Is DirectX 9.0C support really that important?

Brent_Justice said:
SM 3.0 is part of the DX 9 spec, not specifically DX 9.0c

DX9.0c is simply exposing the SM 3.0 caps on the GF6 series

SM 3.0 has been in DX9 since DX9 was released in December of 2002
i guess i'm just confused then, cause that makes it seem like the X800 doesn't support dx9.0c, because the reason for the 'c' is the SM3.0...
 
(cf)Eclipse said:
i guess i'm just confused then, cause that makes it seem like the X800 doesn't support dx9.0c, because the reason for the 'c' is the SM3.0...

SM 3.0 has been in DX9 since DX9 was release in December of 2002

here is an overview of how the DX version numbers work, this is quoted from the Microsoft DX team:

Let me explain the method we use to set the version
numbers of the runtime and where we're heading:

Our versions of the runtime have the following form:
Major.Minor.Letter
ie. DirectX 9 . 0 b

The Major changes for significant runtime changes, e.g. fundamental
architectural changes and API rewrites.

The Minor changes for large feature additions, e.g. the addition of 1.2,
1.3 and 1.4 shader models to 8.1 from 8.0

The Letter changes for feature enablement already exposed in API, bug
fixes, performance updates, etc.

the "c" is in the "Letter" category

SM 3.0 was already in the API, the "c" simply enables it, plus has bug fixes and possibly performance updates

DX 9.0c still has all the same stuff DX9.0b did, so the X800 series support it as well, SM 2.0 is part of DX9.0c still
 
Is this something that ATI can just flash or add to their X800 drivers to add the 9.0C support? If so then this is probably not a huge deal. The fact that the 6800 needs a 480 watt PSU is pretty heavy IMO though.
 
ahh, i see how it works then, although that strikes me as the wrong way to go about labeling stuff. to me, if the difference between 9.0c and 9.0b is that c has the sm3.0 enabled in it, then anything that doesn't support sm3.0 shouldn't support 9.0c, but rather just 9.0b...

edit: ioman, the way i see it, it's more complicated than just a bios flash, cause there needs to be hardware support for sm3.0. and i believe nvidia kicked down the psu requirement to 350watts,
 
(cf)Eclipse said:
ahh, i see how it works then, although that strikes me as the wrong way to go about labeling stuff. to me, if the difference between 9.0c and 9.0b is that c has the sm3.0 enabled in it, then anything that doesn't support sm3.0 shouldn't support 9.0c, but rather just 9.0b...

each version is backwards compatible, and since all you need is to have SM 2.0 support to be DX9 compliant, then they can say the X800Pro is compatible with DX9.0c, which it is very compatible with

it just won't expose SM 3.0 on the X800 series because the X800 series doesn't have the features in hardware

i can see how that can be confusing for some
 
ioman said:
Is this something that ATI can just flash or add to their X800 drivers to add the 9.0C support? If so then this is probably not a huge deal. The fact that the 6800 needs a 480 watt PSU is pretty heavy IMO though.

Shader Model 3.0 is a core hardware feature, it requires transistors in the core
 
Brent_Justice said:
each version is backwards compatible, and since all you need is to have SM 2.0 support to be DX9 compliant, then they can say the X800Pro is compatible with DX9.0c, which it is very compatible with

it just won't expose SM 3.0 on the X800 series because the X800 series doesn't have the features in hardware

i can see how that can be confusing for some
oooohhhhhhh. ha... yeah, really confusing. thanks for clearing it up :cool:
 
MrHappyGoLucky said:
What you have not noticed, Brent, is these guys opinions are the only correct ones; in their own mind of course :p

Well, that's your opinion. ;)
 
Bad_Boy said:
lol

im just saying far cry has been hyped to death. not saying its been hyped as much as hl2 and d3. just because those are the most anticipated games that we have had in a while. i think they would clearly go for the biggest sequals of all time. so far cry cant really match up to that magnitude of hype. but in early 2004, everybody seemed to be on crytek's nuts. :eek: ....then it got released. ;)

In fact the hype really didn´t begin until people had played the demo or beta ;)

And if Far Cry even with as relatively little hype it got has been hyped to death what has then Half Life 2 and especially Doom 3???
 
oozish said:
This thread is getting very gay. The comments about Carmack show how stupid some people are regarding his genuis...in years from now, people will look back and Carmack may very well be viewed as a true genuis in his field, if he isn't already. I'm not ass kissing, I think I'm speaking the truth. Anwyay, your comments are retarded anyway, the DOOM3 engine brings more to the table than just stencil shadows, though there's nothing wrong with their implementation in that game and it will in fact revolutionize real world lighting in games. It also brings many other things you can't possibly know about (nor I) nor judge at this time, such as their work with 5.1 surround, the story line implementation, real world deformation (the extent to which we don't know), AI, and more. Just like the cards we're talking about, yet to a greater extent, it's too early to tell. so don't grab a negative attitude because claustraphobic FPS aren't your thing, you'd probably wet your pants anyway and then start to question your manhood.

LOL, you prove some good, and humorus points :D
 
oqvist said:
Doom 3 is the first title in years where ID really seem to have put some real effort in. I mean what have they released since DOOM 2?
.


well there was quake and it's use of polygons and "true" 3d.... then there was quake 3 that really put 3dcards in the mainstream... but beyond that... not a whole lot.

well that and their continual sponsorship of quakecon... :)

i remember reading that doom 3 engine will support vehicles and outdoor enviroments. and while there's not so much "opening doors" there are "sliding" doors. but if you determine your rating of a game based on it's ability to open doors i think you have more issues than game engines...
 
Bad_Boy said:
in the future....all doors slide ;)


and we'll all get together for once and plan out the jumpsuit diagram. commanding officers get red; engineers and security, yellow; science and health, blue
 
HRslammR said:
and we'll all get together for once and plan out the jumpsuit diagram. commanding officers get red; engineers and security, yellow; science and health, blue

lol :p

....im thinking your referring to star trek but never really watched it lol.
 
HRslammR said:
and we'll all get together for once and plan out the jumpsuit diagram. commanding officers get red; engineers and security, yellow; science and health, blue

i would hate to be a red shirt ;)
 
No no no, I think the guys got a point. Kirk survived just about everything EXECPT wearing a red shirt. R.I.P.
 
Vagrant Zero said:
No no no, I think the guys got a point. Kirk survived just about everything EXECPT wearing a red shirt. R.I.P.
rotflmao

reminds me of Guy on Galaxy Quest...
 
Back
Top