Is my hard drive dying?

LittleMike

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 24, 2008
Messages
356
So I just built a new rig less than a month ago. I have a Crucial 256GB SSD for the OS drive and a Hitachi 1TB Deskstar for storage.

Just recently I keep hearing a clicking noise that sounds suspiciously like the click-of-death emanating from my computer. I disconnected my two external drives and still hear it, leading me to believe it's the Hitachi.

I pulled up both CrystalDiskInfo and HD Tune and both report the Hitachi as "Good." But I keep hearing this incessant clicking. Is my Hitachi on the way out? Is there any other way I can check? I was thinking that if the drive isn't reporting it's bad, the software won't pick that up, but clicking generally = death is coming.

Any advice would be appreciated.

For what it's worth, the full model of the Hitachi is HITACHI Deskstar 7K1000.D HDS721010DLE630 (0F13180) 1TB 7200 RPM 32MB Cache SATA 6.0Gb/s 3.5" Internal Hard Drive -Bare Drive that I bought from NewEgg.

Thanks,
Mike
 
Could this be the normal clicking noise a drive makes when it seeks? You do not have to have any programs running for the drive to be seeking around. Windows 7 and antivirus programs are known to cause a lot of disk access..
 
Could this be the normal clicking noise a drive makes when it seeks? You do not have to have any programs running for the drive to be seeking around. Windows 7 and antivirus programs are known to cause a lot of disk access..

No, it makes a high-pitched squealing noise when it seeks. This is a click-click-click-click.... pause... click-click. It's every few seconds or so but not in a regular pattern.

Besides which, as I stated, it's a storage drive. If I'm just web browsing, it would have no reason to seek anything, no?
 
If possible remove the sata cable from the disk leaving it powered and see if it continues to make the noises.
 
If possible remove the sata cable from the disk leaving it powered and see if it continues to make the noises.

Will it still make the noise, even with the cable disconnected? What's the cause of the click-of-death noise, isn't that the read/write arm/motor? If the SATA cable is disconnected, would it still try to read/write?

*EDIT* I meant to say, I'll give it a shot, but I'm not sure if it would reveal anything. Doing a system image first, then I'll give it a try when that's done.
 
You could also run a chkdsk in windows and scan and attempt to repair any bad sectors on reboot. I'm not familiar with all the tests that CrystalDiskInfo and HD Tune run if that was checked. I've had some drives that as they get older they get louder in laptops where its noticeable that you'll hear clicking during seek / read activity.

Do you have any programs that could have processes running in the background that could be causing the 2nd drive to seek at times. Maybe like Office 2010 that has some background OneNote process or something. You could also just run the drive outside the case temporarily and then put your ear up to the drive. Just take the usual static precautions when doing that.
 
You could also run a chkdsk in windows and scan and attempt to repair any bad sectors on reboot. I'm not familiar with all the tests that CrystalDiskInfo and HD Tune run if that was checked. I've had some drives that as they get older they get louder in laptops where its noticeable that you'll hear clicking during seek / read activity.

Do you have any programs that could have processes running in the background that could be causing the 2nd drive to seek at times. Maybe like Office 2010 that has some background OneNote process or something. You could also just run the drive outside the case temporarily and then put your ear up to the drive. Just take the usual static precautions when doing that.

My biggest issue is that a) this is a brand new drive - less than a month old, and b) this only started happening a couple of days ago. If this was normal seek noise, then I would have heard it right off the bat. The machine has been running 24/7 for almost a month. Any "quirks" the drive has would have shown up by now. This is a new noise.

All of my software is installed on the OS drive and I specifically have this drive set as storage only. Caching is turned off, indexing, etc. While possible, it's not likely anything is accessing the drive on idle because I've went through the trouble of turning it all off.

HD Tach and CrystalDiskInfo are both HD diagnostic tools. They read SMART info from the drives and give it back in a more human-readable form. The also benchtest drives for speed. Neither of them showed any bad sectors on the drive. I'm really leaning towards this thing being ready to die on me.

When the backup is done, I'll try drescherjm's suggestion of disconnecting the SATA cable and seeing if it still makes noise. If THAT doesn't work, then I'll take it out and hook it up to a USB to SATA adapter and check.

I uploaded a video to youtube. The audio isn't the best (I recorded it with my phone) but maybe it'll help identify the noise:

http://youtu.be/hVmPTkql9hw
 
From that video it sure does sound like the click of death. Only other thing i've heard that's similar was a case fan that was dying made a slightly similar sounds being it was stopping and starting basically.

