"It's Beta"

While some bugs are understandable and even excusable under the mantle of Beta, I feel that Battlefield 3 is a beyond the pale. I sincerely hope that what we are seeing is an early beta, and that the game, even as it stands now, is significantly better. But then again, it is DICE we're talking about. BF2 was hardly even beta quality at launch.
 
While some bugs are understandable and even excusable under the mantle of Beta, I feel that Battlefield 3 is a beyond the pale. I sincerely hope that what we are seeing is an early beta, and that the game, even as it stands now, is significantly better. But then again, it is DICE we're talking about. BF2 was hardly even beta quality at launch.

They've said it's an old build already, not really sure why they'd use an old build though :confused:

I'm fairly confident there's going to be a lot of issues at launch, but with such a big title the patches ought to come thick and fast. BF2 was a mess for ages but BC2 was actually pretty well supported (with a few exceptions), so maybe they're improving.
 
Wow you guys complain a lot. Who cares, beta, demo, alpha, a rose by any other name would smell as sweet (or as bad as the case may be). Fact is, its a pre-release build of the game designed to give you a taste of what's in the full game and test out their own systems. If you dont like it, sweet, dont like it, if its got lots of bugs, sweet, wait for the full game and get user opinions on whether or not they're fixed. I really dont understand what all the damn crying is about.

Fact is, they've used this to give you a taste of what is to come, you can make of it what you like. Would I have prefered a proper demo? Maybe, at this stage I couldn't really give a shit either way to be honest.
 
Wow you guys complain a lot. Who cares, beta, demo, alpha, a rose by any other name would smell as sweet (or as bad as the case may be). Fact is, its a pre-release build of the game designed to give you a taste of what's in the full game and test out their own systems. If you dont like it, sweet, dont like it, if its got lots of bugs, sweet, wait for the full game and get user opinions on whether or not they're fixed. I really dont understand what all the damn crying is about.

Fact is, they've used this to give you a taste of what is to come, you can make of it what you like. Would I have prefered a proper demo? Maybe, at this stage I couldn't really give a shit either way to be honest.

People telling you you're not allowed to complain (you) are far worse than the complainers themselves.

Way to be anti-discourse.
 
I don't like this word "WOW clone", WOW did not create the MMO genre, they just made it popular.

WoW is obviously very derivative, but both Rift and SWTOR derive their gameplay and UI directly from wow, and pretty much set up everything the way WoW has implemented everything, down to fine details that normally would differ from themepark game to themepark game. the menu options and hotkeys are also a 100% match. they are more straight WoW clones than EQ clones.

saying WoW is not totally original doesn't make certain games any less WoW clones.
 
People telling you you're not allowed to complain (you) are far worse than the complainers themselves.

Way to be anti-discourse.

I never said people can't complain, quote the part of my post where I said you can't complain, go for it, cry a river if you want. I said "you guys complain a lot" and "who cares", which I think are apt observations/suggestions. Complain all you want, but dont be surprised when people tell you "its beta" and "its prerelease, wait until the final version". At this stage, you've got something for nothing, the beta is free. You can complain all the fuck you want, nothing I have said is saying you can't complain.

What's the old saying... get something for free and complain about the quality afterwards? Don't look a gift horse in the mouth?

You can complain all the hell you want if that's what you want, but when people continually complain about pointless stuff it lessens the impact of complaints about things that actually matter.

Fact is, its a prerelease version of the game designed to give you a taste of the final game, so a natural response to critisms are going to be "its a prerelease version, dont get your knickers in a twist". That's not to say dont point out flaws, but acknowledge that "its a prerelease build" is a genuine response. When the final game comes out and its still got the problems, that's when you complaints will stop falling on deaf ears and actually mean something less trivial.
 
the problem is people don't understand what BETA is in the development cycle of software(games too), it can be different for each company too.

If this was RC1 or RC2, then I would be worried, Also I believe this beta is not the full game, as in they cut part of their code out and sent it out for testing(more like a demo), maybe what they are wanting to test is the scalability and stability over long hours with full servers, and not so much the "key bindings", etc..

when you use a product in BETA, you are doing some QA work for the company, for the price of getting to use a product early. If you don't want to use potentially buggy software, wait for the product to release, then complain about the retail bugs instead ;P
 
They've said it's an old build already, not really sure why they'd use an old build though :confused:

I'm fairly confident there's going to be a lot of issues at launch, but with such a big title the patches ought to come thick and fast. BF2 was a mess for ages but BC2 was actually pretty well supported (with a few exceptions), so maybe they're improving.

Probably packaging. It can take months to get these builds ready for download, so the public beta team probably started several months ago with whatever "stable" build they had on hand at the time.
 
They've said it's an old build already, not really sure why they'd use an old build though :confused:

I'm fairly confident there's going to be a lot of issues at launch, but with such a big title the patches ought to come thick and fast. BF2 was a mess for ages but BC2 was actually pretty well supported (with a few exceptions), so maybe they're improving.

It's such an old build because Sony and Microsoft took so long to approve it.
 
Does anybody here really believe there won't be key binding options in the final product? I mean seriously, honest to goodness believe there won't be any options to set them?
 
your perception of a beta needs an adjustment. beta != go live build. but i believe calling it a beta is more to cover their ass and put out the flames early on. ive had 1 bsod from the game and mostly problems joining friends in game. that said my 2 buddies playing have had numerous crashes and similar issues joining on friends.
 
People telling you you're not allowed to complain (you) are far worse than the complainers themselves.

Way to be anti-discourse.
If you are free to complain, he can complain about your complaining.
 
lol that's the same response I got last night when I was playing BF3.

Me: "Man this squad system really blows"
Random Dude: "Meh, it's beta"
Me: "We can only hope"

Lowest common denominator.
 
People are offended by criticisms like this because the way that you posted makes it sound like you think this is universally true for all games. There are obviously going to be examples of companies that do listen to beta testers and change things, and people who follow those companies and games closely are likely to be offended.

Choose your words more carefully next time if you are worried about offending people.
 
WoW is obviously very derivative, but both Rift and SWTOR derive their gameplay and UI directly from wow, and pretty much set up everything the way WoW has implemented everything, down to fine details that normally would differ from themepark game to themepark game. the menu options and hotkeys are also a 100% match. they are more straight WoW clones than EQ clones.

saying WoW is not totally original doesn't make certain games any less WoW clones.

anarchy-online-2.jpg

Man this game has an action bar, health bars, inventory, chat, minimap, and various interface menus. Must be a WOW clone, oh wait this game was released 3 years prior.
 
welcome to todays games, where they can be released very much undone and under the guise of a beta moniker and patched to death with DLC, further milking your wallet. Instead of like it used to be, when consoles weren't internet connected and PC games had better be top notch without an internet connection or else they fail.
 
its a good thing that i'm patient, have fast internet and accept the need for large patches with todays incredibly complex games. i'll play this and have a blast regardless.
 
I heard that there will be a Hi-res texture pack available for the this thread in a few days.....
how freaking sweet is that?
 
its a good thing that i'm patient, have fast internet and accept the need for large patches with todays incredibly complex games. i'll play this and have a blast regardless.

Same. I'm willing to pay the money to be entertained and deal with the bugs early.

There just seems to be a lot of angst among the [H] these days based solely on personal preferences. It's kind of a bummer to sift through it all for hard facts, tech tid-bits and news. However, I also know that's the way it is and it ain't gonna change. ;) Or maybe I just need to stay away from the BF3-related threads to change my perspective. :D
 
Back
Top