Judge Rules Against Rambus

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
U.S. District Judge Sue Robinson has ruled that the patents in question are unenforceable against Micron because Rambus had destroyed documents pertaining to the case. Thanks to Wayne F. for the linkage.

A U.S. District Court ruled on Friday that Rambus destroyed documents in a court case and therefore may not enforce patents against memory chip maker Micron Technology. "The very integrity of the litigation process has been impugned," U.S. District Judge Sue Robinson said in her decision, issued in Wilmington, Del.
 
Thanks Steve (same guy ;) )

BTW

this is in Rambus home Turf (ie where the incorporated). So this is no commieformia or anywhere else (incase you look up the unclean hands from THREE YEARS ago).

So as things stand TODAY. ALL the patents that RAMBUS was trying to enforce, are unenforceable. This is not only against MICRON now. This is across the board folks. That means that anyone else RAMBUS was trying to enforce these patents have a reprieve for the time being until the forthecoming appeals is completed.
 
Man I hopes this is the start of Rambus just disappearing. I despise companies that do NOTHING but try to litagate on shakey patents they may or may not own to make money instead of actually making a fucking product!
 
They dropped 39.24% today on over 10 TIMES the average volume. The stock was making a comeback too. Oh well.
 
Well, if the theory is correct, Since she was one judge that went against "all" the other judges. The dip will be short lived (depending on when appeals go).
 
Man I hopes this is the start of Rambus just disappearing. I despise companies that do NOTHING but try to litagate on shakey patents they may or may not own to make money instead of actually making a fucking product!

eh? rambus makes products.... they do suck as a company tho lol
 
FINALLY THEY CAN STFU AND DIE

Finally?

Not happening. That was the US District Court for the District of Delaware. Now Rambus is going to appeal to the next higher court in line, which would be the Third Circuit court of Appeals.
 
eh? rambus makes products.... they do suck as a company tho lol

Rambus is a licensing company. They own IP that they license to other companies. Now, there's nothing wrong with that, I guess - it's pretty damn expensive to build fabs and such. But the company's entire existence, really, is predicated upon a legal victory that has maybe a 50-50 chance of success.

This loss or victory (depending upon your point of view) is only good until the appeal, which will happen. I see it going to the 3rd District panel, then the full 3rd District, then getting turned down by the Supreme Court.
 
Rambus is a licensing company. They own IP that they license to other companies. Now, there's nothing wrong with that, I guess - it's pretty damn expensive to build fabs and such. But the company's entire existence, really, is predicated upon a legal victory that has maybe a 50-50 chance of success.

This loss or victory (depending upon your point of view) is only good until the appeal, which will happen. I see it going to the 3rd District panel, then the full 3rd District, then getting turned down by the Supreme Court.

^^^ What they said. Licensing companies for the most part are a bad thing. They sit on all these patents for vauge or ill defined "ideas" and then proceed to MAYBE make a product and sit on the vast majority of the rest. Then when someone makes a product that even vaguely infringes on one of these patents they sue them to make money on something that they themselves have no intention of developing. This is bad for business as a whole because it stifles innovation due to fears of costly litigation.
 
On a twist of the phrase "Are We there Yet?" I'd make It Are They Dead yet? Are They Dead yet? Are They Dead yet? Are They Dead yet? Are They Dead yet? Are They Dead yet? ;)
 
Man I hopes this is the start of Rambus just disappearing. I despise companies that do NOTHING but try to litagate on shakey patents they may or may not own to make money instead of actually making a fucking product!
Quite the contrary, have you heard of XDR?
 
^^^ What they said. Licensing companies for the most part are a bad thing. They sit on all these patents for vauge or ill defined "ideas" and then proceed to MAYBE make a product and sit on the vast majority of the rest. Then when someone makes a product that even vaguely infringes on one of these patents they sue them to make money on something that they themselves have no intention of developing. This is bad for business as a whole because it stifles innovation due to fears of costly litigation.
If anyone's guilty of stifling technology, it was JEDEC.
 
Haha you guys have absolutely no idea what Rambus is or how they have progressed the industry. Just because RAM makers stole Rambus' ideas to make DDR3 and the upcoming DDR4, it doesn't mean Rambus had nothing to do with it. Not only that, Rambus also makes XDR which is hella fast in comparison. And that is just the stupidly short version of Reality
 
If I recall the story as reported here on HardOCP Rambus was participating in the JEDEC meetings to make an industry standard for ddr. Instead of letting the others know about a potential patent violation they drop out of the conference, then after dropping out append an earlier patent and start threatening lawsuits. I am too lazy to look through the news archives to find the articles.

