iPads Restrict Children's Vocabularies

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If this is a problem in your household, it isn't Apple's fault. One or more of your parents may need to be smacked up side the head though. :D

The iPad generation will learn fewer words, experts fear, as using text messages, emails and computers to learn could be stunting children’s vocabulary. "These are visual rather than auditory, so it is likely that they will end up with a lower average number of words than previous generations,” he said.
 
I find it funny that schools, at least when I went, taught you that short hand writing was good for taking notes and learning. Perhaps parents need to monitor what apps their children are installing. I for one think these devices are making children smarter quicker. Parents also need to limit the amount of time their children use these devices and go out and play with their friends. While a lot of learning can be done on a tablet or smartphone, children still need to learn motor skills and exercise their imagination.
 
While a lot of learning can be done on a tablet or smartphone, children still need to learn motor skills and exercise their imagination.

Exactly, social skills are needed as well. I work in the school system and so many kids don't know how to communicate and play with each other. They'd rather play a game on a computer by themselves.
 
My 5 year old son watches me play Borderlands and now runs around the house saying "keep the bullets flying!", I'm not worried about him using less words, as a matter of fact, he may be using too many words!
 
So the excessive amount of reading I did as a child actually made me dumber because I didn't hear it. Officer Barbrady! I call shenanigans.

The people I know with the best vocabulary are the ones who did or do the most reading. In the end how big a child's vocabulary becomes is a result of good teaching, parenting and the child's curiosity. The latter being more important, especially in an age where they have a wealth of information literally at their finger tips.
 
So the excessive amount of reading I did as a child actually made me dumber because I didn't hear it. Officer Barbrady! I call shenanigans.

The people I know with the best vocabulary are the ones who did or do the most reading. In the end how big a child's vocabulary becomes is a result of good teaching, parenting and the child's curiosity. The latter being more important, especially in an age where they have a wealth of information literally at their finger tips.

That's not what the article is saying. More that communication between individuals on the internet typically limits the scope of language one is exposed to, which is true. Also, you are less likely to use a word you know the definition of, but don't know how it is pronounced.
 
Wow ... it's too bad we don't have any apps that speak or teach vocabulary and alternate languages ... oh wait, we do :D ... if anything, given the sad state of learning in the USA, these new computer like tools could actually improve children's language and cognitive skills ... socialization is another thing completely but the original article wasn't about that, just language ;)
 
My 5 year old son watches me play Borderlands and now runs around the house saying "keep the bullets flying!", I'm not worried about him using less words, as a matter of fact, he may be using too many words!

I would never play borderlands in front of a 5 years old... never...
 
Wow ... it's too bad we don't have any apps that speak or teach vocabulary and alternate languages ... oh wait, we do :D ... if anything, given the sad state of learning in the USA, these new computer like tools could actually improve children's language and cognitive skills ... socialization is another thing completely but the original article wasn't about that, just language ;)

The technology could indeed improve language skills. Kids are going to have to be more proactive to expand their knowledge, though.
 
As someone who spent most of their formative years with their nose in a book, I -- obviously -- have no words to describe how implausible I find this little slice of "zOMG APPLE!" click-bait...
 
Eh. It's about the environment at home and when out. This is why I doubt the children of my youngest sister and her husband are theirs, those toddlers speak and think like they have university diplomas compared to their WT parents. They're so bright I want to get them instruments rather than smart-devices.
 
The article has very little to do with Apple. One might say it is irrelevant to the discussion.
 
I'm all for it, these iTards are not going to be competing for my job anytime soon
 
I suspect that if we went back to the 70's and 80's we could find lots of articles that said the same thing about computers ... electronics devices like computers, tablets, smartphones, etc are tools ... they can be used responsibly to provide value or irresponsibly to create harm or injury ... so can a hammer ... if children don't use the tools properly so that they provide benefit that is the fault of parents and teachers (since those are the people facilitating the tool use) ... after all, it isn't Craftsman's fault I whacked a hole in the wall trying to hammer a nail, or maybe it is (LAWSUIT :D ) :p
 
I suspect that if we went back to the 70's and 80's we could find lots of articles that said the same thing about computers

ahh, but computers do make us stupid...I used to be able to do arithmetic, and spell, and remember phone numbers
 
This article is double plus good.

Come on, you think a story like this could go long without a 1984 reference?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak

The aim of Newspeak is to remove all shades of meaning from language, leaving simple concepts (pleasure and pain, happiness and sadness, goodthink and crimethink) that reinforce the total dominance of the State. Newspeak root words serve as both nouns and verbs, further reducing the total number of words; for example, "think" is both noun and verb, so the word thought is not required and can be abolished. The party also intends that Newspeak be spoken in staccato rhythms with syllables that are easy to pronounce. This will make speech more automatic and unconscious and reduce the likelihood of thought. (See duckspeak.)

