IvyBridge system prep, SSD caching?

NathanP2007

[H]ard|Gawd
2FA
Joined
Dec 17, 2007
Messages
1,697
Ok so this kind of borders on a HDD/SSD question, but considering there is no specific good place for those, i'll twist it to involve a motherboard.

So i plan on buying Ivy Bridge, (most likely the 3770K) and i plan on this being a high end system (my first current gen high end system). So i will be going with SSD memory. However i know there are a few options.

-Should i just go the straight forward route, get a SSD (im thinking the Intel 520) 60-120Gb, install my OS on it, and a few key games/programs (Skyrim, BF3, ME3)?

-Or continue using my 640Gb Caviar Black as OS drive, and use a smaller SSD drive as a SSD cache?

-Or try my luck with a seagate momentus xt as OS drive?



Btw, if you are wondering why i want the Intel SSD, i am a little paranoid of the failure rates of SSD's and it seems Intel has the lowest failure rate, and im okay with paying a premium for amazing quality control.

Considering this is the motherboard section, i'll ask this as well. I know you cant predict the future, but do you have any clue which motherboards will be the ones to look out for? Specifically for me i want to buy a gaming motherboard. Tri -SLI/CFX capable, PCI-3.0 (obviously) and all that gaming stuff. I just dont have much experience in the "looking for a highend gaming motherboard" department. The 3 motherboards i have ever bought for PC's ive built have been "good bang for buck, extremely popular, last gen" types.

UPDATE: New question:

I just noticed on Newegg that the Intel 520 120Gb SSD is $230, is that a great deal?

If it is and your recommendation is to buy it now, dont you think i would still wait until i build my new system to install Windows on it and start using it? Isnt it the current smart practice to install the OS fresh when you put the HDD/SSD on a new system? New motherboard and new CPU and all?
I shouldn't install Windows on the SSD while its connected to my Q9550 and P5Q, then when i sell those, just connect up the SSD with windows installed to it and use it, right?


(And btw, why is the 510 of the exact same size, more expensive than the 520? Isnt the 520 the successor in every way?)
 
Last edited:
If you are going to get an SSD, just use it as your main drive. SSD caching was a great idea for smaller SSD drive but once you get to 64+ drives, it is pointless to use a spinner as your main drive.

Assuming you would have 8 GB RAM, disable your pagefile on all drives. This will save a ton of space and will get Win7 pro down around 20GB install size.
From there you are looking at 15GB minimum for BF3 and then your other games.

I would just get a 128GB and not have to worry about drive space once you get a few games installed. Keep your spinner as a storage drive.
 
If you are going to get an SSD, just use it as your main drive. SSD caching was a great idea for smaller SSD drive but once you get to 64+ drives, it is pointless to use a spinner as your main drive.

Assuming you would have 8 GB RAM, disable your pagefile on all drives. .

I agree completely with the first recommendation, but instead of disabling the page file I would recommend just setting a smaller fixed size. That way the page file is there in case a program needs one, but you still get to recover the SSD space. Also recommend disabling hibernation, as it will make a hibernation file the same size as your system RAM - a huge waste of space on a SSD.
 
Thanks guys. I assume i have at least 8Gb of RAM, i plan on going a little overboard and getting 12Gb of DDR3 considering its price is still low. Also 8Gb is getting might close to fully utilized even on my system when playing BF3 64player multi Large maps.

To be honest, i dont know what "Pagefile" and "Smaller fixed Size" are. Hibernation i assume you mean dont create a hibernation option in windows 7, which i understand and can see your point, and will definitely head that advice.
Just a FYI my knowledge on SSD's is pretty much zero, the only thing i have heard a lot about is TRIM, and how that its really good and you want it turned on.
 
The hibernation piece is easy (see link below). You really don't have to fool with the page file at all, just let the system manage it. If you find yourself space constrained on the SSD then you can do the research into changing it - but it is pretty easy to do.

http://support.microsoft.com/kb/920730
 
I have the crucial m4 64gb ssd installed as a cache'er for my samsung spinpoint 7200 rpm 1tb drive and I am very happy with the performance. It was very easy to install and setup and it works great. The first load of a map is always takes a few seconds, but everytime I load the same map again, it takes no less than 1-2 seconds to complete. I do love getting to load maps so fast and not have to spend a ton on medium compacity drives. By the way though, if you are wanting your os on an ssd, I would suggest you do that no matter how small the drive is. Your os drive is always going to take more weight than your other drives, so it is always best to install it on the fastest drive. Everything will run faster if you use your ssd as your os and your spinner as your storage.
 
