IPhone 4 Breaks When Dropped

seems like verizon got all the nice android phones :(

I'm still rockin my G1, which I think might also be glass, or something... not sure...

I really really hope dell releases a T-Mobile version of the streak *crosses fingers*

T-Mobile got the Nexus One. A good phone, not my favorite, but good nonetheless.
 
Don't worry; as we speak, Apple's engineers are hard at work on a fix for this. It's called iDiot. You simply buy a second iPhone, and Apple's proprietary tether, that loops through you sleeves to the other iPhone. This makes them impossible to drop.
 
Companies making devices capable of withstanding what is to be expected during everyday use? Imagine that.

Oh wait, I've had 4 BlackBerries.. I've dropped each of them quite a bit, all are working 100%. My Curve has seen more falls than I can even remember, probably 50-60 in the 2 years I've had it.

You have a foolish attitude.

How? He is promoting personal responsibility. The thing most people, including you, run away from nowadays.

If YOU drop your phone, it's YOUR fault. Not a hard concept to grasp. And if you've dropped your phone that much I'm going to have to go ahead and say you have some sort of problem. Medical maybe? I've dropped my cell phone maybe...MAYBE 4 times in around 2 years. I never put my phones in a case and they all look brand new.


'
 
How? He is promoting personal responsibility. The thing most people, including you, run away from nowadays.

Nobody is running away from that, don't be ridiculous. What people are saying is that you can't build a device that is supposed to be a day-to-day device and make it fragile. That is just reckless. As a manufacturer, it is absolutely your responsibility to make a device that can withstand the expected usage.

If YOU drop your phone, it's YOUR fault. Not a hard concept to grasp. And if you've dropped your phone that much I'm going to have to go ahead and say you have some sort of problem. Medical maybe? I've dropped my cell phone maybe...MAYBE 4 times in around 2 years. I never put my phones in a case and they all look brand new.

Dropping things is a medical problem? Wow dude, just wow...
 
If YOU drop your phone, it's YOUR fault.

You're the second person to say this, and is the second person who has no clue what you're talking about :rolleyes:

This isn't about dropping a phone. It's about a phone that shatters when dropped. No one here has said "Oh, my iPhone broke, it's all Apple's fault that I dropped it". What we're saying is "Oh, my iPhone broke, it's all Apple's fault that the phone isn't as resilliant as claimed or should be expected for a mass-marketed consumer device".
 
I saw several shows on TV showing one company after another doing quality checks. Like putting them in a tumbler, dropping them, and dropping things on them (Like crushing a steel toed boot to see how much it can withstand, or dropping a GPS 1000 times). They're supposed to be very strict. Didn't they do that for the iPhone?
 
Technology is getting more delicate. That's all.

Look at televisions for instance. Before all the flat-screens came out, they were extremely resilient and lasted for an extremely long time. Now, they're delicate and don't last as long on average by comparison.
 
Furthermore. Cartridge based design games to optical discs that can get scratched.
 
Flatscreens are actually more resilient than CRT's (Every one of the TV's i've had has a burn-in) and they only stay in one place for their entire useful life. Our ancient 15" 1024x768 LCD is still working and readable.

Games media are designed for capacity, not durability.


Cell Phones are designed for mobility and everyday rough handling. Which the iPhone is apparently not, which also contradicts what apple said.

Do you think apple can be sued for false advertising?
 
Flatscreens are actually more resilient than CRT's (Every one of the TV's i've had has a burn-in) and they only stay in one place for their entire useful life. Our ancient 15" 1024x768 LCD is still working and readable.

Games media are designed for capacity, not durability.


Cell Phones are designed for mobility and everyday rough handling. Which the iPhone is apparently not, which also contradicts what apple said.

Do you think apple can be sued for false advertising?

That is true now. But it wasn't prior to the Playstation.
 
That really sucks. My now retired 1G iPhone was nearly indestructible, dropped that thing on concrete more times than I could count. The metal bezel/case really made a difference - it would get scratched up, dented in, whatever, but nothing would ever touch the display.

Shame that Apple seems to have gone backwards.
 
That really sucks. My now retired 1G iPhone was nearly indestructible, dropped that thing on concrete more times than I could count. The metal bezel/case really made a difference - it would get scratched up, dented in, whatever, but nothing would ever touch the display.

