iPhone 3G Torture Tested

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
PC World ran Apple’s new iPhone 3G through a series of torture-tests to see how durable it is. It’s a tough little bugger, I’ll give it that. Still pretty darn expensive though.

In PC World's second annual battery of iPhone Stress Tests…our 3G iPhone test unit withstood a serious beating from keys, breakfast cereal, water, dish soap, and the pavement.
 
Pretty durable phone. I almost, almost, feel sorry for it after all of that. I wish they would have made it more entertaining to watch, but whatever. Running it over with the motorcycle was overkill and nice. Personally I would've seen what happens when its tossed violently against a wall or have a sledge hammer "dropped" on it. Thats just me though.
 
The screen cracking within 5 drops isn't very durable to me, which is exactly the issue with the first iPhone. My co-worker was on his second one within 2 months because he's drop it now and then. I literally must drop my phone at least 3-10 times a week and it's still running strong 6 months later.
 
The screen cracking within 5 drops isn't very durable to me, which is exactly the issue with the first iPhone. My co-worker was on his second one within 2 months because he's drop it now and then. I literally must drop my phone at least 3-10 times a week and it's still running strong 6 months later.
I highly recommend some crazy glue or velcro (or go really high-tech with rubber bands) to help with that issue. :D
 
lol quite the dropper.

Blackberries are slippery to hold as well. I have a rubber skin for the back of it which provides excellent grip. You should consider it for yourself and your boss.
 
The screen cracking within 5 drops isn't very durable to me, which is exactly the issue with the first iPhone. My co-worker was on his second one within 2 months because he's drop it now and then. I literally must drop my phone at least 3-10 times a week and it's still running strong 6 months later.

Wow. I wouldn't dare drop my phone (Rzr V3) on pavement. I'm very careful with my cell phones. 3-10 times a week is astounding. You really need to find a better way to hold your phone. Most my phone has dropped in the six months I've had it is onto my carpeted floor from a few feet when I accidentally knock it off of my tower when getting up from my chair.
 
The screen cracking within 5 drops isn't very durable to me, which is exactly the issue with the first iPhone. My co-worker was on his second one within 2 months because he's drop it now and then. I literally must drop my phone at least 3-10 times a week and it's still running strong 6 months later.

Dude, seriously, wtf?! :p The fact that you're quoting 3-10 (give/take '7') demonstrates that you're just not paying attention! Like the other dude said, Velcro 4 u :D
 
I would really like to see some military grade smart phones. (waterproof, drop proof from at least 10 feet, dust proof, etc) Perhaps Panasonic should make one. :p
 
My phone falls onto concrete all of the time, at least twice a week. Black motorola Q. Awesome phone, and the smooth touch black finish is even better because it doesnt scratch like normal paint would. Thing is 2 years old and looks brand new despite at least 20+ falls onto concrete in it's life.
 
I would really like to see some military grade smart phones. (waterproof, drop proof from at least 10 feet, dust proof, etc) Perhaps Panasonic should make one. :p

They do make them, its just that only the military gets them. Plus the most durable cellphone ever made was the Motorola Startac...
 
They do make them, its just that only the military gets them. Plus the most durable cellphone ever made was the Motorola Startac...
That's pretty obvious. :p

But I beg to differ on the the Startac. The flipper broke on those when you dropped them. The most durable phone I've seen/owned was the Motorola Teletac 250. A few months ago I found it in my basement, and the thing still worked. LOL. It sounded clearer than any phone I've owned to date too. To see what it would take to break it, I tossed it about 30 feet in the air and let it fall on down to the concrete. Popped the battery back on, it still worked. Repeated that about 4 times and it was still working. Then I ran it over with my dad's 2007 Tundra and it still worked.. it just bent the clips that held the battery on a little. I dunked it underwater and that killed it. :p
 
The screen cracking within 5 drops isn't very durable to me, which is exactly the issue with the first iPhone. My co-worker was on his second one within 2 months because he's drop it now and then. I literally must drop my phone at least 3-10 times a week and it's still running strong 6 months later.

3 to 10 times a week is pretty damn extreme. You may need a military grade phone to combat your clumsiness. :eek:
 
Seeing a smashed iPhone on the HOCP page sure made my day...
 
That's pretty obvious. :p

But I beg to differ on the the Startac. The flipper broke on those when you dropped them. The most durable phone I've seen/owned was the Motorola Teletac 250. A few months ago I found it in my basement, and the thing still worked. LOL. It sounded clearer than any phone I've owned to date too. To see what it would take to break it, I tossed it about 30 feet in the air and let it fall on down to the concrete. Popped the battery back on, it still worked. Repeated that about 4 times and it was still working. Then I ran it over with my dad's 2007 Tundra and it still worked.. it just bent the clips that held the battery on a little. I dunked it underwater and that killed it. :p

I had two Samsung phones. One I left on top of my car when I was in a rush to get soemwhere. Halfway down the road, I had to brake and the phone slid off my car's roof onto the hood and onto the road below. It didn't even occur to me what fell down until I ran over it.

Just a couple of scratches on the back.

Had a Samsung flipphone after, dropped it on a regular basis when it fell out of my belt clip, but never worse for the wear. Samsung phones were always pretty durable from my use. I still have my third. I must have done worse things to it than the other two, it's scratched up but still fully operational.
 
I drop my Blackberry 8820 fairly frequently. The only time any damage happened was when it fell down some concrete steps. I had to get the microphone replaced (the ceramic mics found in phones aren't too durable to shocks), but it's been a trooper ever since, even down the same steps. Must've been a bad mic.
 
I can do better than that. I tee up my last cell phone and smashed it with a 3 iron. I've been cell phone free for over 9 months now. Freedom!

Cell phones are nothing more than pacifiers for adults.
 
i dropped a old Motorola v220 in the toilet while at the drunk at the bar it never made another call :)

so far my iPhone feels nice and solid it has nice size and weight imo this is my first ever apple product so i hope i don't drop it. but if i do accidentally drop it, it is nice to see it has has a chance of coming out unscathed :)
 
All of the key tests were good. Would have rather seen repeated tests from pocket-height, and then eventually up to ear-height. Then on with the dunking/washing and for good measure, running it over.

I'd also like to see the dropping tests with a case to see how much of a difference it makes. But, they did say they were short on time...
 
I just want a more water resistant cell phone :( My Razr when it would get slightly wet or if i needed to go outside to talk to someone and it was raining would never work right unless i let it sit for a fairly long extended period of time, that seems a bit rediculous when you payed a few hundred dollars for something that can't handle something even a simple watch can.
 
Yeah my verizon razr is pretty strong. It flew over the net of a trampoline and landed on jagged rocks and all that happened was the battary cover blew up and got scratched. I just hope my iphone wont have to go throughat.
 
Back
Top