As for your paranoia of SSD failures, I just found out that my WD 640 Black has bad sectors. Thank goodness my Vertex 2 120GB SSD is holding strong.

For your situation, SSD caching/Hybrid drives have shown to offer significant performance boost over normal hard drives as it learns your usage. I would use those methods as secondary choice to an SSD though, since for some sequential reads/writes SSD's are much faster.

My persona recommendation is to get an SSD that is at least 120GB, as well as hold onto your 640GB hard drive. Use the SSD for your OS and games, but store all files that do not need high performance on the hard drive, ie., video's, music, documents, pictures. If you don't want to mess with having two drives to manage, you could buy a 32-64GB SSD for very little, then set that up using the Intel SSD caching, and install on your HDD. That would give you SSD performance in many cases (after it learns your usage), as well as retain having a very large drive to store on.

If you go the SSD route for your OS/Games, I also suggest disabling hibernation, which would save you a large chunk of SSD space. You can do this via an elevated cmd prompt by typing in:

powercfg -h off

Also it has been recommended to disable your page file. I do not recommend this, regardless of memory. The best solution in my opinion is to set a min/max method. Set the minimal page file to the lowest setting Windows will allow (which is around 400MB), then set the maximum amount to be whatever the default max was when you started the process of adjusting it. This way you have the benefit of a very small page file (99% of the time) but in those rare instances that you need it to increase, the OS has the flexibility to do so. Page File reads/rights are typically very small files, which means that you should absolutely leave the page file on the SSD, rather than moving it to a hard drive. Page Files love SSD's.
 
I just noticed on Newegg that the Intel 520 120Gb SSD is $230, is that a great deal?

If it is and your recommendation is to buy it now, dont you think i would still wait until i build my new system to install Windows on it and start using it? Isnt it the current smart practice to install the OS fresh when you put the HDD/SSD on a new system? New motherboard and new CPU and all?
I shouldn't install Windows on the SSD while its connected to my Q9550 and P5Q, then when i sell those, just connect up the SSD with windows installed to it and use it, right?


(And btw, why is the 510 of the exact same size, more expensive than the 520? Isnt the 520 the successor in every way?)
 
Last edited:
It is considered a best practice to do a fresh install, but with Windows 7 it is by no means necessary. You can install it now and then just pop it in the new system without any major problems - it'll re-detect the hardware and you can install the drivers and be off and running. However, if you are planning a major build in a few months, I'd wait for a good sale price before buying. No need to rush anything.
 
It is considered a best practice to do a fresh install, but with Windows 7 it is by no means necessary. You can install it now and then just pop it in the new system without any major problems - it'll re-detect the hardware and you can install the drivers and be off and running. However, if you are planning a major build in a few months, I'd wait for a good sale price before buying. No need to rush anything.

Thanks, but yeah thats one of my questions, is the $20 off (so its $230 instead of $250) a good sale for the Intel 520 SSD 120Gb?

You answered my second question (involving windows 7 and should i wait or get one now).

My third and final question is, why is the Intel 510 more expensive than the 520? Isnt the 520 the successor and better in ever way? Or what?
 
One thing that is nice about SRT SSD Caching is that the reliability of the SSD is much less of an issue. In enhanced mode, if anything happens to the SSD, all of your data is still there on the mechanical drive. Even in maximized mode the data loss would likely be minimal. You can really make great use of those cheaper bottom-of-the-barrel SSDs that would make a poor choice for a main drive.

Another thing that is nice is that upgrading your SSD down the road is stupid easy. Just disable acceleration, swap out the SSD, enable acceleration, done. No need to re-install windows or anything. I did this when I switched from my X25-M G2 80GB and the process took about 5mins total.
 
Thanks, but yeah thats one of my questions, is the $20 off (so its $230 instead of $250) a good sale for the Intel 520 SSD 120Gb?

You answered my second question (involving windows 7 and should i wait or get one now).

My third and final question is, why is the Intel 510 more expensive than the 520? Isnt the 520 the successor and better in ever way? Or what?

I'd rather have a 510 personally because it uses the proven marvel controller and has lower CPU utilization. Also based on their track record it's possible the 520 series could have an unforeseen bug that needs ironing out like the 320 series 8MB bug when it first launched.
 
I'd rather have a 510 personally because it uses the proven marvel controller and has lower CPU utilization. Also based on their track record it's possible the 520 series could have an unforeseen bug that needs ironing out like the 320 series 8MB bug when it first launched.