To me it seems they let the others commit to manufacturing then cleared up the wording of the patent to cover exactly what they knew was going to violate their patent and proceeded to sue. If it was all good why not tell JEDEC they were infringing? Why ammend a patent? Because JEDEC would have redesigned and RAMBUS would have no money.
 
Haha you guys have absolutely no idea what Rambus is or how they have progressed the industry. Just because RAM makers stole Rambus' ideas to make DDR3 and the upcoming DDR4, it doesn't mean Rambus had nothing to do with it. Not only that, Rambus also makes XDR which is hella fast in comparison. And that is just the stupidly short version of Reality


The problem is, If incase the unclean hands sticks (that is the ruling that made the patent unenforceable against Micron). Then RAMBus was completely aware that they were leading JDEC down a litigating path.

Regardless of performance. Why did Rambus decide to have a "shred" day? No need for that unless you are hidding something, They could patnent the golden toilet that wipes your ass. As of right now, that patent can not be enforced, and since 3rd Circuit is DC home turf... the probability of them winning is not a good one.
 
Your version is skewed and distorted. I'd suggest researching it again to refresh your memory.
 
Your version is skewed and distorted. I'd suggest researching it again to refresh your memory.


Don't need to.

As the unclean hands case is transcribed in full (Thank you Pacernet!) I have access to what was shown in court. Hell Rambus was nice enough to post the entire opinion online in thier investors section.....

seeing as you need a bit of help...

from rambus themselves

http://investor.rambus.com/downloadCenter.cfm?CategoryList=Micron vs Rambus

The PDF itself

and...

the information you are looking for is page 12/35

and of particular instance page 15/35. Item #19.

and I quote

US District Court for the District of Delaware said:
10. On September 3, 1998, Rambus employees participated in an event dubbed "Shred day", during which they destroyed documents pursuant to the companies new document retention policy. 32

and if you read the subscript 32. It seems benign enough. But then when you get to 33. Micron was able to establish that RAMBus did infact shred numerous documents that were discoverable and important to the trial! ;)

Hence why history might have you believe the nonesense you just spewed, but as of right now. It is not. Perhaps appeals might change that but the underlying facts where proven in RAMbus's home turf state of Delaware for having unclean hands. ;)
 
Is this football or something? It doesn't matter what turf said court is in. Appeals will fix that anyways. Still, none of that says Rambus wasn't ripped off and forced out of the industry.
 
Is this football or something? It doesn't matter what turf said court is in. Appeals will fix that anyways. Still, none of that says Rambus wasn't ripped off and forced out of the industry.


lol

If that crystal ball works as well as you think it does, you should go play the lottery (powerball up to 140million).

In this case, what it says is that RAMBus lied, and then tried to cover it up by shreding evidence. ;)
 
lol

If that crystal ball works as well as you think it does, you should go play the lottery (powerball up to 140million).

In this case, what it says is that RAMBus lied, and then tried to cover it up by shreding evidence. ;)

Its ironic how you patronize me for my crystal ball, yet yours lets you look at shredded documents to know what they contain.
 
Rambus's "innovations" are just obvious under the art engineering that others had been involved in across the industry, too obvious for anyone to bother patenting.

The courts aren't buying thier crap anymore, and thier "shred day" speaks volumes for thier own opinion of thier actions. The innocent and righteous don't have "shred days".
 
Its ironic how you patronize me for my crystal ball, yet yours lets you look at shredded documents to know what they contain.

Irony? don't be so dellusional!


Unlike your speculative nonsense. The GUILTY verdict that was passed by the judge disagrees with your rhetoric that you continue to spew, hence why RAMBUS got a non-enforceable patent order against them. You know, that whole cause-effect thing. Cause: RAMBUS shredded docs that had relevant information pertaining to the case. Effect: Judge finds RAMBUS guilty of Unclean Hands and orders all patents that RAMBUS INC. is trying to enforce against Micron, unenforceable. Go ahead and read that again, and again, and again. If, and when you understand that basic fact. THEN get back to me. Until then. It is your ignorant belief and nothing else.

Perhaps a couple classes in juriceprudance would teach you the basics of determining guilt and a basic cause-effect relation. Part of having a case in a court of law.
 
Rambus's "innovations" are just obvious under the art engineering that others had been involved in across the industry, too obvious for anyone to bother patenting.

