Is this the good HGST?

Anyone that knows most anything about storage technology worth their salt would basically choke/gag/spit/vomit at the thought of buying Toshiba storage products, so excuse me while I choke/gag/spit/vomit at the thought of anyone actually doing it. :D

The Hitachi is vastly more reliable, probably will perform better as well and should be your only choice given the "competition," period, and worth every penny and that's all I'm gonna say about it. ;)
 
It's very good drive, but the larger individual platters generally take some time before being perfected. when 4b drives came out they had issues for the first 6 months or so. I tend to wait on new HD tech before adopting.
 
Anyone that knows most anything about storage technology worth their salt would basically choke/gag/spit/vomit at the thought of buying Toshiba storage products, so excuse me while I choke/gag/spit/vomit at the thought of anyone actually doing it. :D

The Hitachi is vastly more reliable, probably will perform better as well and should be your only choice given the "competition," period, and worth every penny and that's all I'm gonna say about it. ;)

Well many people on this forum like the toshiba drives and have had great results and so has backblaze....

Evidence or pure bias conjecture.
 
When I've never encountered a Hitachi (whether I own/owned it or a client did/does) that's failed and I've encountered hundreds of drives that clients own ('cause I wouldn't use a Toshiba hard drive even if it was free) from Toshiba that fail/have failed/in-process of failing/etc then yes, I suppose that would be my direct first-hand evidence, absolutely. Not one Hitachi drive has ever died or failed in my experience of using them - hell I even still have an IBM "DeathStar" 60GXP here in a box, had it since about 1999, still works, has 2 bad sectors on it and it has over 74,000 hours powered on (was used in simple file server for the better part of 11 years) but it's never just up and died like the typical "DeathStar" infamy would have most people believe.

Also, BackBlaze doesn't use many Toshiba drives and there's a reason for that. Compare the numbers of sheer drive counts then contact them and ask why they don't use many Toshibas. It ain't because of pricing or availability, that much I can promise. ;)
 
When I've never encountered a Hitachi (whether I own/owned it or a client did/does) that's failed and I've encountered hundreds of drives that clients own ('cause I wouldn't use a Toshiba hard drive even if it was free) from Toshiba that fail/have failed/in-process of failing/etc then yes, I suppose that would be my direct first-hand evidence, absolutely. Not one Hitachi drive has ever died or failed in my experience of using them - hell I even still have an IBM "DeathStar" 60GXP here in a box, had it since about 1999, still works, has 2 bad sectors on it and it has over 74,000 hours powered on (was used in simple file server for the better part of 11 years) but it's never just up and died like the typical "DeathStar" infamy would have most people believe.

Also, BackBlaze doesn't use many Toshiba drives and there's a reason for that. Compare the numbers of sheer drive counts then contact them and ask why they don't use many Toshibas. It ain't because of pricing or availability, that much I can promise. ;)
still no verifiable data presented here and no forum member that has used Toshiba drives (the only 2 that are recommended here) has complained of any odd failures. Facts are against you here. Plus those examples you posted are not very controlled. Also if you look at newegg you can see the retail Toshiba are one of the highest rated drives. You do not reference any specific drive or whether retail or OEM...pure conjecture and baseless.
 
pure conjecture and baseless.

As noted, personal hands-on experience says otherwise. If you're one of the fortunate few that haven't had problems congrats, doesn't mean others have had, currently do, and most likely will continue to have issues with Toshiba storage devices. As for control examples, you're right: 'cause hard drives sitting in a server in an environmentally controlled atmosphere where they stay powered on (meaning unlike real-world usage by consumers where they're on, off, on, off, etc) always make for the best real-world case usage scenarios as opposed to people using such drives in desktops in not so tightly control environments, and don't even get me started on Toshiba laptop drives, geez.
 
