JBOD or just single disks?

EnderW

[H]F Junkie
2FA
Joined
Sep 25, 2003
Messages
11,465
I've never used JBOD, what would be best for a file server/HTPC?
 
[LYL]Homer;1033668096 said:
I shall give my universal answer: WHS.

I'll be here all week.
I already have a WHS that will backup the fileserver/HTPC. And WHS is not a good choice for HTPC functionality.
 
I already have a WHS that will backup the fileserver/HTPC. And WHS is not a good choice for HTPC functionality.

That depends on what you want your HTPC to do.

Some people like myself have SageTV installed on my WHS so I can record TV to it.
Although it is not hooked up to a TV.

For me Im about to sell my HTPC's and replace them with PCH or SageTV HD Theatres.
That way I can have my server just be a server and record tv, and then have a tiny box that draws ~7watts sit by the TV with my other A/V stuff.

But if you are looking for an AIO type solution that will hookup to the TV, I agree WHS is prob not the best bet.
 
That depends on what you want your HTPC to do.

Some people like myself have SageTV installed on my WHS so I can record TV to it.
Although it is not hooked up to a TV.

For me Im about to sell my HTPC's and replace them with PCH or SageTV HD Theatres.
That way I can have my server just be a server and record tv, and then have a tiny box that draws ~7watts sit by the TV with my other A/V stuff.

But if you are looking for an AIO type solution that will hookup to the TV, I agree WHS is prob not the best bet.
no recording, just a file server mostly so I don't have all these drives crammed in my main machine and to watch .mkv files I download
 
You say to watch videos too but where? If your streaming them over the network then WHS is they way to do it.
If your actually going to be at this box watching it on a monitor or TV connected to it then I'd say Vista and just get a 2tb hard drive.
Disk Spanning is okay, but I dont particularly like it. You have to use dynamic disk for that and you cannot boot up from a dynamic disk so you would need a separate boot disk.
 
You say to watch videos too but where? If your streaming them over the network then WHS is they way to do it.
If your actually going to be at this box watching it on a monitor or TV connected to it then I'd say Vista and just get a 2tb hard drive.
Disk Spanning is okay, but I dont particularly like it. You have to use dynamic disk for that and you cannot boot up from a dynamic disk so you would need a separate boot disk.
this system will be connected to the TV
I also want to store everything on it
WHS will just be a backup of this system and my main PC
 
JBOD/single disks would be best.

That's what I was thinking, my main concern is if there are any issues with adding or removing disks with JBOD. I'd like to be able to drop in new disks later on and have them just show up in the "pool" like WHS.
Also, I may need to add in a controller card like this
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16815121009
to get more SATA ports and I'm not sure if it would be an issue or not.
And one more thing, I would like to be able to change the OS (may upgrade to Windows 7) without it messing anything up.
 
Or my Drobo that is for sale :D
they are way too expensive especially since they don't even have network connectivity ($200 add on :eek:) and only 4 drive bays
they should be about $300 with gigabit built in and 8 drive bays, then I would think about it if it could be backed up to WHS
 
Yea that supermicro card is great.

Umm well you could mount the jbod drives to an empty folder so It would kinda look like one drive. That is what makes WHS such a great OS is that ability.
 
In the Disk Management Snap-in.
Right click on your drive and select "change drive letters and paths" Well Instaed of assigning a drive letter, you can select to "Mount in the following empty NTFS folder"

So on your C: create a folder called "Storage" then you can mount your drive there.
Thats really the closest thing I can think of. That is essentially how WHS pooling is setup but with DE it automatically shows it as one space and does all the file allocation for you. This will be more manual.
 
In the Disk Management Snap-in.
Right click on your drive and select "change drive letters and paths" Well Instaed of assigning a drive letter, you can select to "Mount in the following empty NTFS folder"

So on your C: create a folder called "Storage" then you can mount your drive there.
Thats really the closest thing I can think of. That is essentially how WHS pooling is setup but with DE it automatically shows it as one space and does all the file allocation for you. This will be more manual.
very interesting
my next questions are:
1) I can do multiple drives and they will show up as 1 folder?
2) I can add drives later?
3) if a drive fails, I only lose data on that drive?

thanks
 
1)maybe....I dunno I have never implemented this technique, just know that its an option. I typically would setup a RAID or WHS depending on where it was going.
2)Yes you can add remove drives without really doing anything. If you want to pull a drive out of the box and hook it up to another one to see whats on it no problem. Theres no striping.
3) you will lose only what is on the affected drive(s)


I guess the reason this is kind of a difficult situation is that you was a AIO box.
What I dont understand is, okay so you already have a WHS, why do you want/need another fileserver?
Why not just add the storage to the current WHS, and build a small low power HTPC to watch all your stuff on, or grab an extender that uses like 7watts to watch the stuff?

