It's upgrade time!

cyberslag5k

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 29, 2004
Messages
277
I'm thinking it's motherboard/processor upgrade time. I'm doing my research now on what I'm going to get. I have a few questions so I thought I'd create a thread that explains what I'm looking to do, asks my questions, and gives anyone who would like to an opportunity to recommend a good pairing.

First off, let me give a little overview of the project (just in case anyone can spot any incompatabilities I've missed). I'm only swapping out my processor (2500+ Barton) and motherboard (Asus A7N8X-E). What remains is a gig (2x512) of PC3200 Corsair XMS (with the cool little lights), my BFG 6800GT (that card can really do some damage even with my proc at stock 1.83GHz), 450W PSU, DVD-RW, CD-RW, Soundblaster Live, a 74GB Raptor, and a 120GB WD HDD.

I'm going with an Athlon64 setup. I'm looking for performance and value, though I'm a college student so I can't buy anything rediculous (I was thinking between $175-250 for the proc and like $100-200 for the mobo). I'm leaving the overclocking arena (I don't really have any horror stories, I would just like to stick with stock speeds for now). Oh and my video card is AGP. Other than that I don't really have too many mobo restrictions.

On to the questions:

1. Socket: Is 939 the end-all-be-all? It's the newest (right?) and the home of the Winchester, so I figured I'd go that route, but should I consider 754 or 940 for any reason?

2. Processors: Alot of the ones on newegg say "XXXX+ Processor for Notebook Computers". I can still use them in a desktop setting, though, right? Does this also represent some sort of performance differentiation? Or are these just regular processors and newegg is being silly?

3. Processors continued: Are there any considerations I have to make switching to a 64 bit processor? I'm just going to stick with 32 bit processing for now. My memory and video card should all still work, right? And I can just use my regular Windows XP Pro disk? Will I need to reformat?

That's all I can think of just yet. As I said I'm still doing my initial research. I'm thinking something like a 3200+, but I need to look through the performance charts before I can get any more solid on that.

I would really appreciate any suggestions anyone might have on a mobo, chipset, and proc. I really like ASUS boards, but am willing to entertain other companies (afterall that's how I found ASUS and I couldn't be happier with them).

Thanks in advance!
 
Oh right, you had questions.

cyberslag5k said:
1. Socket: Is 939 the end-all-be-all? It's the newest (right?) and the home of the Winchester, so I figured I'd go that route, but should I consider 754 or 940 for any reason?
754 - No, it doesn't support dual-channel memory.
940 - No, it requires VERY expensive memory

cyberslag5k said:
2. Processors: Alot of the ones on newegg say "XXXX+ Processor for Notebook Computers". I can still use them in a desktop setting, though, right? Does this also represent some sort of performance differentiation? Or are these just regular processors and newegg is being silly?
I think you can, but I wouldn't recommend doing it. Usually a notbook component is designed for power saving over speed.

cyberslag5k said:
3. Processors continued: Are there any considerations I have to make switching to a 64 bit processor? I'm just going to stick with 32 bit processing for now. My memory and video card should all still work, right? And I can just use my regular Windows XP Pro disk? Will I need to reformat?
No considerations to make, just makes your PC futureproof. AMD64 processors can handle 32-bit code just fine. Your fine ont he memory/video. Yes, Windows XP Pro will work fine. Reformat if you like, but it's not absoloutely necessary. I like to just so I can start on a clean slate.
 
According to all the reviews, you will only see about a 5%-10% increase from Socket 754 to Socket 939, due to the Dual Channel memory ability. Although, 939 is the future and should last longer for upgrading then 754, but that is still yet to be seen. You can use all your remaining parts with no problems. As far, as the NewEgg selling laptop processors types, I believe they give you more flexiblity to overclocking, because of the lower voltage requirements and such, so you should be able to use them in desktops as long as they sockets are compatible.

I would say if you have the cash then go 939, if you wish to save a bit for now and then upgrade to 939 with SLI then I would say go 754 now and then save up for the next jump.
Either way you look at it you want to go with Nvidia NForce3 250Gb chipset. It has tons of useful features, like built in firewall, on-chip SATA, on-chip 100/1000 LAN,etc. Or you could go with Via chipset, especially the K8T800 Pro version.

