Is it bad if heatsinks touch?

sm8000

Gawd
Joined
Aug 5, 2004
Messages
525
All right, I have this board with a pair of Opteron 242s:

http://tw.giga-byte.com/Server/Products/Products_ServerBoard_GA-7A8DW.htm

And for CPU coolers I decided on a pair of these:

http://www.tr2tt.com/products/coolers/m14se/m14se.htm

Now I'm leaving the plastic on the bottom, and just gently resting the coolers on the CPU sockets. Lined up, it looks like the two heatsinks will be in contact along the inner edges. Is this bad?

If so, what can you recommend? I bought these because they are 52CFM @ 19dBA. I want to keep these beasts cool but want to do so quietly, short of watercooling.
 
if anything id think it would be good. it 'technically' allows the heat from each CPU to be spread across 2 heatsinks instead of just 1.

now, it may be entirely ineffective, but its at least not a negative effect.
 
The more I think about it, after having posted it, I realized that if they are not laying flat against their respective CPUs, because of pushing against each other, that would be bad.

Just to be safe, are their any slightly narrower recommendations?
 
That's Thermaltake. I'd recommend you to do research on those. Either way, an XP-90 would be better. Just make sure they don't push each other or bend the fins slightly.

-J.
 
XP90s would be worse - what I have are 92mm wide, those are 96. I figure a pair of heatsinks 80mm wide ought to do it.
 
I don't want to argue but I haven't seen or heard anything like this from Thermaltake. No reviews are out there (only one?). I wouldn't bet on getting that HSF. Maybe you've had first hand experience on it but the XP-90 still remains one of the best HSF's out there. Don't think fan size actually matter. :X

-J.
 
an 80mm fan at 60CFM and 19dba is like saying michael jackson never had plastic surgery. they lie (19dba within range of the fan)

ill try and think of alternatives...
 
Well first of all it's a 38 MM thick fan which creates a funnel noise (sounds lower than whirring). It's generally more silent than a 25 mm. They may not be close to 19 DB but it can be pretty damn close. Here's to hoping.

-J.
 
sm8000 said:
The more I think about it, after having posted it, I realized that if they are not laying flat against their respective CPUs, because of pushing against each other, that would be bad.
...tha'ts what I'd worry about the most.

Check with the MoBo manufacturer to see if they have either their own or any recommended heat sinks. I know from building dual Xeon boxes with SuperMicro motherboards that S.M. actually supplies their own thermal solutions so the mechanicals don't become an issue. Darn good ones, at that....:cool:

Regards - B.B.S.
 
GeForceX said:
I don't want to argue but I haven't seen or heard anything like this from Thermaltake. No reviews are out there (only one?). I wouldn't bet on getting that HSF. Maybe you've had first hand experience on it but the XP-90 still remains one of the best HSF's out there. Don't think fan size actually matter. :X

-J.

I'm talking about the size of the heatsinks, the metal blocks, themselves. Not talking about the fan size at all. What I already have are so wide they push against each other such that they don't lie flat on their CPUs. The XP90s are wider.
 
Back
Top