issue with person on transaction

Status
Not open for further replies.

AthlonXP

Fully [H]
2FA
Joined
Oct 14, 2001
Messages
20,695
Before he comes on and rants about me, I want to make this clear that I have no intentions or ripping anyone off or causing pain to them in transactions but I have recently dealt with Dell Dude on a psu swap in which i paid $45 dollars for shipping to and fro and the unit he receive in which paid for a warranty on his part says it doesn't work. He has only shown me on picture on this, as for now I am no longer going to deal with this issue as I am willing to help him RMA the power supply and thats it. The unit was in perfect working order and was not tampering with anything. I have recently worked very hard to build my reputation back up, as for now If anyone does want to do further business with me, we will both take special precaution to prevent this from happening again. Thank you and have a goodnight.
 
Before he comes on and rants about me, I want to make this clear that I have no intentions or ripping anyone off or causing pain to them in transactions but I have recently dealt with Dell Dude on a psu swap in which i paid $45 dollars for shipping to and fro and the unit he receive in which paid for a warranty on his part says it doesn't work. He has only shown me on picture on this, as for now I am no longer going to deal with this issue as I am willing to help him RMA the power supply and thats it. The unit was in perfect working order and was not tampering with anything. I have recently worked very hard to build my reputation back up, as for now If anyone does want to do further business with me, we will both take special precaution to prevent this from happening again. Thank you and have a goodnight.

we agreed on swapping my 750W Silverstone PSU for his 620W Corsair PSU, mine is obviously worth more, i asked him to cover my shipping, which he did. i said i would ship 1st as he needed a psu so he wouldnt have "downtime" on his computer, which was fine with me as i have bough from him and all went well. i know i package my stuff great, as you can ask anyone ive dealy with, he recieves my psu and all is well, so he then ships his to me..

i recieve the psu to find it in a tiny box packed as so:
http://i113.photobucket.com/albums/n240/Dell_Dude/CSHawkeye HORRIBLE packaging/P1010001.jpg
http://i113.photobucket.com/albums/n240/Dell_Dude/CSHawkeye HORRIBLE packaging/P1010002.jpg
http://i113.photobucket.com/albums/n240/Dell_Dude/CSHawkeye HORRIBLE packaging/P1010003.jpg
http://i113.photobucket.com/albums/n240/Dell_Dude/CSHawkeye HORRIBLE packaging/P1010004.jpg

he claims that he wrapped the psu in bubble wrap.. that right there is an obvious lie, as anyone who isnt blind can see in those pictures how well it was packed.

he said he insured it through fedex, but REFUSES to help by filing a claim.

he states its not fair for me to be "pulling this stuff on him" WHAT?!? what the hell did i try to pull on him - please elaborate

this is my first bad deal and dont really know how to precede with it, and obviously he will take advantage of that, he says im shady about all this and im not a good trader, i have 160 perfect feedback that i am proud of, he has 30 positives and 2 negative feedbacks. i dont know why im getting the sour end of the deal here..

does anyone have any ideas of what i can do to settle this?
 
I thought Fedex has a clause where they are not responsible for computer componenets UNLESS it is shipped in the manufacturers box/packaging...

From FEdEx:

Liabilities Not Assumed it will not be held liable for:

Damage to computers, or any components thereof, or any electronic equipment, unless such items are shipped in the manufacturer’s original packaging, which is undamaged and has retained a good, rigid condition. Laptop computers may also be shipped in a FedEx Laptop Box. In the event the original packaging is not available or is not in good, rigid condition, FedEx Kinko’s provides packaging services.

eh.. could be a problem, especially seeing the Fedex box isn't damaged...
 
Well, obviously I am not going to speculate on who may be lying on the packaging. But if that is really how it was packed for shipping, that is indeed poor packing. AthlonXP, I am not sure why you would think it would be ok to pack a PSU like that. Hardware computer parts need cushion on all sides.


The way I see it, there really is a very limited number of options here.

#1. This is pretty much the main option. If the PSU is in fact under warranty, to have it RMA'd. Perhaps Athlon is willing to cover at least half the RMA cost(This is assuming the manufacturer will not). I know this sucks cause you just bought the PSU probably have intentions on using it right away, now have to wait another 2 weeks to get a new one. That sucks but things happen.