Shame that Apple seems to have gone backwards.

It's probably no more destructible than the previous iPhones. Apple's exaggerating and tech journalists are sensationalizing on it as usual.

Wait a month after launch and see how everyone else is doing with them.
 
It's probably no more destructible than the previous iPhones. Apple's exaggerating and tech journalists are sensationalizing on it as usual.

Wait a month after launch and see how everyone else is doing with them.

Other phones are designed to protect their screens, the most common and basic method is to surround the screen with a bazel and use a shell that can absorb the impact.

The iPhone4 doesn't do this. There's no raised edge or reinforced sides. No matter how you drop it, the first thing that will touch the ground will always be glass. And since it's all one rigid piece, the shock goes right through the length of the shell with no buffer zone. The sheer design of this device relies completely on the rigidity of the shell alone. With no gap or joints to help absorb the impact.
 
Other phones are designed to protect their screens, the most common and basic method is to surround the screen with a bazel and use a shell that can absorb the impact.

The iPhone4 doesn't do this. There's no raised edge or reinforced sides. No matter how you drop it, the first thing that will touch the ground will always be glass. And since it's all one rigid piece, the shock goes right through the length of the shell with no buffer zone. The sheer design of this device relies completely on the rigidity of the shell alone. With no gap or joints to help absorb the impact.

Yeah that is a big whoops on Apple's part, something that should have definitely been tested out, but if everyone uses shells or backplates like they have been with their previous phones, it should be ok.
 
Here's an interesting piece of news I found while searching for iPhone4 shells.

http://www.tuaw.com/2010/06/07/apple-announces-bumpers-for-iphone-4-gets-into-the-protection-biz/

As much as I like iPhones (and I do!), I definitely agree that Apple isn't exactly the most honest business in the world. If I'm into conspiracy theories, I'd say that Apple deliberately made the iPhone4 fragile so they can sell these bumpers. But of course the conspiracy is relatively unfounded because majority of older iPhone users buy aftermarket shells anyways, lol.
 
Following that train of thought, it does fit the pattern of the iPad somewhat.

The iPad was touted as Apples answer to the netbook. However, for it to actually get close to the same functionality of a netbook, you have to invest $1200 on your iPad in accessories and upgrades. A stand for holding it up, a keyboard, screen protection, docking port, etc. All of which are integrated into a netbook, are separated, and then individually sold at a premium.

If we were to go with the conspiracy idea, and assume that marketing and research had a hand in the design, it wouldn't be too far off that they'd rely on numbers and just assume that since most users buy protective cases anyway, they can just take out any built in shock resistance and go purely on aesthetics right from the design phase.

If that was true tho, how does it compare to other companies that take durability into their design rather than make it optional?
 
Following that train of thought, it does fit the pattern of the iPad somewhat.

The iPad was touted as Apples answer to the netbook. However, for it to actually get close to the same functionality of a netbook, you have to invest $1200 on your iPad in accessories and upgrades. A stand for holding it up, a keyboard, screen protection, docking port, etc. All of which are integrated into a netbook, are separated, and then individually sold at a premium.

If we were to go with the conspiracy idea, and assume that marketing and research had a hand in the design, it wouldn't be too far off that they'd rely on numbers and just assume that since most users buy protective cases anyway, they can just take out any built in shock resistance and go purely on aesthetics right from the design phase.

If that was true tho, how does it compare to other companies that take durability into their design rather than make it optional?

lol that makes me think about this hilarious Macbook Air vs Lenovo X300 spoof ad.
 
how about -1 for all 3 of you

How is this horrible news? A company is claiming that their device is more rugid that is really is.

Find a story about how a toughbook breaks after a 2 feet fall and send that in to Steve to post.

That isn't their product. It's a shell.
 
Furthermore. Cartridge based design games to optical discs that can get scratched.
Blu ray discs have a scratch resistant coating.

Here's an interesting piece of news I found while searching for iPhone4 shells.

http://www.tuaw.com/2010/06/07/apple-announces-bumpers-for-iphone-4-gets-into-the-protection-biz/

As much as I like iPhones (and I do!), I definitely agree that Apple isn't exactly the most honest business in the world. If I'm into conspiracy theories, I'd say that Apple deliberately made the iPhone4 fragile so they can sell these bumpers. But of course the conspiracy is relatively unfounded because majority of older iPhone users buy aftermarket shells anyways, lol.
You think they made the phones so they could sell cases? Do you think they're going to sell more protectors than phones?
 