In addition, words with negative meanings are removed as redundant, so "bad" becomes "ungood". Words with comparative and superlative meanings are also simplified, so "better" becomes "gooder", and "best" becomes "goodest". Intensifiers can be added, so "great" became "plusgood", and "excellent" and "splendid" become "doubleplusgood". Adjectives are formed by adding the suffix "-ful" to a root word (e.g., "goodthinkful", orthodox in thought), and adverbs by adding "-wise" ("goodthinkwise", in an orthodox manner). This would, of course, not prevent heretic statements such as "Big Brother is ungood," but not only would this statement sound absurd in the ears of the politically orthodox — it would also be impossible to understand exactly what the statement means since all concepts and words that can be used to argue against Big Brother would be eradicated from the language.

Some of the constructions in Newspeak, such as "ungood," are characteristic of agglutinative languages, although foreign to English. It is possible that Orwell modeled aspects of Newspeak on Esperanto; for example, "ungood" is constructed similarly to the Esperanto word malbona. Orwell had been exposed to Esperanto in 1927 when living in Paris with his aunt Ellen Kate Limouzin and her husband Eugène Lanti, a prominent Esperantist. Esperanto was the language of the house, and Orwell was disadvantaged by not speaking it, which may account for some antipathy towards the language.
 
My 5 year old son watches me play Borderlands and now runs around the house saying "keep the bullets flying!", I'm not worried about him using less words, as a matter of fact, he may be using too many words!

My 6 yr old isn't allowed to even see me play FPS games...the wife is dead set against it. He is pretty good on the games we let him play and even taught himself windows 8 shortcuts when he was 5. He talks in tech terms like: "We need to delete some files to make space on the hard drive" or "Looks like this website wants parental approval before I can register"

He was once playing on the android tablet and called out from his room, and I quote: "Dad, has this android tablet ever locked up on you where the sound just repeats itself over and over?" I was taken back and smiled when I heard him ask me that. So I figured I would have to reset it and before I could respond he said this: "It's not a problem, I just rebooted to fix it, just wanted to know if you have ever seen this before."

He no longer asks me what other people are typing in message blocks, he actually reads them and responds. From my experience, you are not going to tell me how kids are 'not' learning vocabulary by using computers.
 
I'm already seeing this with teens. I shudder to think what they would do if it were a criminal offense to use the word "like" in their sentences.
 
I'm already seeing this with teens. I shudder to think what they would do if it were a criminal offense to use the word "like" in their sentences.

That's not new. People have been speaking that way on the west coast since the 80's.
 
I'm going to shout because it needs to be said from the mountaintops:

IF WE TAUGHT KIDS PHONICS ON A TABLET WE WOULD NOT EVEN NEED THE PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM.

I know, I learned phonics. I was reading at today's college level by the time I left grade school. SO WAS EVERY OTHER CHILD IN MY CLASS.

The portable tablets that exist today could easily hammer phonics into the sponge-like minds of a child in mere weeks or months.
 
I think this article has merit. My daughter asked me to buy her an ipad, so I smacked her. Now she has a stutter.
 
My iPad didn't restrict my vocabulary at all. If anything, it did whatever the opposite is called.
 
More that communication between individuals on the internet typically limits the scope of language one is exposed to, which is true. Also, you are less likely to use a word you know the definition of, but don't know how it is pronounced.

I disagree. First by communicating on the internet you are exposed to a larger group of people with a more diverse vocabulary. Secondly, if I don't know how to pronounce a word, I would never use it in a verbal conversation, but I would use it in online communication. Since I'm online I can even look up the word if needed. So the number of words I use and learn will go up by online communications, rather than only communicating with my local peers.
 
Lol @ the article quote, all the complex words are more likely to be encountered visually first.

High level vocabulary comes from people who are literate, and those words will be read, not spoken by random hipsters
 
I have a 2.5yo and the iPad with its great library of apps has taught him shapes I forgot about, like ovals and semi-circles.

He'll be just fine.
 
I ascertain that these men are just jealous of my command of the...English...uh language. I ascertain that it's their problem. They're just jealous of me. It's my right to ascertain things. You should talk to them about their being upset about my...ascertaination.
 
I disagree. First by communicating on the internet you are exposed to a larger group of people with a more diverse vocabulary. Secondly, if I don't know how to pronounce a word, I would never use it in a verbal conversation, but I would use it in online communication. Since I'm online I can even look up the word if needed. So the number of words I use and learn will go up by online communications, rather than only communicating with my local peers.

You usually can't tell if you're talking to an American, Englishman, or Polish person on the internet if they're all speaking the same language. People tend to use neutral language. Not everyone, but the bulk of them.

Though, you can easily be exposed to a more diverse language pool on the internet if you chose to. Nobody is saying you should only communicate one way or the other, it's all about balance. Online communication is a tool that can be used as a toy. People have to willingly use it as a tool for it to have a net positive effect. Also, communicating online isn't automatically inhibit any type of learning unless you let it.
 
me_fail_english_demotivator_by_purplephoneixstar-d4nw89m.jpg
 
Back
Top