I disable UAC at home but I enforce it at work via Group Policy on servers and workstations.
Oh, I meant that as a good thing actually. If software didn't require UAC to be disabled in order to function properly or to update itself (some software is like this), then it would be a lot easier to keep UAC on.
 
UAC is annoying, but it really is a good thing and Windows Update is the best thing that ever happened to WIndows, but it existed long before Vista came out.
 
If UAC couldn't have been turned off, then software developer would have had no choice but to redesign the way their software had to run and update. I disable UAC at home but I enforce it at work via Group Policy on servers and workstations.

Sorry to be blunt but if your software requires UAC to be off in order to run then you fail as a programmer.

At no point was it ever acceptable to have non-system administration related applications require complete administrative access to the system. Lazy programmers simply had an easier time getting away with it.

I've seen games that require administrative access. Games. If anyone had released a game for *nix that required root access, they would have been tarred and feathered for their incompetence.

Not only should UAC have not been able to be turned off but any error should display a message that says this program was written by incompetent morons; here is the number to call and complain to them about it.
 
i bet my windows is more secure than a Mac.

I could give it to my dad and he won't get a virus.
 
Sorry to be blunt but if your software requires UAC to be off in order to run then you fail as a programmer.

At no point was it ever acceptable to have non-system administration related applications require complete administrative access to the system. Lazy programmers simply had an easier time getting away with it.

I've seen games that require administrative access. Games. If anyone had released a game for *nix that required root access, they would have been tarred and feathered for their incompetence.

Not only should UAC have not been able to be turned off but any error should display a message that says this program was written by incompetent morons; here is the number to call and complain to them about it.


I definitely agree, but you still run into problems with programs not interacting well without being used with "Run as Administrator" and such. In the beginning it was a lot of laziness which could have been avoided, now I don't run into very many installs that actually would require it.
 
Impressive.

I wonder how much of that is how they have been hiding the "run it anyway" option (hidden pretty well in win8). Also the basic assumption was that they would break too much legacy code; most of the screams about bad windows updates have been about the UI of win8 (and to a lesser extent vista).

I also have to wonder if they managed to lock down all the places between UAC 1.0 (click anywhere and trigger UAC) and more recent (I believe released before win7) useable UAC. There was a reason that you could compromise an xp box with just about any of those actions.

Of course, if you really want secure: winRT has a walled garden for you.
 
I don't notice UAC much at all to be honest, or maybe I'm just that used to it now.

BTW you might as well assume every piece of hardware and software comes with security risks
 
I don't notice UAC much at all to be honest, or maybe I'm just that used to it now.

BTW you might as well assume every piece of hardware and software comes with security risks

Computer hardware tends to be safe until someone a problem walks up between the keyboard and chair (exceptions: routers have been shipped with default passwords and internet control).

I also think you are missing the history of Microsoft's relentless failures when it comes to security. Not only was it one bad joke after another, it was the same tired old joke of security over and over. It took awhile after Melissa shipped to eventually remove the "turn on macros even if they are supposed to be off" feature that allowed .doc viruses to work on any computers. There were virus named after hoaxes because nobody would be stupid enough to execute code received from email before a human even saw it (Microsoft was that stupid). Jpegs were assumed to be incapable of transmitting viruses (they are data, don't run them) but not only did Microsoft manage to have a buffer overrun (allowing the jpeg to put whatever code into the CPU), they managed to do it in the kernal after welding the browser to the OS.

It is impressive that win7, vista, and win8 aren't on this list. It is absolutely shocking that XP isn't on there (although I don't think winamp could be on there without OS assistance). Seriously, delete all adobe and Java systems you can from your system.

On the other hand, I wouldn't go assuming that your XP system is safe, just because the top ten don't hit you doesn't mean 11-100 aren't going to slip right in. Much like the campers outrunning the bear, even if you can't outrun the bear you at least need to outrun one camper. Having UAC on should go a long way to keep attacks 11-100 out. WinRT is in another league altogether (and should be considered about as much a "PC" as an ipad).
 
Back
Top