ITX mid range gaming rig???

Dr. Righteous

2[H]4U
Joined
Aug 1, 2007
Messages
3,163
Hey guys; take a look at this.

MSI Wind Board D510 Intel Atom D510 BGA559 Intel NM10 Mini ITX Motherboard/CPU Combo
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813130281


The time has come to replace the old P4 my son games on.
He is getting old enough to appreciate nice graphics; but on anything fairly new; it has to be low settings and low FPS. Load times with the old EIDE drives is very very long. Yeah, time to move on.
Space is very limited and I was poking around on NewEgg just to look at pricing and ran across ITX boards with with Atom processors. What low profile PCI-E cards would work with one of these?
what kind of preformance can you expect from an Atom processor??
 
that does not qualify for a mid range gaming board. the atom is probably on par with your sons P4.
youd be far better off getting him a discrete itx board and respective CPU.
the foxconn 1155 itx board and i3-2100 can be had for around $200
 
that does not qualify for a mid range gaming board. the atom is probably on par with your sons P4.
youd be far better off getting him a discrete itx board and respective CPU.
the foxconn 1155 itx board and i3-2100 can be had for around $200

Not so much the process itself (Pentium 4 2.6 Ghz ) but it is a AGP video card ATI HD2600 and a EIDE HD. DDR400 RAM.
I would think a multi core Atom would be on par with this 10 year old antique once you added a low profile modern PCI-E video card. .
 
I would think a multi core Atom would be on par with this 10 year old antique once you added a low profile modern PCI-E video card. .


So you want to "upgrade" to something that has about the same performance?

Why not go with the Sandy Bridge i3 2100 as stated above?
 
A dual core Atom would not even begin to come close to a low-range gaming pc, let alone a mid-range, even with a video card. There were a few laptops a while back sold with Atoms and an Nvidia 9400 video card, and they barely managed playable settings on even older games.

anandtech.com said:
We ran a few games at 800x600 and minimum detail. Half-Life 2: Episode 2 averaged 17 FPS (and 16 FPS at 1366x768), which is hardly playable. Batman Arkham Asylum (without PhysX) averaged 17 FPS as well, with lows of 1 FPS. Even Unreal Tournament 3 couldn't surpass 18 FPS (which is odd since we managed to get 30 FPS on the N10JC last year — perhaps it's a driver update issue, or maybe the shared system RAM is a bottleneck). About the best showing for the Mini 311 was in Plants vs. Zombies, which averaged 26 FPS during an intense survival level; the GMA 950 falls into the low teens and even single digits in similar testing.

Are there games where the ION LE provides acceptable performance? Absolutely. From the 3D gaming genre, though, you'll want to stick to very undemanding games in terms of CPU requirements — mostly stuff from 5+ years back.


At best this machine you plan on building with a high clocked dual core Atom might equal an equally clocked Pentium 4 in gaming performance. They are horrendously slow. If you ran into a CPU limited game like a real-time strategy game, or an MMORPG with tons of people in the server, the performance edge might even go to the Pentium 4. Also, just about any mid to low end graphics card nowadays (less than $100) would probably be so bottlenecked by the lack of cpu power it might never reach acceptable performance.

There are plenty of decent itx boards out there that will accept Core i3's and Core i5's and a few AMD boards also that would accept a low end Phenom II, almost all of them have full length PCIe slots on them for a graphics card also.

Don't waste your money on an Atom motherboard for a gaming computer. At best they are good for internet boxes. The only other thing they are good for is low power home theater pc's, and even then a video card (or an Nvidia chipset with integrated graphics) would be necessary to offload high def video processing.
 
Last edited:
A dual core Atom would not even begin to come close to a low-range gaming pc, let alone a mid-range, even with a video card. There were a few laptops a while back sold with Atoms and an Nvidia 9400 video card, and they barely managed playable settings on even older games.
.

WOW, I didn't realize the Atom preformed that poorly!
Price wise, and it's small size make it attractive; but not at the cost of any usable performance.
 
Atom performs poorly because its designed to be low power..hence its use in box PC's and netbooks. I used to have an Atom ITX build, which was usable only because I didnt do much gaming.
 
its still possible to get a small (form and powered) powerful gaming PC

$210 i5 2500
$90 mini-ITX H67 1155 mobo
$40 2x2GB RAM
$35 400W PSU
$30 case
$50 HDD
<$100 GPU

around $550 for complete build w/o monitor

to get it cheaper, reuse parts, reduce GPU budget, the i5 2500 can be replaced by i3 if you desire(or mobo by a cheaper mATX one)...

or even change the mobo+cpu to an Phenom II x2/x4 ($80 for CPU, $50 for mobo)... if you stay with integrated graphics on the Intel or Phenom II mobos, you can get decent gaming(light gaming, like some Source engine games, starcraft etc)
 
Back
Top