The courts aren't buying thier crap anymore, and thier "shred day" speaks volumes for thier own opinion of thier actions. The innocent and righteous don't have "shred days".

No, they aren't. "obvious innovations" at all.

Irony? don't be so dellusional!


Unlike your speculative nonsense. The GUILTY verdict that was passed by the judge disagrees with your rhetoric that you continue to spew, hence why RAMBUS got a non-enforceable patent order against them. You know, that whole cause-effect thing. Cause: RAMBUS shredded docs that had relevant information pertaining to the case. Effect: Judge finds RAMBUS guilty of Unclean Hands and orders all patents that RAMBUS INC. is trying to enforce against Micron, unenforceable. Go ahead and read that again, and again, and again. If, and when you understand that basic fact. THEN get back to me. Until then. It is your ignorant belief and nothing else.

Perhaps a couple classes in juriceprudance would teach you the basics of determining guilt and a basic cause-effect relation. Part of having a case in a court of law.

I guess we'll find out after the appeals, huh?
 
I guess we'll find out after the appeals, huh?

All the appeals!

Regardless of how appeals go in the 3rd Circuit court of Appeals, it will go up from there, regardless if the appellate courts sides with RAMBUS or Micron. Part of the "game" in the US court system between people/companies with money.
 
'No, they aren't. "obvious innovations" at all.'

Yeah, they are. I've designed dozens of systems, with ram involved since the old 150ns 64K dram chips up to DDR2. I also read through the patents mentioned in that court decision PDF. There is NO innovation in them. Hundreds of engineers in commercial and industrial electronics design have gone down the same paths and developed the same "innovations" in the coursde of doing thier jobs.

Yes, Rambus reduced the design aspects to intergrated silicon, but the design concepts are in fact obvious under the art.

The meaning, legal meaning of OBVIOUS UNDER THE ART used by the PTO (pre-Reagan "reform") really is not hard to understand. Would anyone IN THE INDUSTRY develop the same mechanism in the normal course of design, if faced with a similar problem to be solved? If the answer is yes, then it is obvious under the art.

There are only so many ways to code up calculating the square root, and frankly they are all obvious under the art, though each result can be COPYRIGHTED, and in fact have been in the past. They are not patentable, by are copyrightable.

Rambus could legitimately copyright the transistor pattern on thier chip layout, but simply implementing a specific obvious solution just doesn't cut it for patent protection.

I assure you, the kernal of most of the things they patented are likely duplicated in the technical notebooks of literally dozens of engineers around the nation and the world over the last 30+ years since dynamic ram was first invented.

Far far worse than any of the patenability crap is Rambus's conduct, as illuminated in the court papers.

They sat in on JEDEC, and decided to lay down a mine feild of patent bombs in the pathway of JEDECs direction, all the while acting to steer the body in that very direction.

All members of JEDEC operate under agreement as members, that they MUST alert the body to potential conflicts, not lay in wait, hoping to spring a trap on the industry down the road.

The point of JEDEC is to arrive at open standards that the industry as a whole can rally around. The betrayal of trust is monumental. And Rambus knew there were lines they crossed and much shredding and coverups ensued, according to the court documents.

If the industry knew there were items of the forming standard that would violate someone's patent-s (regardless of it's ultimate validity), and leave all the members in jeopardy in the $millions, they would NOT chose to go down that path... but Rambus wanted them to fall into just such a trap, and acted accordingly.

It is not just Micron and the others affected, I remember motherboard makers being strongarmed in the past by Rambus to pay up if they implemented systems using ...blah blah.

We, the consuming public, we were affected. These tactics acted to derail standards and ultimately raise prices and cost us money as well.

I'll let the lawyers detail what class action suits may come of all this, from JEDEC for violating thier trust and likely their terms of membership. From consumers and state AG's for the added costs borne by the consumer, and by each of the manufacturers who've been the target of what seems to now be a defective legal process.

Everyone Rambus sued and settled or got awards from will potentially come out of the woodwork now, to get their cash back, seek new trials with this new evidence (of the lack of evidence, and document shredding) :cool: so all the finagling Rambus has been involved with is likely to come back to haunt them big time in the future.

This is NOT the way to run an economy, or industry, or company. These are despicable acts and they should be severely punished. :eek::rolleyes::p
 
Its ironic how you patronize me for my crystal ball, yet yours lets you look at shredded documents to know what they contain.