As for recommendations...

Processors
AMD64 2800+
AMD64 3000+
AMD64 3200+
AMD64 3500+

Motherboards
Socket 754

Asus K8N-E Deluxe
MSI K8N Neo Platinum (MS-7030)
DFI LANParty UT NF3-250Gb

Socket 939

Asus A8V Deluxe
MSI K8N Neo2 Platinum

But of course the one to keep your eyes on...

Asus A8N-SLI Deluxe WooHoo!!!!


As for a good HS/F...I have personally installed a ThermalTake Venus 12 and I must say it was the biggest HS/F I have seen to date. I am sure there are bigger and better ones, but I can only personally claim how well this one works.

Hope this helps.

Bob2001
 
Thanks for everyone's suggestions. I'm looking very closely at that ASUS K8NE-Deluxe board. But a question regarding processors. I'm presently looking at the winchester 3200+ and the newcastle 3200+ and 3500+. 3500+ wins the "is a bigger number award", but the winchester 90nm chip is awfully intriguing. What, exactly, would the smaller core offer me? Should I still consider the 3200+ newcastle? It's (negligably) more expensive and an older chip with a larger die. Does it have any merits at all over the winchester 3200+? Again I won't be overclocking at all (blasphemy, I know). The pricing is 196 (winchester), 215, and 267 so all are within my price range, so unless someone can convince me there's a reason to keep looking at the newcastle 3200+, i think it's between the winchester and the 3500+.

Thanks again!

EDIT: And I've just noticed the winchester 3500+. $352 at newegg but I pricewatched a place that will sell it for $251. I'm thinking that may be the way to go. Can anyone recommend some good sites for proc comparisons? I can't seem to access the [H] right now and anandtech didn't really have what I was looking for. I'd be interested to see the performance increase between the 3200+ and the 3500+. If it's significant I think I'll get the latter.
 
If I'm not mistaken, the Winchesters:

Run cooler
Overclock better
Require less power

I know you stated you are leaving the arena on OCing, but you should leave the window open, just in case. Besides, I would get the Winchester simply because it is newer and a bit more "future-proof".
 
sac_tagg said:
If I'm not mistaken, the Winchesters:

Run cooler
Overclock better
Require less power

I know you stated you are leaving the arena on OCing, but you should leave the window open, just in case. Besides, I would get the Winchester simply because it is newer and a bit more "future-proof".

Yes. I think it's definitely between the winchester 3200+ and the 3500+. They're cheaper and it never hurts to have your CPU run cooler. I saw a review on anandtech that showed the 90nm chip ran faster on average (by like 0.01%, but hey) than the 130nm one. Why not pay less for more (albeit insignificant) power. I just need to decide between thw two chips now. The 3200+ appears to be the better value, coming in about $60 less than the 3500+ and the 3500+ appears to only have like a 10% performance boost. I think I'll just have to see where I'm at financially in a few weeks and make a decision form there.

Thanks to everyone for your help!
 
sac_tagg said:
For sure go s939. It supports dual-channel memory, and since you have 2 512MB sticks you can take advantage of this.

Some motherboard recommendations:

DFI "LANPARTY UT nF3 250Gb"
ASUS A8V Deluxe
ABIT AV8 PRO

And some processor recommendations:

AMD Athlon 64 3000+ (OEM)
AMD Athlon 64 3000+ (Retail)
AMD Athlon 64 3200+ (OEM
AMD Athlon 64 3200+ (Retail)

If you go OEM, you ought to get a good heatsink:

Thermalright XP-90
Thermalright XP-120


You encourage s939, and yet you link to a DFI 250 s754 mobo..... teh irony!
 
i recommend msi neo2 plat, my friend just got it and we are very pleased. so far very fast and reliable. and its agp ( a plus for you) and is reliable and easy to oc. just a suggestion. yea definatley get winchester. 3000 or 3200 is your best bet. monarch has the best price on them. and buy.com for mobo :)
 
Right now.. s939 3200+ and a MSI Neo2 Plat... And your XMS sticks are good with the MoBo if I remembered correctly. However do read up on the MSI and the ASUS board since they both have issues and they are well known.
 
Back
Top