The internal guts would make it heavier, which would make it more likely to break, not less. The problem wasn't structural integrity (which could be helped by having more internal guts), but that the glass on the outside of the phone cracked. A more rigid body would actually make the problem worse.

It would stabilize the internal structure. A fiberglass PC board can take a fall better than a glass pane.
 
That was the Macbook Air.

No, it was not. MacBook Air is comparable to small laptops - HP Elitebook, Lenovo X300, Dell Adamo, and so on. The specs and cost is nothing like those of netbooks,
 
Blu ray discs have a scratch resistant coating.


You think they made the phones so they could sell cases? Do you think they're going to sell more protectors than phones?

Where did I say that? Did you conveniently ignore the part where I said "if I was a beliver of conspiracy theories, I would consider this, but I don't?"

Accessories are a big market all by itself too, so it's possible that Apple is aware that they goofed with the design of the iPhone4 and decided to jump into the shell and sleeve market to make up for their mistakes (or profit from it, chose your reasons).
 
In my infinite clumsiness, I've dropped my Droid twice.

Once from about 3 feet onto a sidewalk, and the second time about 6 feet onto rigid carpet. Nothing more than a couple of small scratches on the corners of the metal. :)
 
It would stabilize the internal structure. A fiberglass PC board can take a fall better than a glass pane.

Unfortunately the component inquestion is not an internal one. Since it's outside and always going to hit something. increasing the mass behind hit will only raise the amount of force imparted on the glass, not lower it. No matter what you put inside, the force will always travel through the casing first before reaching the internals.
 
this is GREAT news...

when the iphones 3g's came out, repairs alone, they almost paid for a whole half semester of college :).

and to people who are like "phones break when dropped"...you need o stop buying crappily engineered phones. Nothing breaks as easy as an iphone or a g1. I have thrwon my phoen across the room (by accident), dropped it in concrete and tipped off my desk countless times, its fallen at least 6ft once. I've even thrown up all over it. The ONLY time my tilt broke its screen was when i let my friend borrow it and the corner of an 40 lbs box hit it while in his pocket. other than that...wow...the abuse i put my stuff through...

a phone SHOULD survive such abuse. especially such an expensive phone.
 
And I love your "taking responsability for ones actions" bullshit. If I pay Apple $600 fucking dollars (which I'm not, ever, by the way), I expect something that isn't going to shatter into a million pieces the first time it's dropped. Period. I'd expect that of a glass figurine; not a phone, and certainly not one advertised as "durable" and "stronger than plastic".

What a sense of entitlement: "I paid apple 600$ so my product shouldn't break". If you drop it it is your fault. Simple as that.
 
What a sense of entitlement: "I paid apple 600$ so my product shouldn't break". If you drop it it is your fault. Simple as that.

You guys are totally missing the point. If Apple makes a phone, advertises it as durable, and sells it at a premium, and then the first time you drop it (or the second), its screen shatters, then Apple screwed up in their design or manufacturing.

No one is blaming Apple for the phone being dropped. Don't be dense on purpose.

People are frustrated that they pay a premium for the phone and it possibly can't even handle basic, everyday usage, which includes being dropped from time to time. Sure, most people are careful with their electronics, but accidents happen, and something that is expensive and lives in people's pockets should be able to withstand the stress of everyday use. If it can't, that's a design flaw.

For example, I bet you'd be LIVID if you dropped the keyless entry remote to your car and it bricked right away, and those remotes are typically under a hundred dollars. What would you say? "Well goddamn, these things should be built to withstand being dropped, I mean they're KEYS for crying out loud!" That's exactly the same thing people are saying about the phone!

If Apple is advertising the phone as durable and charging a premium for it, it should be able to withstand occasional drops onto hard surfaces from 3 to 6 feet up. Extreme fragility in a CELLULAR PHONE is a design flaw, pure and simple.
 
a phone SHOULD survive such abuse. especially such an expensive phone.
So a $600 Fabergé egg should be more resistant to damage than a $300 egg because it's more expensive? I genuinely don't understand the logic here.
 