While your backup is running does it vary at all during the constant pull of data from the drive? Notice any abnormal slowdown on data throughputs while backup is running?
 
From that video it sure does sound like the click of death. Only other thing i've heard that's similar was a case fan that was dying made a slightly similar sounds being it was stopping and starting basically.

While your backup is running does it vary at all during the constant pull of data from the drive? Notice any abnormal slowdown on data throughputs while backup is running?

Yes I did. I tried playing a large video file off the drive while I was running the backup and it dropped frames. Tried opening it again and it failed. It doesn't look good :(

On a related note, the damn thing stopped clicking. I don't know if that's a good thing or a bad thing at this point :p

*EDIT* noise started up again. Backup isn't finished yet, so I still haven't tested. Might be going out for the night so I may have to revisit this tomorrow.

Anyone else want to chime in? Check out the video. Does that sound like C-O-D to you as well? Damn DeathStar. I should have known. Next time I stick to Samsung. My Spinpoint F1's were rock solid.
 
Last edited:
Yes I did. I tried playing a large video file off the drive while I was running the backup and it dropped frames. Tried opening it again and it failed. It doesn't look good :(

On a related note, the damn thing stopped clicking. I don't know if that's a good thing or a bad thing at this point :p

*EDIT* noise started up again. Backup isn't finished yet, so I still haven't tested. Might be going out for the night so I may have to revisit this tomorrow.

Anyone else want to chime in? Check out the video. Does that sound like C-O-D to you as well? Damn DeathStar. I should have known. Next time I stick to Samsung. My Spinpoint F1's were rock solid.

From the sound in the video, which are series of a few louder, slower clicks immediately followed by lower, faster clicks that are happening with what seems a very regular period betweeen them, it is either failure and then sector reallocation, or spindown/spinup head movement. I would need to see the internal failure logs from the drive itself (if you have a serial/ttl adapter you can get them) to be more definitive, I am making the best guess from the sounds and your description.
 
From the sound in the video, which are series of a few louder, slower clicks immediately followed by lower, faster clicks that are happening with what seems a very regular period betweeen them, it is either failure and then sector reallocation, or spindown/spinup head movement. I would need to see the internal failure logs from the drive itself (if you have a serial/ttl adapter you can get them) to be more definitive, I am making the best guess from the sounds and your description.

They're not always regular. And that's the thing - there are no failure logs. All SMART data from CrystalDiskInfo and HD Tune are reporting the drive is fine. I just tried using the Hitachi DFT bootable CD and it wouldn't even detect the damn drive.
 
BYJyx.jpg
 
They're not always regular. And that's the thing - there are no failure logs. All SMART data from CrystalDiskInfo and HD Tune are reporting the drive is fine. I just tried using the Hitachi DFT bootable CD and it wouldn't even detect the damn drive.

The logs are not the smart data, you need to be in a serial terminal to the drive to get them. Unfortunately, smart is just a quick overview and not always reliable. I have seen many drive with perfect smart up to the second they failed.
 
Okay, well I took the drive out. How would I get logs out of them? Also note that as soon as I plugged in the USB adapter, it told me it wants to format the drive.
 
Okay, well I took the drive out. How would I get logs out of them? Also note that as soon as I plugged in the USB adapter, it told me it wants to format the drive.

I wasn't asking you to do it, I was just giving you an option. You don't need a USB>SATA adapter, you need a USB>TTL adapter.. Something like this http://www.ebay.com/itm/FT232BM-BL-...812?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item415de51284 Once you are in DIAG mode, you need to go to level T and from there you can display and download the cert and health logs. For a whole list of everything you can do in DIAG mode, you can read more at http://www.scribd.com/mesteroiub/d/39042992-Seagate-Diagnostic-Command . A word or WARNING, you can do a lot of damage to your drive, everything from erasing its defect list to bricking the entire drive with just 1 wrong keystroke while in diag mode. This is just for once your data is off the drive and you don't care about it anymore, as more a thought exercise as to what went wrong. In the right hands, these can be among the most powerful commands to help get data off a drive, but it can also make a drive worse or wreck a drive if used improperly
 