#2. He could file a claim. Because it was a cross-trade, it makes things a little difficult. I would normally say, AthlonXp should refund you and file a claim to get his money back through Fedex, but that is a big pain in the ass anyways. I actually dont think they would refund you anyways because the box doesnt look damaged. I think you have to use special boxes for that anyways. On top of that, obviously no money has changed hands so...
 
yeah, i sold him the other psu in a previous purchase he did with no problem, I am willing to help with some of the costs and cover the rma, but not everything... i am sorry, Its just everything worked fine before I shipped, he wanted this psu back asap and I did the best i could under the circumstances, the box he sent me the psu was damaged pretty badly so I was not going to use that, this box i used was the best bet and I have shipped many items in packaging in similar fashion with no problems./
 
how long did dell have it b4 he let you know it was shot..? Whats actually bad on it? will it not power on? and why not just swap them back and be done with it.. Athlon do you really think he would ruin a psu just to be a pain in the ass?
 
I am totally not sure, but he is just requesting a refund back and honestly before i dish out money back i want to find out what we can do to rectify this, he said he already traded for another psu and just wants the money back... sorry that sounds a little fishy to me. I am willing to refund some money back but I want to rectify the issue before doing that.
 
It is still under warranty isnt it? Why dont you guys just RMA it.
 
it is, and he is saying the sticker was ripped on it, and honestly i dont buy that to much as it so randomly has that ripped off as well, i bought the psu brand new, it was in totally working order when i shipped it, I loved that psu and the only reason i traded it with him was that he has a motherboard in which does not like the silverstone that I originally sold him.
 
Thats why i always write the serial # or whatever number that's on the unit incase someone swapped the unit for a defective one then ask for a refund. Im not saying he did that but i remember selling someone a C2D but before i shipped it, i took some pictures of the batch #. He then accused me of defective cpu when i got the chip back, guess what..wrong chip number.
 
Just to clear up a couple things..

we did originally trade cause the mobo i was going to get has problems with the silverstone PSUs, BUT the guy i was getting the mobo from said it was sent back to him with the box demolished from the shipper and label wasnt readable or something. (keep in mind AthlonXP was still waiting on my PSU to get there, i shipped mine priority and it took i think 13 days to get to him, hence why my box was ruined as he said.) once my PSU did get there, he had it for the weekend to make sure it worked, it works fine, and right after he ships my psu i get word from the guy with the mobo saying there was that shipper problem. so i didnt want to make a big fuss over that so i just waited for the corsair psu to get here, and was planning on reselling since i had no use for it at that point. once fedex drops off the box, i open it up, i was astonished so see how it was packed so i immediately took some pictures just in case id need then for a fedex claim purpose or something.

my buyer for it had paid so the day i got the psu from athlonxp, i shipped it to my buyer (all this was on the 24th) when my buyer got it he let me know it has been giving him nothing but problems, i then refunded my buyer.

now that i have refunded my buyer, im out of ~$100, and a working psu... now all i have is a broken psu and am ~100 poorer.

i just want compensation, OR to be able to get the broken one replaced from corsair and resell when i get a replacment. i just dont like how its like i gave away ~100 bucks, who would like that feeling.

i understand athlonxp is offering some money to help with the RMA which i do indeed appreciate, he said he had "warranty information" or whatever that he'd give me, which i would like. if you, athlonxp, can PM that to me id appreciate it.

about the warranty sticker, its not torn, it looked as if someone tried to peel it off and left that "fuzzy residue" on it it still says all the words "warranty void if removed" but the fact there are those residue spots, i was in doubt that corsair would actually RMA it, but if athlonxp is willing to help me RMA, ill take him up on that offer.
 
sounds like you f*cked big time Dell im afraid. you shouldve tested the PSU when you got it but you didnt. it could have been damaged in post to you, from you to the other buyer, or the other buyer himself or when he sent it back to you. you now cant hold Athlon resposible at all for this. if I was him I wouldnt give you a single cent.

sorry to sound harsh but you cant hold him resposible because a PSU he sent to you, that you sent to someone else that sent it back to you is now having 'problems'.
 
sounds like you f*cked big time Dell im afraid. you shouldve tested the PSU when you got it but you didnt. it could have been damaged in post to you, from you to the other buyer, or the other buyer himself or when he sent it back to you. you now cant hold Athlon resposible at all for this. if I was him I wouldnt give you a single cent.

sorry to sound harsh but you cant hold him resposible because a PSU he sent to you, that you sent to someone else that sent it back to you is now having 'problems'.

i had no way to test it.

i packed it VERY WELL, theres no way it was damaged when i sent it to my buyer i had 3" space all the way around, double boxed..

i have not received it from my buyer so its only gone from athlonxp to me then to my buyer.
 
sounds like you f*cked big time Dell im afraid. you shouldve tested the PSU when you got it but you didnt. it could have been damaged in post to you, from you to the other buyer, or the other buyer himself or when he sent it back to you. you now cant hold Athlon resposible at all for this. if I was him I wouldnt give you a single cent.

sorry to sound harsh but you cant hold him resposible because a PSU he sent to you, that you sent to someone else that sent it back to you is now having 'problems'.