Sorry if I sound skeptical im just trying to wrap my head around the situation.

What I have found is that dual purpose boxes always end up being a compromise, and you end up not being happy and spend more money in the end.
Essentially you have to decide what is most important. FileServing or HTPC? Either one can do the other but you have to decide what you want it to do best.
 
1)maybe....I dunno I have never implemented this technique, just know that its an option. I typically would setup a RAID or WHS depending on where it was going.
2)Yes you can add remove drives without really doing anything. If you want to pull a drive out of the box and hook it up to another one to see whats on it no problem. Theres no striping.
3) you will lose only what is on the affected drive(s)


I guess the reason this is kind of a difficult situation is that you was a AIO box.
What I dont understand is, okay so you already have a WHS, why do you want/need another fileserver?
Why not just add the storage to the current WHS, and build a small low power HTPC to watch all your stuff on, or grab an extender that uses like 7watts to watch the stuff?

Sorry if I sound skeptical im just trying to wrap my head around the situation.

What I have found is that dual purpose boxes always end up being a compromise, and you end up not being happy and spend more money in the end.
Essentially you have to decide what is most important. FileServing or HTPC? Either one can do the other but you have to decide what you want it to do best.
well I want 2 "copies" of everything
so I'm thinking, all my stuff is stored on one system, then backed up to the WHS
that way if either system blows up or something, I have protection
also I like the way you can go back in time with WHS, I accidently deleted a folder on my main system and didn't even realize it until a few weeks ago, luckily I had backed the entire system up on WHS when I first set it up (been inactive for a couple months while I mess around with stuff) and I was able to recover the folder from the WHS
if I had the folder stored on the WHS in a shared folder or something and deleted it, there wouldn't be a history of it like the back ups
I was hoping to combine the file server and HTPC just to avoid having 4 computers

I'm hoping I don't have to compromise, but I am starting to get that feeling so I'm thinking of just throwing together another computer to be the file server, it just seems kinda dumb to have an entire computer that is basically just a bigass external hard drive

JBOD stuff sounds too iffy so I'll probably either get a RAID5 card and put it in the HTPC or build a separate machine

right now I'm leaning towards the RAID card - there is a PCI-X version of my HighPoint 2320 which has worked great for me
that doesn't sound too much like a compromise, the only problem I could see is if I was doing something heavy on the fileserver while watching a file or something, but that shouldn't be too much of an issue I'd think since most of the time it's not going to be doing anything and I'll likely still use my main system for downloading stuff, then just transfer to the file server/HTPC when it's nice and sorted
 
Well ok then if its going to be backed up you could always do the Dynamic Disk and span the drives in the disk manager like I said before, and this will allow you to use different size disk and it will all show up as a single Volume in My Computer.
I dont know what happens if a drive dies though, cause I havent used spanning in a long time. I *think* you just lose what was on the drive but I would look into it a lil more.

Only downside is you have to have a separate boot drive. But you could just get a 40gb Sata drive or 32bg usb drive and install Vista on it, just for boot. My vista HTPC install with all my programs I need for HD playback is only like 16gb.
 
I totally understand what you mean by not wanting to build a separate box for fileserver, or a big external HDD.

I put it off for so long, but my need/want for large amount of data took over.
I dont blame you for wanting to consolidate, and definately dont advise building a box just for fileserving.
 
Well ok then if its going to be backed up you could always do the Dynamic Disk and span the drives in the disk manager like I said before, and this will allow you to use different size disk and it will all show up as a single Volume in My Computer.
I dont know what happens if a drive dies though, cause I havent used spanning in a long time. I *think* you just lose what was on the drive but I would look into it a lil more.

Only downside is you have to have a separate boot drive. But you could just get a 40gb Sata drive or 32bg usb drive and install Vista on it, just for boot. My vista HTPC install with all my programs I need for HD playback is only like 16gb.

I've already got a 640GB drive in there, so that wouldn't be an issue
I think I'm gonna play around with the disk spanning and see what I think
 
Alright well GL
Ill be on tomorrow and ill look into the spanning stuff some more, cause now I'm a bit more interested.
 
Back
Top