Do you know of any articles that talk about your concerns? Like i said i am not a knowledgeable SSD guy so i would have to take your word on the 510 using the CPU less than the 520 (which i hadnt heard of until your comment) and the whole reason i was going Intel (higher cost) was because of their top of the line quality control, and your telling me it might have a bug which i would think Intel would catch and fix in quality checks.
 
Do you know of any articles that talk about your concerns? Like i said i am not a knowledgeable SSD guy so i would have to take your word on the 510 using the CPU less than the 520 (which i hadnt heard of until your comment) and the whole reason i was going Intel (higher cost) was because of their top of the line quality control, and your telling me it might have a bug which i would think Intel would catch and fix in quality checks.

The sandforce powered SSDs such as the 520 have the highest CPU utilization of all other SSDs on the market due to there real time compression/decompression system. It's a trade off of faster transfer speeds for higher CPU usage. This probably isn't a significant issue for most people as we live in the age of 4 and 6 core CPUs. However I can say that in my own personal testing on my last rig (an Athlon II X2 system) in HD tune my sandforce powered SSDs had about 5 times the amount of CPU usage compared to my M4 and Intel 320 series running the same exact benchmark. I'm sure if you compare online reviews you can find this data for yourself relatively easily.

I'm not trying to scare you away from getting a 520 series SSD at all but from personal experience I've learned that your much less likely to buy new computer parts with design flaws if you allow the dust to settle a bit. Good examples would be:

#1 I bought the Original OCZ Vertex right when they were released and they had a major BSOD panic lock bug on the initial firmware revision which eventually caught up to me and bricked the drive. My 2nd Vertex already had the newer firmware and it still runs great to this day.

#2 I bought my Crucial M4 right after the uber high performance firmware 009 came out due to the hype. It turned out there was a major bug in this firmware that causes your PC to restart hourly making the drive extremely unreliable. Well I ended up having to do a mandatory firmware flash which wasn't possible with my system at the time due to a flaw in my motherboard's chipset so I ended up having to spend $75 on a new motherboard and rebuilding my entire system just to make my SSD usable in any form. If I had waited one more month then I would have gotten one of the matured M4s with the reliable firmware already installed.

#3 I bought an Intel 320 Series SSD right when it came out because I thought Intel's QC was infallible at the time but soon after I got mine Intel announced that it had a major firmware bug that would reduce your SSD to only 8MB in size and that your data is not recoverable if this happens. Seeing as I bought the OEM version with only a 1 year warranty this doesn't leave me feeling very assured.

Anyways you live you learn. Some people like to tweak their hardware, flash firmware, overclock and actually enjoy building there computers but I don't. I want to just buy something, put it together in one evening, run it at stock and enjoy using it immediately. Bah I didn't mean to ramble on for so long but I hope somebody gets something out of it.
 
The sandforce powered SSDs such as the 520 have the highest CPU utilization of all other SSDs on the market due to there real time compression/decompression system. It's a trade off of faster transfer speeds for higher CPU usage. This probably isn't a significant issue for most people as we live in the age of 4 and 6 core CPUs. However I can say that in my own personal testing on my last rig (an Athlon II X2 system) in HD tune my sandforce powered SSDs had about 5 times the amount of CPU usage compared to my M4 and Intel 320 series running the same exact benchmark. I'm sure if you compare online reviews you can find this data for yourself relatively easily.

I think something else must be the explanation for what you were seeing, because the Sandforce compression is done on-board the SSD, and is transparent to the operating system. The OS doesn't have any idea what kind of controller is in the SSD, it just sees the SATA device unless you are installing a non-standard (not msahci or iastor) driver for it. I did a quick Google search and couldn't find anything to indicate that Sandforce SSDs had higher than normal CPU utilization - although it's possible I didn't search well.
 
I think something else must be the explanation for what you were seeing, because the Sandforce compression is done on-board the SSD, and is transparent to the operating system. The OS doesn't have any idea what kind of controller is in the SSD, it just sees the SATA device unless you are installing a non-standard (not msahci or iastor) driver for it. I did a quick Google search and couldn't find anything to indicate that Sandforce SSDs had higher than normal CPU utilization - although it's possible I didn't search well.

Oh, well if it is handled by a processor on the SSD I hadn't heard of it until now. And admittingly I don't have a Intel 520 series to test. I was merely testing 2 different Vertex 2's (one 34nm and one 25nm) against the M4 and 320 series. However on the same system and SATA port the CPU usage on the Vertex 2s were 5 times higher for what that's worth.
 
Last edited:
This is interesting, but i hope we can find out if his results are flawed or right, cause if the IvyBridge CPU's arent delayed..iv got a month until i need to decide on a SSD to buy.
 
Back
Top