is X1900XT + 4x PCI-e OK?

gorilla show

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 14, 2006
Messages
389
Just a quick question:

I have the 775 Dual VSTA mobo with a 4x PCI-e slot. I just ordered an X1900XT 256MB from the egg. Will the 4x PCI-e slot bottleneck the card's performance? If so, is it something reasonable like 5-10% (which is my guesstimate)?

Thanks in advance :)
 
from the reviews I've seen it may limit performance by 10% or so in strenuous benchmarks (3dmark06, for example) but the real-world performance should be nearly the same. I wouldn't worry about it.
 
Will it fit? PCIe 4x has 64 pins, PCIe 16x has 164, and as I understand it compatibility is upward-only, i.e. a 4x card will work in a 16x slot but not vice versa.
 
Will it fit? PCIe 4x has 64 pins, PCIe 16x has 164, and as I understand it compatibility is upward-only, i.e. a 4x card will work in a 16x slot but not vice versa.

Nah it goes both ways. All PCI-E cards are required to support 1X according to the standard.
 
Electrically yes, but definitely not physically, the slots are completely different!
 
Electrically yes, but definitely not physically, the slots are completely different!

Exactly..
pciexpress.jpg


The slot on the top is 16x
The slot on the bottom is 1x.
 
Electrically yes, but definitely not physically, the slots are completely different!


even then they can still work. As long as the smaller slot is a "universal" slot (meaning that the end is open) you can still put a larger card into it. And no the slots are not completely different...the pinouts of larger slots is identical to the smaller slots, just with more lanes. As long as the end is open, you could put a pci-e x16 video card into a 1x slot and it would work fine.
 
even then they can still work. As long as the smaller slot is a "universal" slot (meaning that the end is open) you can still put a larger card into it. And no the slots are not completely different...the pinouts of larger slots is identical to the smaller slots, just with more lanes. As long as the end is open, you could put a pci-e x16 video card into a 1x slot and it would work fine.


....and looking at every board that has ever passed through my hands, I have never once seen one that has an open end.
 
You can also clip the end off, and have it work perfectly.
The first one I could find has a picture of a PCI-E x4 open-ended.

AS890_slots.jpg
 
Per wikipedia:

A PCIe card will physically fit (and work correctly) in any slot that is at least as large as it is (e.g. an x1 card will work in an x4 or x16 slot), and a slot of a large physical size (e.g. x16) can be wired electrically with fewer lanes (e.g. x1 or x8; however, it must still provide the power and ground connections required by the larger physical slot size). In both cases, the PCIe link will negotiate the highest mutually supported number of lanes. It is not, however, possible for a device to operate in a slot that is physically smaller than it (e.g. an x4 card can't fit in a slot which is physically an x1 slot — though it could operate in a x4 slot wired with only 1 lane).
 
....and looking at every board that has ever passed through my hands, I have never once seen one that has an open end.

and clearly because you have personally never seen one, then it must not exist :rolleyes:

And that wikipedia article is wrong. Look at the picture MrMike posted. You could stick an x16 card into that slot and it would work just fine.
 
and clearly because you have personally never seen one, then it must not exist

Please don't put words in my mouth...
I was implying that they are rare.
 
Just a quick question:

I have the 775 Dual VSTA mobo with a 4x PCI-e slot. I just ordered an X1900XT 256MB from the egg. Will the 4x PCI-e slot bottleneck the card's performance? If so, is it something reasonable like 5-10% (which is my guesstimate)?

Thanks in advance :)

I installed a 1900XT 512MB on my ASRock 775Dual-VSTA and I'm seeing great performance increases in Oblivion (with LOD, texture, landscape + other mods) and Gothic 3. It runs great!! I even have it overclocked to 670/1440 from 620/1440.

-optimummind
 
I installed a 1900XT 512MB on my ASRock 775Dual-VSTA and I'm seeing great performance increases in Oblivion (with LOD, texture, landscape + other mods) and Gothic 3. It runs great!! I even have it overclocked to 670/1440 from 620/1440.



Guess that settles it.
 
SWEET:) Gets here tomorrow. Looking forward to some nice performance on oblivion and FEAR. thanks all.
 
Back
Top