IPhone 4 Breaks When Dropped

Nobody is running away from that, don't be ridiculous. What people are saying is that you can't build a device that is supposed to be a day-to-day device and make it fragile. That is just reckless. As a manufacturer, it is absolutely your responsibility to make a device that can withstand the expected usage.



Dropping things is a medical problem? Wow dude, just wow...

YES. Dropping your phone 50 or 60 times in that period of time means there is something wrong with you, that's for sure.
 
I'll be the 1st to diss an Apple product, but in their defense, an iPhone, or any phone w/ glass in the front, should be protected by a skin or at least a case. That would do a lot to prevent screen glass from breaking.
 
I'll be the 1st to diss an Apple product, but in their defense, an iPhone, or any phone w/ glass in the front, should be protected by a skin or at least a case. That would do a lot to prevent screen glass from breaking.

but what does that have to do with their claim?

What you and other seem to be missing is that the point isn't that it broke, it is that a sales point is supposed to be how much stronger this screen is than other screens. A few test were done and it was found to be just as fragile as one would expect a screen to be.

I don't plan on dropping my laptop off my desk. But if i by a toughbook then i would expect it to survive if i did as they tell me that it will. I don't plan on spilling a drink onto a keyboard but if it says that it is water resistant then i would expect me accidently doing it not to fry it.
 
What you and other seem to be missing is that the point isn't that it broke, it is that a sales point is supposed to be how much stronger this screen is than other screens.
Show me where they made that claim.
A few test were done and it was found to be just as fragile as one would expect a screen to be.
They never tested the phone, they tested the shell. Do you perform a collision test on a car with its insides removed?
 
I think perhaps some of you should better familiarize yourselves with Apple's claims:
All the breakthrough technology in iPhone 4 is situated between two glossy panels of aluminosilicate glass — the same type of glass used in the windshields of helicopters and high-speed trains. Chemically strengthened to be 20 times stiffer and 30 times harder than plastic, the glass is ultradurable and more scratch resistant than ever.
So, we have four basic claims here:
  • The glass is 20 times "stiffer" than an undefined plastic (I would guess the least "stiff" plastic available)
  • It's 30 times "harder" than plastic
  • It's "ultradurable"
  • It's more resistant to scratches than previous models
The first two qualities, "stiffness" and "hardness" aren't what you want high levels of in a drop test: you want softness and flexibility to prevent cracking. They're beneficial to preventing scratches, though, I'm sure. "Ultradurable" is a vague, practically unquantifiable term. Ultradurable compared to what, and in what respects? Scratch resistance is likely the result of the material hardness, so it's a given that a harder-than-plastic material is less prone to scratching.

I don't see where the results of this phone drop test conflict with Apple's claims about the glass. Are there others durability claims I'm not aware of?
 
YES. Dropping your phone 50 or 60 times in that period of time means there is something wrong with you, that's for sure.

Except we are talking about 3 times, not 50 or 60.

No wonder your comments are ridiculous, you completely failed to read the article.

The case is flexible, not rigid. Lacking innards gives it the ability to bend to its breaking point more easily. Internal components will reduce this.

A pane of glass is likely to break when dropped. Secure two panes of glass together, and it's less likely to break. Sandwich a piece of wood between two panes and the assembly is even less likely to break.

Watch this:
http://www.apple.com/iphone/design/#design-video
Skip to 5:23 where it shows them bending the glass.

Yes, but bending wasn't the problem. It didn't break when it was dropped on a corner or edge (bending force), but rather when it was dropped *flat on its surface* (no bending force). There wasn't a bending force when it broke, which is why internal components aren't going to help.

Also, remember this isn't regular glass.
 
The case is flexible, not rigid. Lacking innards gives it the ability to bend to its breaking point more easily. Internal components will reduce this.

A pane of glass is likely to break when dropped. Secure two panes of glass together, and it's less likely to break. Sandwich a piece of wood between two panes and the assembly is even less likely to break.

Watch this:
http://www.apple.com/iphone/design/#design-video
Skip to 5:23 where it shows them bending the glass.

Can't watch, i don't have quicktime. But is that the one where they show a metal bending the glass? It only shows it's flexible. That's not how you do an impact test..
 
That's not how you do an impact test..
Nor is testing the durability of one piece of the product.
There wasn't a bending force when it broke.
So the ground broke it through telepathy?

Taking it in your hands and snapping it will make a simple concave bend, whereas dropping it will produce a more complex, wavelike bend. It can't break if it isn't bent or stretched.
Essentially, the internal components will cushion the glass, and vice versa.

Either way, it's pretty pointless to bash a product that doesn't exist yet based on tests performed on its replica.
 
Nor is testing the durability of one piece of the product.

Hundreds of thousands of the same thing already manufactured, sure there's bound to be defects, but so far two have been tested and it's batting a 1.0.

Btw. The bumper cases are apparently $30.00 each.
 
