Just got a PS3, have a video cable question

I'm guessing you mean HDMI vs. Component (RBG) cables, yes?
HDMI is the best cable solution, period. It carries both your audio and video and it'll do 1080p and lossless audio, too. No other solution will do that.
You might need to run a separate audio cable if you have a surround sound receiver with no HDMI in/out. Otherwise, HDMI is an all-in-one solution.
"Optical" is the fiber-optic audio cable. It's a great solution for 99% of cases, but HDMI is better if you have a receiver that can utilize it. If you're only listening through your TV's speakers, it'll also work just fine.
 
I'm guessing you mean HDMI vs. Component (RBG) cables, yes?
HDMI is the best cable solution, period. It carries both your audio and video and it'll do 1080p and lossless audio, too. No other solution will do that.
You might need to run a separate audio cable if you have a surround sound receiver with no HDMI in/out. Otherwise, HDMI is an all-in-one solution.
"Optical" is the fiber-optic audio cable. It's a great solution for 99% of cases, but HDMI is better if you have a receiver that can utilize it. If you're only listening through your TV's speakers, it'll also work just fine.

optical will do lossless too, yes?
 
No Optical will not do lossless. The PS3 converts to PCM. HDMI is the only current interface that will do lossless, and you need a receiver to support it. I use HDMi for video, optical for audio since I'm not upgrading my receiver just yet.

See the Onkyo 605 for that :)
 
No Optical will not do lossless. The PS3 converts to PCM. HDMI is the only current interface that will do lossless, and you need a receiver to support it. I use HDMi for video, optical for audio since I'm not upgrading my receiver just yet.

See the Onkyo 605 for that :)

Yeah, I just bought an SR-605 a couple of months ago. I don't like that you can't name the inputs but beyond that it's flawless.
 
No Optical will not do lossless. The PS3 converts to PCM. HDMI is the only current interface that will do lossless, and you need a receiver to support it. I use HDMi for video, optical for audio since I'm not upgrading my receiver just yet.

See the Onkyo 605 for that :)

ok, makes sense. Optical will still do Dolby True-HD and DTS-Hd though, yes?
 
ok, makes sense. Optical will still do Dolby True-HD and DTS-Hd though, yes?
No. Those are lossless formats and Optical cable simply does not have the bandwidth to handle an uncompressed audio format.
Corret me if I am wrong though, I am not expert.
 
ok, makes sense. Optical will still do Dolby True-HD and DTS-Hd though, yes?

I *think* so, but that's tough to say. The PS3's really odd with those formats. It wants to either decode them itself, or otherwise it doesn't work with them.
With optical it claims it's playing them itself, but I can't really prove it. The receiver won't confirm it, obviously.
 
However you would need some extremely expensive hard-to-obtain sound development type speakers in order to tell the difference between HDMI and optical audio.
 
However you would need some extremely expensive hard-to-obtain sound development type speakers in order to tell the difference between HDMI and optical audio.

This is true, 'cept for the 7.1 and lossless items. You can tell the difference between those with a set of pawn shop speakers. It's not huge or a deal breaker, but you can tell pretty easily. For 95% of customers, you're right though.
 
No. Those are lossless formats and Optical cable simply does not have the bandwidth to handle an uncompressed audio format.
Corret me if I am wrong though, I am not expert.

I thought lossless was just PCM 6.1/7.1/5.1, and the HD standards were still compressed, just very high bitrate. :confused:
 
I thought lossless was just PCM 6.1/7.1/5.1, and the HD standards were still compressed, just very high bitrate. :confused:

Yeah, that's my understanding. PCM 5.1 and 7.1 are the way to go. The PS3 will tell you how much data is passing through and the the PCM audio has about twice as much data as the HD versions of Dolby and DTS. I personally can't really tell the difference, though.
As far as I can guess, the Dolby and DTS HD formats might be for receivers that can't do multi-channel PCM. Right now I dunno of any that are in that boat, but maybe in in a few years it'll be cheaper. Either that or maybe future disks won't have the multi-channel PCM audio but will instead have only the HD codecs.
 
Yeah, that's my understanding. PCM 5.1 and 7.1 are the way to go. The PS3 will tell you how much data is passing through and the the PCM audio has about twice as much data as the HD versions of Dolby and DTS. I personally can't really tell the difference, though.
As far as I can guess, the Dolby and DTS HD formats might be for receivers that can't do multi-channel PCM. Right now I dunno of any that are in that boat, but maybe in in a few years it'll be cheaper. Either that or maybe future disks won't have the multi-channel PCM audio but will instead have only the HD codecs.

Odd, I don't know of any recievers that can do more than stereo PCM... :confused:

HD codec recievers are at 1500+ easily. What reciever can do 5.1+ PCM?
 
Back
Top