Yep, I'm with you here pumbertot.
It's cool that Athlon is willing to help you out Dell Dude, but once it's passed to another person, it's between the two of you.
Also, correct me if I'm wrong, but it doesn't sound like you've tested it at this point (seeing as you don't have it back), so you're just going on what your buyer told you. Maybe they just have an incompatible system?
 
Yeah that is a good point I didnt even think of. Perhaps the other user is an idiot or has an incompatible system. Or maybe even he did something to break it. I dont see how that is Athlons responsibility either.

The only thing I see that is negative on AthlonXP is the poor packingg. But we do not know for sure it was that which caused it to be doa, if it even is doa. But since you never tested it and decided to quickly turn around and sell to someone else....that makes things a little more complicated.
 
im just not gonna worry about it anymore, my buyer is not an idiot, he has better rep than athlonxp and no negatives..

i realize pumbertot's point and will just deal with my buyer..

i was already dealing with my buyer as soon athlonxp blocked me on AIM, then he starts a thread, he states "before i rant about him". lol, i wasnt even planning on that, he just jumped to conclusions.

he says he doesnt want to cause grief, well he has caused me a little through all this, he constantly would avoid this over AIM saying that "im done here", "end of discussion", "goodbye". well if hes gonna have that attitude and then jump to conclusions like that, then whatever, not everyone is easy to deal with.

im done here...
 
First of all, you should test the PSU before selling it to someone else. Secondly, No matter how poor his packaging are it doesn't mean the PSU is dead. Finally, althonxp is kind enough to try to help you get a RMA so i dont see why you should ask him for a refund.

*Next time you should take pictures of the item in working condition and packaging before shipping it to prevent any misunderstanding.


btw, here is your RMA link.

http://www.corsairmemory.com/corsair/warranty.html
 
I don't understand why anyone would throw away the sweet box those corsair HX psus come in... :p
 
...I have recently worked very hard to build my reputation back up....

...... i have 160 perfect feedback that i am proud of, he has 30 positives and 2 negative feedbacks.....

just saying something to think about............


Dell I would tend to be on your side 100% if you still had the PSU and hadn't traded it off. To me that means you found it acceptable, and forfeit your right to bitch about it. If you had tested it in a timely manner and then also raised the issue of AthlonXP sucky ass packing, then you'd have a claim. :eek:
 
well i had 2 transactions that didn't turn out so well, that was if you see on my heat over 3 years ago. Also I am willing to help with paying for shipping to get it rma'ed and it was my fault for not packaging it well, I did throughly make sure the unti was protected from bouncing around and unfortunately the box was thrown out by my roommate, but finding out he never tested it when he got it and sells it off draws suspicions now on this transaction and right now I am not willing to part any money since he did not test it out when he got it, i usually try and get a hold of anyone i do business with when i sell them something to make sure everything is ok.
 
AthlonXP said:
well i had 2 transactions that didn't turn out so well, that was if you see on my heat over 3 years ago.

well it doesnt matter when you had problems, its the fact you had problems period.

i have a friend on this forum that was banned from anandtech over 2 years ago for not being a good trader at the time, to this day they still will not let him back on anandtech even though he has over 150 positive heat evals AFTER the negatives he got. so theres an example that its not when you had a problem, its the fact you had a problem in the 1st place...

AthlonXP said:
it was my fault for not packaging it well, I did throughly make sure the unti was protected from bouncing around and unfortunately the box was thrown out by my roommate

huh?... you throughly made sure it was not going to bounce around so you put it in a small ass box that left absolutely no room for padding on 5 of the 6 sides od the psu?? thats completely ridiculous.

also, YOU need to take care of your packages, dont leave it to your 'roommate' to handle them for you, thats very stupid and just makes you look worse in the end..

AthlonXP said:
i usually try and get a hold of anyone i do business with when i sell them something to make sure everything is ok.

ill put it this way, the first deal which was a decent one, you never "got a hold of me to make sure everything was ok", ever... in this current deal, i was the one that contacted you to let you know what was up...

IMHO you are a person who should not be in selling/buying/trading, at least until you get a grip of the packaging perspective, not blaming problems on others, and not lying..
 
obviously this is going to go nowhere between us as the psu was not tested out, right now I want to take the high road and offer money to pay for shipping to have the unit sent to RMA and thats it. I am not sure how old you are Dell Dude, but I am offering what happens most of the times on this forums with issues like this and thats that. For you not to test the psu before shipping it off pretty much renegs anything from me as that is what 99.9% of everyone on this forums does when they get thier items. If you have noticed with my recent transactions and people I have delt with on this forums I am doing what everyone would agree as the acceptable method of dealings.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top