Seriously... In 2 weeks I'm sure we will get plenty of videos with iPhones getting smashed wait till then. The website in question hasn't posted any videos and offer no evidence just hear say and if it was to generate hits to the website. By god it was ingenious. They probably made up enough revenue in hits the first 2 days of the story than 2 years worth trying to sell repairs for the iPhone. It's fun reading all the vehement and hatred for one company and one unreleased product though.
 
what a surprise, and so is every phone with a huge screen if you drop it!! The review should of said, the iphone should glide when falling down.
 
but what does that have to do with their claim?

What you and other seem to be missing is that the point isn't that it broke, it is that a sales point is supposed to be how much stronger this screen is than other screens. A few test were done and it was found to be just as fragile as one would expect a screen to be.

I don't plan on dropping my laptop off my desk. But if i by a toughbook then i would expect it to survive if i did as they tell me that it will. I don't plan on spilling a drink onto a keyboard but if it says that it is water resistant then i would expect me accidently doing it not to fry it.
Well, I never believe Apple's claims. I remember back in the day when they said the (then-original) iMac was some bogus value percentage faster than the then-latest Pentium chip. That was a bunch of baloney back then and their claims are still baloney now. I'm just saying that no matter what a manufacturer claims about the screen, I'd put a case and/or skin on it to protect it. But that's just me.

[T5K]thrasher;1035830245 said:
I drop my 3GS maybe once a week from 3'-4' and its survived just fine so far.
Are you really that clumsy? :eek:
 
So the ground broke it through telepathy?

No.

Taking it in your hands and snapping it will make a simple concave bend, whereas dropping it will produce a more complex, wavelike bend. It can't break if it isn't bent or stretched.

No, bending it creates sheer stress, a flat impact produces compression stress. A flat impact like they tested would produce a compressive force, not a shearing one.

Essentially, the internal components will cushion the glass, and vice versa.

For the internal components to cushion the glass the internal components would need to hit the ground first. The glass "cushions" the internal components, yes, but not vice versa.

Either way, it's pretty pointless to bash a product that doesn't exist yet based on tests performed on its replica.

Its not a replica, its official Apple replacement parts. They used the real parts from Apple. It isn't a replica.
 
Except we are talking about 3 times, not 50 or 60.

No wonder your comments are ridiculous, you completely failed to read the article.



Yes, but bending wasn't the problem. It didn't break when it was dropped on a corner or edge (bending force), but rather when it was dropped *flat on its surface* (no bending force). There wasn't a bending force when it broke, which is why internal components aren't going to help.

Also, remember this isn't regular glass.

I was talking to the guy who said he dropped his phone 50 or 60 times. What's ridiculous is that you can't even follow the conversations in a thread.

Listen up people. I hate Apple more than anyone, but the phone isn't going to break like that from a couple of small drops. I've never heard of a phone, in production, that would break like that on a large scale.

So give it up. Do you honestly think tons of these things are going to come out, and in the first week 90% of them come back with huge breaks in the glass?

WOW.

And did any of you see the tests done on Gorilla Glass on the Dell Streak. The thing is hard fucking core.

I'd grab my pitch fork at the drop of a hat when it comes to Apple, but for a legit reason. This isn't legit at all.

I can't even believe this thread is this long. Anyone who is sane should look at this and laugh. I mean, the phone isn't even 100% there. This phone will sell tons and maybe 2% will break when dropped from a normal height. This is a joke, and will be the least of the Iphone 4 problems.

\thread
 
No, bending it creates sheer stress, a flat impact produces compression stress. A flat impact like they tested would produce a compressive force, not a shearing one.
Did you mean "sheer" or "shear"? Either way, compression is another type of bend. A solid ball of glass will bounce when dropped.
And unless it landed perfectly parallel to to ground, it would produce significant compression waves which would reverberate through the entire device
Its not a replica, its official Apple replacement parts. They used the real parts from Apple. It isn't a replica.
But they didn't use an iPhone.
 
Ryken's Steps to a Successful Tech Blog:

1) obtain Apple product (doesn't matter which one)
2) make outrageous claim about product's durability/reliability/performance/etc
3) open comment section
4) start comments with 2-3 extreme pro- and anti-Apple statements
 
Did you mean "sheer" or "shear"? Either way, compression is another type of bend. A solid ball of glass will bounce when dropped.
And unless it landed perfectly parallel to to ground, it would produce significant compression waves which would reverberate through the entire device

I meant shear, and no, compression is not another type of bend. Shear and compression are two *different* forces.

And a stiffer backing will make it more likely to break. It will increase the forces involved.

But they didn't use an iPhone.

Yes they did, it just didn't have a circuit board. It was a real iPhone 4 case with a real iPhone 4 screen.
 
I meant shear, and no, compression is not another type of bend. Shear and compression are two *different* forces.

And a stiffer backing will make it more likely to break. It will increase the forces involved.



Yes they did, it just didn't have a circuit board. It was a real iPhone 4 case with a real iPhone 4 screen.

Um, if they didn't use a fully assembled iphone, it's not even close to being a valid test.

Once again, end thread.
 
Um, if they didn't use a fully assembled iphone, it's not even close to being a valid test.

Once again, end thread.

It absolutely is a valid test. Most likely a fully assembled iphone will do the *exact same thing* when dropped. It's highly possible it will even be more likely to break.
 
Back
Top