Is Our Internet Future In Danger?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
InfoWorld has a five page article on the signs that point to a shortage of bandwidth and why they think we’ll all be paying more for broadband usage soon. Raise your hand if you think our country is headed for a bandwidth shortage.

The digital Disneyland of the future -- where we freely work and play online -- may be at risk. Why? Because, some argue, broadband carriers can't support it. The Internet's "free ride" culture has led to more people downloading gigabytes of data at practically no cost. Even if broadband infrastructure's capacity doubled or tripled, there's no avoiding the equivalent of an abrupt work stoppage.
 
Why would ISP's offer high bandwidth services to people if they don't want them to use it? I feel obligated to have something downloading 24/7 to get my "money's worth."
 
hmm... ok

so lets give up on all the new technologies and innovations... and instead use all our resources to build a big fucking violin.
 
there wouldnt BE a shortage if the telcos would just go to FTTP like verizon
this is just FUD to make people think caps and throttling is ok
 
We all pay monthly bills. If the isps invested the money in upgrades instead of lobbying, maybe there wouldn't be such a problem. But that doesn't result in the largest short term profits for the shareholders and execs, now does it? Caps & overage fees mean no more infrastructure upgrades required, keeps tv competition over internet sites to a minimum since both cable and telco offer tv now, and profits soar. It's all about the money. As much as I'd like to hate the corporations for being greedy, it's their job to turn a profit, nothing else. There's absolutely no incentive to upgrade when 98% of their customer base would get along fine at 5gb/mo. To be clear where I'm coming from, I'm on 20/20 fios transferring ~200gb a day, enjoying the bandwidth while I can.
 
The only reason we can't support is because people don't upgrade their equipment. That is like saying I can't store more than 1 gallon of water in my house as I only have a 1 gallon pitcher. All i would have to do is buy more to store more. Same here, all they need to do is buy more fiber and they would solve the problem.
 
there wouldnt BE a shortage if the telcos would just go to FTTP like verizon
this is just FUD to make people think caps and throttling is ok

Yup, FTTP ftw. I mean seriously the possibilities are limitless with it, more companies need to start developing and implementing this tech. I want fiber optics right into my comp! I wish I could get FIOS. :(
 
so lets give up on all the new technologies and innovations... and instead use all our resources to build a big fucking violin.

LOL

Yeah, I think a lot of the problem is simply the providers' infrastructure. Take Bright House for example. Locally, there are sections of their system that is 30 years old and simply cannot handle the needs of the users at this point.
 
is all about the bottom line, money , ISP dont want to spend it, so they throttle the high bandwidth useers who use what they paid for, punish those who use the service you offered them, real nice!
 
there wouldnt BE a shortage if the telcos would just go to FTTP like verizon
this is just FUD to make people think caps and throttling is ok

How the hell do you come up with that. I have yet to figure out why the hell you all want to think that FTTP = unlimited access to the web.

Do you know anything about networking? You could have 1GB to every computer in your house, but that doesn't mean that your connection to the world is automatically 1GB. Same with FTTP. Just becuase they have fiber to the home, unless they upgrade their connection to the backbone all you are getting is a fast local network and a slow connection to the world. Example, my home has 1 GB connection between all computer, yet my machine only has 6MB DSL.
 
I don't see Japan or the Europeans crying that the internet is coming to an end. And Japan has speeds WAY faster than ours, and arguably a more internet intensive population.
 
I feel obligated to have something downloading 24/7 to get my "money's worth."

I suppose you leave you TV on all the time, and let your water faucets run all day too. :rolleyes:

As they mention in the article broadband should be a pay for usage system. That's the only fair way to level the playing field.
 
Rather than expanding infrastructure to meet demand the telecomms are more than happy to raise prices for the bandwith so they can charge higher fees. Once the new fee structure is set, they will probably expand and we won't see any reduction in monthly fees though they will have plenty more supply of bandwith. Like Enron and oil refineries.
 