In a civil litigation, both parties have a duty to preserve relevant evidence when litigation is reasonably foreseeable between the parties. If you destroy evidence that is relevant to a civil litigation, the opposing party can claim spoliation based on the destruction of that evidence. The court can infer that you destroyed evidence that was harmful to your position (which seems fair, given that you had a duty not to destroy it in the first place and, lets face it, you're not going to destroy helpful evidence) and sanction or instruct the jury as necessary to overcome the prejudice inherent from the loss of relevant evidence.

In this case, the sanction was the a variation of the so-called "death-penalty" - RAMBUS loses and can't bring a suit against Micron on the same cause of action (patent infringement on these patents) again.
 
the confusion continues

By Greg Stohr

Feb. 23 (Bloomberg) -- The U.S. Supreme Court turned away the Federal Trade Commission’s bid to impose antitrust penalties that would have limited the royalties collected by memory-chip technology company Rambus Inc.

The justices, without comment, left intact a federal appeals court decision favoring Rambus, which gets more than 80 percent of its revenue from royalties. The lower court threw out FTC findings that Rambus undermined competition in the $20 billion market for dynamic random-access memory chips by scheming to get secretly patented technology included in industrywide standards.

Today’s rebuff is a setback to four chipmakers that stood to benefit from the FTC order -- Micron Technology Inc., Hynix Semiconductor Inc., Nanya Technology Corp. and Nvidia Corp. Those companies, all involved in litigation with Rambus, joined the agency in urging review. The high court rejection may mark the end to the FTC’s seven-year pursuit of Rambus.

“After enduring years of lost business, uncertainty, and spending millions of dollars defending ourselves against the FTC’s ill-founded allegations, we’re pleased the Supreme Court has put an end to these claims,” Rambus general counsel Tom Lavelle said in a statement.

Rambus rose 39 cents, or 6.2 percent, to $6.70 at 4 p.m. New York time in Nasdaq Stock Market trading. The company is based in Los Altos, California.

“This was not the decision we were hoping for, and we are now reviewing our options,” said David Wales, acting director of the FTC’s Bureau of Competition.

FTC Allegations

The FTC argued in court papers filed in Washington that Rambus “waited to assert its patent interests until the new standards had been widely implemented.” The agency said Rambus then “demanded stiff royalties from makers of the great majority of computer memory chips.”

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia rejected the FTC’s case on a 3-0 vote. The panel said the FTC had taken “an aggressive interpretation of rather weak evidence.”

After the appeals court ruling, Rambus said it will get $5.2 million in royalties that were held back during the case.

The case had implications for hundreds of private standard- setting organizations, many of them in high-tech fields. More than 20 such groups told the justices that the type of conduct in which Rambus allegedly engaged could “severely undermine and jeopardize” standard-setting efforts.

Four computer industry companies -- Hewlett-Packard Co., Cisco Systems Inc., Sun Microsystems Inc. and Oracle Corp. --made similar arguments in calling on the court to hear the case.

Following the Rules

Rambus says it never had any undisclosed patents or pending applications while it was a member of the standard-setting body, known as the Joint Electronic Device Engineering Council or JEDEC. Rambus also says JEDEC had no rule requiring members to disclose their intellectual property.

The FTC contended that JEDEC, had it known about Rambus’s plans to seek patent coverage, would have either adopted different technologies or required that the company agree to limits on its royalties.

The appeals court faulted the FTC for not specifying which of those outcomes would have occurred. The three-judge panel also said that higher royalties weren’t enough to establish the required anticompetitive effect.

Rambus said the appeals court used the right analysis. Federal antitrust law “requires proof that the misconduct resulted in a less competitive market,” the company argued.

Misconduct Alleged

The FTC said the lower court “ignored the commission’s detailed showing that Rambus’s misconduct had seriously disrupted the competitive process in which technologies compete for inclusion in industry standards.”

The full D.C. Circuit refused to reconsider the ruling in August. The FTC’s prospects for Supreme Court review then suffered a blow when U.S. Solicitor General Gregory Garre, who served as the Bush administration’s top courtroom lawyer, opted not to join the agency in seeking a hearing.

“Everybody else who has looked at it has said there was no duty to disclose,” Lavelle said in an interview.

The case is Federal Trade Commission v. Rambus, 08-694.

To contact the reporter on this story: Greg Stohr in Washington at gstohr@bloomberg.net.

Last Updated: February 23, 2009 16:08 EST

http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20670001&refer=home&sid=at5P6AmiOMsQ#
 
Back
Top