Is ATI Still in it?

tybert7

2[H]4U
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
2,763
I know they were late, but damn, there seems to be a dearth of interest in their offerings compared to nvidia.
 
It is pretty bad for them this round.. It is as bad as the NV5xxx series was for Nv.. The Ati 2xxx series is a pretty decent contender in certain price segments.. But it was late and really did not contend at the top end at release.. Driver improvement have caught it up some but it is prolly too late for the 2xxx series imho... Nv9xxx series is just around the corner and Ati's next offerings, hopefully, will not be too far off from that..
 
Pretty much comes down to "too little too late."

I had 4 ATI cards prior to my 8800 GTX. Before that, 3DFX. All my CPUs have been AMD up until my current laptop and desktop. I'm not a fanboy for anybody, I just go where the power is. ATI and AMD aren't where the power is right now.
 
I wouldnt count ATI out yet. I dont think the AMD deal is helping them at the moment. This year its all nVidia but never know about next year. :)
 
I wouldnt count ATI out yet. I dont think the AMD deal is helping them at the moment. This year its all nVidia but never know about next year. :)

agreed they might just come back and come back strong.
 
The 2900 has some life in it as the drivers mature and optimizations pop up, Nvidias Bioshock driver improved performance by 65% in some tests while ATIs just made that "Nvidia The Way It's Meant To Be Sponsored" game run properly.

While the high performance card was a disappointment because it didn't beat the 8800 series into the ground like everybody expected it to, the 2400-2600 line has been marvellous.

I mostly worry about Crossfire because it's like a 3D de-accelerator in some games, and when it works it either scales better than Nvidias SLI or it's slower. This is nowhere near as bad as Nvidias 5X00 series, I was around at the dawning of the leafblower and I know.
 
They are still in it for the long haul. Their low-end range as usual is very strong. Inq rumormill was they bumped nVidia out of Dell and Apple OEM offers again. So that will be HUGE cashflow for them.

Something about better price, less power, and trumps nvidia in hardware video decoding so cheaper to the masses kind of pc's with lower end cpu's can decode HD content well.

More than any high end enthusiast card would ever bring.
 
Been wondering about this myself, but I cant imagine ATi being content with just being the "kings of mid-range" in terms of GPU's. I've got a feeling they're going to come back with something high-end and solid maybe next year.

I also ran only ATi until late this year when I switched to an 8800GTX, and am actually hoping they do come back with something high-end. Never know... might just give nVidia a run for their money, and the "competition" is always enjoyable in terms of seeing the differences between what the two manufacturers come out with. Gives us consumers a bit more in terms of options as well, obviously.
 
I was reading some "real" benchmarks and it seems as if 2900xt outperofms myt 8800gtx in that game by nearlu 20 fps. Meh, I think with some driver optimization that card could be a best in the months to come.
 
the fact that the 2900 xt beats the 800 gtx is some games considering the $150 price difference is just amazing. this would be like the 8600 gts beating the 2900 xt in some cases, which of course it doesn't. :)
 
the fact that the 2900 xt beats the 800 gtx is some games considering the $150 price difference is just amazing. this would be like the 8600 gts beating the 2900 xt in some cases, which it of course it doesn't. :)

I am thinking that I should have went with 2900xt. I think with some driver optimization, this coule be one hell of a card :)
 
the fact that the 2900 xt beats the 800 gtx is some games considering the $150 price difference is just amazing. this would be like the 8600 gts beating the 2900 xt in some cases, which of course it doesn't. :)

Actually, yes, it does in some cases.

Edit: wait.... The 8800 GTS 320MB beats out the 2900 XT in some cases. The 8600 GTS does not. I guess I read over it because the claim was so ridiculous.

How do you get to comparing the 8600 GTS and the 2900 XT? Mid range to the highest of ATI's high end? Considering you can get 320MB 8800 GTS for $260 or so AR now and the 2900 XT goes for $400+ I'd say that's much more similar to the sort of match-up you're claiming to make. You'd be hard pressed to pay $250 for an 8600 GTS.
 
They will be in it until Nvidia flat-out buys out the company, and I don't see that happening in the near or not so near future.
 
They will be in it until Nvidia flat-out buys out the company, and I don't see that happening in the near or not so near future.

Considering AMD already bought Ati, I don't ever see Nv ever buying them..
 
it is only bad for them in the high end market against the 8800GTX and GTS, where how much profit comes from? next to none there 2400 and 2600 cards are ass kickers for that range vs anything nvidia has, and no, i am not talking "gaming" either, cause video cards are used for alot more then that.
 
Actually, yes, it does in some cases.

Edit: wait.... The 8800 GTS 320MB beats out the 2900 XT in some cases. The 8600 GTS does not. I guess I read over it because the claim was so ridiculous.

How do you get to comparing the 8600 GTS and the 2900 XT? Mid range to the highest of ATI's high end? Considering you can get 320MB 8800 GTS for $260 or so AR now and the 2900 XT goes for $400+ I'd say that's much more similar to the sort of match-up you're claiming to make. You'd be hard pressed to pay $250 for an 8600 GTS.

what he said was the 2900XT beating out the GTX in some games (lets talk the 640mb card, not the 320 - since the XT was to compete with the GTS not the GTX), would be the SAME as an 8600GT beating out the 2900XT he was simply making a reference of specs, not that they are actually competing.
 
judging by the steam survey lots of ppl have the 2900 not bad for being out a few months.
some have 2600 also not many but a decent amount. of course the nvidia offerings are very high in number also .
 
Valve Survey Summary

DirectX10 Systems (Vista with DirectX10 GPU) - 2.31% of users
NVIDIA GeForce 8800 18,005 1.65 % ##
NVIDIA GeForce 8600 3,487 0.32 %
NVIDIA GeForce 8600M 1,087 0.10 %
ATI Radeon HD 2900 XT 1,068 0.10 %
NVIDIA GeForce 8500 990 0.09 %
NVIDIA GeForce 8400M 461 0.04 %
ATI Radeon HD 2600 XT 106 0.01 %
ATI Mobility Radeon HD 2300 30 0.00 %
Intel Bearlake B Express Chipset 2 0.00 %
 
Back
Top