I don't see Japan or the Europeans crying that the internet is coming to an end. And Japan has speeds WAY faster than ours, and arguably a more internet intensive population.

As for Japan, that country is roughly the size of Montana. Linking cities and the whole country is MUCH cheaper than here in the states. Most stuff accessed online is contained within the country, same as here. For data entering or leaving the country the speeds I am sure slow down, just like here. Europe on the otherhand, I honestly don't know enough about to make a good conclusion or statement.
 
Japan is also like 1/30th the size of the US (not statistically accurate, but you get my point)
 
Yet more scare mongering, I would be content with a 4, or even a 2MB cable connection with Comcast, as long as I can can game online and download stuff (even if it is slower) I couldn't care less.

Don't know if Verizon are out here yet, will look into that one.
 
Oh and for a previous question, the United Kingdom...My parent's (I have been living in the US since 06) had to wait for about 7 years before our neighbourhood was considered for broadband, we basically had to stick our name on a list for our village to get the network installed (had to have at least 200 names on the list before the phone company would do anything), and you don't get a choice outside of the towns most of the time, it's the phone company (BT) broadband or if your lucky you can get a cable connection from a competitor.

So America isn't doing that bad for a service that supports most of the country (just guessing that just over a billion people are on it), England is having enough trouble with 26 million.
 
Japan is also like 1/30th the size of the US (not statistically accurate, but you get my point)

Actually you are pretty damn close. The US is roughly 26x larger than Japan in terms of area. In terms of population the US is roughly 2.5x larger.
 
What happened to all that "dark fiber" that was laying around after they figured out how to send multiple data streams over fiber optic cable using different frequencies of light?
 
Why would ISP's offer high bandwidth services to people if they don't want them to use it? I feel obligated to have something downloading 24/7 to get my "money's worth."

That's how I feel and even though I don't want something i still download it because I feel I have to get my "money's worth". If they didn't charge an arm and a leg I wouldn't feel this way.
 
corprate greed makes the world turn around. Look at wall street, the government is throwing money at the people that are the most wealthy instead of those that need it. Its all about their !@#$ greed!
 
Looks like they are taking their que from the oil companies. "There is a shortage we have to raise prices, Our refineries are down for maintenace." AT&T charges me for premium service but can't give me the speed as I am over 10k feet from the CO. But that is covered in their EULA, "you might not get what you pay for."

Looks like they are trying to cram 10 pounds of crapoloa in a two pound bag. Everybody is pushing streaming video including AT&T. Now they cry no bandwidth. How about building a system that can handle it first. WASS "we are so screwed."
 
^^I totally agree. All of these broadband companies always advertise "stream high quality video!!" yet they obviously can't handle it. It's ridiculous. They need to just do a widescale upgrade to fiber. It might hit them pretty hard to do full upgrades like that, but it will eventually even itself out.
 
What happened to all that "dark fiber" that was laying around after they figured out how to send multiple data streams over fiber optic cable using different frequencies of light?

Some places tore it up. There is rule that if you have dark fiber that you haven't used in x amount of time and somebody else wants to use it, you have to let them use it, or something among those lines.

So my guess is that most of it got tore up to keep competitors from coming in and using the fiber that was already there.

Also I'm not sure how many places are using the multiple data streams.

I work for a small telco and as far as I know we haven't switched very much stuff over to that. It would require new equipment at both ends so they just go with the mind set that it is working how it is, so why put money into changing it before we need to. Although I know that it was brought up with all the new equipment that is being looked at.
 
I suppose you leave you TV on all the time, and let your water faucets run all day too. :rolleyes:

As they mention in the article broadband should be a pay for usage system. That's the only fair way to level the playing field.

Good point, but at the same time, I dont get charged more for watching more TV. One price and thats it.
 
AT$T is just using the limited bandwidth argument to pull bandwidth caps as part of Net Neutrality. They really don't care about content, it's more a case of the more AT$T has to build the less profit they have. I worked for them for 3 years, AT$T doesn't understand that you have to spend money to make money. That why America has such a sh_tty cell and broadband infrastructure.
 
