Judge Blocks Webcam in RIAA Case

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
We just got word from the Harvard Law team that the First Circuit Court has blocked the requested webcast in the case of the Recording Industry Association of America vs. Joel Tenenbaum. As always, thanks to Debbie Rosenbaum for keeping us in the loop.

SELYA, Circuit Judge. This mandamus proceeding requires us to address a question of first impression: does a federal district judge have the authority to permit gavel-to-gavel webcasting of a hearing in a civil case? Footnote The district court thought that it had that authority. Capitol Records, Inc. v. Alaujan, 593 F. Supp. 2d 319, 324-25 (D. Mass. 2009). After careful consideration, we hold that a local rule, applicable in this case, when read in conjunction with an announced policy of the Judicial Conference of the United States and a resolution of the First Circuit Judicial Council, precludes such an action. Accordingly, we forbid enforcement of the challenged order and remand for proceedings consistent with this opinion.
 
Since we are the first people to get this (straight from the Harvard Legal Team) I submitted this to Digg to get the word out

You can DIGG IT too.
 
SELYA, Circuit Judge. This mandamus proceeding requires us to address a question of first impression: does a federal district judge have the authority to permit gavel-to-gavel webcasting of a hearing in a civil case? Footnote The district court thought that it had that authority. Capitol Records, Inc. v. Alaujan, 593 F. Supp. 2d 319, 324-25 (D. Mass. 2009). After careful consideration, we hold that a local rule, applicable in this case, when read in conjunction with an announced policy of the Judicial Conference of the United States and a resolution of the First Circuit Judicial Council, precludes such an action. Accordingly, we forbid enforcement of the challenged order and remand for proceedings consistent with this opinion.

Allow me to translate:

Judge Selya is writing this opinion. He is a circuit court judge (circuit courts are above federal district courts and one step below the Supreme court). A writ of mandamus regards a judicial command. A question of first impression is one that has not been decided before. The citation after "Capitol Records v. Alugan" indicates that the case can be found in the Federal Supplement (a book of federal cases) and the page numbers. The court has read a local rule (rules of the court in the jurisdiction the case is being heard) to prohibit webcams.
 
The concurring opinion is good and hopefully will at least have some effect in the future. For the 99.9% of people who I am sure will not read the entire opinion :p here is part of the concurrence:
[T]his case calls into question the continued relevance and vitality of a rule that requires such a disagreeable outcome. . . . The Local Rule at the center of this controversy was adopted in 1990. Since its adoption, dramatic advances in communications technology have had a profound effect on our society. These new technological capabilities provide an unprecedented opportunity to increase public access to the judicial system in appropriate circumstances. They have also created expectations that judges will respond sensibly to these opportunities. With its sweeping prohibition on the broadcasting or recording of district court proceedings, Local Rule 83.3 prevents such responses in civil cases. So too do the Policy of the Judicial Conference and the Resolution of the Judicial Council of the First Circuit that underlie the Local Rule. As the outcome of this proceeding demonstrates, the Rule, the Policy, and the Resolution should all be reexamined promptly.

Obviously won't happen anytime soon but good to see judges recognizing that changes should perhaps be made.
 
The concurring opinion is good and hopefully will at least have some effect in the future. For the 99.9% of people who I am sure will not read the entire opinion :p here is part of the concurrence:


Obviously won't happen anytime soon but good to see judges recognizing that changes should perhaps be made.

In other words,they're saying it's a good idea,and is bound to happen sometime,but they don't have the guts to be the first.:rolleyes:
 
In other words,they're saying it's a good idea,and is bound to happen sometime,but they don't have the guts to be the first.

No, it means they don't think they have the proper authority to be the first.
 
Personally, trials involving murder, divorce, child custody and the like, should be kept as private as possible as the impact and the benefits of publicity are of fairly nominal value to the public at large.

However, a trial involving a consortium that is doing its best to pervert the laws of the land to become the Law of the land should be given as much daylight and visibility as possible to afford the People as much of an opportunity as possible to see and rise up against the evil festering on the periphery.

I continue to wait for someone to dig up whatever bit is missing that would enable R.I.A.A. to come under investigation from a RICO standpoint.
 
RIAA needs to be put in prison along with the pirates. RIAA takes digital money, pirates take digital property. They would all do well with their own bubba.
 
The concurring opinion is good and hopefully will at least have some effect in the future. For the 99.9% of people who I am sure will not read the entire opinion :p here is part of the concurrence:


Obviously won't happen anytime soon but good to see judges recognizing that changes should perhaps be made.

So, they're saying that it can't be recorded because it's a civil matter and not criminal?

...that still makes absolutely no sense to me if you apply it to an RIAA case. I mean, I understand that the parties involved in a civil trial (like a divorce or breach of contract) wouldn't want their dirty laundry aired. The problem is that the RIAA is saying that the defendants are stealing and are criminals, yet it's still a civil trial (and there are no criminal charges).

If you caught a shoplifter (which to my understanding is what the RIAA lawyers equate piracy to), they'd be arrested and charged as a criminal. You wouldn't automatically call them a criminal and waive the charges to pursue a civil trial. Isn't this completely bypassing and perverting the criminal justice system?
 
Back
Top