Last edited:
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I wasn't asking you to do it, I was just giving you an option. You don't need a USB>SATA adapter, you need a USB>TTL adapter.. Something like this http://www.ebay.com/itm/FT232BM-BL-...812?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item415de51284 Once you are in DIAG mode, you need to go to level T and from there you can display and download the cert and health logs. For a whole list of everything you can do in DIAG mode, you can read more at http://www.scribd.com/mesteroiub/d/39042992-Seagate-Diagnostic-Command . A word or WARNING, you can do a lot of damage to your drive, everything from erasing its defect list to bricking the entire drive with just 1 wrong keystroke while in diag mode. This is just for once your data is off the drive and you don't care about it anymore, as more a thought exercise as to what went wrong. In the right hands, these can be among the most powerful commands to help get data off a drive, but it can also make a drive worse or wreck a drive if used improperly

Oh gotcha. I misunderstood.

So how does that help me diagnose my current issue. No performance issues that I can tell, diagnostic software (albeit not perfect) shows no issues with the drive, yet you can most definitely hear that clicking in the video.
 
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Oh gotcha. I misunderstood.

So how does that help me diagnose my current issue. No performance issues that I can tell, diagnostic software (albeit not perfect) shows no issues with the drive, yet you can most definitely hear that clicking in the video.

Your drive is more than likely on the way out and I would get the data off as soon as possible. If it is still under warranty RMA it. The sounds are enough to worry me about its continued life. As to what it could tell, you could run a health log before and after the sound, to see if it logged any differences. C1 or C2 errors, multiple re-reads, etc.
 
Your drive is more than likely on the way out and I would get the data off as soon as possible. If it is still under warranty RMA it. The sounds are enough to worry me about its continued life. As to what it could tell, you could run a health log before and after the sound, to see if it logged any differences. C1 or C2 errors, multiple re-reads, etc.

good information. Thank you.

I bought it less than 30 days ago. I just did a Windows system image/data backup so everything is clear. According to NewEgg it's still within the return window. Maybe I should just return it for credit and get something else.
 
good information. Thank you.

I bought it less than 30 days ago. I just did a Windows system image/data backup so everything is clear. According to NewEgg it's still within the return window. Maybe I should just return it for credit and get something else.

Without question. Send it back either for another of the same, or a different model. But do it before that window closes.
 
good information. Thank you.

I bought it less than 30 days ago. I just did a Windows system image/data backup so everything is clear. According to NewEgg it's still within the return window. Maybe I should just return it for credit and get something else.

Return it, Get a Western Digital.
 
LOCO - I was actually thinking about that. Instead of a 1TB, upgrade to a 2TB WD Black like this one:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...ckTab=true&Keywords=(keywords)#scrollFullInfo

Unless anyone has any other suggestions. After reading all the reviews and seeing all the miserable failures, I'm afraid to go with a replacement for the same thing.

As a matter of fact, that WD I just linked to has a lot of DOA's or soon after deaths too. Damn, are there any good SATA 6.0Gb/s drives out right now?
 
LOCO - I was actually thinking about that. Instead of a 1TB, upgrade to a 2TB WD Black like this one:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...ckTab=true&Keywords=(keywords)#scrollFullInfo

Unless anyone has any other suggestions. After reading all the reviews and seeing all the miserable failures, I'm afraid to go with a replacement for the same thing.

As a matter of fact, that WD I just linked to has a lot of DOA's or soon after deaths too. Damn, are there any good SATA 6.0Gb/s drives out right now?

Well, every drive manufacturer and model has failures. Sometimes there is a bad production run and someone gets 2 or more bad drives. But many more people, probably 10:1 or more go online to complain rather than to praise. I personally love Hitachi (formerly IBM) right now. But after the IBM 75GXP fiasco years ago, I hated them for a while (100 bad drives within a year). It is all a crapshoot..
 
Well, every drive manufacturer and model has failures. Sometimes there is a bad production run and someone gets 2 or more bad drives. But many more people, probably 10:1 or more go online to complain rather than to praise. I personally love Hitachi (formerly IBM) right now. But after the IBM 75GXP fiasco years ago, I hated them for a while (100 bad drives within a year). It is all a crapshoot..

Maybe I'll go with that WD Black 2TB then. Returns or not, the last 2 weeks it only had 5 star reviews and I had 2 WD Green 1.5TB in my WHS that worked just great (incidentally the 750GB Seagate the WHS came with died in just over a year)

I just submitted a return. NewEgg makes you pay for RMA's now? I just had to spend $10 to ship the drive back to them UPS. What a rip!
 