^^I totally agree. All of these broadband companies always advertise "stream high quality video!!" yet they obviously can't handle it. It's ridiculous. They need to just do a widescale upgrade to fiber. It might hit them pretty hard to do full upgrades like that, but it will eventually even itself out.

What do you think they use now?

The internet backbone isn't copper. Also fiber has more than 1 speed.

I'll ask you the same thing I have said a few times now to see if you answer. What makes you think that fiber to the home will change a damn thing?
 
boy these guys are gettin real creative. now were running out of internet and need to cut back on usage?


is this PEAK WEB?
 
What do you think they use now?

The internet backbone isn't copper. Also fiber has more than 1 speed.

I'll ask you the same thing I have said a few times now to see if you answer. What makes you think that fiber to the home will change a damn thing?

I think you may have missed - hell - everyone's posts in this thread, and quite possibly the way things are! There may be a slight "backbone" of fiber out there, but the point is that the majority of systems in place are 30 years old, and made of an eroding metal that can no longer stand up to the challenge. Those areas are capped badly, and as long as there's that bottleneck, it doesn't matter how much fiber we have here and there in between, there's still that 30 year old bottleneck clogging everything up, plain and simple. Get rid of the bottleneck, build on to that backbone, and then we can finally have a system in place that can meet the needs of internet consumers.
 
Japan is also like 1/30th the size of the US (not statistically accurate, but you get my point)

then why not in cities like New York, LA, and DC?
about the same pop per square mile

oh right the telcos DONT WANT to spend money on it

its just more FUD

i bet if MS or even Kyle called there ISP right that was serving the Hard site
and ask are they running out of bandwidth they would say no

the issue is the last mile not the back bones

this is why FTTP is the only way
look at Verizon; NO CAPS NO THROTTLING NO FILTERING
why becouse there last mile is nearly unlimited
 
It would never go as a purely usage based model like a regular utility. What might happen is a reduction in monthly access fee's for everyone, and then charging the heavier users more. One of my buddies got a "stop downloading so much or we will cut you off" letter from his ISP...so he stopped downloading so much. I'm a pretty heavy user but would simply stop watching TV shows on Hulu or playing flash games on Kongregate if I knew I was being charged a dollar everytime I went to either site. The internet is based on getting as many subscribers as possible, they share the costs to increase the bandwith. The fact that providers are crying that some users are actually using it is a sign of a corporate culture that has lost base with reality. It takes a pretty stupid buisnessperson to be pissed that their product is in demand.
 
I think you may have missed - hell - everyone's posts in this thread, and quite possibly the way things are! There may be a slight "backbone" of fiber out there, but the point is that the majority of systems in place are 30 years old, and made of an eroding metal that can no longer stand up to the challenge. Those areas are capped badly, and as long as there's that bottleneck, it doesn't matter how much fiber we have here and there in between, there's still that 30 year old bottleneck clogging everything up, plain and simple. Get rid of the bottleneck, build on to that backbone, and then we can finally have a system in place that can meet the needs of internet consumers.

That isn't what people have been saying though. They have been saying the they need to switch to fiber to the house so that there is no bandwidth limit for the telcos. Which isn't true. Or at least not by itself.

I understand how things are, as I mentioned I work for a small telco. I might work IT but I still have an understanding of how the rest of our stuff works as I have to help support some of the central office equipment. I know how our stuff is layed out. And I can tell you that 30 years old is better than some stuff that we have. However that doesn't effect our internet speeds for everyone. How our stuff is layed out is fiber out to lightspans and dslams in the field then copper from there to the home.