As noted, personal hands-on experience says otherwise. If you're one of the fortunate few that haven't had problems congrats, doesn't mean others have had, currently do, and most likely will continue to have issues with Toshiba storage devices. As for control examples, you're right: 'cause hard drives sitting in a server in an environmentally controlled atmosphere where they stay powered on (meaning unlike real-world usage by consumers where they're on, off, on, off, etc) always make for the best real-world case usage scenarios as opposed to people using such drives in desktops in not so tightly control environments, and don't even get me started on Toshiba laptop drives, geez.
again the topic is for NASes here....on off and moving around is moot....this isn't complicated tib...
 
When I've never encountered a Hitachi (whether I own/owned it or a client did/does) that's failed and I've encountered hundreds of drives that clients own ('cause I wouldn't use a Toshiba hard drive even if it was free) from Toshiba that fail/have failed/in-process of failing/etc then yes, I suppose that would be my direct first-hand evidence, absolutely. Not one Hitachi drive has ever died or failed in my experience of using them - hell I even still have an IBM "DeathStar" 60GXP here in a box, had it since about 1999, still works, has 2 bad sectors on it and it has over 74,000 hours powered on (was used in simple file server for the better part of 11 years) but it's never just up and died like the typical "DeathStar" infamy would have most people believe.

Also, BackBlaze doesn't use many Toshiba drives and there's a reason for that. Compare the numbers of sheer drive counts then contact them and ask why they don't use many Toshibas. It ain't because of pricing or availability, that much I can promise.

BULLSHIT!!! You are talking out of your ass and it makes you look like a fool.

I have purchased many of the Toshiba 5TB and 6TB hard drives and have had no problems with them. They are the SECOND most reliable drives on the market and are some of the fastest. All drives can fail even HGST. If the HGST drives are out of my price range when I need them, I always go for Toshiba over Seagate or WD.

I asked Backblaze why they don't use as many Toshiba drives and their answer was "It has to do with what is available for us to buy at what price. We purchase our drives from the reseller channel. We ask for quotes on say 5,000, 4TB drives, to be available on "X date". To date, Toshiba resellers have not met those criteria. We have been offered lower (much lower) quantities of Toshiba drives at a higher unit price but that doesn't make much business sense. We have nothing against Toshiba drives, we like to have multiple vendors, but we just have not been able to get the quantity and price we need."

If you think they are lying about that then take a second look at their hard drive reliability reports and you will see that the Toshiba drives perform better than Seagate or WD. There are many people on this forum, myself included, who would dissagre with you.
 
I can't tell you if you should go for Toshiba drives.

All I know is that Toshiba tends to be ridiculously customer-hostile and dishonest when it comes to warranty service and RMAs.
 
BULLSHIT!!! You are talking out of your ass and it makes you look like a fool.

I have purchased many of the Toshiba 5TB and 6TB hard drives and have had no problems with them. They are the SECOND most reliable drives on the market and are some of the fastest. All drives can fail even HGST. If the HGST drives are out of my price range when I need them, I always go for Toshiba over Seagate or WD.

I asked Backblaze why they don't use as many Toshiba drives and their answer was "It has to do with what is available for us to buy at what price. We purchase our drives from the reseller channel. We ask for quotes on say 5,000, 4TB drives, to be available on "X date". To date, Toshiba resellers have not met those criteria. We have been offered lower (much lower) quantities of Toshiba drives at a higher unit price but that doesn't make much business sense. We have nothing against Toshiba drives, we like to have multiple vendors, but we just have not been able to get the quantity and price we need."

If you think they are lying about that then take a second look at their hard drive reliability reports and you will see that the Toshiba drives perform better than Seagate or WD. There are many people on this forum, myself included, who would dissagre with you.
where is the quote pulled from?
 
I provided a link. Don't you see the word "asked" in yellowish orange. It is their response to the question I asked them on their "Hard Drive Reliability Review for 2015" blog post.
 
I provided a link. Don't you see the word "asked" in yellowish orange. It is their response to the question I asked them on their "Hard Drive Reliability Review for 2015" blog post.
I see your question but no response from BB

I controlled F to find the quote of BB and its not in the entire page.

ahhh nm. I see you need to click load more. Their response was hidden. Here is a direct link to BB response.

Hard Drive Reviews: Update on 2015 Hard Drive Reliability

I just wanted to fact check :D
 
Back
Top