[Tripod]MajorPayne;1035827167 said:
You guys are totally missing the point. If Apple makes a phone, advertises it as durable, and sells it at a premium, and then the first time you drop it (or the second), its screen shatters, then Apple screwed up in their design or manufacturing.

Incorrect. They simply lie in their marketing. Yeah, I know - an unthinkable concept for Apple ;)
 
So a $600 Fabergé egg should be more resistant to damage than a $300 egg because it's more expensive? I genuinely don't understand the logic here.

A phone that's more expensive has theoretically been more thoroughly designed and manufactured with better components, making it either perform better or become more durable. Or, in Apple's case, both, as they advertised.

People expect more when they pay more, or "supply and demand" goes out the window, so expecting your $600 phone to hold up better than a $50 cheap piece of junk isn't unreasonable.

CP3: Yes, you have a point there, but I was trying to refute the arguments of the people who were saying "Dropping your phone is only your fault! Apple could make it out of tissue paper and sugar glaze, but you should NEVER drop it!"
 
[Tripod]MajorPayne;1035827210 said:
A phone that's more expensive has theoretically been more thoroughly designed and manufactured with better components, making it either perform better or become more durable. Or, in Apple's case, both, as they advertised.
As I said, they claim the glass is more durable, not the phone itself. We don't know if that claim is accurate or not because it hasn't been tested. All we know is that, in this scenario, the glass in the iPhone shattered at a drop from about 3.5 feet the third time. We don't know if a similar iPhone with another type of supposedly less-durable glass would shatter from the same drop height because it hasn't been tested.

[Tripod]MajorPayne;1035827210 said:
People expect more when they pay more, or "supply and demand" goes out the window, so expecting your $600 phone to hold up better than a $50 cheap piece of junk isn't unreasonable.
It is when the $600 phone is sandwiched between two pieces of glass and the $50 phone is not. Just because Apple claims the glass to be "ultradurable" doesn't necessarily mean that it's highly resistant to cracking upon drop impact: "durable" is a rather vague term, and that works to Apple's advantage. It may be quite durable against scuffs and scratches and dramatic temperature shifts but quite prone to cracking when dropped compared to other types of glass.
 
Unfortunately the component inquestion is not an internal one. Since it's outside and always going to hit something. increasing the mass behind hit will only raise the amount of force imparted on the glass, not lower it. No matter what you put inside, the force will always travel through the casing first before reaching the internals.
The case is flexible, not rigid. Lacking innards gives it the ability to bend to its breaking point more easily. Internal components will reduce this.

A pane of glass is likely to break when dropped. Secure two panes of glass together, and it's less likely to break. Sandwich a piece of wood between two panes and the assembly is even less likely to break.

Watch this:
http://www.apple.com/iphone/design/#design-video
Skip to 5:23 where it shows them bending the glass.
this is GREAT news...

when the iphones 3g's came out, repairs alone, they almost paid for a whole half semester of college :).

and to people who are like "phones break when dropped"...you need o stop buying crappily engineered phones. Nothing breaks as easy as an iphone or a g1. I have thrwon my phoen across the room (by accident), dropped it in concrete and tipped off my desk countless times, its fallen at least 6ft once. I've even thrown up all over it. The ONLY time my tilt broke its screen was when i let my friend borrow it and the corner of an 40 lbs box hit it while in his pocket. other than that...wow...the abuse i put my stuff through...

a phone SHOULD survive such abuse. especially such an expensive phone.
If your motor skill are thus, then the iPhone might not be what you need. It can probably withstand "normal" impacts, but maybe not being accidentally thrown. There are indeed more durable phones on the market.
 
You're the second person to say this, and is the second person who has no clue what you're talking about :rolleyes:

This isn't about dropping a phone. It's about a phone that shatters when dropped. No one here has said "Oh, my iPhone broke, it's all Apple's fault that I dropped it". What we're saying is "Oh, my iPhone broke, it's all Apple's fault that the phone isn't as resilliant as claimed or should be expected for a mass-marketed consumer device".

I don't know what to tell you guys. My iphones never broke when dropped, and my wife drops hers a LOT.

Secondly, we don't even have the new iphone in our hands yet.

Do you really REALLY think it's going to be made this poorly?

There are some people in this thread who don't know what they are talking about, but it certainly isn't me.
 
Back
Top