Our ISP sister company if I am correct has an OC3 that connects the customers to the world (thats about 155.52 Mbit/s). Even if we switched everyone to fiber they still couldn't supply them anythig more than the OC3 to the world. Our DSL speeds are 3Mbps down. Using our equipment we have for deployeeing DSL right now we might be able to push that up to about 8Mbps in some areas. By using some other equipment that we have inside 2 towns we can deploy AnnexM DSL with speeds of 24+Mbps down. Notice a problem? Even though we have the stuff right now to deploy 24+Mbps down to at least a few dozen customers that doesn't mean shit if the OC3 wasn't replaced. Same goes for fiber. There are a few places that we have been looking into giving fiber. However if we don't replace the OC3 we are going to be limited as to how much bandwidth they would actually be able to utilize. Right now I think our bandwidth is something like 70% utilized with everyone having up to 3Mbps (not sure of the exact numbers that this not something I am in charge of), other than a few employees that are testing the AnnexM.

What I am trying to point out that fiber to the home alone isn't going to change anything. They have to replace everything from the home to the office to the world. Also as I said fiber has more than 1 speed Fiber doesn't have to be supper hight speed. T1s go over fiber. Is a T1 fast? You can have an OC1 which is about 51.82Mbit/s, OC3 which is about 155.52Mbit/s, OC12 (622.08Mbit/s), OC48 (2488.32 Mbit/s), OC92 (4976.64 Mbit/s), OC192 (9953.28 Mbit/s), OC768 (39,813.12 Mbit/s )

I fully agree about the need to get rid of the bottle neck and build upon an sound backbone. However copper the last mile isn't going to be as much of a bottle neck as the ISP having a slow connection to the world. It also doesn't effect you only being allowed the transfer 30 Gb per month as opposed to unlimited. Copper doesn't add the limit, your ISP does.
 
Why would ISP's offer high bandwidth services to people if they don't want them to use it? I feel obligated to have something downloading 24/7 to get my "money's worth."

Agreed. My ISP recently sent out a letter encouraging me to upgrade to a 50Mb/s connection. In the advertising material, one of the examples they used was the time taken to download a 750MB movie at my existing download speed vs 50Mb.

You can even pay extra to get your upload speed boosted from 768Kb to 10Mb.. Why would you want to do that unless you're planning on uploading lots of data, e.g by downloading torrents or uploading gigabytes to online storage services?

The company knows that this service appeals to heavy bandwidth users, not casual internet users. They also know that those who're willing to pay so much ($50 a month) for 50Mb will be using a lot of bandwidth.

If I'm going to start paying 2x as much ($50 a month instead of $25) for this faster connection, I'd want to make sure I fully take advantage of it. This is no different from signing up for lots of movie TV channels - if I'm paying lots of money every month for ad free movie channels, I'd make sure to watch them as much as possible to get my money's worth. I wouldn't accept it if after having watched three movies one evening, a message suddenly pops up on the TV saying I've exceeded my quota for the day.
 
I fully agree about the need to get rid of the bottle neck and build upon an sound backbone. However copper the last mile isn't going to be as much of a bottle neck as the ISP having a slow connection to the world. It also doesn't effect you only being allowed the transfer 30 Gb per month as opposed to unlimited. Copper doesn't add the limit, your ISP does.

My whole point is that this bottleneck is due to the companies themselves, NOT because of our usage habits. In one form or the other, they need to upgrade, get rid of the bottlenecks, and make sure that their connection to the rest of the world is a good one.
 
Pretty much the only bottleknecks I can think of, for a DOCSIS network at least are the capabilities of the individual nodes and ultimately whatever fiber the ISP pays for. More capable nodes aka DOCSIS 3 is probably the short term fix.

But what do I care? I work for my ISP and get unlimited free internet. Sorry, felt like bragging.
 
Our new president elect Obama wants to put a stop to this. He's well aware of what AT&T has been doing on the north east coast with tierd pricing and caps. Though I've read that Biden has backed the RIAA's suits in the past which doesn't speak well for his support, but hopefully he will have little influence in this matter.
 
Comcast I love!.. not.. 250g Cap! 60$ per month..

and I guess that still is advertised as Unlimited =D..

damn..
 
Back
Top