LOCO - I was actually thinking about that. Instead of a 1TB, upgrade to a 2TB WD Black like this one:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...ckTab=true&Keywords=(keywords)#scrollFullInfo

Unless anyone has any other suggestions. After reading all the reviews and seeing all the miserable failures, I'm afraid to go with a replacement for the same thing.

As a matter of fact, that WD I just linked to has a lot of DOA's or soon after deaths too. Damn, are there any good SATA 6.0Gb/s drives out right now?

I love my 1TB versions. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136533

Both work flawlessly since I got them. DOA's do happen with anyone.
 
I love my 1TB versions. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136533

Both work flawlessly since I got them. DOA's do happen with anyone.

True. And for $80 more I can double the space. That's not a bad deal. I think I'll go with that.

Anyone ever do the UPS printing via NewEgg before? I clicked on the button, filled in my financial info and it basically said okay thanks for placing your order. That's it. Where are my return labels?

*EDIT* Never mind on the UPS thing - apparently it just took 20 minutes to process. They emailed me the label.
 
Last edited:
True. And for $80 more I can double the space. That's not a bad deal. I think I'll go with that.

Anyone ever do the UPS printing via NewEgg before? I clicked on the button, filled in my financial info and it basically said okay thanks for placing your order. That's it. Where are my return labels?

*EDIT* Never mind on the UPS thing - apparently it just took 20 minutes to process. They emailed me the label.

Question, How was the packaging from Newegg with the Hitachi drive?
 
Question, How was the packaging from Newegg with the Hitachi drive?

It was absolutely encased in bubble wrap. It was an OEM/bare drive. They made a bubble wrap brick out of it. I think I could have dropped it from 10 stories up and it wouldn't have so much as scratched it. And as much as UPS sucks with keeping things crush-free and safe, I can't blame shipping on this one.

On a related note, being that my girlfriend is the queen of shipping, I had eco-friendly air bags and the perfect size box to put it in to ship back. Put in poly-fill for good measure. UPS label is affixed and ready to go. Now all I have to do is drop this off tomorrow and wait.
 
Okay, so the noise decided to stop again. Took out the drive anyway, threw in a different one to restore to, and I started hearing the noise again. WTH? Now I'm questioning whether it really was the drive or not. I could always cancel the RMA, but now I'm wondering what the hell is making the noise.
 
Last edited:
back the drive and run DFT see what it throws back....either way clicking on a hard drive is not a good thing
 
Okay, so quick update - it's not the hard drive. After taking out any additional hard drive other than the SSD (no moving parts) and still hearing the noise, I spent the past few hours trying to track it down.

It appears to be coming from the power supply. Not exactly sure if it's the fan or something internal, but it actually sounds less like a hard drive with the side of the case off.

I literally got down on my hands and knees and put my ear to the machine with the side off listening. At least I figured it out. The power is stable on it, so I'm guessing it's just a quirk of the PSU (older Corsair HX1000) or just the acoustics of it while in the case. Not sure if it's worth replacing it, though that will depend on me getting used to the noise or getting driven nuts by it :p

Thanks all for all the suggestions. Looks like this problem is solved.
 
Okay, so quick update - it's not the hard drive. After taking out any additional hard drive other than the SSD (no moving parts) and still hearing the noise, I spent the past few hours trying to track it down.

It appears to be coming from the power supply. Not exactly sure if it's the fan or something internal, but it actually sounds less like a hard drive with the side of the case off.

I literally got down on my hands and knees and put my ear to the machine with the side off listening. At least I figured it out. The power is stable on it, so I'm guessing it's just a quirk of the PSU (older Corsair HX1000) or just the acoustics of it while in the case. Not sure if it's worth replacing it, though that will depend on me getting used to the noise or getting driven nuts by it :p

Thanks all for all the suggestions. Looks like this problem is solved.

Well, since it is not the drive, it is most likely the PFC chokes or the DC to DC converters in the power supply. That by itself doesn't mean that there is anything wrong with the PS, thought if it is annoying you might want to swap it out.
 
Well, since it is not the drive, it is most likely the PFC chokes or the DC to DC converters in the power supply. That by itself doesn't mean that there is anything wrong with the PS, thought if it is annoying you might want to swap it out.

I agree. Just a quirk of that PSU, I guess. I never used that particular model before. I may keep it as a spare and buy a new one to use. Any suggestions? I'm partial to Corsair, but not marries to them. Good support and we have a rep here too, if I remember right.
 
Back
Top